Lecture 2-3: Images of God and Early Relationships
목차 31
- Lecture 1-1: A Map Is Not the Ground
- Lecture 1-2: Scripture and Psychology: The Positions
- Lecture 1-3: Questions to Ask of Any Theory
- Lecture 1-4: Why This Matters for Those Who Care
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: My Own Map
- Lecture 2-1: The Psychodynamic Tradition
- Lecture 2-2: Attachment
- Lecture 2-3: Images of God and Early Relationships
- Lecture 2-4: Hidden Motives and the Heart
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Reading One Scene Two Ways
- Lecture 3-1: Behaviour and Learning
- Lecture 3-2: Cognitive Theories
- Lecture 3-3: Renewing the Mind: Cognitive Approaches and Scripture
- Lecture 3-4: What Habit and Thought Cannot Reach
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Same Event, Two Readings
- Lecture 4-1: The Person-Centred Approach
- Lecture 4-2: Meaning and Existence
- Lecture 4-3: Story and Solutions
- Lecture 4-4: Three Gifts, Three Cautions
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: How Do I Listen?
- Lecture 5-1: Family Systems
- Lecture 5-2: Culture, Society and Context
- Lecture 5-3: The Church as a System
- Lecture 5-4: Seeing Wider
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Drawing a Web
Ask ten believers in the same congregation to say what God is like, and you will hear the same creed from all ten. Ask them privately what God is like when I have failed, or when I am afraid, and the answers may differ. One person quietly pictures a judge with arms folded. Another pictures a father who is busy and distant. A third pictures a friend, close and warm. They all say the same words on Sunday. They do not all feel the same thing on Monday.
This lecture asks where that difference might come from. Some psychologists have suggested that part of the answer lies in the first relationships of a person's life. It joins lecture 2-1 (the inner images of early carers) to lecture 2-2 (the secure base), and applies them to a question that matters to anyone who cares for believers: why is trust in God easy for some and hard for others?
The subject needs care. The suggestion is real but its evidence is limited. And the claim that God is a shadow of someone's family is one that Christian faith firmly refuses. So this lecture presents the idea carefully, tests it, and then sets it beside what Scripture says.
이 19분으로 얻는 것
- Distinguish between what a person says about God and the felt image of God they carry.
- State the idea that a felt image of God may be linked to early relationships, and the two main forms of that idea.
- Explain why the evidence is limited and why the idea must not be used to explain a person's faith.
- State why the God of Scripture is not a projection of human experience.
- Describe what this means for a carer: patience, not argument.
Yahweh passed by before him, and proclaimed, “Yahweh! Yahweh, a merciful and gracious God, slow to anger, and abundant in loving kindness and truth," — Exodus 34:6
World English Bible
For you didn’t receive the spirit of bondage again to fear, but you received the Spirit of adoption, by whom we cry, “Abba! Father!”" — Romans 8:15
WEB
Yahweh appeared of old to me, saying, Yes, I have loved you with an everlasting love: therefore with loving kindness have I drawn you." — Jeremiah 31:3
WEB
The first verse is God describing himself, in his own words, to Moses. The second is a believer's cry. The third is a promise made to a people who had good reason to doubt. Read all three as speech from God and about God, before reading anything about psychology.
1. What the idea says
A doctrine of God is what a person or a church teaches about God: that he is one, that he is good, that he is merciful. An in the sense used in this lecture is something different. It is the felt picture a person carries — the face they imagine when they pray, the mood they expect God to be in, the way they think God will react to their failure. The two can differ. A person may state a doctrine of grace with complete honesty and carry, without knowing it, an image of someone who is hard to please.
One writer who made this distinction well known was Ana-Maria Rizzuto, a psychoanalyst, who argued that every person forms some inner representation of God, built from the materials of their early life, and that it goes on changing. Whether or not one accepts all of her argument, the observation matches what many carers notice: the God a person feels and the God a person confesses are not always the same.
Two forms of the idea have been proposed:
- The correspondence idea. A person's image of God is likely to resemble the way they experienced important adults. A child whose parents were warm and reliable may find it easier to imagine a warm and reliable God. A child whose parents were harsh, absent or unpredictable may find a harsh, distant or unpredictable God easier to imagine.
- The compensation idea. A person who lacked something in early life may turn to God to supply it. A child with an absent father may long for a God who is a Father in the full sense. On this view, the image of God may be the opposite of what the person knew, and a source of comfort.
Researchers have looked for both. The results are, in careful words, mixed. There is some evidence of a link in some groups of people, and some evidence for compensation in others. Many studies depended on what people said about themselves in questionnaires, and most were done with limited samples. The honest summary is that early relationships may shape how a person pictures God, and that they are one influence among many.
Other influences are large. A person's image of God is shaped by what they were taught, by the worship they have been part of, by the stories they heard, by friends and teachers, by suffering, by an experience of being forgiven, and by the Spirit. Churches themselves shape the image. A congregation that talks mainly of judgement will shape one image; one that talks mainly of welcome will shape another. And an image can change. People often find that their picture of God is altered by a single good friendship, by long prayer, or by hard times.
2. An invented example
(an invented example) Daniel is a man in his forties who has attended his assembly for many years. He can recite the doctrine of grace. In a small group, a leader notices that whenever Daniel speaks of prayer, he says things such as, "I'm sure God is tired of hearing from me," and "I don't want to bother him." Daniel is not troubled by the doctrine. He is troubled by a feeling he cannot argue with.
Now, a carer who knows only a little about this lecture may be tempted to say, "You had a hard father, and so you picture God as hard." That would be a mistake in three ways. First, the carer does not know it. Daniel has not said it. Second, even if Daniel's father was hard, the link between a father and an image of God is only a possibility, not an explanation. Third, the sentence would hand Daniel a theory in place of a welcome. We will return to what a carer might do instead.
