Lecture 5-4: Hope, and Prayer for the Dead
목차 31
- Lecture 1-1: Grief in Scripture
- Lecture 1-2: How Traditions Understand Death, Funeral and Remembrance
- Lecture 1-3: Grief Is Love in Another Form
- Lecture 1-4: The Carer's Place and Limits
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: What We Say About Death and Loss
- Lecture 2-1: The First Days
- Lecture 2-2: The Funeral Season Beside the Family
- Lecture 2-3: Words That Hurt, Words That Help
- Lecture 2-4: Practical Help That Is Specific
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: A First Visit
- Lecture 3-1: Sudden Death
- Lecture 3-2: Long Illness, and the Death of an Older Person
- Lecture 3-3: The Death of a Child, Miscarriage and Stillbirth
- Lecture 3-4: Suicide Loss: Standing Beside Without Stigma
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Standing Differently for Different Losses
- Lecture 4-1: Grieving Children
- Lecture 4-2: Grieving Teenagers
- Lecture 4-3: Conflict Inside a Bereaved Family
- Lecture 4-4: Anger, Doubt and Hard Questions to God
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Talking With a Child, Standing Between Relatives
- Lecture 5-1: Anniversaries and the Long Months
- Lecture 5-2: Long Accompaniment
- Lecture 5-3: When Grief Needs More Help: Noticing and Connecting
- Lecture 5-4: Hope, and Prayer for the Dead
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Three Cases and an Anniversary Card
Sooner or later a bereaved person asks the questions that no one can answer from experience. Where is she now? Can I still pray for him? Will I see them again? A carer who has been staying beside the family for months is often the one who is asked. The carer may be afraid to answer, afraid of saying too much, or afraid of saying too little.
This lecture is about the Christian hope that the whole church holds, and about the places where churches differ on prayer for the dead and on what lies between death and resurrection. It asks the carer to speak from the hope that is shared, to know the differences fairly, and to respect the bereaved person's own tradition without correcting it beside a grieving person. The central claim of the course returns: grief is not an illness; it is love in another form. A church carer is not a fixer but someone who stays beside. The carer does not hurry, does not prescribe stages, helps more by presence than by words, and connects to professionals when more help is needed. The carer has losses and limits too.
This course is not grief therapy, and it gives no medical or psychological advice. It prepares a carer to be present and to know when to help someone find a professional.
이 33분으로 얻는 것
- State, in a few plain sentences, the hope that Christians across traditions share about death, the resurrection and the mercy of God.
- Explain why hope does not cancel grief, and why a carer does not use it to close a conversation or to correct a person's sorrow.
- Describe fairly, without judging any of them, the main positions on prayer for the dead and on what lies between death and the resurrection.
- Explain why a carer makes no assertion about any individual's salvation or the state of the dead, and say what the carer can say instead.
- Describe how a carer responds, within the person's own tradition, when someone asks whether they may pray for the one who has died.
But we don’t want you to be ignorant, brothers, concerning those who have fallen asleep, so that you don’t grieve like the rest, who have no hope." — 1 Thessalonians 4:13
World English Bible
For if we believe that Jesus died and rose again, even so God will bring with him those who have fallen asleep in Jesus." — 1 Thessalonians 4:14
WEB
Jesus said to her, “I am the resurrection and the life. He who believes in me will still live, even if he dies." — John 11:25
WEB
Whoever lives and believes in me will never die. Do you believe this?”" — John 11:26
WEB
But now Christ has been raised from the dead. He became the first fruits of those who are asleep." — 1 Corinthians 15:20
WEB
For if we live, we live to the Lord. Or if we die, we die to the Lord. If therefore we live or die, we are the Lord’s." — Romans 14:8
WEB
For to this end Christ died, rose, and lived again, that he might be Lord of both the dead and the living." — Romans 14:9
WEB
He will wipe away from them every tear from their eyes. Death will be no more; neither will there be mourning, nor crying, nor pain, any more. The first things have passed away.”" — Revelation 21:4
WEB
1 Thessalonians 4:13 does not say that Christians do not grieve. It says that they do not grieve "like the rest, who have no hope". Grief and hope are together in one sentence. 1 Thessalonians 4:14 grounds that hope in Jesus' death and resurrection. John 11:25 and 11:26 are Jesus' words to Martha, spoken beside a grave, and they come in a chapter where Jesus himself weeps (lecture 1-1). 1 Corinthians 15:20 calls Christ the first fruits of those who are asleep. Romans 14:8 and 14:9 say that whether we live or die we belong to the Lord, and that Christ is Lord of both the dead and the living; this is the verse behind much that churches say when they entrust the dead to God. Revelation 21:4 looks toward the end of death, mourning, crying and pain. Together these verses are the shared ground of the church's hope. None is a verdict on any individual, and none is a weapon to end someone's sorrow.
