Lecture 2-4: When Discipling Harms
목차 31
- Lecture 1-1: Disciples, Not Customers
- Lecture 1-2: How Adults Learn
- Lecture 1-3: The Real Lives of Adults
- Lecture 1-4: Discipleship in Many Traditions
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: A Day in One Adult's Life
- Lecture 2-1: One Person's Road
- Lecture 2-2: One to One, Small Group or Class
- Lecture 2-3: The Person Who Walks Beside
- Lecture 2-4: When Discipling Harms
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: One Person's Road on One Page
- Lecture 3-1: Starting From Life
- Lecture 3-2: Reading Scripture With Adults
- Lecture 3-3: Doubt, Questions and Reworking Faith
- Lecture 3-4: Online and Blended Learning
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: One Session Frame
- Lecture 4-1: Prayer, the Word and Rest
- Lecture 4-2: Faith at Work and at Home
- Lecture 4-3: Community and Accountability
- Lecture 4-4: Giving and Serving
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: One Small Habit and One Companion
- Lecture 5-1: Long-Time Members Who Are Stuck
- Lecture 5-2: People Hurt by the Church
- Lecture 5-3: Singles, Single Parents, Carers and Older Adults
- Lecture 5-4: Adults With Different Beliefs in the Room
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: The First Sentence Beside Someone Who Has Stopped
A woman has been guided by an older member for three years. At first the guidance was welcome. Now she is told which job she may take, whom she may visit, and what she may say to her family. When she asks why, she is told that questions show a proud heart. She has stopped seeing her old friends. She no longer knows whether what she feels is her own judgement or the other person's. (an invented example)
This lecture is hard because it concerns care gone wrong. The people who cause such harm are seldom villains. Often they began with sincere love, sometimes with real gifts, and slid by degrees. The adults who suffer it are often among the most committed. For that reason the lecture avoids stock villains and tries instead to name signs, so that an adult, a companion and a community can see early what is happening.
The lecture does four things. It states fairly the case for strong spiritual guidance and says what separates it from control. It names five signs that care has become control. It says what an adult can do. It says what a community can do. It uses no names and no graphic detail, and it follows the ethic of this course: notice, stay, pass on.
이 23분으로 얻는 것
- State fairly the case for strong spiritual guidance, and say what separates it from control.
- Name five signs that care has become control.
- Describe what an adult who suspects this can do, and whom to tell.
- Describe what a community can do to make such harm less likely and to respond when it happens.
- Explain why a companion must also watch for these signs in himself or herself.
But Jesus summoned them, and said, “You know that the rulers of the nations lord it over them, and their great ones exercise authority over them. It shall not be so among you, but whoever desires to become great among you shall be your servant. Whoever desires to be first among you shall be your bondservant, even as the Son of Man came not to be served, but to serve, and to give his life as a ransom for many.”" — Matthew 20:25-28
World English Bible
I wrote to the assembly, but Diotrephes, who loves to be first among them, doesn’t accept what we say. Therefore if I come, I will call attention to his deeds which he does, unjustly accusing us with wicked words. Not content with this, neither does he himself receive the brothers, and those who would, he forbids and throws out of the assembly." — 3 John 1:9-10
WEB
Son of man, prophesy against the shepherds of Israel, prophesy, and tell them, even to the shepherds, Thus says the Lord Yahweh: Woe to the shepherds of Israel who feed themselves! Shouldn’t the shepherds feed the sheep? You eat the fat, and you clothe yourself with the wool, you kill the fatlings; but you don’t feed the sheep. You haven’t strengthened the diseased, neither have you healed that which was sick, neither have you bound up that which was broken, neither have you brought back that which was driven away, neither have you sought that which was lost; but with force and with rigor you have ruled over them." — Ezekiel 34:2-4
WEB
Jesus says his followers must not rule as the nations do. John writes about a person in a church who loved to be first and shut others out. Ezekiel speaks against shepherds who fed themselves and ruled the sheep with force.
1. The strongest case for strong guidance
Before naming harm, it is fair to state the case that some will bring against this lecture. Many serious Christians, in many centuries, have given themselves to a guide. Monks and nuns in several traditions promise obedience to a superior or an . An Orthodox believer may ask a spiritual father or mother for direction in daily life. A Catholic may put themselves under a director. Some Pentecostal and evangelical believers deliberately place themselves under a pastor or a discipler and ask to be corrected. They would say that an adult who answers to no one answers to the self alone, that the self is a poor judge, and that a trusted guide has helped them see what they could not.
