Lecture 2-3: The Person Who Walks Beside
목차 31
- Lecture 1-1: Disciples, Not Customers
- Lecture 1-2: How Adults Learn
- Lecture 1-3: The Real Lives of Adults
- Lecture 1-4: Discipleship in Many Traditions
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: A Day in One Adult's Life
- Lecture 2-1: One Person's Road
- Lecture 2-2: One to One, Small Group or Class
- Lecture 2-3: The Person Who Walks Beside
- Lecture 2-4: When Discipling Harms
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: One Person's Road on One Page
- Lecture 3-1: Starting From Life
- Lecture 3-2: Reading Scripture With Adults
- Lecture 3-3: Doubt, Questions and Reworking Faith
- Lecture 3-4: Online and Blended Learning
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: One Session Frame
- Lecture 4-1: Prayer, the Word and Rest
- Lecture 4-2: Faith at Work and at Home
- Lecture 4-3: Community and Accountability
- Lecture 4-4: Giving and Serving
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: One Small Habit and One Companion
- Lecture 5-1: Long-Time Members Who Are Stuck
- Lecture 5-2: People Hurt by the Church
- Lecture 5-3: Singles, Single Parents, Carers and Older Adults
- Lecture 5-4: Adults With Different Beliefs in the Room
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: The First Sentence Beside Someone Who Has Stopped
An adult sits with a companion every second Thursday. After a year, the adult begins to ring before making any decision: a change of job, a quarrel with a sister, whether to buy a car. The companion is flattered at first, and then uneasy. Nobody has done anything wrong. Yet something has shifted, and the companion is now the person whose opinion decides. (an invented example)
This lecture is about the companion: the person who walks beside an adult. A companion has influence. Influence is not a fault. It is what makes a companion useful. But influence can grow into dependence, and dependence can become control. The companion's first duty is to know that this is possible and to hold power loosely.
The lecture covers five subjects. First, the nature of a companion's influence. Second, the limits of confidence, including the exceptions that safety requires. Third, meeting alone and why care is needed. Fourth, matters of marriage and family. Fifth, how to refer an adult to a pastor or professional. In the middle it states fairly a disagreement among Christians about how strong accountability should be. It follows the ethic of this course: notice, stay, pass on.
이 27분으로 얻는 것
- Explain how a companion's influence can grow into dependence, and name signs of it.
- State what a companion should say at the start about confidence, and why safety limits it.
- Give reasons for care when a companion meets an adult alone, and name some ways to meet with care.
- Describe a companion's right place in an adult's marriage and family matters.
- State fairly two views on the strength of accountability, and the requirement this course keeps.
I exhort the elders among you, as a fellow elder, and a witness of the sufferings of Christ, and who will also share in the glory that will be revealed. Shepherd the flock of God which is among you, exercising the oversight, not under compulsion, but voluntarily, not for dishonest gain, but willingly; neither as lording it over those entrusted to you, but making yourselves examples to the flock. When the chief Shepherd is revealed, you will receive the crown of glory that doesn’t fade away." — 1 Peter 5:1-4
World English Bible
Jesus summoned them, and said to them, “You know that they who are recognized as rulers over the nations lord it over them, and their great ones exercise authority over them. But it shall not be so among you, but whoever wants to become great among you shall be your servant. Whoever of you wants to become first among you, shall be bondservant of all. For the Son of Man also came not to be served, but to serve, and to give his life as a ransom for many.”" — Mark 10:42-45
WEB
Brothers, even if a man is caught in some fault, you who are spiritual must restore such a one in a spirit of gentleness; looking to yourself so that you also aren’t tempted. Bear one another’s burdens, and so fulfill the law of Christ." — Galatians 6:1-2
WEB
Peter writes to elders about shepherding without lording it over others. Jesus contrasts the way rulers use power with the way his followers should. Paul describes restoring a person gently and bearing burdens together.
