무료

수료증 무료 발급 — 2027년 3월 31일까지.

PT724E Grief and Bereavement Care: Walking Beside the Bereaved

Lecture 4-4: Anger, Doubt and Hard Questions to God

목차 31
PT724E Grief and Bereavement Care: Walking Beside the Bereaved
제 0 장 · Introduction: Staying Beside
  1. Lecture 0: Introduction: Staying Beside
제 1 장 · Week 1: Grief in Scripture and the Carer's Place
  1. Lecture 1-1: Grief in Scripture
  2. Lecture 1-2: How Traditions Understand Death, Funeral and Remembrance
  3. Lecture 1-3: Grief Is Love in Another Form
  4. Lecture 1-4: The Carer's Place and Limits
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: What We Say About Death and Loss
제 2 장 · Week 2: Around the Funeral
  1. Lecture 2-1: The First Days
  2. Lecture 2-2: The Funeral Season Beside the Family
  3. Lecture 2-3: Words That Hurt, Words That Help
  4. Lecture 2-4: Practical Help That Is Specific
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: A First Visit
제 3 장 · Week 3: Different Losses
  1. Lecture 3-1: Sudden Death
  2. Lecture 3-2: Long Illness, and the Death of an Older Person
  3. Lecture 3-3: The Death of a Child, Miscarriage and Stillbirth
  4. Lecture 3-4: Suicide Loss: Standing Beside Without Stigma
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Standing Differently for Different Losses
제 4 장 · Week 4: Children, Teenagers and the Family
  1. Lecture 4-1: Grieving Children
  2. Lecture 4-2: Grieving Teenagers
  3. Lecture 4-3: Conflict Inside a Bereaved Family
  4. Lecture 4-4: Anger, Doubt and Hard Questions to God
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Talking With a Child, Standing Between Relatives
제 5 장 · Week 5: Long Accompaniment and Referral
  1. Lecture 5-1: Anniversaries and the Long Months
  2. Lecture 5-2: Long Accompaniment
  3. Lecture 5-3: When Grief Needs More Help: Noticing and Connecting
  4. Lecture 5-4: Hope, and Prayer for the Dead
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Three Cases and an Anniversary Card
제 6 장 · Week 6: The Carer and the Congregation
  1. Lecture 6-1: The Carer's Own Losses
  2. Lecture 6-2: Limits, Rest and Not Being the Fixer
  3. Lecture 6-3: A Church That Cares for the Bereaved Over Years
  4. Lecture 6-4: Many Kinds of Community
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab: A One-Page Bereavement Care Policy

핵심만 먼저 보기 ↓

31분

Sooner or later, a carer who stays beside the bereaved will hear a sentence that sounds like the end of faith. Where was God? I do not pray any more. I am so angry at God I cannot go into the church. If God is good, why did he let her die? Maybe there is nothing there at all. Often the carer's first impulse is to answer: to explain, to defend God, to quote a verse, to say "You don't mean that." Sometimes the carer's second impulse is fear, for the person and for the carer's own faith.

This lecture argues that the carer's first task is not to answer but to stay. The Bible has a long tradition of protest, complaint and honest questions put to God, and it keeps them in the book. A person who is angry at God or doubting God is, in that tradition, often still speaking to God. The carer does not need to correct them, to win an argument or to repair a belief. The carer can listen, keep the door open, and trust that God is not frightened by a bereaved person's anger. The central claim of the course returns: grief is not an illness; it is love in another form. A church carer is not a fixer but someone who stays beside. The carer does not hurry, does not prescribe stages, helps more by presence than by words, and connects to professionals when more help is needed. The carer has losses and limits too.

This course is not grief therapy, and it gives no medical or psychological advice. It does not offer an answer to the problem of why God allows suffering; the course on suffering and illness takes that up at length. It prepares a carer to be present. The lecture describes no death scene, and it makes no assertion about any individual's salvation or the state of the dead.

이 31분으로 얻는 것

  • Describe the Bible's tradition of lament, protest and honest question, with examples from the Psalms, Job and the Gospels.
  • Explain why a carer does not correct, argue with or defend God against a bereaved person's anger or doubt.
  • Recognise some of the forms that anger, doubt and silence toward God take, including anger at the dead, at the church and at the carer.
  • Name responses that stay beside the person, and responses that close the conversation or use Scripture as a weapon.
  • Explain what a carer does when asked "Why?", "Where was God?" or whether a person is condemned, without a verdict.
  • Say when a carer should be concerned that more is going on than anger or doubt, and how to connect the person to help.

