Lecture 1-3: Questions to Ask of Any Theory
목차 31
- Lecture 1-1: A Map Is Not the Ground
- Lecture 1-2: Scripture and Psychology: The Positions
- Lecture 1-3: Questions to Ask of Any Theory
- Lecture 1-4: Why This Matters for Those Who Care
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: My Own Map
- Lecture 2-1: The Psychodynamic Tradition
- Lecture 2-2: Attachment
- Lecture 2-3: Images of God and Early Relationships
- Lecture 2-4: Hidden Motives and the Heart
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Reading One Scene Two Ways
- Lecture 3-1: Behaviour and Learning
- Lecture 3-2: Cognitive Theories
- Lecture 3-3: Renewing the Mind: Cognitive Approaches and Scripture
- Lecture 3-4: What Habit and Thought Cannot Reach
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Same Event, Two Readings
- Lecture 4-1: The Person-Centred Approach
- Lecture 4-2: Meaning and Existence
- Lecture 4-3: Story and Solutions
- Lecture 4-4: Three Gifts, Three Cautions
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: How Do I Listen?
- Lecture 5-1: Family Systems
- Lecture 5-2: Culture, Society and Context
- Lecture 5-3: The Church as a System
- Lecture 5-4: Seeing Wider
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Drawing a Web
A traveller who is given a new map does not simply follow it. She asks: Who drew this? When? From what height did they look? What did they leave out? Does it match the road under my feet? These questions are not rude. They are what a sensible traveller does.
This lecture gives you a set of questions of that kind, for any theory of counselling or human development. They will be used in every later week. The lecture also sketches, briefly, the picture of the human person that Scripture and the Christian traditions give, so that you have something to hold a theory beside. And it teaches a skill that sounds small and is not: telling a useful insight from an assumption.
이 16분으로 얻는 것
- List the main questions to ask of any theory.
- Explain why evidence from research, from clinical experience and from a thinker's own reflection are different kinds of support.
- Describe, in six short phrases, the biblical picture of the human person used in this course.
- Separate a useful insight from an assumption in a sample statement.
- Explain why the questions are not a method for deciding which theory is "right".
God created man in his own image. In God’s image he created him; male and female he created them." — Genesis 1:27
World English Bible
I will give thanks to you, for I am fearfully and wonderfully made. Your works are wonderful. My soul knows that very well." — Psalms 139:14
WEB
for all have sinned, and fall short of the glory of God;" — Romans 3:23
WEB
Therefore if anyone is in Christ, he is a new creation. The old things have passed away. Behold, all things have become new." — 2 Corinthians 5:17
WEB
These four verses are not a full doctrine of the person. They are four pegs on which to hang a sketch: made in God's image, made with care, fallen short, made new. The full teaching is in the theology course, ST3E.
1. Seven questions
Here are seven questions to ask of any theory. You do not need to answer all of them for every theory. They are a way of looking, not a form to be filled in.
1. What is its picture of the person? This is the first of the four parts from lecture 1-1. Look for the picture that is spoken, and then look for the one that is assumed. A theory may never say what a person is, and still treat the person as if they were one thing: a machine, a plant, a story, a member of a team.
2. What kind of evidence does it rest on? There are several kinds, and they are not the same.
- Research: studies in which many people are observed or measured, often compared, and results are checked by others. Research can show patterns across many people. It can be weak if the study was small, short or poorly designed, and good studies still describe groups, not individuals.
- Clinical experience: what practitioners have seen over years of work with patients. This can be rich and deep, and it often notices what research misses. But it is gathered from the people who came for help, and the practitioner's own expectations can shape what is noticed.
- A thinker's reflection: a large idea from a gifted mind, drawn from observation and from thought. Many important theories began this way. Such ideas may be wise, and they may also be hard to test.
Most theories rest on a mixture. Ask which kind carries the most weight, and do not treat all three as equal. Do not assume that a theory is true because a famous person said it, or false because it is old.
3. From which culture and sample does it come? Many theories of counselling and development were first built by people in a few countries, often in universities and clinics, studying people near at hand. That does not make them false. It does mean that the first question to ask of a claim about "people" is: which people? A pattern found among families in one kind of society may look different in another. Lecture 5-2 returns to this in detail, but you can ask the question from the beginning.
4. What does it explain well? Be generous. Every theory that has lasted has lasted because it helps with something. A fair reader names the strength first.
5. What does it miss? Then ask what the theory leaves in the dark. Does it say little about the body? About society? About choice? About God? About joy? A theory is usually strongest where its lamp is turned and weakest where it is not.
6. Where does it meet the biblical picture, and where does it collide? This is the question that makes a course like this one different from a course in a secular university. Below, you will find a short sketch of the biblical picture to hold the theory beside.
7. What is the theory for? Some theories were made to explain, some to treat, some to describe how people grow. A theory built for one purpose can be badly misused when taken for another.
2. A short sketch of the biblical picture
Scripture and the Christian traditions give a picture of the human person with several parts. The details are taught in the theology course, ST3E; what is needed here is only an outline, so that you have something to hold a theory beside. Remember too that Christians differ on some points, and the outline is the common ground rather than the whole of any one tradition.
