Lecture 1-1: Companions, Not Projects
목차 31
- Lecture 1-1: Companions, Not Projects
- Lecture 1-2: Many Shapes of Youth Ministry
- Lecture 1-3: The Youth Worker's Place and Limits
- Lecture 1-4: What Youth Ministry Is For
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: The Shape of Our Youth Ministry
- Lecture 2-1: Reading Culture With Curiosity
- Lecture 2-2: Friends, Belonging and Loneliness
- Lecture 2-3: School, Work and the Pressure of Time
- Lecture 2-4: Faith Among Many Beliefs
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: One Question of Curiosity
- Lecture 3-1: Relationship Is the Ministry
- Lecture 3-2: Boundaries for Mentors
- Lecture 3-3: Listening and Passing On
- Lecture 3-4: Mentoring Across Differences
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: What I Will Say and What I Will Not Do
- Lecture 4-1: The Shape of a Youth Gathering
- Lecture 4-2: Small Groups and Honest Conversation
- Lecture 4-3: Camps, Trips and Events
- Lecture 4-4: Talking About Hard Topics
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: One Evening and Its Risks
- Lecture 5-1: Prayer, Scripture and Worship With Young People
- Lecture 5-2: Serving and Leading
- Lecture 5-3: Sharing Faith Without Pressure
- Lecture 5-4: Faith in Daily Choices
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: One Small Way to Live It
A parish priest is speaking at a meeting of the church council. "The young people are the church of the future," he says, and nobody disagrees. Heads nod. A woman offers to buy new chairs for the youth room. A man asks how many teenagers came last year compared with the year before. Nobody in the room says anything unkind about teenagers. And yet, if a fifteen-year-old were sitting at the back, she might notice that every sentence is about what she will become, and none is about who she is today.
This lecture asks you to look at a very familiar sentence and at the picture hidden inside it. The sentence is kind. The picture is not always kind. It treats young people as material that a community shapes now so that something good will come out later. This course takes another view, and states it in one claim that every chapter will return to:
Youth ministry is not managing young people as the objects of a programme. It is standing beside people who are making their faith their own, as honest and safe adults who walk with them. The relationship is the ministry, safety comes first, and we walk with the parents.
Read the claim slowly. "Standing beside" is different from standing over, and different from standing in front to perform. "Making their faith their own" assumes that the faith of a young person is not simply handed down: it is received, questioned and chosen, and the young person does the choosing. "Honest and safe adults" puts two demands on us, and the second one is not negotiable. "We walk with the parents" says that the family is a partner, not an obstacle and not a rival.
This is a course about practice. It does not teach how young people grow and change; that is the work of the course PT706E, How Children and Young People Grow in Faith. Here we ask what a faithful adult does, week by week, beside people between about thirteen and eighteen.
이 23분으로 얻는 것
- Explain the hidden picture inside the phrase "the church of the future", and say what it can do to a young person.
- Give two reasons from Scripture to treat young people as persons in the present.
- Name five things a youth worker actually does.
- State the central claim of the course in your own words.
Let no man despise your youth; but be an example to those who believe, in word, in your way of life, in love, in spirit, in faith, and in purity." — 1 Timothy 4:12
World English Bible
After three days they found him in the temple, sitting in the midst of the teachers, both listening to them, and asking them questions." — Luke 2:46
WEB
Yahweh came, and stood, and called as at other times, “Samuel! Samuel!” Then Samuel said, “Speak; for your servant hears.”" — 1 Samuel 3:10
WEB
Three scenes: a young leader told not to let his youth be despised, a boy in a room of teachers who listens and asks, and a child who hears a call and does not yet know what it is. In each, a young person is already a person in the story, and an older person has a part to play beside him.
1. The sentence that sounds kind
"Young people are the church of the future" is said in nearly every tradition, in cathedrals and in rented halls. It is usually said with love. It is also, as a description, only half true.
It is true that young people will, in time, carry the work of the community. Every community depends on the next generation, and a community that does not think about its young is not thinking about its own survival. Nothing in this lecture says that long-term care is wrong.
The trouble is in what the sentence leaves out and what it suggests. It leaves out now. It suggests that the real church is the adult one and that the young are, for the present, in a waiting room. A community that holds this picture without noticing it begins to behave in certain ways.
- It measures young people by what they will become: a future leader, a future giver, a future parent in the pews.
- It judges its own youth work by its output: numbers who stay, numbers who are confirmed or baptised, numbers who "come back".
- It talks about young people rather than to them, often in their hearing.
