Lecture 3-2: Boundaries for Mentors
목차 31
- Lecture 1-1: Companions, Not Projects
- Lecture 1-2: Many Shapes of Youth Ministry
- Lecture 1-3: The Youth Worker's Place and Limits
- Lecture 1-4: What Youth Ministry Is For
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: The Shape of Our Youth Ministry
- Lecture 2-1: Reading Culture With Curiosity
- Lecture 2-2: Friends, Belonging and Loneliness
- Lecture 2-3: School, Work and the Pressure of Time
- Lecture 2-4: Faith Among Many Beliefs
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: One Question of Curiosity
- Lecture 3-1: Relationship Is the Ministry
- Lecture 3-2: Boundaries for Mentors
- Lecture 3-3: Listening and Passing On
- Lecture 3-4: Mentoring Across Differences
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: What I Will Say and What I Will Not Do
- Lecture 4-1: The Shape of a Youth Gathering
- Lecture 4-2: Small Groups and Honest Conversation
- Lecture 4-3: Camps, Trips and Events
- Lecture 4-4: Talking About Hard Topics
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: One Evening and Its Risks
- Lecture 5-1: Prayer, Scripture and Worship With Young People
- Lecture 5-2: Serving and Leading
- Lecture 5-3: Sharing Faith Without Pressure
- Lecture 5-4: Faith in Daily Choices
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: One Small Way to Live It
A volunteer, Tomas, has been mentoring a sixteen-year-old for a year. They get on well. One Friday the young person writes late at night: "Can I ask you something I don't want my parents to know?" Tomas feels two pulls. One says: this is trust, answer warmly. The other says: this is the kind of message I should not be answering alone, in secret, at this hour. (An invented example.) What Tomas does next depends mostly on what he decided long before that night.
This lecture is about the decisions made beforehand. A boundary is a line drawn in calm so that you do not have to draw it in pressure. The last lecture said that the relationship is the ministry. This one says what keeps it safe. Boundaries protect the young person, and they protect the adult. They are not a sign that the adult is thought to be dangerous, and they are not a way to keep love at a distance. They are habits that let love be seen as it is.
The lecture teaches reasons and habits. It does not give the rules of your community or your country, because those differ and they are written elsewhere. It sends you to two sources: the written policy of your community and the local law. Where the lecture says "follow the policy", it means that. Nothing here is legal advice.
이 21분으로 얻는 것
- Explain why boundaries protect both the young person and the adult, and why they are not a sign of suspicion.
- Describe the habits around one-to-one meetings, messages, gifts, secrets, physical contact, rides and pairings, and give the reason for each.
- State fairly the disagreement between very strict rules and rules that rely more on relationship, and say what this course requires in both cases.
- Say what to do when no written policy exists, and when the policy and the situation do not seem to fit.
- Explain why a boundary should be applied equally to every adult and known to the parents.
A prudent man sees danger, and hides himself; but the simple pass on, and suffer for it." — Proverbs 22:3
World English Bible
Don’t rebuke an older man, but exhort him as a father; the younger men as brothers;" — 1 Timothy 5:1
WEB
the elder women as mothers; the younger as sisters, in all purity." — 1 Timothy 5:2
WEB
So then, let us follow after things which make for peace, and things by which we may build one another up." — Romans 14:19
WEB
Proverbs praises foresight: a wise person looks ahead. Paul asks Timothy to treat each member of the community as family, with purity. Romans gives the aim of all rules: peace and building one another up, not fear.
1. Why boundaries are an act of love
Some people feel that boundaries and warmth pull against each other. The warmer you are, the thinking goes, the fewer rules you need. And a mentor who is hedged about by rules seems to be treating the young person as a risk.
This is a misreading, and it helps to see why. A boundary does at least four things.
It protects the young person. Children and young people can be harmed by adults who have power over them, and this has happened in every kind of community. Most mentors are not like that. But a community cannot see into hearts, and a young person cannot be expected to judge which adult is safe. A boundary that applies to everyone does not depend on judging anyone.
It protects the adult. A mentor who is alone with a young person, in secret, for long hours, can be misunderstood even when everything is innocent. A mentor who follows open habits has an answer ready: everything was visible. The boundary is the adult's shield as well as the young person's.
