Lecture 1-2: Scripture and Psychology: The Positions
목차 31
- Lecture 1-1: A Map Is Not the Ground
- Lecture 1-2: Scripture and Psychology: The Positions
- Lecture 1-3: Questions to Ask of Any Theory
- Lecture 1-4: Why This Matters for Those Who Care
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: My Own Map
- Lecture 2-1: The Psychodynamic Tradition
- Lecture 2-2: Attachment
- Lecture 2-3: Images of God and Early Relationships
- Lecture 2-4: Hidden Motives and the Heart
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Reading One Scene Two Ways
- Lecture 3-1: Behaviour and Learning
- Lecture 3-2: Cognitive Theories
- Lecture 3-3: Renewing the Mind: Cognitive Approaches and Scripture
- Lecture 3-4: What Habit and Thought Cannot Reach
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Same Event, Two Readings
- Lecture 4-1: The Person-Centred Approach
- Lecture 4-2: Meaning and Existence
- Lecture 4-3: Story and Solutions
- Lecture 4-4: Three Gifts, Three Cautions
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: How Do I Listen?
- Lecture 5-1: Family Systems
- Lecture 5-2: Culture, Society and Context
- Lecture 5-3: The Church as a System
- Lecture 5-4: Seeing Wider
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Drawing a Web
Sooner or later a student of this course will hear someone say, "A Christian should not need psychology. We have the Bible." Another person will say, "Psychology studies how God made the mind. It would be foolish to ignore it." Both speak sincerely, and both can point to Scripture.
This lecture does not settle that argument. It sets out four common ways Christians have understood the relation between Scripture and the study of the human mind, and it states each in a form its own supporters would recognise. It also gives the method this course will follow in every later week.
A word on scope. This is a short map of the positions, not a history of Christian counselling and the disputes within it. That history is taught in the Christian counselling course, PT4E. Here you need only know that the positions exist, why serious people hold them, and how this course will read.
이 17분으로 얻는 것
- State four positions on how Scripture relates to psychology, each in a way its supporters would accept.
- Name at least one passage that people of each position often cite.
- Explain why Catholic and Orthodox traditions of pastoral care do not fit neatly into these four labels.
- Describe the three steps this course takes with every theory: learn it, name its assumptions, hold it beside Scripture.
Every Scripture is God-breathed and profitable for teaching, for reproof, for correction, and for instruction in righteousness," — 2 Timothy 3:16
World English Bible
that the man of God may be complete, thoroughly equipped for every good work." — 2 Timothy 3:17
WEB
seeing that his divine power has granted to us all things that pertain to life and godliness, through the knowledge of him who called us by his own glory and virtue;" — 2 Peter 1:3
WEB
For the invisible things of him since the creation of the world are clearly seen, being perceived through the things that are made, even his everlasting power and divinity; that they may be without excuse." — Romans 1:20
WEB
The heavens declare the glory of God. The expanse shows his handiwork. Day after day they pour out speech, and night after night they display knowledge. There is no speech nor language, where their voice is not heard. Their voice has gone out through all the earth, their words to the end of the world. In them he has set a tent for the sun," — Psalms 19:1-4
WEB
The first two passages are often cited by those who stress the sufficiency of Scripture. The last two are often cited by those who stress that God can be known, and creation studied, outside the pages of the Bible. Read all four. A careful reader will see that none of them was written to answer a question about modern psychology. They are used because they speak of what Scripture is for and of what creation shows.
1. Why there are positions at all
Psychology, as a modern field, is young. The Bible and the great Christian traditions are old. When the two meet, a question arises that neither could answer ahead of time: how far may a Christian learn about the human person from sources outside Scripture?
The question is not only academic. A woman in a parish is struggling and her priest wonders whether to offer her a book on anxiety. A small-group leader is asked whether it is right to use a personality test. A pastor reads a theory of grief and wonders whether to trust it. Each of them needs some way of thinking about the question, and Christians have given different answers, for reasons that deserve respect.
Four answers appear again and again. They are not parties in a war. They are better read as four settled habits of mind, and individuals often hold a mixture.
2. Position one: Scripture is sufficient
The first position holds that Scripture is enough for the care of souls. Its supporters point to passages such as 2 Timothy 3:16-17, which says that Scripture equips the person of God for "every good work," and 2 Peter 1:3, which says that God has granted "all things that pertain to life and godliness."
The strongest form of this view is not that the Bible is a medical or scientific textbook. It is that the deep questions of counselling are questions about the heart, sin, suffering, hope and the way of life, and on these questions Scripture speaks with an authority no human system can match. Supporters worry about something real: that a theory made outside the faith, with its own picture of the person, may quietly take the place of the gospel while a church thinks it is only borrowing a tool. They want every claim about the person tested by Scripture first, and they distrust systems that explain people without mentioning God.
3. Position two: Integration
The second position holds that all truth is God's truth, and that the study of the mind, like the study of the body or the stars, can be a study of God's creation. Supporters point to Romans 1:20, which speaks of what can be seen "through the things that are made," and to Psalm 19:1-4, where the heavens "pour out speech" day after day.
The strongest form of this view is that refusing to learn what careful observation has found about people is not faithfulness; it is a kind of carelessness. A Christian physician does not refuse medicine because the Bible is silent about antibiotics. In the same way, the argument runs, a Christian carer may learn from careful research on grief, memory or family life, always placing what is learned under the authority of Scripture. Integration means holding the two together, not mixing them without care. Supporters know the risk of importing hidden assumptions, and they say the answer is to test what is imported, not to refuse it.
