무료

수료증 무료 발급 — 2027년 3월 31일까지.

PT724E Grief and Bereavement Care: Walking Beside the Bereaved

Lecture 3-3: The Death of a Child, Miscarriage and Stillbirth

목차 31
PT724E Grief and Bereavement Care: Walking Beside the Bereaved
제 0 장 · Introduction: Staying Beside
  1. Lecture 0: Introduction: Staying Beside
제 1 장 · Week 1: Grief in Scripture and the Carer's Place
  1. Lecture 1-1: Grief in Scripture
  2. Lecture 1-2: How Traditions Understand Death, Funeral and Remembrance
  3. Lecture 1-3: Grief Is Love in Another Form
  4. Lecture 1-4: The Carer's Place and Limits
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: What We Say About Death and Loss
제 2 장 · Week 2: Around the Funeral
  1. Lecture 2-1: The First Days
  2. Lecture 2-2: The Funeral Season Beside the Family
  3. Lecture 2-3: Words That Hurt, Words That Help
  4. Lecture 2-4: Practical Help That Is Specific
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: A First Visit
제 3 장 · Week 3: Different Losses
  1. Lecture 3-1: Sudden Death
  2. Lecture 3-2: Long Illness, and the Death of an Older Person
  3. Lecture 3-3: The Death of a Child, Miscarriage and Stillbirth
  4. Lecture 3-4: Suicide Loss: Standing Beside Without Stigma
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Standing Differently for Different Losses
제 4 장 · Week 4: Children, Teenagers and the Family
  1. Lecture 4-1: Grieving Children
  2. Lecture 4-2: Grieving Teenagers
  3. Lecture 4-3: Conflict Inside a Bereaved Family
  4. Lecture 4-4: Anger, Doubt and Hard Questions to God
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Talking With a Child, Standing Between Relatives
제 5 장 · Week 5: Long Accompaniment and Referral
  1. Lecture 5-1: Anniversaries and the Long Months
  2. Lecture 5-2: Long Accompaniment
  3. Lecture 5-3: When Grief Needs More Help: Noticing and Connecting
  4. Lecture 5-4: Hope, and Prayer for the Dead
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Three Cases and an Anniversary Card
제 6 장 · Week 6: The Carer and the Congregation
  1. Lecture 6-1: The Carer's Own Losses
  2. Lecture 6-2: Limits, Rest and Not Being the Fixer
  3. Lecture 6-3: A Church That Cares for the Bereaved Over Years
  4. Lecture 6-4: Many Kinds of Community
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab: A One-Page Bereavement Care Policy

핵심만 먼저 보기 ↓

26분

Of all the losses a carer meets, the death of a child may be the hardest to stand beside. It reverses what people expect: children are meant to outlive their parents. The words that come easily at other funerals can sound hollow here, and many carers are afraid they will say the wrong thing. The fear is understandable, and it is not a reason to stay away.

This lecture covers three related losses: the death of a child or young person, miscarriage, and stillbirth. They are not the same, and their griefs differ. They share one feature that matters for a carer: the person lost often had a very short life, or no life outside the womb, and the world around may not recognise how much was lost. Hopes, plans, a name, a place in the family, a future: all of these were already there. The central claim of the course returns: grief is not an illness; it is love in another form. A church carer is not a fixer but someone who stays beside. The carer does not hurry, does not prescribe stages, helps more by presence than by words, and connects to professionals when more help is needed. The carer has losses and limits too.

This course is not grief therapy, and it gives no medical or psychological advice. Questions about the cause of a death, about future pregnancies, or about the health of the mother belong to doctors and midwives; the carer does not answer them. This lecture describes no death and no cause.

이 26분으로 얻는 것

  • Explain why the death of a child, a miscarriage and a stillbirth are each real bereavements, and why the last two are often not recognised.
  • Describe how parents may grieve differently from each other, and how siblings and grandparents are also bereaved.
  • Name words that help and words that harm, including the sentences "you can have another" and "it was God's will".
  • Describe practical ways to honour a child's name and memory, if the family wishes, and how traditions differ in their rites.
  • Explain what a carer says, and does not say, about where the child is, within the church's hope.
  • Describe this care in a small and in a large community, and say when a professional is the right next step.

