Lecture 3-3: Doubt, Questions and Reworking Faith
목차 31
- Lecture 1-1: Disciples, Not Customers
- Lecture 1-2: How Adults Learn
- Lecture 1-3: The Real Lives of Adults
- Lecture 1-4: Discipleship in Many Traditions
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: A Day in One Adult's Life
- Lecture 2-1: One Person's Road
- Lecture 2-2: One to One, Small Group or Class
- Lecture 2-3: The Person Who Walks Beside
- Lecture 2-4: When Discipling Harms
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: One Person's Road on One Page
- Lecture 3-1: Starting From Life
- Lecture 3-2: Reading Scripture With Adults
- Lecture 3-3: Doubt, Questions and Reworking Faith
- Lecture 3-4: Online and Blended Learning
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: One Session Frame
- Lecture 4-1: Prayer, the Word and Rest
- Lecture 4-2: Faith at Work and at Home
- Lecture 4-3: Community and Accountability
- Lecture 4-4: Giving and Serving
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: One Small Habit and One Companion
- Lecture 5-1: Long-Time Members Who Are Stuck
- Lecture 5-2: People Hurt by the Church
- Lecture 5-3: Singles, Single Parents, Carers and Older Adults
- Lecture 5-4: Adults With Different Beliefs in the Room
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: The First Sentence Beside Someone Who Has Stopped
A woman who has been in her church for thirty years stays behind after the group has left. She says quietly that for some months she has not known whether she believes what she says in the creed. She is afraid to tell her husband, who is a deacon. She is afraid to tell the pastor, because she thinks it would worry him. She has told the leader, she says, because the leader is the one person who never seemed shocked.
This is a good moment to be a companion, and a dangerous one. The person who hears it can do a great deal of good by listening, and a great deal of harm by hurrying: with a verse, with an argument, with a report to someone else, or with a face that shows alarm. This lecture is about how to receive a question and a doubt without hurry, how to be honest about what you cannot answer, and how a community can make room for adults to rework their faith without being shamed.
The lecture does not teach apologetics, and it gives no ready answers to the great questions. It describes a posture. It also states where Christians differ on whether doubt belongs in the group or in a private conversation, and what this course requires whichever view a community holds.
이 23분으로 얻는 것
- Explain why doubt among adults is common and why it is not always a crisis.
- Describe how to receive a question or a doubt without hurry.
- Say what to do when you cannot answer, and when a question is beyond a lay companion.
- Name three kinds of question adults bring (from science, from history, from suffering) and one caution for each.
- State fairly two views on where doubt should be spoken, and the requirement this course holds.
Then he said to Thomas, “Reach here your finger, and see my hands. Reach here your hand, and put it into my side. Don’t be unbelieving, but believing.” Thomas answered him, “My Lord and my God!” Jesus said to him, “Because you have seen me, you have believed. Blessed are those who have not seen, and have believed.”" — John 20:27-29
World English Bible
How long, Yahweh? Will you forget me forever? How long will you hide your face from me? How long shall I take counsel in my soul, having sorrow in my heart every day? How long shall my enemy triumph over me?" — Psalm 13:1-2
WEB
Immediately the father of the child cried out with tears, “I believe. Help my unbelief!”" — Mark 9:24
WEB
Three voices of struggle. Thomas says he will not believe without seeing, and Jesus comes to him and offers what he asked. The psalmist asks "How long?" four times in a prayer that is still a prayer. A father cries out that he believes and does not, in the same breath, and asks for help with the second. None of them is sent away.
1. Doubt is common, and it is not one thing
Ask a group of adults whether they have ever doubted, and watch who looks away. In many congregations, doubt is the thing everyone has and nobody mentions.
This lecture makes no claim about how many people doubt, or how often. It is enough to say that a companion who works with adults for any length of time will meet it. What matters is that "doubt" is a word for several different experiences, and a companion helps best by finding out which one is in the room.
- A question that wants an answer. "How can the Bible say this and that?" The person wants information and a way to think.
- A crisis of trust. "I prayed for months and it made no difference." The person's question is less about ideas than about whether God can be trusted.
- Tiredness. "I just cannot feel anything when I pray any more." The person is worn out. A rested person might not use the word doubt.
- Anger. "How could God allow this?" The person is angry, and anger is a way of still addressing God.
- A real change of mind. "I no longer think this part of our teaching is true." The person is reworking what they believe.
- A fear of what the question would cost. "If I said this aloud, my family would be hurt." The person is carrying not only a doubt but a secret.