How long, Yahweh? Will you forget me forever? How long will you hide your face from me?" — Psalm 13:1

World English Bible

How long shall I take counsel in my soul, having sorrow in my heart every day? How long shall my enemy triumph over me?" — Psalm 13:2

WEB

My God, my God, why have you forsaken me? Why are you so far from helping me, and from the words of my groaning?" — Psalm 22:1

WEB

Yahweh, why do you reject my soul? Why do you hide your face from me?" — Psalm 88:14

WEB

Therefore I will not keep silent. I will speak in the anguish of my spirit. I will complain in the bitterness of my soul." — Job 7:11

WEB

It was so, that after Yahweh had spoken these words to Job, Yahweh said to Eliphaz the Temanite, “My wrath is kindled against you, and against your two friends; for you have not spoken of me the thing that is right, as my servant Job has." — Job 42:7

WEB

Therefore Martha said to Jesus, “Lord, if you would have been here, my brother wouldn’t have died." — John 11:21

WEB

Immediately the father of the child cried out with tears, “I believe. Help my unbelief!”" — Mark 9:24

WEB

Psalm 13:1 and 13:2 ask "How long?" four times in two verses. Psalm 22:1 opens with the words "My God, my God, why have you forsaken me?" Psalm 88:14 asks why Yahweh rejects the soul and hides his face, and Psalm 88 is notable because, unlike most laments, it ends without any turn to praise. These are in the Bible's own book of prayer. Job 7:11 records Job's decision not to keep silent: he will speak in the anguish of his spirit and complain in the bitterness of his soul. In Job 42:7 Yahweh tells Eliphaz that he is angry with him and his friends, because they have not spoken of him what is right "as my servant Job has". The verse is read in more than one way, and this lecture does not settle it. At the least it shows that Job's honest complaint is not condemned. In John 11:21 Martha says to Jesus, "Lord, if you would have been here, my brother wouldn't have died." Jesus does not rebuke her. He talks with her. In Mark 9:24 a father cries out with tears, "I believe. Help my unbelief!" Belief and doubt are said in one breath, and Jesus helps. Taken together, these passages show that anger, grief and uncertainty are not outside the faith the Bible describes. They are in it.

1. What a carer may hear

The forms are many, and a carer is wise to listen for more than the words.

Anger at God. How could you let this happen? I will never forgive him. This is the form people expect. It can be loud, or cold, or tired.

Questions put to God, or to no one. Why her? Why now? What was the point? These are not always seeking an answer. They are often a way of saying how large the loss is.

Doubt about whether God is there at all. Maybe none of it is true. Maybe I was a fool to pray. A death can shake a belief that was never tested before, or one that had held for decades.

Silence and distance. The person stops praying, stops reading Scripture, stops coming to worship. They may say nothing about it. They may say, "I just can't."

Anger at the church. At the minister who said the wrong thing, the members who did not call, the congregation that gossiped, the funeral that was not what the family wanted. Sometimes the anger at God is displaced onto the church because the church is nearer.

Anger at the dead. How could she leave me? Why did he not take care of himself? People often feel guilty at this. It is part of love's response, as lecture 3-4 said.

Anger at the carer. Sometimes the person turns on the one who comes, because the carer is there. A carer who has been snapped at has not necessarily failed.

Guilt and fear of punishment. Is God punishing me? Did my sin cause this? The person is turning the question inward. The carer does not confirm and does not scold.

Anger without words. A person may stand stiff in the pew, or leave early, or refuse to sing.

None of these is a stage. A person may move among them in a day. They may also be present together with real faith, deep sorrow and warm love for God.

2. The Bible's tradition of protest

A carer who has been taught that faith is always calm may be alarmed. The Bible itself is not calm.

The Psalms are full of complaint. A large part of the book of Psalms is lament: cries to God from people who feel abandoned, wronged, ill, grieving. They ask "How long?" and "Why?" and "Where are you?". They accuse. Many end in trust, some do not. They are not cut out as embarrassing. They are the prayer book of God's people. In many traditions they are sung and read in worship.

