Lecture 1-3: The Youth Worker's Place and Limits
목차 31
- Lecture 1-1: Companions, Not Projects
- Lecture 1-2: Many Shapes of Youth Ministry
- Lecture 1-3: The Youth Worker's Place and Limits
- Lecture 1-4: What Youth Ministry Is For
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: The Shape of Our Youth Ministry
- Lecture 2-1: Reading Culture With Curiosity
- Lecture 2-2: Friends, Belonging and Loneliness
- Lecture 2-3: School, Work and the Pressure of Time
- Lecture 2-4: Faith Among Many Beliefs
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: One Question of Curiosity
- Lecture 3-1: Relationship Is the Ministry
- Lecture 3-2: Boundaries for Mentors
- Lecture 3-3: Listening and Passing On
- Lecture 3-4: Mentoring Across Differences
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: What I Will Say and What I Will Not Do
- Lecture 4-1: The Shape of a Youth Gathering
- Lecture 4-2: Small Groups and Honest Conversation
- Lecture 4-3: Camps, Trips and Events
- Lecture 4-4: Talking About Hard Topics
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: One Evening and Its Risks
- Lecture 5-1: Prayer, Scripture and Worship With Young People
- Lecture 5-2: Serving and Leading
- Lecture 5-3: Sharing Faith Without Pressure
- Lecture 5-4: Faith in Daily Choices
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: One Small Way to Live It
Ngozi is nineteen and studies engineering. Two years ago her parish asked whether she would help with the teenagers on Friday evenings, because she was the only young adult who had said she might. She said yes. Now she is the person fourteen young people text when they are bored, when their parents are shouting, when they have failed a test, or when it is eleven at night and they cannot sleep. She is warm, she is funny, and she is tired. Last week one of the girls wrote: "You are the only person I can tell." Ngozi felt proud and frightened in the same moment, and she did not know which feeling to trust. (An invented example.)
Ngozi's situation is not unusual. People who work with young people are often asked to be more than one thing at once, and they tend to say yes. The community needs a teacher, a leader, a friend, a driver, a cook and a counsellor, and there is one willing person. The need is real. But there is a cost, and the cost falls on the worker and on the young people.
This lecture asks a plain question: what is the place of a youth worker, and where are the limits? The answer is neither "do everything" nor "keep your distance". It is that a youth worker is a trustworthy adult beside a young person, who is not a parent, not a counsellor and not a best friend, and who does not carry the work alone. That is a smaller job than the one people often imagine. It is also a job a person can do for years.
이 24분으로 얻는 것
- Describe the pull and the risk in five common roles: teacher, leader, young adult leader, clergy and parent-helper.
- Explain in your own words why a youth worker is not a parent, a counsellor or a best friend, and what a worker is instead.
- Explain why a young leader only a few years older has both a special place and a special risk.
- Give two reasons from Scripture for sharing the work, and one practical way to do it.
Moses’ father-in-law said to him, “The thing that you do is not good. You will surely wear away, both you, and this people that is with you; for the thing is too heavy for you. You are not able to perform it yourself alone." — Exodus 18:17-18
World English Bible
Even so, affectionately longing for you, we were well pleased to impart to you, not the Good News of God only, but also our own souls, because you had become very dear to us." — 1 Thessalonians 2:8
WEB
Therefore select from among you, brothers, seven men of good report, full of the Holy Spirit and of wisdom, whom we may appoint over this business." — Acts 6:3
WEB
Moses is told that the work is too heavy to do alone. Paul describes love that gives more than a message. The apostles share a burden with people chosen by the community. Taken together, they say two things that sound opposed: give yourself, and do not try to be everything.
1. Five people, one need
Most people who work with young people arrive by one of five roads. Each road has a natural strength and a natural pull. Look for yourself in the list.
The teacher. A school teacher, a catechist or a confirmation instructor already knows how to run a room and has authority in the eyes of the young people. The strength is skill and respect. The pull is to treat the youth gathering as another lesson, with a plan to cover and a result to check. The young person who has been in a classroom all week may feel that the church is just more school. (The craft of teaching belongs to LM402E, How to Teach.)
The leader. Some people organise by temperament. They plan, recruit helpers, book the hall and keep the calendar. The strength is order; without it nothing happens. The pull is to be satisfied with a good event and to miss the one young person who spoke to nobody.
The young adult leader. A person in their late teens or twenties is close enough in age to understand the language and the humour, and may be admired. The strength is real, and so is the risk. We look at it below.