For you formed my inmost being. You knit me together in my mother’s womb." — Psalm 139:13

World English Bible

Can a woman forget her nursing child, that she should not have compassion on the son of her womb? Yes, these may forget, yet I will not forget you!" — Isaiah 49:15

WEB

Thus says Yahweh: A voice is heard in Ramah, lamentation, and bitter weeping, Rachel weeping for her children; she refuses to be comforted for her children, because they are no more." — Jeremiah 31:15

WEB

But when Jesus saw it, he was moved with indignation, and said to them, “Allow the little children to come to me! Don’t forbid them, for the Kingdom of God belongs to such as these." — Mark 10:14

WEB

He took them in his arms, and blessed them, laying his hands on them." — Mark 10:16

WEB

Psalm 139:13 speaks of God forming a person in the womb. It does not say when a person's life begins in law or in medicine, and this lecture does not take up that debate. It says that God has to do with the hidden beginnings of every life, and that a parent who grieves a pregnancy has not lost "nothing". Isaiah 49:15 uses the picture of a mother's love, to say that God's care is steadier still. It is not a verse to say to a bereaved mother, as if it explained her loss; it shows the seriousness of what a parent's love is. Jeremiah 31:15 is a lament: Rachel weeping for her children and refusing to be comforted. The Bible allows a mother to refuse comfort, and does not correct her. In Mark 10, Jesus is indignant when the children are kept away, welcomes them, takes them in his arms and blesses them. These verses are for the carer's own understanding, and are rarely quoted aloud in the first weeks; a family may hear a verse as a closing of the subject.

1. A loss that turns the order of life upside down

The loss of a child leaves parents with grief that does not resemble other griefs. They have lost the person, and they have lost a future. They may have lost the part of themselves that was a mother or a father day by day. They may also fear that they will be blamed, or may blame themselves, whatever the cause. A carer who has not lost a child should be honest about not knowing how it feels. "I cannot know what this is like" is a truthful and respectful thing to say.

Do not compare. Do not say, "I know how you feel" unless it is certainly true, and even then, say it carefully: each loss is its own. Do not say, "At least you have other children," or "at least you are young." Each of these puts a limit on how much a parent may mourn.

A carer must not describe a death, ask how a child died, or discuss the circumstances. If a parent chooses to speak about it, listen. If not, do not ask.

2. Parents, and the ways they differ

Two parents rarely grieve in the same way, and they may not grieve at the same time. One may weep openly and need to talk; the other may go quiet and take up work or practical tasks. One may want to keep the child's room as it was; the other may need to move things. One may want to be with people; one may want to be alone. These differences can hurt a couple who each feel the other does not understand. Lecture 4-3 returns to conflict inside a bereaved family. For now, a carer can say, to either parent, "People grieve in very different ways, even in one home. It does not mean they care less." This sentence is a general observation and not a prediction, and it should not be used to tell either parent what they should feel.

Where there is a single parent, or parents separated, or a parent who was not present, or a step-parent, or a grandparent who raised the child, the carer asks who the child's people were, and does not assume. A parent who was not married to the other, a foster parent or a guardian, an adoptive parent: each has lost a child. The carer does not rank them.

3. Siblings, grandparents and others

Brothers and sisters are also bereaved, and often overlooked. Parents are overwhelmed; relatives and visitors ask after the parents; a child or teenager may feel invisible, or may feel responsible. Lecture 4-1 and lecture 4-2 look at children and teenagers who grieve. For now, the carer who visits a family can greet the other children by name, and ask the parents, if it is welcome, whether the children would like a visit of their own.

Grandparents carry a double grief: they mourn the grandchild, and they watch their own child suffer. They may feel unable to speak of their own sorrow because the parents' sorrow seems larger. A carer can notice them.

Others too: an aunt or uncle, a cousin, a close friend of the family, a godparent, a teacher or a group leader at the church, a child's friends. Each may need a place to be sad.

4. Miscarriage and stillbirth: losses society may not see

When a pregnancy ends in miscarriage or stillbirth, the parents have lost a child whom few other people met. In some places a pregnancy is not announced until it is well advanced, and so there may be no one to mourn with. When the loss comes, the parents may be left to grieve in private or in silence. Colleagues may not know. Relatives may say, "It was early." Others may say nothing, from fear. This is the kind of loss that lecture 1-3 called unrecognised: a bereavement that society gives little room to.

A carer should be clear in their own mind: a miscarriage or a stillbirth is the death of a child who was wanted, expected, perhaps named, and hoped for. The mother's body has been through something. The father or other parent has lost the future they imagined. Both, and others, may grieve for a long time. Neither needs to prove that the loss "counts".

Here are some things a carer should know.

Timing is not the measure. A carer does not say that a loss was "early" and therefore small. A parent may grieve deeply for a pregnancy that ended after only a few weeks. The depth of grief follows the love and the hope, not the calendar.