Made in God's image. The person is not an accident or a machine. Genesis 1:27 says that God made human beings in his image. Christians have understood this in different ways, but most agree that it gives every person a dignity that does not depend on health, usefulness or success.
Embodied. Psalm 139:14 says that the person is "fearfully and wonderfully made." The person is not a mind with a body attached. Body, feeling, thought and spirit belong together, and care for one cannot ignore the others.
Relational. From the first chapters of Scripture, the person is made for relationship with God and with other people. Loneliness, bonds, family and community are not extras.
Fallen. Romans 3:23 says that all have sinned and fall short of the glory of God. Christians understand human trouble as having more than one source: a person may suffer from what others have done, from what has happened to them in a broken world, and from their own wrongdoing. Each of these must be named honestly, and they are not the same thing. A person who has been wronged is not told that their suffering is simply their own fault.
Redeemed. In Christ, 2 Corinthians 5:17 speaks of a new creation. The Christian story does not end with . It speaks of forgiveness, change and hope, though traditions describe the means and the pace of change differently.
Searching for meaning. Human beings ask why. They look for purpose, for a story that makes sense of their life, for a reason to hope. Scripture takes these questions seriously, in the Psalms, in Job and Ecclesiastes, and in the teaching of Jesus.
These six phrases are not a test that a theory must pass. They are a place to stand while reading.
3. Separating an insight from an assumption
Here is the most useful skill in this course, and it can be practised now.
An insight is something observed that helps you see better. An assumption is something taken for granted, often unspoken, about what a person is or what matters most. A theory nearly always contains both, tangled together.
Read the following invented statement.
(An invented example) A teacher says: "Children who are praised too much become unable to cope with failure, so we should be careful to praise only what is truly earned."
Pull it apart. Is there an insight? Possibly yes: some children, in some situations, may come to depend on praise, and praise that is not tied to anything real may not help. That is something a careful observer might notice. What assumptions lie underneath? That the main way a child develops is through the pattern of praise and failure. That the child's strength is mainly a matter of habit. That coping is the chief goal. That the child has no other sources of confidence, such as a stable home, the love of a grandparent or faith. Some of these assumptions may be right. None of them is proved by the statement. A careful reader keeps the insight and tests the assumptions.
Here is the same exercise on a smaller scale. Suppose a person says, "Those who had a hard childhood will have a hard adult life." The insight might be that early hardship can leave marks that matter later. The assumption is that the marks decide the outcome. Scripture, human experience and much careful research all point to many exceptions, to healing and to change. The insight may be kept without the assumption.
When you read a theory, you will often find that the insight is what the theory saw and the assumption is what it did not know it was saying.
4. Using the questions without ranking
One more warning. These questions are for reading, not for ranking. Do not use them to decide which theory is "the correct one" or "the most biblical." A theory may be strong in research and weak in its picture of the person. Another may have a rich picture and little evidence. A third may be useful for one purpose and misleading for another. The questions help you see what you have before you. They do not remove the need for judgement, and they do not turn a student into a judge of other people's work.
They also do not turn a student into a diagnostician. As lecture 1-1 said, a theory is not to be used to diagnose yourself or anyone else.
Each theory in the following weeks will be read in three steps: what it says, what it explains and what it misses, and how it meets the Christian picture. These seven questions are the tools for those steps. Keep them near.
Diagram 1. Seven questions, and the biblical picture to hold beside
핵심 요약
- Seven questions help in reading any theory: its picture of the person, its evidence, its culture and sample, its strengths, its gaps, its meeting with Scripture, and its purpose.
- Research, clinical experience and a thinker's reflection are different kinds of support. Ask which carries the most weight.
- Many theories were first built from samples in a few countries, so ask of any claim about "people": which people?
- The biblical picture used here has six phrases: made in God's image, embodied, relational, fallen, redeemed, and searching for meaning.
- An insight is something observed. An assumption is something taken for granted. Keep the insight and test the assumption.
- The questions are for reading, not for ranking theories or for diagnosing people.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Three kinds of evidence | Research (patterns across many people); clinical experience (what practitioners have seen); a thinker's reflection (a large idea from a gifted mind). |
| The question about sample | Which people did the theory come from? A claim about "people" may fit some and not others. |
| The biblical picture, in six phrases | Made in God's image; embodied; relational; fallen; redeemed; searching for meaning. |
| Insight versus assumption | An insight is observed and helps you see. An assumption is taken for granted and must be tested. |
One sentence to remember Ask of every theory what it sees, what it takes for granted, and where it meets the Christian picture of the person.
This week's action Take one claim about people that you often hear and write one insight in it and one assumption under it.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- Pick any idea about people that you hold strongly. Which kind of evidence supports it: research, clinical experience, or a thinker's reflection? Which kind do you tend to trust most, and why?
- Why is "which people?" an important question to ask when a theory speaks about "people"?
- Look at the six phrases of the biblical picture. Which one do you think is most often forgotten by theories of the person? Which is most often forgotten by churches?
- Write a statement you have heard about why people struggle. Separate the insight from the assumption.
- Why is it dangerous to use these questions to decide which theory is "the correct one"?