The same sentence, "I don't know if I believe," can mean any of these. A companion who answers the first when the person is in the third has not heard them.
2. Thomas, the psalmist and the father
The three passages above do not agree on how a doubting person is treated, but they have something in common. In each, the person speaks honestly and remains in conversation with God and with others.
Thomas is absent when the others see Jesus. He says what he would need. A week later Jesus comes and offers him exactly that, and Thomas answers with the plainest confession in the Gospel. Jesus does not shame him. He also adds a word about those who believe without seeing, and that word reaches the readers of the Gospel, not only Thomas. Read the whole scene and you do not find approval of the demand for proof as a rule, and you do not find a rebuke. You find a person met.
Psalm 13 is a prayer that complains. "How long?" is asked of God, not of the neighbour. The psalm ends with trust, but it does not begin there, and the psalmist is not made to say the end before the beginning. Many traditions use the psalms of lament in worship because they give honest voices a place.
The father in Mark 9 is perhaps the most useful figure for a companion. He does not claim more faith than he has, or less. "I believe. Help my unbelief!" holds both in one cry. It is a model of how a person can stand when belief and doubt are both present.
Be careful not to use these passages as a trick: "See, even Thomas doubted, so you are fine." Some doubts are heavy, and the person needs more than a precedent. Use the passages as company, not as a verdict.
3. Receiving a question without hurry
Suppose an adult says a doubt aloud. What does the person who hears it do in the first minute?
Slow down. The first impulse is often to answer. Resist it. Take a breath. Let a pause be a pause. A person who has just said something frightening is watching your face.
Thank the person for the trust. "Thank you for telling me." This is not flattery. It is the plain truth, and it tells the person that the telling was not a mistake.
Ask, don't assume. "Can you tell me more about how it is for you?" "When did it begin?" "Is it an idea you want to think about, or a heaviness you are carrying?" You are trying to find out which of the experiences above is in front of you.
Keep your face and voice steady. A person who sees alarm learns that the doubt is dangerous, and may not speak again.
Do not argue the point in the first conversation. Even if you have a good answer, the first conversation is for being heard. An answer offered too early closes the door.
Do not promise what you cannot keep. Do not say "I won't tell anyone" if you may have to. If the person speaks about harm to themselves or to someone else, or about being harmed, you cannot keep it secret. Say so at the start if you think the conversation may go that way. Listening skills are the subject of LM205E; here the point is only to receive the person steadily.
4. Questions you cannot answer
You will not be able to answer many of the questions you are asked. That is not a failure. Lecture 3-2 says to say "I do not know" and to look. Here are three more cautions.
Do not answer what you cannot. A confident answer you do not hold is worse than silence. It will meet the person's next question and fall.
Do not hide behind a verse. A verse can be a gift and a wall. If you are not sure which, ask the person.
Know when a question is beyond you. Some questions need a pastor, priest or teacher with training. Some need a counsellor or doctor, especially if the person seems low in mood, hopeless, or unable to function. Be ready to say: "I would like us to talk with someone who knows more about this. Would you like me to come with you?" Do not hand a person on abruptly, as though they were a problem. Stay beside them while they find the right person, and ask the person's permission before telling anyone. If you fear for the person's safety, tell the person responsible in your community, and in immediate danger call the local emergency number. Duties to report differ by country and by role; follow your community's written policy and local law.
5. Three kinds of question
Adults bring questions from many places. Three are common enough to deserve a word each.
Questions from science. An adult who works in a laboratory, a hospital or a school may hold what they learned there beside what they learned in church, and wonder whether the two can be kept together. The caution: do not make a science question into a test of loyalty. Christians hold a range of views on how to relate the Bible to the sciences, and a companion who treats one answer as the only faithful one may lose the person. Say honestly where your own community stands, and that thoughtful Christians have read the matter in more than one way. If the person needs expert help, point to a trustworthy teacher.
Questions from history. "How do we know the Gospels were written by those who are named?" "Why do the accounts differ?" "What do we know about how the Bible came to be?" The caution: do not claim to know more than you do, and do not dismiss the question as an attack. Many of these are honest questions, and many have a long history of careful answers. Say so, and help the person find a reliable guide.
Questions from suffering. "Why did my child die?" "Why did God not stop it?" This is the hardest of the three, because it is rarely only a question. The caution: do not explain. A reasoned answer to a grieving person is almost always the wrong gift. Stay. Listen. Allow the lament. The psalms give you words if the person wants them. The question may stay a question for years. A companion who can sit with that is giving the most important thing.