1. Influence is not a fault
A companion who has no influence is of no use. An adult comes to a companion because the companion seems wise, kind, trustworthy or further along the road. The adult listens. The adult may be changed by what the companion says. That is the point.
Influence also has a shadow. Consider what makes a companion influential: the adult trusts, the adult may be vulnerable, the companion often knows more about the adult's inner life than anyone else does, and the companion is often older, more experienced, better educated or holds an office. Each of these gives the companion more power than the adult. Some of it is real and good. Some of it is simply an imbalance that the adult did not choose.
Scripture is plain about this. Peter tells elders to shepherd the flock "not under compulsion, but voluntarily," not for gain, "neither as lording it over those entrusted to you, but making yourselves examples." Jesus, in Mark 10:42-45, says that among rulers of the nations great ones "exercise authority" over others, but "it shall not be so among you." Authority in the church is not abolished. It is turned over: the great person becomes the servant. A companion who has read these two passages has been warned. Power is part of the subject, and the way to hold it is to be a servant and an example, not a ruler.
2. How influence becomes dependence
Dependence grows slowly. It rarely starts with a demand. It starts with trust and a few small habits. A companion can watch for these signs, in the adult and in himself or herself.
- The adult asks the companion before making ordinary decisions that the adult is well able to make.
- The adult stops speaking with other trusted people about what matters most.
- The adult reports to the companion, between meetings, in a way that feels like checking in with an authority.
- The companion begins to feel that the adult could not manage without them, and feels a flicker of pleasure at the thought.
- The companion finds it hard to say "I do not know," or "ask someone else," or "I think you can decide this."
- The companion is the only person who knows certain things about the adult.
The last two are the companion's own signs. A person who walks beside others needs to notice what the role gives them. Being needed is pleasant. It can slowly become the reason for the relationship.
The remedies are simple and need courage. Ask the adult, from time to time, who else they talk to. Return decisions to the adult with a question: "What do you think is right? What would you do if I had not said anything?" Say "I do not know" when you do not. Encourage other friendships and other company, including those you do not control. Review the companionship openly now and then, and say that ending it, or changing it, is always allowed. Chapter 4 returns to community, and lecture 2-4 to what happens when these remedies are not used.
3. Confidence and its limits
Adults tell their companions things they have told no one else. A good companion keeps what is said. Confidence is the ground of trust, and without it the adult will say only what is safe.
Yet confidence has limits, and a companion must say so at the start, not at the moment when it matters. A promise of secrecy that safety does not allow is one the companion cannot keep. If it is made, it will be broken, and the harm will be worse.
So at the beginning of a companionship, the companion should say something like this, in his or her own words:
"What you say to me, I will keep between us. There are things I could not keep. If I thought you or someone else were in danger of serious harm, I would have to tell someone responsible, and I would try to tell you first. I may also need to share things with my own pastor or supervisor, without your name, so that I can do this well. And my community has rules that I follow."
Several things deserve to be said about this speech.
It names a category of exceptions: serious harm to the adult or to someone else, including a child or a person who cannot protect themselves. It does not list laws. The duties of a church worker to report certain matters differ greatly from country to country, from role to role and from one denomination's rules to another's. In some places the law requires a report; in others it does not; in some a clergy person has a special protected status in conversation, and in others not. Do not assume any rule is universal. Know your community's written policy, and know the law of the place where you live. If you do not know, ask your pastor or the person responsible before you begin to walk beside anyone.
It promises to tell the adult first, where that is safe. The adult is not an object of a report but a person who deserves to know what is happening.
It admits that the companion also needs support. A companion who holds everything alone will break or will harm. Speaking, without names, to a pastor or supervisor about how the companionship is going is part of the work. The adult should know this in advance.
If an adult says something that suggests immediate danger, such as a plan to harm themselves or another person, or that a child is being harmed, do not wait for the next meeting and do not try to deal with it alone. Call the local emergency number if the danger is now. Tell the person in your community who is responsible. Stay with the adult if it is safe to do so. A companion is not a counsellor, a doctor, a lawyer or a police officer. The companion is the person who notices, stays and passes on.
