Lecture 1-3: The Learning Agreement and the Supervisor
목차 31
- Lecture 1-1: What a Placement Is For
- Lecture 1-2: Choosing Where to Learn
- Lecture 1-3: The Learning Agreement and the Supervisor
- Lecture 1-4: Placements Under Many Roofs
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: My Learning Aims and Agreement Draft
- Lecture 2-1: Why Keep a Record
- Lecture 2-2: Writing a Placement Journal
- Lecture 2-3: Writing About People Without Harming Them
- Lecture 2-4: Honest Hours and Honest Accounts
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: One Journal Page
- Lecture 3-1: What Reflection Is
- Lecture 3-2: From an Event to a Question
- Lecture 3-3: Bringing Scripture and Tradition into the Conversation
- Lecture 3-4: Reflecting With Others
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Reflecting on One Event
- Lecture 4-1: What a Placement Student Is and Is Not
- Lecture 4-2: What You Hear, and What You Must Tell
- Lecture 4-3: Being Used and Using Others
- Lecture 4-4: Your Own Safety and Wellbeing
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab, My Limits and My Help Routes
- Lecture 5-1: Working With Your Supervisor
- Lecture 5-2: Receiving Feedback
- Lecture 5-3: Conflict and Difficulty
- Lecture 5-4: When a Placement Is Not Working
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Preparing for a Supervision Meeting
When you have chosen a place, one step remains before the work starts: you write down, together with your supervisor, what you will learn and how. This is called a learning agreement, which means a written plan agreed between the student and the supervisor. It is not a form from this seminar. The programme guide and the school's staff may ask for a particular document, or for none, and may say how it is filed. This lecture does not invent any such rule. If the programme guide asks for a form, use it. If it does not, the content described here is still worth writing, because it is what makes a placement a placement.
We will see what a good agreement contains, who a supervisor is and what a supervisor can and cannot be, and how a weak draft differs from a better one. Throughout, the agreement is a tool for honest conversation. It is not a contract that ties anyone to a legal duty; this course says nothing about legal force, which differs from place to place. And the rules of the site and the supervisor's instructions come before it.
The week's principle is visible here. Good preparation names both the aims and the limits. An agreement that lists only what you hope to do, and not what you will leave alone, is half an agreement.
이 24분으로 얻는 것
- Say what a learning agreement is and name its main parts.
- Explain why an agreement should state tasks the student will not take on, and not only tasks the student will.
- Describe who a supervisor is, what a supervisor does, and who sets the requirements for supervisors.
- Compare a weak draft of an agreement with a better one and say what changed.
- Describe what a good use of the supervisor's authority and of the student's trust looks like.
Do two walk together, unless they have agreed?" — Amos 3:3
World English Bible
But let your ‘Yes’ be ‘Yes’ and your ‘No’ be ‘No.’ Whatever is more than these is of the evil one." — Matthew 5:37
WEB
Moses’ father-in-law said to him, “The thing that you do is not good. You will surely wear away, both you, and this people that is with you; for the thing is too heavy for you. You are not able to perform it yourself alone." — Exodus 18:17-18
WEB
Moreover you shall provide out of all the people able men, such as fear God: men of truth, hating unjust gain; and place such over them, to be rulers of thousands, rulers of hundreds, rulers of fifties, and rulers of tens. Let them judge the people at all times. It shall be that every great matter they shall bring to you, but every small matter they shall judge themselves. So shall it be easier for you, and they shall share the load with you." — Exodus 18:21-22
WEB
Two people cannot walk together without some shared understanding of where they are going. A learning agreement is a way of reaching that understanding on purpose.
Jesus speaks here about plain speech. The passage is about oaths, not about agreements between students and supervisors, but it supports an ordinary habit: say clearly what you mean and do what you said.
Moses' father-in-law sees that Moses is trying to carry too much alone. A supervisor is a person with limits, and the agreement should take that into account.
The advice is to share the load among people who are able and honest, with a clear division between large matters and small ones. A good agreement divides responsibility in a similar way.
1. Why write it down
A spoken agreement is easy to make and easy to remember differently. A student and a supervisor may leave a first conversation each sure that the other agreed to something, and later find that they agreed to two different things. Writing it down does not remove all misunderstanding. But it makes the misunderstanding visible early, when it is cheap to correct.
Writing also helps the student. A student who writes "I want to learn how to prepare and lead a small group study" will notice, three months later, that no one has let them lead one. A student who wrote nothing may not notice. The agreement is a way of remembering why you are there.
And writing it helps the supervisor. Many supervisors are volunteers with other work. A short page tells them what is expected and helps them to say what they cannot do. A supervisor who reads "weekly meetings of an hour" and knows this is impossible should say so at the beginning, not after two months.
2. What a good agreement contains
There is no required list in this seminar. But experience in many kinds of training suggests that a useful agreement covers the following. Use what fits your place and leave out what does not.