- It gives young people tasks that serve the adult picture, such as the welcome desk and the quiet seat, and is surprised when they ask why.
(An invented example.) Tomasz is sixteen. His parish runs a good confirmation class. After the class, a catechist tells him: "We are so glad you are here. You are the ones who will keep this parish alive." Tomasz is a little proud, and a little uneasy. He goes home wondering what happens if he does not keep it alive, and whether anyone would still be glad he came. The catechist meant only kindness. But the sentence told Tomasz that his value lay in the future, and that it was a job.
We can call this the project picture. The word is not an insult. A project has a plan, a goal, a budget and a measure of success. Some things in a community properly work that way, such as a roof repair or a harvest supper. A person does not. When a young person senses that they are the object of someone's project, they usually do not say so. They go quiet, or they perform the part that is expected, or they drift away, and the adults are left puzzled because the programme was so well organised.
2. The present tense of a young person
Scripture does not treat young people as people in a waiting room, and the three passages above show it in three different ways.
The apostle writes to a young leader. Paul's words to Timothy are "Let no man despise your youth" (1 Timothy 4:12). We do not know exactly how old Timothy was, and we should not claim it. What the verse shows is that a person regarded as young is told to be an example to believers, in speech, in the way of life, in love, in faith. The word is addressed to him in the present, and "those who believe" are the ones who watch him. At the same time, the verse is a request to the community: do not look down on this person for his age. Notice that Paul does not tell Timothy to prove himself by being impressive. The example is made of ordinary things: how he speaks, how he lives, how he loves. These are things that young people are able to do today.
A boy among the teachers. In Luke 2:46-52 Jesus, aged twelve at that point in the story, is found in the temple "sitting in the midst of the teachers, both listening to them, and asking them questions." The verse names two things he does: he listens, and he asks. The teachers do not appear to treat the questions as an interruption. Verse 47 tells us that "All who heard him were amazed at his understanding and his answers." Then the story turns, and it is worth reading honestly. His mother says: "Son, why have you treated us this way? Behold, your father and I were anxiously looking for you" (Luke 2:48, WEB). The parents were frightened. They did not understand his answer. And yet verse 51 says that he went down with them and "was subject to them", and that his mother "kept all these sayings in her heart." A young person grows in his own understanding. His parents are anxious and do not understand it all. Both are true, and nobody in the story is a villain. That is a good picture of what youth ministry often looks like from the inside. We will come back to it in the lectures on families.
A child who does not yet know who is . In 1 Samuel 3, the boy Samuel hears a voice in the night. He thinks it is Eli, the older priest, and goes to him three times. "Eli perceived that Yahweh had called the child" (1 Samuel 3:8, WEB). Then Eli gives Samuel an instruction: go back, lie down, and if the voice calls, say "Speak, Yahweh; for your servant hears." Look at what Eli does and does not do. He does not claim the call as his own work. He does not take the place of the one who is calling. He notices, he waits through three false starts, and he points the boy to the one who is speaking. Then he steps back, and Samuel answers for himself. The older person's task is to help a young person listen, not to speak instead.
Put the three scenes together. A young person can be an example now. A young person can ask real questions now, and parents and elders can be frightened and proud at once. A young person can be addressed by God now, and an older person can help them hear. None of these scenes describes a waiting room.
3. What this means in traditions that count membership differently
Communities disagree about when a young person becomes a member. Some baptise infants and confirm in the early teens. Some wait for a personal profession of faith at an age the young person chooses. Some dedicate children and baptise later. Some Orthodox families have the child baptised, chrismated and communing from infancy.
This lecture does not ask you to settle that. It asks for something that every one of these communities can say. If your tradition counts a baptised child as a member, then a fifteen-year-old is already a member and not a visitor. If your tradition waits for a personal confession, then a fifteen-year-old who has not made one is still a person God knows and a neighbour in your community, and so is entitled to the same welcome. In either case the young person is not a prospect.
4. What a youth worker actually does
If the work is not managing a programme, what is it? Here is a plain list of five things, kept deliberately modest.
- Welcomes. The first task is to make sure that each young person is glad to have come, and knows that somebody noticed. That includes the one who sits by the door.
- Listens. Not only with the ears. A good youth worker learns what is on the young person's mind, their music, their worries about exams, the thing that happened at school. Listening is also where a worker learns when to be quiet.
- Stays. Being the same adult from month to month, keeping a promise, turning up when it is not exciting. Chapter 3 is about this in detail.