1. The hope the church holds together
Christians differ on many things about death. On some things they agree, and a carer can stand on this ground with confidence. It can be said in a few sentences:
- God is merciful, and knows how we are made (Psalm 103, read in lecture 3-4).
- Christ has died and has been raised, and in him death does not have the last word.
- Those who belong to the Lord, whether living or dead, belong to him (Romans 14:8-9).
- The church waits for the resurrection of the dead and the life of the world to come.
- God will wipe away every tear, and death will be no more (Revelation 21:4).
These are words that Catholic, Orthodox, Anglican, Baptist, Pentecostal, Presbyterian, Methodist and independent Christians can say together, in the form of their own creeds and prayers. A carer who stays within them is on safe ground. This is the "church's confession of hope" that earlier lectures spoke of.
Please notice two limits. First, this hope is a hope: it rests on God's promise and mercy, and it is not a guarantee that a carer can hand out about a named person. Second, the hope does not say that the dead are not missed. The bereaved are missing a real person.
2. Hope does not cancel grief
1 Thessalonians 4:13 is sometimes read as if it said that Christians should not grieve. It says that they should not grieve like those who have no hope. The Bible does not tell the bereaved to stop weeping. The same Jesus who says "I am the resurrection and the life" is the one who wept at a tomb.
For a carer, the practical meaning is simple. Hope is not a reply to sorrow. A sentence such as "She is with the Lord, so you don't need to cry" takes a real hope and uses it to quiet a real person. The person hears: your grief is a lack of faith. That is false, and it hurts. Lecture 1-1 said that grief is not a lack of faith. The carer lets the hope be present, and also lets the weeping be present. A person can believe in the resurrection and also not be able to get through the morning.
Use hope as a lamp, not as a lid. A carer may quietly say, "We hold [name] in God's hands, and we wait in hope." The words are not a closing of the matter. They are said beside the sorrow, and the carer then stays. If the bereaved person answers, "I don't feel that hope today", the carer says, "That's all right. The hope doesn't depend on how you feel today. I'm here." Feelings of hope, like feelings of everything, come and go.
3. What the carer does not say
Earlier lectures set out a safety line that applies here with full force: the carer makes no assertion about any individual's salvation or the state of the dead. The carer does not say, "He is in heaven." The carer does not say, "She is lost." The carer does not say, "They are in a better place," or "they are at peace now," as if the carer knew. The carer does not know. Nor does any human being who is not God.
This is not a coldness. It is an honesty, and it protects the bereaved person from two harms. One is false comfort, which does not last, and which may feel like being managed. The other is a verdict of condemnation, which could not be borne. A carer who says only what the church's hope allows may seem to say little. But it is solid.
What the carer can say, within the church's hope, are sentences such as:
- "We entrust [name] to God, who is merciful."
- "God knows [name] better than any of us did, and loves them."
- "We don't know all the answers. We know God's mercy is wide."
- "Would you like to pray for [name] together? Or would you like to talk with your pastor or priest about this?"
A word about suicide loss and about people who, as far as the family knows, had not professed faith. These are the places where the fear is sharpest. The same rule holds. The carer makes no verdict, entrusts the person to God, and sends the question to the person's own pastor, priest or (lecture 3-4). The carer does not offer a private theory, and does not argue about who is "in" or "out".
4. What a bereaved person may ask
It may help to name the questions that come, so that the carer is not caught off guard.
"Where is he now?" The carer says what the church's hope says: "He is in God's hands. I don't know more than that, and I trust God's mercy."
"Will I see her again?" Here the shared hope is clearest: the resurrection, and the life of the world to come. The carer says what the person's own tradition teaches, if the carer knows it, or says, "That is the hope we hold. Would you like to talk with your pastor about it?"
"Is it wrong to pray for him?" This is the place where traditions differ. See below.
"Does he know I am still thinking of him?" The carer does not claim to know. The carer can say, "I don't know how that works. I know that your love for him is real."
"Was it my fault that he died outside the faith?" or similar questions of guilt. The carer listens, does not agree or argue, and sends the person gently to their pastor. This is heavy, and the person may need more than the carer can give.
5. Where traditions differ
Churches have thought about the dead for a very long time, and they have not reached one answer. The carer needs to know the main differences, and to know them fairly, so as not to run down the tradition of the person in front of them. What follows is a short sketch in general terms. It does not settle anything, and it is not complete.
Prayer for the dead. Many Christians, including Catholic and Orthodox Christians and some within other families of churches, pray for the dead and see this as an act of love that continues past the grave. They remember the dead at a memorial, at the , on anniversaries and at certain seasons of the church's year. They hold that the communion of the church includes the living and the dead, and that to cease praying for someone because they have died would be a kind of abandonment. Many Protestants and other Christians do not pray for the dead. They hold that the Bible does not command it, that the destiny of the dead is entrusted wholly to God's grace in Christ and does not depend on the prayers of the living, and that to pray for the dead suggests an uncertainty about what Christ has done. Many of these Christians nevertheless give thanks to God for the dead, remember them with love, and entrust them to God, and they may see little difference in practice between thanksgiving and commendation. Some traditions hold other positions in between.