The clergy or the pastoral leader. A priest, pastor, or carries the community's authority. Young people may see them as "the church" in person. The strength is trust and a long view. The pull is to treat youth work as one item in a crowded week, and the risk is that a young person who needs a trusted adult finds only a person in a hurry. A young person may find it hard to say what they really think to someone who holds so much authority, so it helps to ask who else is near enough for them to talk to.
The parent-helper. A mother or father who helps with the group because their own child is in it, or because there is no one else. The strength is stability and a stake in the community. The pull is to treat the group as an extension of the family, and the risk is that the child of the helper is in an awkward position, either treated too strictly or too leniently, and the other young people notice. A parent-helper may do best to lead a group that their own child is not in, if the community can arrange it.
No road is better. Most people are two or three of these at once. The point is to know which pull you are likely to feel.
2. What a youth worker is not
Because the needs are great, it is easy to drift into roles that do not belong to you. There are four common ones. Each is born of kindness, and each causes harm.
Not a parent. A parent has legal and moral responsibility for a child, a shared history and a daily presence. A youth worker has none of these. When a worker begins to speak as if they were the parent ("I will decide what is best for you"), they step on the family and risk a conflict the young person must carry. The worker's role is to support the family, not to replace it. If a young person's home is a hard place, the answer is not for the worker to take over. It is to tell the right person (lecture 3-3), and to stay a steady adult in the young person's life.
Not a counsellor. A youth worker listens. They may hear that a young person is sad, frightened or angry. But a worker is not trained to treat these things and should not try to. The ethic of this course is to notice, to stay and to pass on. A worker notices that something is wrong, stays with the young person in the conversation without hurrying away, and passes on to the person responsible and, where it is right, to someone with the right training. A worker who tries to treat a deep difficulty alone may delay real help. The skills of listening are the subject of LM205E, and the signs that a young person is struggling are taught in PT706E; this course asks only that you know where your part ends.
Not a best friend. A friendship is between equals, and it can keep secrets. A youth worker is an adult with responsibility. A young person who calls the worker "my best friend" is giving a compliment and telling you about their need for someone. The worker can be warm and can be glad of the closeness, and still know that they cannot promise to keep everything secret and cannot treat the young person as a confidant for the worker's own troubles. When a worker needs a friend, they need one among adults.
Not a saviour. There is a quiet temptation to believe that this young person's life will go well if only I am here. It feels like love. It is closer to a burden placed on a young person, who then feels responsible for the worker's hopes. God and the young person's own life are larger than any single adult. The worker's task is to be faithful for the time they are given, and to be able to let go.
Now put the four "nots" together. What is left is something smaller and sturdier: a trustworthy adult beside. Such an adult is steady, tells the truth, keeps their promises, respects the family, is open to correction, answers to someone, and knows who else is needed. That adult is not a hero. Many youth workers report that one such adult can make a large difference to a young person; that is a pastoral observation and not a measured fact, but it is a reason to take the small job seriously.
3. Why a few years makes a difference
Back to Ngozi. Young adult leaders deserve a section of their own, because in many communities they carry much of the work and are seldom prepared for it.
Their special place is real. A nineteen-year-old can say, "I remember that," and be believed. A young person may hear from a young adult what they would not hear from a parent or a priest. Young adult leaders show that faith belongs to the young as well as to the old, and they often give the best example of what the next five years can look like.
Their special risk has three parts.
- The role is blurred. A nineteen-year-old may be a friend of the sixteen-year-old's older sister, share the same social circles and follow the same accounts. It is hard to be both a friend and an adult with responsibility. The young person may not know which Ngozi they are talking to, and neither may Ngozi.
- The authority is thin. A young leader may feel unable to say no, to enforce a rule or to speak to a loud room, and may then quietly give up the structure that keeps everyone safe.
- The load is heavy. A young adult is also studying, working, finding a place to live and working out their own faith. They are often asked to do too much because they are willing and because they have not yet learned to refuse.
What does a young adult leader need? Not less trust, but more support. They need an older adult to whom they report and with whom they talk regularly. They need clear written expectations, including the community's policy on messages, meetings and what to do when a young person tells them something serious. They need permission to say "I cannot do this one" and to pass things on. And they need to hear plainly that a young person who says "you are the only person I can tell" is giving them an honour and a signal. The honour is to be received. The signal is to be acted on: tell the person responsible, as chapter 3 will explain. It is not a duty to carry the secret.
If Ngozi is reading this, her question is not "Am I doing something wrong?" She is doing something good. The question is "Who is beside me?"