This is a serious view. This lecture does not deny it. It does not say that guidance should be light or that an adult should never obey a guide. It says that what makes strong guidance safe is a short list of conditions, and that harm is nearly always the failure of one or more of them:
- the adult chose it freely, and can leave it without punishment;
- it is limited to the matters the adult agreed to, and does not spread into everything;
- the guide is accountable to others, and the adult can speak to someone outside the relationship;
- questions are allowed, including questions about the guide;
- there are no secrets that the guide keeps from every other trusted person, and no secrecy used as a weapon.
Where these conditions hold, strong guidance can be a gift. Where they are missing, the same words, "obedience", "submission", "accountability", "covering", can describe harm.
2. Five signs that care has become control
No single sign proves harm. A pattern of several should make a person stop and look.
1. Obedience is expected in private life. The companion begins to decide matters that belong to the adult: whom to marry, whether to take a job, how to spend money, how to raise children, which doctor to see, whether to leave. An adult may seek advice on these, and may take it. But the decision remains the adult's, and a companion who would be displeased if the adult decided otherwise has moved from advice to command.
2. The adult is cut off from others. The companion discourages, subtly or openly, contact with family, old friends, other churches or other advisers. The reasons sound spiritual: "they will pull you down," "they do not understand," "this season needs focus." The effect is that the companion becomes the adult's only trusted voice. Isolation is one of the plainest signs, because without other voices an adult cannot compare.
3. Shame is used as a tool. The companion corrects by making the adult feel small. The adult is spoken about before others, or reminded of past faults, or told that doubt, tiredness or sorrow is a sign of weak faith. Honest conviction of wrong is one thing. Shame that works to keep a person quiet and obedient is another. A companion who needs the adult to feel worthless in order to be heeded is not guiding.
4. Secrets and a closed circle. The companion asks the adult to keep the relationship, or what is said, from the pastor, family or others who would normally know. The adult is told that outsiders would not understand or would misuse what is shared. A companion who is open to being known has nothing to fear from other eyes. Secrecy that protects the adult's dignity is one thing. Secrecy that protects the companion is another, and the difference is often visible: ask who is protected.
5. Questions are punished. The adult who asks "why?", who disagrees, or who wishes to go elsewhere, meets coolness, anger, withdrawal of attention or warnings about the spiritual cost. Questions are treated as rebellion. In a healthy relationship, a question is a sign that the adult is thinking, and the companion is glad of it.
Other signs often travel with these: demands for money or labour to be given in ways that favour the companion, a sense that the companion's word is on the level of Scripture, fear in the adult before meetings, relief when a meeting is cancelled, and an inability to say "no" without bracing for the response.
The signs are about what the relationship does, not about how the companion feels. A companion may be sincere, kind in public and convinced of acting for the adult's good. The question is the pattern.
3. What Scripture says about power
Matthew 20:25-28 repeats the central teaching: among the nations, rulers "lord it over" others, "it shall not be so among you." The great person is the servant. The Son of Man himself came "not to be served, but to serve." This is not a warning against all authority. It describes how authority is held in Christ's community: as service, open to the person who is served.
Ezekiel 34 is a stern word to the leaders of a people. The shepherds "feed themselves," do not strengthen the weak, and rule "with force and with rigor." The passage does not condemn shepherding. It condemns shepherding that serves the shepherd. It is a text to read slowly, as a companion, and to ask: am I feeding the sheep, or am I being fed by them?
3 John 9-10 describes a person who "loves to be first." He does not receive the brothers and "throws out of the assembly" those who would. We know little about him beyond these lines, and it would be unwise to build a full portrait. But the text shows two signs from our list in the first century: a love of being first, and the shutting out of others. Harm of this kind is not new.
4. The companion examines himself or herself
Most companions will read this lecture and think of other people. Good. But the more important question is about oneself. Control rarely announces itself. A companion who is tired, anxious about the adult, or proud of a successful companionship can slide into it.
Some questions a companion can ask, privately or with a trusted supervisor:
- Would I be hurt if this adult chose differently from my advice? How hurt?
- Does this adult have other people to turn to? Do I encourage that?
- Have I ever kept something about this relationship from my pastor because I thought they would not understand?
- Do I enjoy being needed more than I enjoy the adult's growing freedom?
- Could I say "I was wrong" to this adult?
- Is the adult afraid of me, even a little?
If the answers worry you, the remedy is not despair. It is to tell someone responsible, to loosen your hold, to return decisions, and to be open to correction. Chapter 6 returns to the companion's own need of a companion.
5. What an adult can do
An adult who suspects that a relationship has become controlling may feel confused, ashamed or afraid. The feeling of confusion is itself a common sign. The suggestions below are not a formula. They are offered to a person who wishes to think.
Notice and trust the noticing. Writing a few lines privately about what is asked and how it feels can bring clarity. You are allowed to say that something is wrong without proving it.
Speak with someone outside the relationship. Choose a person you trust who is not under the companion's influence: a pastor of your community or of another church, a family member, a friend, a doctor, a qualified counsellor. Say what is happening, in as much detail as you wish. You do not have to name anyone if you are not ready.
