Lecture 4-4: Disagreements in Today's Praying
목차 31
- Lecture 1-1: How Scripture Shows Us Prayer
- Lecture 1-2: The Early Church at Prayer
- Lecture 1-3: The Desert and the Monastery
- Lecture 1-4: Praying the Psalms with the Church
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: The Lord's Prayer, Slowly
- Lecture 2-1: The Eastern Way: The Jesus Prayer and the Quiet
- Lecture 2-2: The Western Middle Ages: Hours and Holy Reading
- Lecture 2-3: The Mystics and the Dark Nights
- Lecture 2-4: Praying with Mary and the Saints?
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Holy Reading
- Lecture 3-1: Luther and Calvin at Prayer
- Lecture 3-2: Common Prayer, Quiet Gatherings, and the Examen
- Lecture 3-3: Puritans, Pietists, Moravians, Wesley
- Lecture 3-4: Brother Lawrence and Prayer in Daily Work
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Praying with a Frame
- Lecture 4-1: Revival and Mission
- Lecture 4-2: Prayer in Korea and Elsewhere
- Lecture 4-3: The Twentieth Century: Many Streams
- Lecture 4-4: Disagreements in Today's Praying
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: A Daily Rhythm
- Lecture 5-1: A Map of Prayer
- Lecture 5-2: Asking, Answers, and Unanswered Prayer
- Lecture 5-3: Dryness, Distraction and Silence
- Lecture 5-4: Praying Together
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: A Prayer Log and a Prayer Partner
Christians who agree about almost everything can still disagree about how to pray. Some of the disagreements are small and some are serious. This lecture takes three of them: wordless, contemplative prayer and speaking in tongues in prayer; the idea that prayer is a way to gain wealth or health; and the practical question of how to learn from a tradition that is not your own.
The aim is not to settle these questions. Many of them have been argued for centuries, by people who love God and love the Scripture. The aim is to help you state each position as its own supporters would, to see what they fear, and to know what you can do while the questions remain open. A reader who can explain a view they do not hold, so that someone who does hold it says, "yes, that is what I mean," has learned more than a reader who has chosen a side.
This lecture does not name or judge any present-day person, church or ministry. Where it describes a teaching, it describes the teaching.
이 22분으로 얻는 것
- State, in each side's strongest form, the supporters' and critics' arguments about contemplative or centering prayer.
- Say how a tradition that practises praying in tongues understands it, and what the main objections are, without arguing the theology.
- Explain the critique of prayer as a means to wealth or health, and the reasons given by those who teach it.
- Use a set of questions to learn from a tradition that is not your own, without either copying it blindly or condemning it.
When you pray, you shall not be as the hypocrites, for they love to stand and pray in the synagogues and in the corners of the streets, that they may be seen by men. Most certainly, I tell you, they have received their reward." — Matthew 6:5
World English Bible
In praying, don’t use vain repetitions, as the Gentiles do; for they think that they will be heard for their much speaking." — Matthew 6:7
WEB
Therefore don’t be like them, for your Father knows what things you need, before you ask him." — Matthew 6:8
WEB
But the tax collector, standing far away, wouldn’t even lift up his eyes to heaven, but beat his breast, saying, ‘God, be merciful to me, a sinner!’" — Luke 18:13
WEB
I tell you, this man went down to his house justified rather than the other; for everyone who exalts himself will be humbled, but he who humbles himself will be exalted.”" — Luke 18:14
WEB
For if I pray in another language, my spirit prays, but my understanding is unfruitful." — 1 Corinthians 14:14
WEB
What is it then? I will pray with the spirit, and I will pray with the understanding also. I will sing with the spirit, and I will sing with the understanding also." — 1 Corinthians 14:15
WEB
Matthew 6 and Luke 18 are the two places where Jesus speaks most directly about how not to pray. First Corinthians 14 is the passage most often cited in the discussion about prayer in tongues. They are read here as the starting point for a discussion, not as a way of ending one.
1. Two kinds of disagreement
Before looking at any case, a distinction helps. Some disagreements are about facts: did this thing happen, what did this text mean? Others are about method: is this a safe or faithful way to pray? And some are about purpose: what is prayer for? It is easy to treat a disagreement of one kind as if it were another, and then to talk past each other.
The three cases below are of different kinds. Wordless prayer and tongues are mainly about method. The prayer-for-wealth question is mainly about purpose. The last section, on learning from others, is about how to live with all three.
2. Contemplative and centering prayer
What it is. Lecture 2-3 introduced The Cloud of Unknowing, and lecture 4-3 described centering prayer as taught by Trappist monks in the 1970s. The practice, in its usual form, is simple. The person sits quietly for a set time, often twenty minutes. They choose a single word as a sign that they are willing to be with God. When thoughts arise, they gently return to the word. They do not try to produce feelings or visions. The wider category, "contemplative prayer", includes many forms of wordless, attentive prayer found in different centuries and traditions.
