Lecture 2-1: Reading Culture With Curiosity
목차 31
- Lecture 1-1: Companions, Not Projects
- Lecture 1-2: Many Shapes of Youth Ministry
- Lecture 1-3: The Youth Worker's Place and Limits
- Lecture 1-4: What Youth Ministry Is For
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: The Shape of Our Youth Ministry
- Lecture 2-1: Reading Culture With Curiosity
- Lecture 2-2: Friends, Belonging and Loneliness
- Lecture 2-3: School, Work and the Pressure of Time
- Lecture 2-4: Faith Among Many Beliefs
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: One Question of Curiosity
- Lecture 3-1: Relationship Is the Ministry
- Lecture 3-2: Boundaries for Mentors
- Lecture 3-3: Listening and Passing On
- Lecture 3-4: Mentoring Across Differences
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: What I Will Say and What I Will Not Do
- Lecture 4-1: The Shape of a Youth Gathering
- Lecture 4-2: Small Groups and Honest Conversation
- Lecture 4-3: Camps, Trips and Events
- Lecture 4-4: Talking About Hard Topics
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: One Evening and Its Risks
- Lecture 5-1: Prayer, Scripture and Worship With Young People
- Lecture 5-2: Serving and Leading
- Lecture 5-3: Sharing Faith Without Pressure
- Lecture 5-4: Faith in Daily Choices
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: One Small Way to Live It
(An invented example.) Hana helps with the youth group at her parish. On the way back from a day trip, three of the young people in the minibus sing along to a song she has never heard. They know every word. They laugh at a line that she does not understand. She feels two things at once: a small wish to be part of the joke, and a small worry about what the song is saying. She says nothing. The song ends. The moment passes.
What Hana does next is the subject of this lecture. She can decide the song is a danger and say so. She can decide it is harmless and pretend to like it. Or she can do something slower: she can ask, "What is that song? Who is it by? What is the joke in that line?" and listen to the answer.
This week's principle is that we learn the world of young people by asking before judging, and we ask what the pressure is, not only what the behaviour is. This first lecture applies it to the most visible part of that world: music, film, games, trends and language. It makes three claims. Culture is first of all a language that young people speak, and only afterwards a possible danger. Real curiosity means real questions, not a pretended knowledge and not an imitation. And discernment is best done in conversation with the young person, and not over their head.
The lecture does not teach how young people develop or how screens affect them. That belongs to PT706E, How Children and Young People Grow in Faith.
이 25분으로 얻는 것
- Explain why culture is better understood first as a language than as a danger.
- Name the three common postures towards youth culture and state each one fairly.
- Ask a real question about a piece of youth culture without pretending to knowledge you do not have.
- Describe how a youth worker tests what young people enjoy through conversation, using the questions of 1 Thessalonians 5:21 and Philippians 4:8.
- Say why no single country's youth culture can be taken as the standard.
Paul stood in the middle of the Areopagus, and said, “You men of Athens, I perceive that you are very religious in all things. For as I passed along, and observed the objects of your worship, I found also an altar with this inscription: ‘TO AN UNKNOWN GOD.’ What therefore you worship in ignorance, this I announce to you. The God who made the world and all things in it, he, being Lord of heaven and earth, doesn’t dwell in temples made with hands, neither is he served by men’s hands, as though he needed anything, seeing he himself gives to all life and breath, and all things. He made from one blood every nation of men to dwell on all the surface of the earth, having determined appointed seasons, and the boundaries of their dwellings, that they should seek the Lord, if perhaps they might reach out for him and find him, though he is not far from each one of us. ‘For in him we live, and move, and have our being.’ As some of your own poets have said, ‘For we are also his offspring.’" — Acts 17:22-28
World English Bible
Test all things, and hold firmly that which is good." — 1 Thessalonians 5:21
WEB
Finally, brothers, whatever things are true, whatever things are honorable, whatever things are just, whatever things are pure, whatever things are lovely, whatever things are of good report; if there is any virtue, and if there is any praise, think about these things." — Philippians 4:8
WEB
The first passage is Paul speaking in Athens. He had walked through the city and looked at what its people worshipped before he said a word. He then spoke in terms they knew, even quoting their poets. The second and third passages give two tools for the next step: to test, and to look for what is true and lovely.
1. A language before a danger
Every group of people has ways of speaking that insiders understand at once and outsiders do not. Young people have them too: songs, films, videos, games, jokes, slang, clothes, ways of greeting, sports teams, favourite foods. Together these are young people's culture. In this lecture the word means the shared habits and shared stories of a group, and it does not mean only art.
The first thing to see is that culture is how young people talk to each other about what matters to them. A love song carries what a young person cannot yet say about a hope or a hurt. A game gives a group of friends an evening in which they are good at something together. A trend of clothing or speech says, "I belong here." When an adult sees only the risk in these things, the adult misses what they are for.