4. Warmth is not the problem
Do not conclude from all this that a youth worker should be cool and distant. The opposite is true. In 1 Thessalonians 2, Paul describes his own conduct among the believers in Thessalonica in startlingly tender words: "we were gentle among you, like a nursing mother cherishes her own children" (verse 7). Then comes verse 8: "affectionately longing for you, we were well pleased to impart to you, not the Good News of God only, but also our own souls, because you had become very dear to us."
Notice the shape of that verse. Paul gives the message. He also gives himself: his time, his presence, his heart. People were dear to him. A youth worker who gives only a programme gives less than Paul did. The practice of ministry among young people is a practice of presence.
Two cautions keep this honest. First, Paul wrote to adults, in an age and a place very different from ours, and the verse does not tell a worker how to behave with a fifteen-year-old in a modern country; the habits and the written policy of the community do that, and chapter 3 of this course comes back to this. Second, giving oneself is not the same as giving everything. Warmth can be real and also bounded: the same worker who is affectionate in a group does not keep secrets from the person responsible, does not have a hidden channel to a single young person, and does not need the young person to love them. The boundaries are not the opposite of warmth. They are what keeps warmth safe for the young person and for the worker.
5. Do not carry it alone
In Exodus 18, Moses sits from morning to evening hearing the people's cases. His father-in-law watches and says: "The thing that you do is not good" (verse 17). It is a startling sentence. Moses is doing a good work for good reasons, and he is told that the way he is doing it is not good. The reason follows: "You will surely wear away, both you, and this people that is with you; for the thing is too heavy for you. You are not able to perform it yourself alone" (verse 18).
Two things are said. The worker will wear away, and so will the people. The weight harms those who carry it and those who wait to be served. Then the remedy is given in verses 21 and 22: appoint capable people, each over a manageable number, with small matters decided by them and great matters brought to Moses, so that "they shall share the load with you." Acts 6 repeats the pattern in the early church. The apostles do not say "we will try harder." They ask the community to choose seven who are known and trusted, and they keep to their own work.
A youth worker can apply this in four plain ways.
- Have a second adult. Not as a favour, but as the ordinary way of working. A second adult means that no one carries everything, that two people can notice what one misses, and that no one is left alone in a way that would be unsafe for the young person or for the adult. The details are the community's written policy and local law.
- Know who is responsible. Name the person you answer to, and tell them what you are carrying. The person might be a priest, an elder, a parent representative or a youth committee.
- Know who else is needed. A teacher for a young person who is failing at school, a doctor, a counsellor or a social service, a pastor for a question of faith. You do not have to be the person who answers every question. You can be the person who knows whom to ask.
- Plan your rest. A worker who never rests is not a more faithful worker. Lecture 6-3 returns to the care of the team.
For readers with one helper and no committee, this still applies, in a smaller form. The second adult might be a spouse, a friend from another church, or a retired neighbour. The person responsible might be your minister, or the parents of the young people together. The point is that you are not the only adult who knows what you are doing.
Diagram 1. Who stands around a young person
핵심 요약
- Youth workers arrive as teachers, leaders, young adult leaders, clergy or parent-helpers; each road has a strength and a pull.
- A youth worker is a trustworthy adult beside a young person: not a parent, not a counsellor, not a best friend, not a saviour.
- The ethic is to notice, to stay and to pass on; deep difficulties need the right person and the right training.
- A young leader a few years older has a real place and a special risk: a blurred role, thin authority and a heavy load; support matters more than distrust.
- Warmth is not the problem; Paul gave himself, and boundaries keep warmth safe.
- Share the work: a second adult, a named person responsible, others to call, and rest.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| What a youth worker is | A trustworthy adult beside a young person, who answers to someone and does not work alone. |
| What a worker is not | A parent, a counsellor, a best friend or a saviour. |
| Notice, stay, pass on | Notice that something is wrong, stay in the conversation, pass on to the person responsible and the right professional. |
| Why young leaders need more support | The role is blurred, the authority is thin and the load is heavy. |
One sentence to remember Give yourself to the young people you serve, and do not try to be everything to them.
This week's action Write the name of the person you answer to in your youth work, and tell them one thing you are carrying.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- Which of the five roads (teacher, leader, young adult leader, clergy, parent-helper) is closest to yours? What pull do you recognise?
- Of the four "nots" (parent, counsellor, best friend, saviour), which is the hardest for you to avoid? What makes it attractive?
- If a young person said to you "you are the only person I can tell", how would you want to respond in the first minute? Who would you want to tell afterwards?
- In your community, who is the person a youth worker answers to? If nobody, who could be?
- Moses was told that his good work was not good in its present form. Is there a good work you are doing in a way that is not good for you or for those you serve?
- Who is the second adult in your work? If there is none, what is the smallest step toward having one?