Job refuses to be silent. Job loses his children and his health. His friends, who first sat with him in silence, begin to speak, and what they say is explanation: that suffering must have a cause, that Job must have done something, that he should repent. Job refuses. He complains, he demands an answer, he says he is innocent. At the end, God speaks, and the passage quoted above says something about the friends and Job. Readers differ on the meaning of the whole book. What is clear is that the book gives a great deal of space to a man's anger and questions, and that those who tried to argue him out of them are the ones who are rebuked.

The prophets complain. Jeremiah and Habakkuk ask God why the wicked prosper and why God seems not to hear. They are not struck down.

In the Gospels, grief is spoken to Jesus. Martha and Mary each say to Jesus, "if you had been here, my brother would not have died." They say it as an accusation and as a statement of faith at once. Jesus weeps (John 11:35) and does not reprimand them. On the cross Jesus himself takes up the words "My God, my God, why have you forsaken me?" The cry of abandonment is within the Gospel story.

Faith and doubt are said together. "I believe. Help my unbelief." A person need not choose between them.

From this tradition a carer can take a simple thing. A bereaved person who says harsh things to God is not outside the people of God. They may be standing in a long line of people who prayed that way. The carer can say so, if it helps: "The Bible has people who said exactly this to God." The carer says it gently, as a sign that the person is not alone, and not as a lesson.

3. What the carer does not do

The carer does not correct. A person says, "God doesn't care." The carer does not say, "Of course he does." The carer does not defend God. God does not need defending by a carer at a kitchen table, and the person does not need to be told they are wrong in the middle of grief. Correcting leaves the person feeling that they cannot say it to the carer, and so they will say it to no one.

The carer does not argue. Argument turns the conversation into a debate, and the person into an opponent.

The carer does not explain. It is part of God's plan. God is teaching you something. Everything happens for a reason. God took her to spare her something worse. The carer does not know. These sentences claim to know God's reasons, and many bereaved people hear them as saying that the death was meant, or was good. The comfort they are meant to give often falls flat.

The carer does not say, "If you had faith..." or "A stronger believer would not feel this way." This lays a second weight on a person already carrying the first. Anger and doubt are not a lack of faith. Lecture 1-1 said that grief is not a lack of faith, and this is the same point applied to anger.

The carer does not quote Scripture as a weapon or a plaster. Verses on trust, on God's plan or on rejoicing in all things, offered to a person in the first weeks, can feel like being told to stop. Scripture is not forbidden. A carer may read a lament with a person who wants it. But the carer does not use a verse to close a conversation. If a verse is offered, it is offered as company ("these words may say it for you") and not as a correction.

The carer does not hurry the person back. There is no date by which a bereaved person ought to be praying or in church again. The carer does not pressure, does not check attendance as a sign of recovery and does not tell the person that they are letting down the congregation.

The carer does not take it personally. If anger lands on the carer, the carer can say, "I can hear how angry you are. I'm still here." The carer does not defend themself or withdraw their care.

The carer does not tell the person's words to others as a matter of concern. A conversation of this kind is confidential, subject to the limits of lecture 1-4: except where someone is in danger, and local rules differ: check locally. A prayer chain or a leaders' meeting is not the place to report "she has lost her faith".

4. What the carer can do

Listen and say it back. "You are angry at God." "You do not know whether anyone is listening." Saying it back does not agree and does not argue. It tells the person that they have been heard.

Allow silence. A person who has just said something terrible may need a moment. The carer does not hurry to fill it.

Say what is true without claiming more. "I do not know why this happened. I do not have an answer for you. I am here." This is honest, and in the long run more trusted than a neat explanation.

Give permission to say it to God. Some people fear that their anger is itself a sin, or that God will punish them. A carer can say, kindly, "You are allowed to say all this to God. The Psalms are full of it." That may be the first time anyone has told them so. If the person's tradition has particular forms of prayer for such times, the carer follows those.

Be a witness to hope without pressing it. The carer may say, if it is true for the carer and suits the person, "I will go on praying, even when you cannot." This is a gift that takes nothing from the person. The carer might also say, "You do not have to believe anything today."