This is not a claim that everything in youth culture is good. Some of it is unkind, some of it is cheap, and some of it can harm. It is a claim about the order in which an adult looks. Look first at what it does for the young people, then at what it may do to them. An adult who begins with the danger often reads a whole culture as a threat and then cannot hear any young person speak about it. An adult who begins with curiosity will usually know more, and will be listened to when a real danger needs to be named.
2. What belongs to "their world"
A youth worker does not need to know everything. It helps to know what kinds of things there are to ask about.
- Music and sound: what they listen to, on what, with whom, and in which language.
- Film, video and stories: series, short videos, comics, books, and the characters they admire.
- Games: which ones, with whom, how long a session lasts, and what counts as winning.
- Sport and play: teams, matches, who is good, who is left out.
- Language and humour: words that change fast, jokes between friends, what is funny and what is not.
- Clothes, food and style: what marks a group, and what costs money.
- The online world: where friends meet. The effects of screens on young people belong to PT706E; here it is enough to say that it is another place where culture lives, and to ask about it with the same curiosity.
Now an important caution. Youth culture is not the same in every country, or even in every town or family. A young person in a large city with fast internet, a young person in a village where the shared phone is used for one hour in the evening, and a young person who moves each year with a family of migrant workers live in different worlds. Some young people have a great deal of money to spend on style; many have almost none. Some are free to roam; some are not allowed out after dark. A book about teenagers written in one country describes teenagers in that country. Do not treat any one country's teenage life as the standard, and be careful of any sentence that begins "Young people today…" The right sentence is usually "Some of the young people I know…" or "Ask them."
3. Three postures, and one that is not a posture
Communities take three common stances towards youth culture.
This is a point where readers will not agree. Some Christians see youth culture chiefly as a risk that adults must guard against. They point out, truthfully, that young people are open to influence, that commercial interests aim at them, and that some content is harmful; and they hold that the church's first duty is to protect. Others see culture chiefly as a language to be learned. They point to the way Paul spoke in Athens, to the fact that many generations of adults have called the songs of the young dangerous, and to the way that listening gives an adult a bridge. Others stress critical discernment: neither fearing nor welcoming, but teaching young people to ask what a piece of culture assumes and what it asks of them. Most good youth workers use all three at different times. This course requires less than any of them requires on its own: begin with curiosity and listening before judging, and do not imitate everything. Whether a particular song, game or show is acceptable in a particular community is a matter for that community and its parents. The course does not decide it, and no lecture can decide it for a place it has never seen.
There is also something that is not a posture and is worth naming: imitation. Some adults, wishing to be close, adopt young people's slang, buy their clothes, and mention their favourite band in every talk. Young people usually notice. Many find it uncomfortable, and some find it false. The aim is not to become like young people. It is to be an honest adult who is interested in them. "I do not know that game; explain it to me" does more than a bad copy of their slang.
4. How Paul walked through Athens
Acts 17 gives a picture of an outsider meeting another culture. Paul waited in Athens for his friends, and "his spirit was provoked within him as he saw the city full of idols" (verse 16). That is honest: he was troubled. But look at what he does with the trouble. He does not shout from the steps. He reasons in the synagogue and in the marketplace "every day with those who met him" (verse 17), so he spends time with the people. When he is asked to speak at the Areopagus, he begins with something he has seen: "as I passed along, and observed the objects of your worship, I found also an altar with this inscription: 'TO AN UNKNOWN GOD'" (verse 23). He has looked closely at their world and found a place to start. He also quotes their own poets (verse 28).
Notice five things.
First, he looked before he spoke. He walked past the objects of worship and read what was written on them.
Second, he began from something the Athenians already said, not from what they lacked. The altar was theirs.
Third, he did not pretend to agree with everything. The speech goes on to say that God does not live in shrines made by hands, and that the times of ignorance are over (verses 24 and 30). He kept his own convictions.
Fourth, the result was mixed. Some mocked, some said "We want to hear you again", and a few believed (verses 32-34). Curiosity does not guarantee agreement. It earns a hearing, and a hearing is all that an honest person can ask.
Fifth, Paul was an adult speaking to adults in a public place. Nothing in the passage tells us how to speak to a fifteen-year-old, so it should not be pressed into a method. What it offers is a habit: look, begin from what is theirs, keep your convictions, and accept the result.
5. Real questions
Curiosity is not a mood. It is a skill, and it begins with the kind of question you ask.
A real question is one where you do not know the answer and want it. "What do you like about this?" "Who is your favourite character, and why?" "What is the goal in this game, and what makes someone good at it?" "Which of your friends listens to this?" "What does that word mean when you use it?" A real question asks for a story or an explanation, and it can be answered with more than yes or no.