It protects the relationship. A relationship with clear edges can be generous inside them. A mentor who has not thought about the edges often finds that they are drawn suddenly and painfully, when something goes wrong.
It protects the community's trust. Parents give their children into the care of the community. The boundaries are part of how the community keeps its word.
None of this needs a suspicious tone. A good boundary is announced in the same voice in which you say "the doors open at six."
2. Habits, and the reasons behind them
What follows is a set of widely used habits. Your community's policy may say more or less, or say it differently. If it does, follow the policy. The reasons are given so that the habits make sense and so that you can recognise the purpose when a situation is new.
One-to-one meetings: in open or known places. If you meet a young person individually, choose a place where others can see you, or where it is known where you are: a café with other people in it, a room with a window in the door, the church hall during an activity. The reason is visibility. A conversation can be private in content and still public in setting. Tell someone, preferably a second adult and the young person's parent, when and where you are meeting.
Messages and social media: agreed channels, with the parents' knowledge. Many young people live a great part of their social life online, and an adult who refuses all contact may lose them. But a private, late-night channel between one adult and one young person is the pattern that most needs care. A common habit is to use a group chat that includes at least one other adult, or a channel the community has chosen, with the parents told what is used and when. Keep to hours that you have stated. Do not send or ask for private images. Do not use disappearing messages with a young person. Screens and the online world as a subject belong to PT706E; here the point is the habit of keeping the channel open to view.
Gifts: small, open and equal. A card at a birthday, a sweet at the end of a trip, a book for everyone who completes a course. These are easy to explain. A costly or secret gift to one young person is harder to explain and can create a feeling of obligation. The reason is fairness and clarity.
Secrets: do not promise them. A young person will sometimes say, "Promise you won't tell." Do not promise. You can say: "I can't promise that. If it's something that keeps you safe, I will always need to tell the right person. I will tell you who and why, and I will stay with you." The next lecture develops this. Here, the habit is to avoid secrets that can only be kept by being alone with them. Reasons: a promise of secrecy can bind an adult to silence about something that is harming a young person; and a pattern of secrets between an adult and a young person is a known way that harm begins.
Physical contact: minimal, open, and with the young person's consent. Customs about touch differ greatly between countries, cultures and traditions. In some places a hand on the shoulder or a hug is ordinary, and holding back would seem cold. In others it is rare. A young person may also dislike touch for reasons you do not know. A wise habit is to let the young person lead, to avoid touch that is lingering, private or in a closed room, and to follow your community's policy and the customs of the young person's family. If a young person is distressed, you can stay beside them and offer a tissue, a chair or a glass of water without touching. Liturgical practices such as the laying on of hands, a blessing or the kiss of peace are public and ordered, and are outside this concern when done as the tradition prescribes.
Rides: avoid being alone in a vehicle with one young person. If you must give a lift, follow the policy: often this means a second person present, the parents' consent, and a direct route. The reason is the same as for meetings: a closed space with one adult and one young person is the setting with the least visibility. Where a community lacks public transport and a lift is the only way home, agree on a rule beforehand with the parents, and tell someone when the journey starts and ends.
Mixed-sex pairings. Some communities ask that a mentor and a young person of the opposite sex meet only in a group or with a second adult. Others apply the rule to every pairing. Some apply it to none. The reasons given are protection from harm and from misunderstanding. The habit that matters is to know your community's rule and to apply it the same way to everyone.
3. Where readers will not agree
This is a point where readers will not agree about how closely mentors should be bound by rules. One group holds that the rules should be strict and specific: no one-to-one meetings at all, no private messages, no lifts, always two adults. Their strongest reason is that harm to a young person is grave and often hidden, that rules that do not depend on anyone’s judgement protect most reliably, and that a young person is helped when every adult is held to the same standard. The other group holds that relationship and common sense should carry more weight: a mentor who can never be alone with a young person cannot be a mentor, a rural congregation with few adults cannot run a two-adult rule for everything, and rules that are too heavy tend to drive out good volunteers or to be quietly ignored. Their strongest reason is that a young person is helped most by a stable, trusting adult, and that over-strict rules can make the relationship the very thing it should not be: cold and fearful. Both groups want the young person safe.