4. Position three: Levels of explanation
The third position says that theology and psychology answer different kinds of questions, and that they are not rivals. Think of how many accounts we can give of one event. A kettle boils. A physicist says it is molecules moving. A cook says it is time for tea. Neither contradicts the other, because they answer different questions at different levels.
On this view, a person's experience can be described in many ways at once: in terms of the body, of the mind, of relationships, of society and of the person's standing before God. The strongest form is that a good account at one level does not cancel an account at another. A study of memory does not answer whether a person is forgiven; a doctrine of forgiveness does not explain how memory works. The task is to keep the levels distinct and ask how they relate. Supporters warn against two errors: reducing everything to one level, and using talk about one level to dismiss another.
5. Position four: Christian psychology
The fourth position seeks to build an account of the person from within the Christian view, drawing on Scripture and the long history of Christian reflection on the soul, rather than adapting a psychology first built on other foundations. Supporters point out that the church has thought about the passions, the will, habit, memory and desire for many centuries, and they believe this inheritance has too often been forgotten.
The strongest form of this view is that a field cannot be neutral about what a person is, so Christians should not simply receive their picture of the person from elsewhere and then adjust it. They should do the work of building one. Supporters do not usually say that everything outside the church is useless. They say that the foundations matter, and that the work of reconstruction, though slow, belongs to the church.
6. A note on the liturgical traditions
These four labels were mostly shaped in some Protestant settings. They do not map neatly onto the Catholic and Orthodox churches, and a student from one of those traditions should not feel obliged to find a place for themselves among them.
Catholic and Orthodox traditions have long histories of that begin from other questions. They speak of the care of souls through confession, spiritual direction, the examination of conscience, the counsel of a spiritual father or mother, the sacraments and the life of prayer. In these traditions the person is carried by the whole life of a community, its calendar and its worship, as well as by individual conversations. In many places, Pentecostal and charismatic communities also have their own ways of speaking about care, such as prayer for healing, testimony and the guidance of the Spirit. These ways of care did not begin as answers to modern psychology, and they cannot be fully described by the four positions. Throughout this course we will try to speak in ways that all of these communities can recognise, and we will often come back to the practices of the church as well as to the ideas of the theorists.
7. Where readers will not agree
This is a point where readers will not agree. Some Christians hold that Scripture is sufficient for the care of souls and distrust importing psychological systems. Some hold that psychology studies God's creation and can be integrated under Scripture. Some treat theology and psychology as different levels of explanation. Some seek to rebuild psychology from within a Christian view of the person. Each of these positions has thoughtful supporters, each is trying to be faithful, and each has a fair worry about the others. The first worries about imported assumptions. The second worries about ignoring truth. The third worries about confusion between kinds of question. The fourth worries about foundations.
This course does not require you to choose one. It asks for less. Every theory is to be read with its assumptions named and tested against Scripture. No tradition is called the only faithful one. A student who holds the first position will find it respected in this course, and so will a student who holds the second. The detail of these debates, and the people who have argued them, is in PT4E.
8. How this course reads
Whatever position you hold, the method in this course is the same. For each theory, we take three steps.
Learn it fairly. State what the theory says in a way its own supporters would recognise. A critic who cannot do this has not yet earned the right to criticise.
Name its assumptions. Every theory carries beliefs about what a person is, why people suffer and what helps. Say them out loud. Often the most important things in a theory are the ones it never says.
Hold it beside Scripture and the traditions. Ask where the theory agrees with what Scripture and the church say of the human person, where it differs, and where Christians themselves disagree. Then keep what is helpful, set aside what is not, and say plainly which is which.
This method leaves room for all four positions. A person who holds the sufficiency of Scripture can use it as a way of testing. A person who prefers integration can use it as a way of learning. And all of us can keep to the central claim of the course: a theory is a map, and a map is not the person.
Diagram 1. Four positions on Scripture and psychology
핵심 요약
- Christians have given four common answers on how Scripture relates to psychology: sufficiency of Scripture, integration, levels of explanation, and Christian psychology.
- Each position has serious supporters and a fair worry about the others. None is the only faithful one.
- Catholic, Orthodox and Pentecostal traditions have their own long ways of caring for souls that the four labels do not fully describe.
- This course asks for less than any one position requires: read each theory with its assumptions named and tested against Scripture.
- The method has three steps: learn the theory fairly, name its assumptions, and hold it beside Scripture and the traditions.
- The detail of the debate belongs to the course PT4E.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| The four positions | Sufficiency of Scripture; integration; levels of explanation; Christian psychology. |
| Worry of the sufficiency view | Imported ideas may quietly replace the gospel while a church thinks it is only borrowing a tool. |
| Worry of the integration view | Refusing what careful study has found is a kind of carelessness, not faithfulness. |
| The three steps of this course | Learn the theory fairly; name its assumptions; hold it beside Scripture and the traditions. |
One sentence to remember Faithful Christians read psychology in different ways, and this course asks only that every theory be read with its assumptions named and tested against Scripture.
This week's action Write down which of the four positions is nearest to your own and one thing you could learn from another.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- Which of the four positions is closest to the way you were taught? What strength does it have that the others lack?
- Choose one position you do not hold. State it in a way that a person who holds it would say, "Yes, that is what I mean."
- Each position has a worry about the others. Is any of those worries one you share?
- How does your own tradition speak about the care of souls? What practices does it have that the four labels do not capture?
- Why might "learn it fairly" be the hardest of the three steps?