Keep open the door. Invite the person to church, to a meal, to a walk, in a way that can be declined without fuss. If they stay away, a card, a call, a note: "We are thinking of you. There is a place for you when you want it, and no hurry."

Refer a question that belongs elsewhere. If a person asks a theological question the carer cannot answer, such as why God allows suffering, the carer can say honestly, "I do not know. I would like to find someone you can talk to about it, if you want to." That might be the minister, a priest or a spiritual director. The carer does not offer a half-remembered argument. The course on suffering and illness in general treats this question at length.

Respect the person's tradition. Traditions have their own ways of speaking to God in grief: set prayers, lament psalms, silent adoration, the of confession, anointing. The carer does not substitute their own way, and does not correct the person's.

5. "Why?", "Where was God?", and "Is she lost?"

These questions will come. Some principles.

"Why did God let this happen?" The carer does not give a reason. The carer can say, "I do not know. I think it is the question that nearly everyone asks. I do not want to answer it too quickly." Then the carer listens. Often the person does not want an answer. They want the question to be allowed.

"Where was God?" A carer may say, "I do not know. I do know that the Bible says God is near to the broken-hearted. I do not claim to understand how." That is a statement of hope within the church's confession. The carer does not use it to deny what the person feels, which may be that God was absent.

"Is it my fault? Is God punishing me?" A carer does not agree, and does not say with certainty that it is not. The carer can say, "I do not believe that God is looking for a reason to hurt you. I think you are in terrible pain." If the person is carrying a specific guilt, the carer can offer to help them speak to their own pastor, priest or confessor, according to their tradition.

"Is he in hell?" or "Is she saved?" This course makes no assertion about any individual's salvation or the state of the dead. The carer does not say yes or no. The carer can say what lecture 3-4 said: that God is merciful, that the dead are entrusted to God, and that the church waits in hope of the resurrection. The carer does not offer a private theory and does not say what the person wants to hear if it cannot honestly be said. The question can be taken to the person's own pastor or priest. Lecture 5-4 sets out the differences among traditions.

6. When there is more than anger or doubt

Anger and doubt are normal. A carer also needs to notice when something else is happening.

Danger signs. If a person speaks of wishing to die, or of wanting to join the one who died, or says "there's no point in going on", the carer does not treat this as only a theological problem. The carer stays, does not leave the person alone, and seeks help at once. This is the work of the crisis course.

Heavy, lasting withdrawal. If a person has stopped eating, sleeping, working or caring for those who depend on them for a long time, and nothing seems to lift, the problem may be more than spiritual. The carer can say, kindly and not as a verdict, "Some people find it helps to see a doctor or a counsellor at a time like this. It is not because you are weak." Lecture 5-3 returns to noticing and connecting.

A spiritual crisis within a particular tradition. Some people, in their own tradition, will need a priest, pastor or to hear them. The carer can help them find that person.

Anger that becomes dangerous to others. If the anger takes the form of threats or violence, the carer's safety and the safety of others come first, and the carer seeks help from the proper authorities. This is rare.

7. The carer's own questions

A carer who sits with a person's anger toward God may find their own faith shaken. This is not a failure. A carer who has lost someone may be tempted to say what they themselves needed to hear, or may feel anger rising that they have not yet faced. A carer who is shaken can step back and ask another to take the visits. Lecture 6-1 returns to the carer's own losses. The carer is not required to have everything settled, and a carer who is able to say "I do not know" is often more trusted than one who has an answer ready.

8. Small and large communities

(an invented example) In a house church of about twelve, a young mother, Mrs Ogunleye, lost her sister. After the funeral she stopped coming. The member who had been closest to her, Mr Santos, rang her. She said, "I'm not coming back. I've been praying for years and it did nothing." He did not say anything about prayer. He said, "That sounds like a lot of anger." She said, "Yes." They were quiet for a while. He said, "I'll ring again next week. You don't have to say anything." Each week he rang for a few minutes. In the fourth week she said, "I read a psalm last night. I don't know why." He said, "Which one?" He did not comment further. In a small group the person who is missed is noticed at once, and one steady voice on the phone may be enough.