This is a point where readers will not agree.
Those who support it give several reasons. The practice has deep roots: the desert fathers' short repeated prayers, Cassian's writings, the medieval authors who wrote about a "cloud of unknowing", and Eastern teaching on quiet. It answers a real problem, which is that many people, in a noisy world, find it hard to be still at all. It is not an attempt to empty the mind of God. Its supporters say it is the opposite: a way of consenting to God's presence under all the thoughts. And they point to Scripture's invitations to stillness and to Romans 8:26, where the Spirit prays when words fail.
Those who criticise it, from several traditions, give other reasons. Some Protestant and evangelical writers worry that a practice with no content may open the person to influences other than the Holy Spirit, and that it may be too close to meditation methods from other religions. They say that biblical meditation is always on something: God's word, God's works. Some also say that silence with no word of Scripture does not obviously meet Paul's call to pray with the understanding also (1 Corinthians 14:15). A Catholic document from the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith in 1989, a letter on Christian meditation, warned against methods taken from other religions that lose their centre in Christ and the Church, and spoke of the need for discernment. Orthodox teachers likewise tend to say that practices of inner quiet should be taken only with an experienced guide, inside the Church's life.
Notice that the debate does not run neatly along denominational lines. There are Catholics who practise centering prayer and Catholics who have doubts about it, evangelicals who practise something like it and evangelicals who reject it. Each person's reasons deserve a hearing.
What this course requires. Less than either side asks. It does not require you to take up wordless prayer, and it does not require you to avoid it. It asks that you follow the guidance of your own community and your own pastor or priest, that you know the debate before you decide, and that you do not judge the person who decides differently. If you try silence and find it hard, or if it brings up distress, stop. Silence is optional, and the other practices of this course are enough.
3. Tongues in prayer
The question here is small in one sense, because it concerns one practice. It is large in another, because the practice is central to the lives of millions of Christians and is opposed by others. The theology of the Spirit's gifts belongs to Systematic Theology VI: Pneumatology (ST6E), and this lecture will not try to resolve it. It will only say how the question touches prayer.
How the tradition that practises it understands it. Pentecostal and charismatic Christians generally hold that praying in tongues is a gift of the Spirit that the believer uses in prayer. They read 1 Corinthians 14:14-15 as Paul's description of praying "in another language", in which "my spirit prays". They say it can be used privately, to pray when one has no words, and many link it with the "groanings which can’t be uttered" of Romans 8:26. Some also practise it in the gathered church, where Paul says it should be done in order, one at a time, with someone to interpret (1 Corinthians 14:27-28).
This is a point where readers will not agree.
Other Christians understand the same chapter differently. Some believe that the gift of tongues was given for the early church and has ceased. Some believe the gift continues but is not given to all, and they point to Paul's questions, "Do all speak with various languages?" (1 Corinthians 12:30), expecting the answer no. Some are concerned about order and about the effect on people who visit a church. They point to Paul's own words, that in the assembly he would rather speak five words with understanding than ten thousand in another language (1 Corinthians 14:19). And some Christians, in the Catholic, Orthodox and Anglican traditions, hold views that do not fit either camp.
Supporters answer that Paul himself says, "I thank my God, I speak with other languages more than you all" (1 Corinthians 14:18), and that the same chapter that asks for order also says, “don’t forbid speaking with other languages” (1 Corinthians 14:39). Critics reply that the whole chapter is a correction of a church that valued the gift too much. Each is reading the same text with care.
What this course requires. That you describe the practice as its practitioners do. That you follow the teaching of your own community. That you do not mock someone who prays this way, and do not press someone who does not. And that you remember Paul's own guide in 1 Corinthians 14:15, where both the spirit and the understanding have a place.
4. Prayer as a means to wealth or health
A third discussion is about the purpose of prayer rather than its method. In several traditions, and in some popular media, there is teaching that presents prayer as the way to obtain material blessing: money, success, health, a house. We will call it simply "prayer as a means to wealth or health". The description that follows is of a type of teaching, not of any group.
What those who teach it say. They say that God is good and wants his children to flourish. They point out that Scripture's prayers often ask for ordinary goods: daily bread, safety, healing, a good harvest. They say that Jesus invites us to ask, and that poor people have been told for too long to expect nothing. They say that hope is a gift, and that people stirred by faith that God will provide have often found strength to work and to rise out of hardship.
What the critics say. The critique has been made by Christians of many kinds, including some within communities that teach such things. It can be put in four points.
- It turns prayer into a transaction. Jesus' warning in Matthew 6:7-8, not to pile up words as if God needed persuading, and his reminder that the Father knows what we need, points away from prayer as a technique that produces results.