4. Meeting alone
Many companionships are one to one. The reasons for care in meeting alone are old and serious, and they protect both people. An adult who is alone with a person of influence is more exposed than one in company. A companion who is alone with an adult can be misunderstood, or accused falsely, with no one to speak for him or her. Neither danger is imaginary. Misuse of trust has happened in every kind of community.
Practices vary, and communities should write down theirs. Common ones include:
- meeting in a place where others can be near or can see, such as a church hall, a cafe, a room with a glass door or an open door;
- a second adult in the building, who knows that the meeting is taking place;
- an agreed place, time and length, so that the meeting does not drift into private rooms or long evenings;
- meeting by video or telephone in a way that the community's policy allows, and not on private messaging apps that no one else may see;
- the companion's own pastor or supervisor knowing that the companionship exists.
Some traditions have long practice about who may meet whom, based on their view of Scripture and of tradition. Some ask that a companion be of the same sex as the adult. Others do not. This course does not decide among them. It says only that a community should have a written way of meeting, that it should be known to the adults, and that the companion should follow it even when it is inconvenient. An adult who proposes to meet in a private place, late, or by secret messages is asking for something the companion should decline, whatever the adult's reason.
Culture matters too. In some places, two people meeting privately will be misread, however innocent they are. In others, a conversation in a public space is felt as exposure. The companion should ask the adult what would feel safe and should not insist on one habit. But the companion should never agree to a pattern that hides the meetings from every other person.
5. Marriage and family
Companions are often asked about marriage and family. A wife says her husband is cold. A father says his son has stopped speaking to him. A man says he does not love his wife any more. These are among the most intimate matters an adult may bring, and the companion's power is both great and risky here.
A companion's place is limited, for three reasons.
First, the companion hears one side. A story told in a quiet room by one person is never the whole story, however honest the person is. The other people are not present.
Second, the companion does not live in that household. The choice to stay, to leave, to forgive, to separate or to seek help is a weighty one with effects the companion will not bear.
Third, a companion can easily take sides without meaning to. A word of agreement can become fuel. A cautious word can sound like a command to endure harm.
So the posture is to listen, to ask good questions, to pray with the adult if the adult wishes, and not to take sides or tell the adult to stay or go. Where the matter is a marriage in trouble, a pastor or a trained counsellor can help, and the companion can help the adult reach one. Where there are signs of violence, fear, threats, control of money or movement, or harm to a child, this is not a matter for private advice. The companion should help the adult to reach people who are trained, and, if there is immediate danger, to reach the emergency services. Do not ask the adult to return to a person who may be harming them, and do not promise secrecy that safety cannot keep. Duties to report differ by country and role. Follow your community's written policy.
Traditions teach different things about marriage, divorce and remarriage, and an adult may be hurt by a particular rule. A companion who is not a pastor does not settle those questions. A companion hears the person, and takes the question to the right person.
6. Referring: when and how
Knowing when to pass on is a skill. Some signs that an adult needs more than a companion can give:
- the adult speaks of wanting to die or to harm themselves or someone else;
- the adult is being harmed, or is harming someone, including a child;
- the adult is deeply depressed, anxious or unable to function for weeks;
- the adult has an addiction that is damaging their life;
- the adult needs legal, medical or financial help beyond the companion's competence;
- the adult is asking the companion for something the companion cannot properly give;
- the companion is out of their depth, tired, or too close to the matter.
When any of these appears, the companion's task is to say so honestly, stay in touch if the adult wishes, and help the adult reach the right person, such as a pastor, a qualified counsellor, a doctor, or the emergency services. A referral is not a rejection. A good way to say it is: "I want you to have more help than I can give, and I would like to stay beside you while you find it."
The skill of listening is taught in the course LM205E. This lecture assumes it and does not repeat it.
7. Strong accountability and light accompaniment
This is a point where readers will not agree about how firm a companion's accountability should be, and it matters because it shapes what a companion may ask for.