Aims. What do you want to learn? State this as learning, not as tasks. "To visit people" is a task. "To learn how to be with a person who is anxious, and to notice what helps" is learning. Three or four aims are enough. Each should be something you could say, at the end, whether you have learned or not.
Tasks taken. What will you do? Be as specific as the place allows: leading a small group, helping with the weekly meal, visiting a named kind of person on a list that the site provides, answering messages on the site's behalf under its rules.
Tasks not taken, or not yet. What will you not do? This is the part that many drafts leave out. A placement student is not yet a professional (week 4 says more). You should write which matters you will pass to your supervisor: for example, counselling that needs training, medical or legal questions, money, or anything the site's own rules say a student must not do. Writing this is not a failure. It protects you and the people you serve. It also protects your supervisor, who can see that you know the limit.
The pattern of hours. When will you be at the site, in what rhythm, and how will you and your supervisor know that the pattern is being kept? The school sets the total of 200 hours and decides what counts, so do not use the agreement to decide that. Use it to say what is practical: which days, which part of the week, how you will tell your supervisor if something changes.
Regular meetings. How often will you meet your supervisor, for how long, where, and in what way (in person, by telephone, by video)? What will each of you bring? A meeting that is "when possible" is a meeting that does not happen. Choose a rhythm that both of you can keep and write it down.
Records. What will you keep, in what form, and where will it be stored? Week 2 teaches how to keep records and how to write about people without harming them. At this stage, agree that records will not carry real names or identifying detail, and ask whether the site has its own rules for notes.
Whom you tell. If you are worried about someone's safety or your own, whom do you tell, and how fast? The answer is usually "my supervisor, at once." State it. And add the name of the person to tell if your supervisor cannot be reached. In immediate danger, call your local emergency number.
How the placement may change or end. What will you do if the aims turn out to be wrong, if the supervisor can no longer meet, or if either of you wants to stop? Naming the way out in advance is not unfaithful. It makes an honest change possible.
Signatures or marks of agreement. If the programme guide asks for a form, follow it. If you simply sign a page, that is fine too. Keep a copy.
Notice that none of these items is about the number 200. The agreement is about learning, relationships and limits. The programme guide and the staff handle what counts as hours.
3. Who a supervisor is
A supervisor is a person who is responsible for your learning in the placement: someone who teaches you, oversees what you do, meets you regularly, and, at the end, confirms the placement. These three actions are separate. A person may teach you without overseeing your work, or oversee your work without teaching you. A good supervisor does both, and also takes the confirmation seriously.
The programme guide and the school's staff decide who may be a supervisor. This seminar does not set qualifications, and it does not say that a supervisor must be ordained, paid, trained or of any tradition. If you are not sure whether a person may supervise you, ask the staff before you begin. Do not suppose that a person is eligible only because they are kind or senior.
A supervisor is also a person with limits. Many supervisors are volunteers. Some are pastors or priests with a heavy load, some are teachers or nurses who supervise in addition to a full job, and some have never supervised before. They have an inner life, a family and bad days. This is why the agreement matters: it helps a person with little time to give the time they can.
What does a good use of a supervisor's authority look like? It looks like giving reasons when saying no. It looks like letting the student try tasks that stretch them, with a safe way to ask for help. It looks like telling the student the truth about their work, kindly and promptly, and not saving it for the end. It looks like keeping the confirmation honest: signing what was done, and not what was hoped. A supervisor who does these things is giving the student a great deal, even if the meetings are short.
And what does a good use of a student's trust look like? Telling the supervisor what is really happening, including mistakes. Asking for help early. Keeping to the agreed time, and saying so when something changes. Accepting correction without making the supervisor afraid to give it. Neither side has to be perfect. Both have to be honest.
4. A sample agreement, weak and better
Here is an invented example. It is only a sample, and a real agreement will be different because every place is different. Read the weak draft first, and ask what is missing.
(An invented example.) Joy will serve at a small after-school programme for children, run by a congregation. She and her supervisor, a volunteer who leads the programme, write down this plan.
A weak draft
| Part | What it says |
|---|---|
| Aims | To help at the programme and gain experience. |
| Tasks | To help with whatever is needed. |
| Hours | To come when she can. |
| Meetings | To talk when there is time. |
| Records | To keep notes if needed. |
| Ending | To finish when the hours are done. |
Nothing in this draft is wrong. But nothing in it can be checked. "Gain experience" cannot be learned or missed. "Whatever is needed" includes tasks Joy is not ready for, such as handling a child's serious difficulty alone. "When she can" and "when there is time" mean that nobody will notice when the arrangement stops working. And there is nothing about whom to tell if she is worried, or what to do if the arrangement does not work. A draft like this is not a lie, but it is a promise that cannot be kept, because it promises nothing.