The body matters. The mother's body is affected, and there may be physical pain, medical care and recovery. A carer does not give medical advice and does not ask medical questions. It is enough to say, "I hope you have good care," and to ask what help would be welcome.

Fathers and partners grieve too. They are often expected to be supportive and may have no place of their own. A carer can ask them how they are, not only how their partner is.

Silence can be heavy. Some parents want to speak of the child openly; some prefer privacy. A carer follows the parents' lead. A good question is, "Would you like people to know, or would you rather keep this between us?"

Guilt and blame. Parents may blame themselves for something they did or did not do. A carer cannot know the cause and should not guess. The carer should not say, "It was nothing you did," because they do not know, and a parent may not believe it. Say instead, "I am so sorry. I know you loved this child," and leave the question of cause to the doctors, who may or may not have an answer.

Other pregnancies. For many families, a later pregnancy brings fear as well as hope. The carer does not say, "You can have another." It is not a promise anyone can make, and it treats this child as replaceable. If there is a later pregnancy, the carer can say, quietly, that they are thinking of the family and of the child who died.

5. Words that harm, and words that help

The stock phrases of lecture 2-3 are especially hurtful here. They are usually spoken from love, from awkwardness, or from wanting to bring comfort quickly. A carer can forgive them in others, and avoid them themselves.

Words that often harm:

  • "You can have another one." (Treats the child as replaceable.)
  • "At least you didn't get to know the baby." (Treats the loss as smaller.)
  • "It was God's will." (May be taken as saying that God caused the loss, and may feel like a closed door.)
  • "God needed another angel." (Says what no one can know, and may leave a child frightened of God.)
  • "She is in a better place." (Says what is not known, and may sound as if the parents' arms are worse.)
  • "It was nature's way of dealing with a problem." (Makes a child into a medical event.)
  • "Be strong for your other children." (Asks the parent to postpone their grief.)
  • "You are young; you will recover." (Sets a deadline.)

Words that often help:

  • "I am so sorry."
  • "I am thinking of [name]." (Use the name if the family has given one; ask if you do not know.)
  • "I cannot imagine how hard this is. I would like to be with you."
  • "You do not have to talk. I will sit with you."
  • "What was [name] like?" (If the child lived for a while.)
  • "May I bring a meal on Thursday?"
  • "I will remember [name]."

Silence, a presence, a hand on a shoulder where touch is welcome, are all within the tradition of Job's friends in their first seven days (Job 2:13, lecture 1-1).

6. Naming and remembering

Parents often want the child to be remembered, and sometimes fear that everyone will forget. Some want a name spoken; some have not yet chosen a name, and a carer can say, "Do you have a name for [him/her/them] yet? Only if you wish to say." The carer does not assume a gender or a name.

Practical ways of remembering, if the family wishes:

  • Speaking the child's name, in prayer or in conversation.
  • A small service, a prayer, a blessing, or a time of silence at church or at home. Traditions differ in what is offered, and the carer follows the church's own practice, asking the minister. Some traditions have a service for the burial of a child, a naming, or a blessing after a miscarriage; some do not; and some leave the matter to the family and the pastor. The carer should know their own church's practice and where to ask.
  • A keepsake: a candle, a small object, a name on a card, a place in a garden, a page in a notebook. The family decides what is kept and what is not.
  • Marking a date: a day of the loss or of the expected birth. This is often most painful in the months that follow, and lecture 5-1 considers anniversaries.
  • A note from the church on the date. Some parents find it a quiet comfort that someone remembered.

Traditions also differ on the question of baptism, blessing or burial for a child who died very young or before birth, and on what is taught about that child's place before God. This is a subject on which the churches do not agree, and some parents carry a fear about it. This course makes no assertion about where any individual child stands. The carer's part is to entrust the child to God, to speak within the church's hope in the mercy of God, and to refer the parents, if they are anxious, to their own pastor or priest, who can speak within the tradition. The carer does not offer a private theory. Lecture 5-4 looks at hope and at differences among traditions.

7. Small and large communities

(an invented example) In a small congregation of about twenty-five people in a village, a young couple, Rosalind and Kofi, lost a child before birth. They had told only a few people. The pastor, an older woman with no children of her own, knew that she could not understand the loss, and said so. She brought a meal and said, "I am not sure what to say, and I would like to be with you." She asked whether they wished the church to know. They said they would like it to be known quietly. She spoke to the two or three women who helped most in the congregation, and asked them to say nothing to the couple except "we are thinking of you". After a few weeks the pastor asked whether the couple might like a short prayer in the church, with no more than a few people. They did, and they gave the child a name. In a small place a loss can be held quietly by a few, if they have been asked.