Some Christians hold that needs firm mutual accountability. They point to Galatians 6:1-2, where Paul tells the "spiritual" to restore a person caught in a fault, and to the long Christian practice of confession, of rules of life and of spiritual direction. They say that without a person who will ask hard questions, adults hide in comfortable vagueness and sin goes unchecked. The idea of a friend who asks, "Did you do what you said you would?" has helped many people, and it is the strong form of care. A person who has freely asked for such a friend knows that it is not a sign of mistrust but of love.
Other Christians hold that discipleship is best carried as light companionship. They point to Jesus' words in Mark 10:42-45, and to the experience that heavy accountability easily turns into surveillance, especially when one person holds more power than the other. They say that an adult is accountable to God and to the community, and that a companion should offer company, prayer and counsel, and not report cards. A person who has been checked and measured by a leader knows how a friend can become a judge.
Both are serious positions, and each has seen real good and real harm. The firm form has helped people who wanted help, and has also been used to control people who did not. The light form has given room, and has sometimes left people alone with their patterns.
This course requires less than either side asks, and the requirement is the same for both: the adult's own decisions are respected; power must not collect in one person; and the companion refers when the matter is beyond them. A firm form is acceptable if the adult chose it freely, can change or leave it, and the companion is himself or herself accountable to someone else. A light form is acceptable if it still includes someone who will say, with kindness, what is hard to hear. Where either form fails these tests, change it.
8. What a companion keeps and does not keep
Putting this lecture together, here are the commitments that mark a companion who holds power loosely.
- Say what you will and will not keep private, at the start.
- Meet in a way that others know about and a policy supports.
- Return decisions to the adult, and be glad when the adult decides without you.
- Do not take sides in a household.
- Pass on early. Refer when the matter is beyond you, and stay beside the adult while they find help.
- Be accountable yourself. Have a pastor, a supervisor or a trusted colleague with whom you speak (without names) about your work. Chapter 6 returns to this.
- Accept an end. An adult may stop, or change companion, and it is not a betrayal.
Diagram 1. The companion's influence, and where it can go wrong
핵심 요약
- A companion's influence is the gift that makes company useful, and also the shadow that can grow into dependence and control.
- Signs of dependence include asking before ordinary decisions and withdrawing from other trusted people; the companion must watch for it in himself or herself.
- Say at the start what you will keep private and what safety would force you to share; duties to report differ by country and role.
- Meet in ways that others know about and a written policy supports; the care protects both the adult and the companion.
- On marriage and family, listen and do not take sides or tell an adult to stay or go; refer to a pastor or professional, and in danger call the emergency number.
- This course requires that the adult's decisions are respected, power does not collect in one person, and the companion refers when needed.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| From influence to control | Trust, then dependence (asking before ordinary decisions), then control (the companion decides and cannot be questioned). |
| What to say at the start | What you will keep private, what safety would make you share, that you may speak to your pastor without names, and that the community has rules. |
| Marriage and family | Listen, pray if asked, take no side, do not say stay or go; help reach a pastor or professional; in danger call the emergency number. |
| The course's requirement on accountability | Respect the adult's decisions; let power collect in no one; refer when the matter is beyond you. |
One sentence to remember A companion holds power loosely by saying what stays private, meeting in the open, returning decisions, and passing on early.
This week's action Write, in your own words, three sentences you would say at the start of a companionship about what you will keep private and what you could not.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- Which of the signs of dependence have you seen, in an adult you walk beside or in yourself as an adult being walked beside? What did you do?
- If you were to say at the start what you would keep private and what you would not, what words would you use? Does your community have written guidance?
- What does your community's written policy say about meeting alone? If it has none, who should write it?
- Which of the two views on accountability (firm or light) is nearer to your tradition's practice? What is the strongest thing the other view says?
- Think of a time when someone gave you advice about your family that you were not ready for. What would have been a better question?
- Whom do you speak with, without names, about your own work as a companion? If no one, what is the first step toward having someone?