A better draft
| Part | What it says |
|---|---|
| Aims | To learn to lead a short activity with a group of children. To learn how to respond calmly when a child is upset. To notice what helps children trust an adult. |
| Tasks taken | Help set up each session. Lead one short activity after the first month, with the supervisor present. Sit with the children during the meal. |
| Tasks not taken | Does not give a child private counselling. Does not give any medicine. Does not take a child home or arrange a meeting outside the programme. Passes to the supervisor anything a child says that causes worry. |
| Pattern | Two afternoons each week and a monthly Saturday event. Tells the supervisor by message if she cannot come, and does so before the session. |
| Meetings | Fifteen minutes with the supervisor after the second session each week; a longer conversation once a month. At each meeting Joy brings one question and one thing she noticed. |
| Records | A short note after each session, without real names or identifying detail, kept in a notebook that stays with her. She does not share it without checking with the supervisor. |
| Whom she tells | If she is worried about a child, or about her own safety, she tells the supervisor at once. If the supervisor cannot be reached, she tells the programme's second leader. In immediate danger, she calls the local emergency number. |
| Change or ending | If either wants to change the plan, they say so at a monthly meeting and write the new plan. If the arrangement cannot continue, they tell each other and talk with the school's staff about what to do next. |
The better draft is not longer for the sake of length. Each line says something that can be checked. The aims name learning. The tasks include a clear step, to lead an activity after the first month, which gives the learning a place to happen. The matters Joy will pass on are named, and whom she tells is plain. If something goes wrong, there is a way to talk about it.
Notice also what is not in either draft: the number of hours that count, the form of the confirmation, any deadline. Those belong to the programme guide and the staff. A student who writes in such details from guesswork may mislead everyone.
5. When the agreement is tested
An agreement is not finished when it is signed. It is used. Here are two small cases of what that looks like.
(An invented example.) Daniel's agreement says that he and his supervisor will meet every second week. After two meetings, the supervisor cancels three in a row because of illness in the family. Daniel says nothing, because he does not want to add to the burden. After two months, he realises that he has been serving without teaching for weeks.
What was crossed here is that kindness became silence. A better path is for Daniel to go back to the agreement and say gently, "We agreed to meet every second week and we have not been able to. I know things are hard for you. Could we find a time that is possible, even if it is short? Or is there someone else who could meet with me while things are difficult?" He is not accusing anyone. He is bringing the agreement back into the room. If the supervisor cannot meet at all, the school's staff can be asked what to do. The programme guide and the staff decide what happens next.
(An invented example.) Esther's agreement lists "visiting people in their homes" as a task. At the first meeting the supervisor says, "Start with the visits, and then we will see." Within a week she is visiting a man who is very ill, alone. She has been given no instruction on what to do if he asks her something she cannot answer. She feels out of her depth but does not want to seem unwilling.
What was crossed here is that the list of tasks had no limits. A better path is for Esther to say, before the next visit, "I would like to be clear about what I should do and not do. If he asks about his treatment, or if I am worried about him, who should I tell?" The supervisor can then add a line to the agreement. It is the student's right and the student's duty to ask. A supervisor who is asked a question like this has been helped, because the question exposes a gap that would have caused harm.
An agreement is a conversation on paper
It can be changed whenever both agree and the programme guide allows it. A page that is never looked at has failed, however well it was written.
Diagram 1. The parts of a learning agreement
핵심 요약
- A learning agreement is a written plan between student and supervisor; the programme guide and the staff may require a particular form, and this seminar invents none.
- A good agreement states aims as learning, tasks taken, tasks not taken, a practical pattern of time, regular meetings, records, whom to tell, and how the placement may change or end.
- A supervisor teaches, oversees and confirms; the programme guide and the staff decide who may supervise.
- A supervisor is a person with limits, and an agreement helps a person with little time to give what they can.
- A weak draft promises nothing that can be checked; a better one names learning, limits and a way to talk when the plan is not working.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| A learning agreement | A written plan agreed between student and supervisor: aims, tasks taken and not taken, pattern of time, meetings, records, whom to tell, how it may change or end. |
| Why write what you will not take on | It protects the student and the people served, and it shows the supervisor that the student knows the limit. |
| The three jobs of a supervisor | Teaches, oversees and confirms. Who may supervise is set by the programme guide and the staff. |
| What makes a draft weak | Aims and tasks that cannot be checked, no limits, no fixed meetings, and no way to talk when it fails. |
One sentence to remember An agreement is worth writing when it can be checked and changed.
This week's action Write the first two lines of your own agreement: one aim stated as learning, and one task you will not take on yet. If you are not yet in a placement, write them for a place you expect.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- Look at the weak draft. Which line would you most want to change first, and why?
- Why do you think many first drafts leave out "tasks not taken"? What does it cost a student to write it, and what does it protect?
- The supervisor of a placement has limits. What are some ways a student can help a busy supervisor to give the time they really can?
- In what situation might it be hard for you to tell a supervisor the truth about a mistake? What would make it easier?
- If the programme guide asks for a particular form, and your supervisor would prefer a different one, whom would you ask?