6. Reworking faith
Adults rework what they believe. A faith that fitted a child, or a young adult, may not fit a person who has buried a parent, lost a job, or raised children. This is not always a loss. It can be a growing. It can also hurt. A person may feel that they are losing what they were given, or that they are betraying family and community.
A companion can help by naming that reworking is part of an adult's life, by asking what the person wants to hold on to, and by not demanding that the process be hurried or finished. Different traditions have their own words for this: a dark night, a desert, a time of testing, a deepening. This lecture does not choose among them. It asks the companion to remember that a person who is reworking their faith is still on the road, even when they cannot see the way.
7. Where readers will not agree: where doubt is spoken
This is a point where readers will not agree. Where should a doubt be spoken: in the group, or in a private conversation?
Some hold that doubt should be spoken openly in the group. They argue that most adults in a room share the same quiet questions, that a group in which no one dares to speak a doubt is a group in which everyone thinks they are alone, and that honest speaking is a form of trust. A group that has heard one person say "I find this hard to believe" and then has seen that person received with kindness learns that the community is a safe place to bring a question. They also point out that the hidden doubt of a person who is never heard may grow into a departure without a word.
Others hold that doubt is best handled one-to-one or with a pastor, priest or spiritual father or mother. They argue that a group may not have the skill to receive a heavy doubt, that a new believer who hears a doubt spoken aloud may be unsettled, that a public question can turn into a debate in which the person feels attacked, and that a person's inner struggle is theirs to share when and with whom they choose. In many liturgical and many pastoral traditions, the serious questions of a person are brought to a trusted guide, not to the room.
Both views are held by thoughtful people, and each protects something real: the first, the honesty and belonging of the group; the second, the dignity and safety of the person.
This course requires less than either view. Whichever your community holds, no one is shamed for a question. If the group is the place for doubt, then the group is led so that no one is mocked or corrected in front of others. If the one-to-one conversation is the place, then the person is told where to go and is welcomed there, and the group does not treat a person with a question as a problem. And in both, a person who asks is not treated as one who has failed.
8. Liturgical and free-church settings
In a parish with an adult catechumenate, questions are expected: the person coming toward baptism asks, and the sponsor and catechist hear. The risk is that the questions are collected into set stages and answered by the book. In an Orthodox community, a person may bring a doubt to a spiritual father or mother, and be given not an argument but a way of prayer. In a Pentecostal assembly, doubt may be spoken of as a lack of faith, and an adult who has a question may fear to be thought spiritually weak. A leader there can say aloud that a question is not a sin. In an evangelical church with discipling pairs, the pair is a natural place for a question, but the pair should not become a place where doubt is fixed with a quick answer. A small house church has no staff to refer to; the leader can still say, "I do not know; let us ask someone who does."
Diagram 1. What to do in the first minutes after a doubt is spoken
핵심 요약
- "Doubt" names several experiences: a question, a crisis of trust, tiredness, anger, a change of mind, or fear of the cost of speaking.
- Thomas, the psalmist and the father speak honestly and stay in conversation; use these passages as company and not as a verdict.
- Receive a doubt by slowing down, thanking, asking, keeping steady, not arguing the point at once, and not promising secrecy you cannot keep.
- Do not answer what you cannot; know when a question needs a pastor, a teacher or a professional, and go with the person.
- Readers differ on whether doubt belongs in the group or in a private conversation; this course requires that no one is shamed for a question.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| First response to a doubt | Slow down, thank the person, ask, and keep steady; do not argue the point at once. |
| Why not just say "I won't tell anyone"? | You may have to tell someone if there is danger; say so early. |
| Science, history, suffering | Do not make science a loyalty test; do not claim what you do not know; do not explain suffering, stay. |
| The course's requirement on doubt | Whether in the group or one to one, no one is shamed for a question. |
One sentence to remember A question received without hurry is a door left open.
This week's action Think of one adult in your care who may be carrying a quiet question, and decide how you would receive it before it is said.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- Which of the six experiences (a question, a crisis of trust, tiredness, anger, a change of mind, a fear of what the question would cost) have you met in others? In yourself?
- What happens in your face and voice when someone tells you something that alarms you? How might you keep them steady?
- Which of the three passages (Thomas, Psalm 13, the father in Mark 9) speaks most to you at present? Why?
- Where does your community expect a doubt to be spoken? Does an adult know where to go?
- Which kind of question (science, history, suffering) do you find hardest to receive? What would help?
- Have you ever been given an answer too early? What did it do to the conversation?