- It puts the failure on the person. If prayer guarantees a result, then a person who stays poor or ill must not have prayed well, or believed enough. This is cruel, and it is not what Scripture says to the sufferer. The Psalms of lament do not tell the suffering to try harder, and the Book of Job rejects the friends who say it.
- It narrows what God is for. The parable in Luke 18:9-14 ends with a man who asks for nothing but mercy. A prayer life made entirely of requests for gain misses other voices: praise, confession, lament, silence.
- It can be used to take money. Where a leader says that giving to the ministry will bring a return, the prayer is in danger of being used for the leader's benefit. (Lecture 6-2 returns to this.)
A fair common ground. Most critics agree that it is right to ask God for daily needs, and that it is right to hope. Most supporters agree that God is not obliged to give what we ask. The sharpest point of disagreement is whether prayer, rightly done, guarantees a particular outcome. This course holds that it does not, and that prayer and medical care, honest work and generous community go together. A person who is ill needs a doctor and prayer, not one in place of the other. Lecture 5-2 returns to asking, answers and unanswered prayer.
5. Learning from a tradition that is not yours
Now the practical question. You have met in this course forms of prayer from many traditions. Some you found moving. Some you found strange. Some you were taught to avoid. How do you learn from a tradition that is not yours?
There are two mistakes, and both are tempting.
The first mistake is to copy. You see something beautiful, perhaps a chant, a prayer rope, an hour of silence or a way of praying aloud, and you take it whole, without asking what it means in its home or what your own community would say. A practice can lose its meaning when lifted out of the life that held it. And it may sit badly with what you believe, or leave you without the guidance the tradition itself would have given.
The second mistake is to condemn. You see something unfamiliar and decide at once that it is empty, dangerous or unbiblical. The Pharisee of Luke 18 prayed, "God, I thank you, that I am not like the rest of men", and Jesus said the tax collector went home right with God. A prayer whose chief content is a comparison with other people's prayer has gone wrong, whatever its form.
Between those two mistakes there is a narrow, honest path. Here are six questions to walk it.
- What is it for? Ask people who practise it, in their own words, and not only critics or enthusiasts.
- What does the tradition itself say about its risks? Almost every tradition has cautions. Read them.
- What does my own community teach? Ask your pastor, priest or . If your community has said no, ask why before deciding.
- Is there a guide? Some practices need an experienced person alongside.
- What is the stop-sign? Decide in advance what will make you stop: distress, confusion, pressure, a sense that it is taking the place of something more important.
- What is the smallest honest step? Often it is not to adopt the practice, but to learn the one thing behind it: to be quiet for two minutes, to say one line slowly, to ask someone how they pray.
This is not a recipe for agreement. You may end up deciding that a practice is not for you, and that decision can be as faithful as adopting it. The point is that the decision is made by knowing, and not by fear or by fashion.
Diagram 1. Six questions for learning from a tradition not your own
핵심 요약
- Disagreements about prayer can be about facts, method or purpose, and it helps to know which kind you are in.
- Supporters of contemplative prayer cite its old roots and its answer to restlessness. Critics ask about content, discernment and guidance. Both sides exist in many traditions.
- Pentecostal and charismatic Christians understand praying in tongues as a gift of the Spirit. Others hold that it has ceased, is not for all, or needs order. This course describes; it does not settle.
- Critics of prayer as a means to wealth or health say it makes prayer a transaction and blames the sufferer. Prayer and medical care go together.
- Learning from another tradition avoids two mistakes: copying without questions, and condemning without knowing.
- Six questions help: what is it for, its cautions, my community's teaching, a guide, a stop-sign, the smallest honest step.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Centering prayer, in brief | Sitting quietly, choosing one word as a sign of consent to God, and returning to it when the mind wanders. |
| Why critics worry about it | Possible lack of content, borrowed methods, need for discernment and a guide. |
| A main critique of prayer for wealth or health | It turns prayer into a transaction and can blame a person who stays poor or ill. |
| The two mistakes with another tradition | Copying it whole without questions, or condemning it without knowing. |
One sentence to remember You can learn from a tradition that is not yours without copying it and without condemning it, by asking honest questions first.
This week's action Pick one practice from another tradition and write its answers to the first two of the six questions: what it is for, and what its own cautions are.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- Try to state the case for centering prayer so that someone who practises it would say, "yes, that is what I mean". Then do the same for the case against it.
- The lecture says it will not settle the question of tongues. Why might it be wiser, in a course on prayer, to describe the practice than to argue the theology?
- The critics of prayer as a means to wealth say that it puts the failure on the person. Why is that a serious charge? What would you say to someone who has been told that their illness shows weak faith?
- What makes the Pharisee in Luke 18 a warning for anyone who studies other people's prayer, including this lecture's reader?
- Think of a practice from another tradition that you are curious about. Walk through the six questions. What do you learn?
- Is there a practice in your own tradition that others misunderstand? How would you explain it fairly?