(an invented example) In a large church with a team, a father named Mr Eze lost his young son. The team had an outline of what to do, but it had been written for adults. A , Mrs Watanabe, rang Mr Eze and asked what the family needed. He said, "I would like someone to take my daughter to school for a week, and I would like nobody to ask me how." Mrs Watanabe asked the team to arrange a rota for the school journey and sent word to the congregation that the family would be glad of cards but not of questions. In a large community the danger is a standard response; the strength is many hands, which can be directed by what the family asks.

In both places, the family led. The carer asked, and followed.

8. Care for those who care

A carer who has lost a child, or a pregnancy, or who is expecting, or who is anxious about their own children, may find this subject very hard. That is human. A carer may need to step aside and let another carer take this visit. This is not a failure. Lecture 6-1 returns to the carer's own losses. The carer who cannot take the visit can still help by arranging for someone else to go.

9. When a professional is needed

Most parents, with time and company, find a way to carry the loss. But the death of a child can bring grief that is very heavy, and parents, siblings and grandparents may need more help than a church carer can give. If a parent cannot eat or sleep for a long time, cannot care for other children, or seems unable to carry on, the carer can say, kindly, "I wonder whether it might help to see a doctor or counsellor as well. It is not because you are weak." The mother of a miscarriage or stillbirth may also need medical care that nobody has asked about; the carer can ask, "Are you getting the care you need?" and leave the rest to the doctors. If anyone says they wish to die or to join the child, the crisis course applies. If a child in the household seems to be at risk, the safe church course applies.


Diagram 1. Who is bereaved when a child dies

Who is bereaved A circle wider than the parents. Each may grieve in a different way. Parents and those who raised the child Mothers, fathers, step, adoptive, foster, guardians Brothers and sisters Easily overlooked. Greet them by name. Grandparents and wider family A double grief: the child, and their own child Friends, teachers, church members Each may need a place to be sad After miscarriage or stillbirth A wanted child has died. Timing is not the measure. Fathers and partners grieve too. Ask whether the family wishes it known. Follow their lead.

Diagram 2. Words to avoid, words to offer

Words after the death of a child The speaker meant love. The carer can forgive others and choose differently. Often harm "You can have another." "At least you did not know the baby." "It was God's will." "God needed another angel." "Be strong for your other children." "You are young; you will recover." Often help "I am so sorry." "I am thinking of [name]." "I cannot imagine. I would like to be with you." "May I bring a meal on Thursday?" "I will remember [name]." Or sit, and say nothing.

핵심 요약

  • The death of a child, a miscarriage and a stillbirth are each real bereavements; the last two are often unseen. Timing is not the measure of grief.
  • Parents grieve in different ways and at different times; brothers, sisters, grandparents and others are bereaved too.
  • Avoid "you can have another", "it was God's will", "God needed another angel" and similar phrases; offer presence, the child's name if given, and concrete help.
  • Remembering the child by name, a small service or a keepsake is the family's choice; traditions differ, and the carer follows the church's own practice.
  • The carer makes no assertion about where any child stands before God, and entrusts the child to God within the church's hope.
  • If grief is very heavy for long, suggest a doctor or counsellor kindly; a wish to die belongs to the crisis course.
Front Back
Unrecognised losses Miscarriage and stillbirth: a wanted child has died, and timing is not the measure.
Who grieves Parents (each differently), siblings, grandparents, friends, and the wider circle.
Words to avoid "You can have another", "God's will", "God needed another angel", "at least..."
On the child's place before God No private assertion; entrust to God; refer anxious parents to their own pastor or priest.

One sentence to remember When a child has died, the carer does not explain, compare or replace; the carer says the name, asks what is needed, and stays.

This week's action Ask your minister what your church offers when a child or a pregnancy is lost, and write down who a family could ask.

이 과목 요약 전체 보기 →

스스로 확인해 보세요

읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.

묵상 및 토론

  • Why might a carer be afraid to visit a family that has lost a child? What would you want to tell yourself before you went?
  • Why is a miscarriage or a stillbirth often a loss that others do not see? Who in your community might carry such a loss without anyone knowing?
  • Two parents grieve in different ways. What could a carer say to each, without taking a side?
  • How does your church's tradition mark the death of a very young child or a pregnancy loss? Who would you ask if you did not know?
  • Which words in the lists above have you said, or heard said, with love? What would you say now?

로그인하시면 여기에 답을 적고 보관하실 수 있습니다

다음 단계

여기까지가 강의입니다. 아래는 읽은 사람들이 남긴 글입니다.