You may slow down, step back or stop. An adult has the right to decline a request, to end a meeting, to change companions or to leave a group. A true guide will let you go. If you fear leaving, that fear is itself information to bring to the person you trust.
Keep contact with others. Do not cut off family, friends or other company, even if you are told to.
If you are in danger now, whether from a person's threats, violence, or your own thoughts of harming yourself, call the local emergency number. Duties to report and available help differ by country; a trusted person or a local helpline can tell you what is available where you live.
You are not guilty for having been guided. Many careful, faithful people have found themselves in this position. Leaving or questioning is not a betrayal of God.
6. What a community can do
Harm of this kind is much more likely where nobody else can see. A community can take steps that reduce it without making anyone suspicious of every friendship.
Write down a policy. Put in writing how companions are chosen, how they meet, what they may and may not ask of adults, whom they answer to, and what an adult can do if something seems wrong. Publish it so that adults can read it.
Make sure every companion has someone above or beside them. A pastor, a supervisor or a small team who hears, without names, how the work is going. A companion who answers to no one is a risk, whatever his or her character.
Give adults other doors. Tell adults who they can speak to if they have a concern, including a person outside the line of the companion and, where possible, someone from outside the congregation. In a very small church, this may be a neighbouring church's pastor or a trusted person from the wider denomination.
Welcome questions about guidance. If asking is treated as disloyalty, the community has trained itself not to see.
Respond to a concern with care. When an adult comes forward, listen, take it seriously, do not defend the companion at once, and do not interrogate the adult. Do not put pressure on anyone to keep silent. Follow the written policy and, where the matter may be serious, involve those who have proper authority and training. The duties of a church to report certain matters differ greatly between countries, and a community must know the law where it lives. Respond to immediate danger with the emergency number.
Do not make a villain too soon. A companion who is the subject of a concern deserves to be treated fairly and to be heard. But fairness to the companion does not come before the safety of the adult. A process should protect the person who spoke and the person spoken about, and be run by people who are not their friends.
Learn from what happened. A community that discovers harm has the duty to change what allowed it, and not merely to remove a person.
7. A difference of tradition
A liturgical community may have an established structure of guidance, with a bishop, a priest or an elder above the guide, and a body of rules about what a guide may ask. This is a strength. The risk is that the structure is trusted so much that nobody asks questions inside it.
A free church or an assembly may have loose arrangements and little hierarchy. The risk is that a gifted leader's influence has no outside limit, and the congregation has no way to question him or her.
A very small church with one leader and a few helpers has the hardest task, because there may be no one above the leader. Here the best course is to connect with a wider body: a neighbouring church, a denominational office, a trusted retired pastor, or a few mature members who agree to act as a check. Even a very small church can write down what a companion may not do.
Diagram 1. Five signs of control, and the doors that stay open
핵심 요약
- Strong spiritual guidance is a serious practice; it is safe when it is chosen, limited, accountable, open to questions and free of secrets.
- Five signs of control: obedience in private life, isolation from others, shame as a tool, secrets and a closed circle, and punished questions.
- No single sign proves harm; the pattern matters, and the question is what the relationship does, not how the companion feels.
- Matthew 20:25-28 says authority among Christ's followers is service; Ezekiel 34 condemns shepherds who feed themselves.
- An adult can notice, speak with someone outside, step back, keep other company, and call the emergency number in danger.
- A community can write a policy, give adults other doors, welcome questions, and respond with care; a companion must also examine himself or herself.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| When is strong guidance safe? | When it is chosen, limited, accountable to others, open to questions, and free of secrecy. |
| Five signs of control | Obedience in private life; cutting off from others; shame as a tool; secrets; punished questions. |
| What an adult can do | Notice, speak with someone outside the relationship, step back, keep other company, call the emergency number in danger. |
| What a community can do | Write a policy, give other doors, welcome questions, respond with care and fairness. |
One sentence to remember Care becomes control when the relationship takes away choices, other voices and questions; keep all three open.
This week's action Write down two people outside your own circle of guides whom you could speak to if you ever had a worry about a guide, and keep the page where only you will find it.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- Strong guidance is practised in many traditions. Which of the five conditions (chosen, limited, accountable, questions allowed, no secrets) do you think is most often missing when it goes wrong? Why?
- Which of the five signs would be hardest for you to notice in a relationship you value? Why?
- Why might an adult who is being controlled be the last person to name it?
- If someone came to you with a worry about a companion, what would you say in your first minute? What would you avoid saying?
- Read Ezekiel 34:2-4 as a companion. What does the passage ask you to examine in yourself?
- Does your community have a written policy on how companions are chosen and whom they answer to? If not, who might begin one?