(an invented example) In a large church, a man named Mr Wiśniewski lost his wife. He wrote an angry note to the pastor saying that the church had failed him and that he did not believe any more. The pastor passed the note to the bereavement team. The team leader, Ms Abara, rang him. She said, "I read your note. I'm sorry that we let you down. I'm not ringing to change your mind." He talked for forty minutes, mostly about the church. At the end she asked, "Would you let me ring you again next month?" He said, "If you want." She kept a note of the date, with no detail of what he had said, in the team's confidential record. In a large community a letter can be passed from desk to desk, and the strength is a person whose task it is to ring back.

9. Summary of what to remember

Anger, doubt and hard questions to God are not the opposite of faith. The Bible is full of lament and protest, and it keeps them. The carer does not correct, argue, explain or defend God, and does not use Scripture as a weapon or tell a person that they lack faith. The carer listens, says what is true without claiming more, allows the person to say it to God, and keeps the door open. The carer makes no verdict about anyone's salvation and refers questions that belong with the person's own pastor or priest. A carer watches for danger signs and heavy, lasting withdrawal, and helps the person toward the crisis course or a professional. The carer's own questions are allowed too.


Diagram 1. Two ways to answer "Where was God?"

When a person is angry at God Answers that close the door, and company that keeps it open Answers that close it "Of course God cares." "Everything happens for a reason." "If you had more faith..." "You shouldn't say that." A verse offered to end the talk A report to leaders: "she lost her faith" Company that keeps it open "You are angry at God." "I do not know why. I am here." "The Psalms say this too." "I will pray when you cannot." "There is a place for you, no hurry." Silence, and a call next week

Diagram 2. The tradition of protest in the Bible

Honest speech to God is in the Bible A carer does not need to correct what the book keeps The Psalms "How long?" "Why have you forsaken me?" Some end in trust, one ends in darkness. Job Will not keep silent. The friends who explain are the ones called to account. The Gospels Martha and Mary: "If you had been here." Jesus does not rebuke. A father: "Help my unbelief." What it means for the carer Anger, doubt and silence are not a lack of faith. They may be a person still speaking to God. The carer listens and keeps the door open. Danger signs go to the crisis course.

핵심 요약

  • Anger, doubt, silence and hard questions to God are common in grief, and are not by themselves a lack of faith.
  • The Bible keeps lament and protest: the Psalms, Job and the sisters at Bethany; Jesus does not rebuke honest grief.
  • The carer does not correct, argue, explain God's reasons, say "if you had faith" or use Scripture to close a conversation.
  • The carer listens, says what is true without claiming more, gives permission to speak to God, and keeps the door open.
  • The carer makes no verdict on anyone's salvation; fears about the dead go with the person's own pastor or priest.
  • A wish to die needs the crisis course at once; long, heavy withdrawal calls for a kind suggestion of a professional.
Front Back
Anger and doubt Common in grief, not a lack of faith; the Bible keeps the Psalms of complaint, Job, and the cry "Help my unbelief".
What the carer does not do Correct, argue, explain God's reasons, say "if you had faith", use a verse to close the talk, or report the person to others.
What the carer can do Listen and say it back, say "I do not know, and I am here", allow speech to God, keep the door open.
Questions about the dead No verdict; entrust to God within the church's hope; the person's own pastor or priest for more.

One sentence to remember A person who rages at God is often still speaking to God, and the carer's task is to stay, not to win.

This week's action Choose one lament psalm to read in quiet, and write one sentence you could say to a person who says they cannot pray.

이 과목 요약 전체 보기 →

스스로 확인해 보세요

읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.

묵상 및 토론

  • Which of the carer's impulses (to answer, defend God, quote a verse, reassure) is strongest in you? What might the bereaved person hear in it?
  • Why do you think the Bible keeps the Psalms of complaint and the book of Job? What does that suggest about how a church should treat a bereaved person's anger?
  • A person says, "I'm not coming back to church." Write two sentences you could say and one thing you could do in the weeks that follow.
  • Someone asks, "Is she lost?" What can you say that is honest, that makes no verdict, and that leaves the question with God and the person's own pastor or priest?
  • What are the signs that it is more than anger or doubt? Who would you ask, and what would you say to the person?

로그인하시면 여기에 답을 적고 보관하실 수 있습니다

다음 단계

여기까지가 강의입니다. 아래는 읽은 사람들이 남긴 글입니다.