3. What it explains, and what it misses
It helps explain:
- Why a person can confess a gracious God and feel a demanding one.
- Why two people who have heard the same sermons respond so differently.
- Why arguments rarely change a felt image, however good they are.
- Why words like "Father" are a comfort to some and a wound to others.
It misses, or may mislead:
- It can make faith look like nothing more than the echo of childhood. A believer may then wonder whether their trust is real or only inherited. The evidence does not support that conclusion.
- It can be applied to anyone, in any direction. If a person trusts God, "he had a good father." If a person doubts, "he had a bad one." A theory that explains every case and could be proved wrong by none is weak.
- It tends to overlook the many people whose image of God is better than their family, or worse, than the link would predict.
- It looks at the person and not at God. It tells you how a picture of God forms; it cannot tell you whether the picture is true.
4. How it meets the Christian picture of the person
Where it overlaps. Scripture itself accepts that the human mind forms images of God and that those images can be wrong. The Old Testament warns against making God in a human likeness. The New Testament speaks of a "spirit of bondage again to fear" that a believer can carry and that the Spirit of answers. Paul's phrase suggests that a person can come to God with an inherited fear and be taught something else. The Bible also uses family words — Father, mother, child, brother — as a way of speaking about God and his people. So there is room in Scripture for the thought that our first relationships colour how we hear those words.
Where it differs. Here the Christian answer is firm. God is not the shadow of anyone's family. The God of the Bible is not discovered by looking at one's own parents and enlarging them. He speaks, in Exodus 34:6, and says who he is: merciful, gracious, slow to anger, abundant in loving kindness and truth. This is the first thing to be said and the last. A person's felt image may be dim or dark; it is corrected by hearing who God says he is, in Scripture, in worship and in the life of the church — and not by a better theory about childhood. Many Christian traditions would add that God is met in the sacraments or ordinances, in the community, in the lives of saints and in prayer, in ways that go beyond any individual's inner picture.
This is a point where readers will not agree. Some Christians find in this research a real help. They say it explains why trust in God is hard for some and easy for others, and it teaches carers to be patient with a person whose felt image does not match their creed. Other Christians warn that the research risks making God's character depend on human experience: if a person's picture of God is built from their family, then the argument slides towards saying that God is only a projection, and the gospel's claim that God has made himself known is lost. Both concerns are serious. This course requires only that you hold the following together: that early experience may shape a felt image; that the evidence is limited; that correlation is not destiny; and that God is not the shadow of the family.
5. What this means for a carer
If a person's felt image of God is dark, a carer's first gift is not an argument. People rarely abandon a felt image because they lost a debate. A carer can do better in three ways, none of which requires a theory.
Patience. An image formed over years does not change in an afternoon. Do not take it as a failure of faith, in the person or in yourself, if it takes a long time.
A different experience. Often the image softens through being treated well: through a friend who is steady, through a worship service where the person is welcomed, through being forgiven by someone. The carer's own reliable presence is part of how the person learns what God is like. That is a heavy thing to say, and it must be said with humility; no carer can be God.
Scripture and the church's words, offered gently. Not as a verdict, but alongside. A short reading, a psalm, a prayer said together, a hymn. Let the person hear what God says of himself without being pushed to feel it.
And one honest limit. If a person's picture of God is bound up with fear that does not lift, or with memories of being hurt, or with thoughts of harming themselves, that is beyond what a friend or a pastor should handle alone. Stay with the person, and connect them with a qualified professional. If someone is in danger, call your local emergency number. In the United States, the 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline is available; other countries have their own crisis lines. Find the local number before you need it.
6. The map is not the person
The idea that our first relationships colour our picture of God is a map, and a useful one for a patient listener. It is not a reason to say, "I know why you believe what you do." It does not tell you what God is like. It tells you a little about why a particular person may find it hard to believe he is. The ground is God himself, who has made himself known, and the person in front of you, who is more than their childhood.
Diagram 1. Two sources of the picture of God
핵심 요약
- A person may confess a gracious God and carry a felt image of a harsher one. The two are not always the same.
- Two ideas link the felt image to early life: correspondence (the image resembles the carers) and compensation (the image fills a lack).
- The evidence is mixed and limited. Early relationships are one influence among many, and an image can change.
- God is not the shadow of anyone's family. He makes himself known in Scripture, worship and the church.
- A carer's gifts are patience, a different experience of being treated well, and God's words offered gently. They are not an argument or a theory about childhood.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Doctrine of God and felt image | Doctrine is what is taught. The felt image is the picture a person carries and feels in prayer. They can differ. |
| Correspondence and compensation | The image resembles early carers; or the image supplies what early carers lacked. Evidence for each is mixed. |
| What the evidence allows | Early relationships may shape the image. They are one influence among many and do not decide it. |
| What a carer offers | Patience, steady presence and God's own words offered gently, not an argument or a diagnosis. |
One sentence to remember Early life may colour how a person pictures God, but God is not the shadow of anyone's family.
This week's action Read Exodus 34:6 slowly, twice, in your own language. Write down one word in it that surprised you.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- What is the difference between what a person confesses about God and the felt image they carry? Why might they differ?
- Explain the correspondence idea and the compensation idea in your own words. Why does having two ideas weaken the theory?
- What was wrong with the carer's sentence to Daniel in the invented example? What might a carer say or do instead?
- Why is it a mistake to say that God is a projection of the family?
- Read Romans 8:15 again. What does it suggest about a believer who carries fear of God into the church?
- State fairly the two Christian positions on this research. Which question would you most want to put to each?