This course does not choose between them. It requires something that both can accept: one written policy for everyone, applied equally, followed with the parents’ knowledge, and never used as a reason for suspicion of any person. If your community's rules are strict, keep them without resentment. If they are light, make sure they are at least written down, that everyone has read them, and that nobody is treated as an exception because they are well liked. Where a rule cannot be kept, such as a lift that cannot be avoided, tell someone before, not after.
4. When there is no policy, or the situation does not fit
Some communities have no written policy. If yours is one, say so to the person responsible and ask for one to be written. In the meantime, ask the person responsible what the community expects, and do the following: keep every contact visible to at least one other adult; let the parents know where and when you meet their child; avoid secrets; and do not do anything you would not do in front of the young person's parent. Policy templates are available from many denominations and national bodies; the person responsible can find one that fits local law.
Sometimes a situation arises that the policy did not foresee: a storm, a missed bus, a young person who needs help at once. The aim then is to keep to the purpose: visibility, parents’ knowledge, no secrets. Call the person responsible as soon as you can, and write down what happened and what you did. If there is immediate danger, call the local emergency number first.
5. Boundaries apply to everyone, including the loved ones
The hardest part of boundaries is not the stranger. It is the long-serving, much-loved leader whom everybody trusts. It is tempting to treat such a person as an exception. This is exactly the wrong move, for two reasons. First, trust earned is not proof; a community cannot tell the trustworthy from the untrustworthy by feeling. Second, an exception puts the loved person in a worse position: the one time something is misunderstood, there is no habit to point to.
The same applies to young adult leaders, who are only a few years older than the young people and often their friends. They need the boundaries too, and they need the habits to be explained kindly. Lecture 3-4 returns to them. And it applies to the clergy. A priest, pastor or is not exempt from the rule on one-to-one meetings or messages.
6. In a parish and in a small assembly
(An invented example.) In a cathedral parish, some pastoral meetings with young people, such as preparation for confirmation or confession, take place in settings the tradition and the parish have defined. The parish adds its own policy for activities: two adults at a retreat, a window in the door of the meeting room, a parent list of those who have been approved. The risk is that the policy lives in a file and nobody has read it. The remedy is a short talk at the start of each year.
(An invented example.) In a small assembly meeting in a rented hall, there may be only one other adult at a given gathering. The rule "always two adults" may be hard to keep. The assembly agrees: when only one adult is present, the door stays open, a parent is nearby in the building, and a message goes to the leader before and after. This is not perfect, but it is written, known and applied equally.
Diagram 1. Habits that keep a relationship in the open
핵심 요약
- Boundaries are drawn in calm, protect the young person, the adult, the relationship and the community's trust, and are not a sign of suspicion.
- The habits: open or known places for meetings; agreed channels for messages; small, open gifts; no promised secrets; minimal, open contact; no closed-space rides; one rule for pairings.
- Readers differ on how strict rules should be; the course requires one written policy, applied equally, known to parents.
- When there is no policy, ask for one; in the meantime keep contact visible and avoid secrets.
- The much-loved leader, the young adult leader and the clergy are bound by the same habits.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Why have boundaries? | They protect the young person, the adult, the relationship and the community's trust; they do not imply suspicion. |
| What do the habits share? | Visibility, the parents' knowledge, and no secrets that isolate an adult and a young person. |
| What does the course require on strict or light rules? | One written policy for all, applied equally, with the parents' knowledge, never used to suspect a person. |
| Who must keep them? | Everyone: the new volunteer, the loved leader, the young adult leader and the clergy. |
One sentence to remember A boundary is love drawn in calm, so that it is not drawn in a crisis.
This week's action Find your community's written policy for work with young people and read it once through. If there is none, ask the person responsible who could help to write one.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- Does your community have a written policy for youth work? Have you read it? If not, whom could you ask for it this month?
- Which of the seven habits (meetings, messages, gifts, secrets, contact, rides, pairings) is hardest to keep where you live? What would make it possible to keep?
- Think of a loved leader who has been treated as an exception. What would it take to say, kindly, that the habit applies to them too?
- A young person says, "Promise you won't tell." Write, in your own words, one sentence you could say that is honest and kind.
- State the strict view and the lighter view as their holders would state them. Which of the two do you naturally lean towards, and what does the other view warn you about?
- How would you explain these habits to a nervous new volunteer so that they hear care and not suspicion?