- Prays and reads beside them. Not for them, and not at them, but alongside. The youth worker is also a person who is trying to follow Christ, and does not hide it or perform it.
- Connects. The worker joins the young person to other adults, to the whole community, and to the family. A youth worker who becomes the only adult in a young person's spiritual life has failed, however popular they are.
Notice what is not on the list. A youth worker is not required to be funny, to play an instrument, to know the newest games or to be young. These can help, and they are not the work. Notice also that every item on the list is a relationship. This is why the claim says that the relationship is the ministry.
5. The central claim, phrase by phrase
Return to the claim at the start.
"Standing beside." The preposition matters. In front of young people, the worker performs. Over them, the worker controls. Beside them, the worker walks at the same pace and sees the same road. This is hard for many adults, because standing beside means being able to be corrected, to say "I do not know", and to be seen as a human being with faults.
"People who are making their faith their own." Some things a young person receives from their family and community. At some point, often in these years, they begin to ask whether it is theirs. A worker who treats those questions as a threat teaches the young person to hide them. A worker who welcomes them teaches the young person that the faith is strong enough to be questioned. This is not a recommendation to be careless about truth. It is a recognition that faith that was never questioned has not yet been chosen.
"Honest and safe adults." Honesty includes honesty about our own limits and about the community's imperfections. Safety is not an extra. A caring adult who is not safe is a danger, and a safe adult who does not care is an empty chair. The course returns to safety throughout and teaches it as habits and reasons, because the written policy of your own community and the law where you live are what set the rules.
"The relationship is the ministry." If a programme is excellent and no adult knows the names of the young people, there is no ministry, only an activity. If a small group meets in a kitchen with no programme at all and one adult knows each young person well, there is ministry. Programmes serve relationships. They do not replace them.
"We walk with the parents." Parents often feel judged, tired and frightened for their children. They are not an audience to be managed or an obstacle to be got around. They are, in most cases, the people who know the young person best and who will be there long after the programme ends. Chapter 6 develops this.
6. Two communities, one claim
In a cathedral parish with a staff member for youth, a confirmation class and a choir of teenagers, the temptation is to measure by activity: how many events, how many in the class. The corrective is to ask whether each young person has an adult who knows their name and their story, and whether those adults are safe.
In a small assembly or a house church that has three teenagers and no youth worker, the temptation is different: to conclude that "we have no youth ministry" because there is no programme. But three teenagers, a mother who makes tea and an older man who asks about their week may be doing the whole job. The claim of this lecture does not need a building, a budget or a title. It needs an adult who is willing to stand beside.
7. A word about what the worker is not
You will meet a great many ideas about what a youth worker should be: an entertainer, a counsellor, an older sibling, a parent substitute, a recruiter. Lecture 1-3 looks at the limits. For now, hold one sentence: the worker is a trustworthy adult beside the young person, and does not have to be everything.
Diagram 1. Two pictures of the same young person
핵심 요약
- "The church of the future" hides a picture in which young people are waiting and the adult church is the real one; it can teach a young person that their value lies later.
- The project picture measures young people by output; the companion picture asks who knows each young person by name.
- Scripture shows young people as persons now: an example to believers, a questioner among teachers, a child whom God calls.
- A youth worker welcomes, listens, stays, prays and reads beside, and connects the young person to others.
- The central claim: the relationship is the ministry, safety comes first, and we walk with the parents.
- The claim needs no building or budget, only an adult willing to stand beside.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| The hidden picture in "church of the future" | Young people wait in a waiting room while the adult church is the real one; their value is placed later. |
| Eli and Samuel | The older person notices, waits, points to the one who calls, and steps back. |
| Five things a youth worker does | Welcomes, listens, stays, prays and reads beside, connects. |
| The central claim in short | Standing beside, honest and safe adults, relationship is the ministry, parents walked with. |
One sentence to remember A young person is a person God knows today, and not a project for tomorrow.
This week's action Listen for one sentence about young people that is said in your community, and ask yourself what a fifteen-year-old would hear in it.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- When you hear "the church of the future", what picture comes to mind? Who is in it, and who is missing?
- Think back to your own teens. Was there an adult who treated you as a person in the present? What did they do?
- Of the five things a youth worker does (welcomes, listens, stays, prays and reads beside, connects), which is easiest for you and which is hardest?
- In your community, which sentences about young people are said in front of young people? How might a young person hear them?
- In Luke 2:48-51, the parents are anxious and the son is growing. How do you hold both of these when you work with a young person and their family?
- If your community had no building, no budget and one helper, what part of the central claim could still be carried out next week?