A disguised question is a judgement with a question mark on the end. "Do you really think that is a good thing to watch?" "Don't you think that song is a bit much?" Young people hear the difference at once, and the conversation ends. If you have a worry, say it as a worry, once, kindly, after you have listened: "I would like to understand more about it. One thing I wondered about was this line. What do you think it means?"
Some habits help.
- Ask one question and wait. Do not ask three in a row.
- Let the young person be the expert. In this one area, they are.
- Say "I do not know." An adult who does not know and says so is more trusted than one who pretends.
- Do not turn the answer into a lesson. If a young person tells you what a song means to them, the right answer is "thank you for telling me," and not a sermon. A sermon teaches them not to tell you again.
- Keep what you hear in the conversation. What a young person says about their taste or their world is not a story to repeat to other adults. Lecture 3-3 deals with the few things that must be passed on.
6. Testing together
Curiosity is not the same as approval. The same Paul who spoke at Athens wrote, "Test all things, and hold firmly that which is good" (1 Thessalonians 5:21), and the letter to the Philippians gives a list of things worth thinking about: whatever is true, honorable, just, pure, lovely and of good report (Philippians 4:8). Both verses ask for testing and for choosing, and both assume that the believer will do it.
The question is who does the testing. An adult can test for the young person and announce the result: "This is fine; this is not." That is quick, and it works while the adult is present. Or the adult can test with the young person, by asking the questions that the two verses suggest.
- Is it true? What does this song or show say about people, love, money, success? Is that how things are?
- Is it kind? How does it treat people who are different, weaker, or on the other side?
- What does it ask of me? Does it ask me to want something, buy something, hate someone?
- What does it give me? A laugh, a feeling, a friend, a skill, a place?
- What do I want to keep, and what do I want to leave?
(An invented example.) Kwame, who is fifteen, plays an online game for two hours most evenings with friends from his school. His youth leader Ruth had decided in advance that she disliked the game. She asked instead, "Tell me how it works." Kwame explained the teams, the rules and the way his friends plan together. Ruth then asked, "What do you like best about it?" He said, "That we are a team and we win together." After a pause he added, "I don't like it when people shout at each other." Ruth said, "That sounds important." She had not given an opinion. Kwame had given his own, and it was a fair one. Many weeks later he mentioned, on his own, that he had started muting a player who shouted. Ruth did not tell him what to do. She listened, and he tested.
This does not mean that an adult must never say no. A community has rules about what may be shown or played in its own gatherings, and those rules should be kept and explained. A parent has the right to decide what a child watches at home. And a youth worker who hears something that signals danger to a young person should not wait for a conversation to unfold: that is a matter to pass on (lecture 3-3). What this lecture asks is that the ordinary run of conversation about culture is a conversation, and not a series of verdicts.
7. The same habit in different communities
In a liturgical parish the youth may be asked to sing the chant or serve at the altar on Sunday and listen to different music on every other day. The youth worker's task is not to pull the two apart but to ask what each means: "What do you notice when you hear this on Sunday, and when you hear that in your headphones?" In a free-church assembly with a band, the question of culture comes up in the worship itself: whose music is it, and who chose it? A good question to ask the young musicians is "What helps you pray?" In a small house church with three teenagers and no budget, the youth worker may simply spend a car journey asking each one to choose a song. In every case the first step costs nothing: one honest question and the willingness to listen.
Diagram 1. From noticing to deciding
핵심 요약
- Culture is first of all a language that young people speak to each other; look at what it does for them before what it may do to them.
- Youth culture differs by country, town and family, so no single country's teenage life is the standard.
- Communities guard, learn or discern; this course asks for curiosity and listening before judging, and no imitation of everything.
- Paul in Athens looked, began from what was theirs, kept his convictions and accepted a mixed result.
- Ask a real question, wait, let the young person be the expert, and say "I do not know" when it is true.
- Test together: is it true, is it kind, what does it ask, what do I keep and what do I leave?
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Culture first as... | A language that young people speak, before it is a danger. |
| The three postures | Guard against it, learn it as a language, or discern it critically. |
| Real or disguised question? | A real one wants an answer; a disguised one is a verdict with a question mark. |
| Testing together | Ask with the young person: is it true, is it kind, what does it ask, what do I keep? |
One sentence to remember Look at what it does for them before what it may do to them, and ask before you judge.
This week's action Ask one young person to explain one thing they enjoy, listen for five minutes, and do not give your opinion.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- What is one piece of young people's culture that you do not understand at all? What would be one real question you could ask about it?
- Which of the three postures (guard, learn, discern) is nearest to your own community's habit? What does it see well, and what does it miss?
- Recall a time when an adult spoke to you about something you liked, in a way that closed the conversation. What did they say? What would have kept it open?
- In Acts 17, Paul began from something the Athenians already had. In your place, what do young people already have that you could begin from?
- Where you live, what is young people's culture like, and how is it different from what you see on screens from other countries?
- Which of the five questions in "Testing together" would you find hardest to ask, and why?