What lies between death and the resurrection. Christians agree that the dead will be raised. They differ on what is said about the time between. Some point to texts such as these:
"But I am in a dilemma between the two, having the desire to depart and be with Christ, which is far better." — Philippians 1:23 (WEB)
"We are courageous, I say, and are willing rather to be absent from the body, and to be at home with the Lord." — 2 Corinthians 5:8 (WEB)
and hold that those who die in Christ are at once with Christ, consciously, in a state of rest or joy while they await the resurrection of the body. Others point to the language of "sleep", as in 1 Thessalonians 4:14 above and in
"Many of those who sleep in the dust of the earth shall awake, some to everlasting life, and some to shame and everlasting contempt." — Daniel 12:2 (WEB)
and hold that the dead are in a state of rest in which nothing is felt until the resurrection; some, in this way of speaking, see the "sleep" as a way of speaking of death's quiet and not a teaching on consciousness. Others, notably the Catholic Church, teach that some who die in friendship with God still need purification before they enter into the fullness of God's presence, and they read texts such as
"If any man’s work is burned, he will suffer loss, but he himself will be saved, but as through fire." — 1 Corinthians 3:15 (WEB)
as pointing that way, though many other Christians read the same text as speaking of the testing of a believer's work and not of a state after death. Orthodox Christians, who do not use the word in the same way, speak of the dead as in a condition where the prayers of the church are a real help, and where God's mercy is more than anyone can measure. Some churches' Bibles also include books that bear on prayer for the dead, such as 2 Maccabees. This course quotes only from the World English Bible text it uses, which does not include those books, so they are not quoted here.
Many Christians accept none of these accounts in detail and say that Scripture does not tell us enough to settle the question, and that the church should say only what it knows.
This is a point where readers will not agree. Some Christians, including Catholic and Orthodox traditions and others, hold that prayer for the dead is a faithful and loving act, rooted in the communion of all who belong to Christ and in a long Christian practice of remembering the dead before God. They would say it is the opposite of abandonment. Other Christians, in many Protestant traditions, hold that Scripture does not teach prayer for the dead, that the eternal state of a person is entrusted to God's grace and is not changed by the prayers of the living, and that such prayer can leave grieving people uncertain about what Christ has already done. They would say that giving thanks for the dead and commending them to God is enough and is honest. On what lies between death and resurrection, some hold that the dead are consciously with Christ; some that they sleep until the resurrection; some that there is a purification; and some that Scripture does not tell us. Every one of these Christians holds that the dead will be raised and that God is merciful. This course requires the following. The carer does not judge the salvation of any individual. The carer knows these differences fairly, and does not run down a tradition that is not their own. The carer respects the bereaved person's own tradition and does not correct it beside a grieving person: the carer does not argue the point at a funeral, a graveside or a kitchen table. The carer knows their own church's position, speaks of it humbly if asked, and sends the deeper question to the pastor or priest of the person's own church.
6. When someone asks, "May I pray for her?"
This is a real question, and it is asked by Christians of every tradition. The right answer depends on the person's tradition, and the carer's job is to help the person ask the right person, not to rule.
If the person's church prays for the dead, the carer lets it happen. The carer does not say, "We don't do that here." If the carer's own church does not pray for the dead, the carer can be honest and kind: "Our church does not pray in that way, but I'm glad you do, and I won't stop you. Would you like to pray in your own words, or shall I sit with you?"
If the person's church does not pray for the dead, and the person feels a need to, the carer does not forbid it. Many Christians whose churches do not pray for the dead nonetheless find that they cannot stop, and say, quietly, "Lord, be merciful to her." The carer can say, "Your love for her doesn't stop. Would you like to talk with your pastor about how your church thinks of this?" The carer does not solve the matter and does not take a side.
If the family is divided, because the mother's church prayed for the dead and the son's does not, or the reverse, the carer does not take sides and does not decide. Lecture 4-3 spoke of conflict inside a bereaved family. A day of grief is the worst day to settle a doctrinal question. The carer can help the family to find a form that each can bear, such as silence, a reading that all can share, a simple commendation to God's mercy, or two small moments for those who wish. The minister makes the decision where the question concerns a service.
If the person has come from another tradition, or no tradition, the carer asks gently what they would like and who they would like to ask.
Remembering is not the same as praying for. A candle, a name read at an anniversary, a photograph, a visit to a grave or a meal in memory: these can be done by Christians in all traditions, and different families give them different meanings. Some regard them as a form of honouring the dead, some as a form of prayer, some as simple remembering. Lecture 1-2 spoke of the dispute over rites to ancestors in many churches; this course took no side there and takes none here. The carer does not interrogate the meaning of a family's customs beside the family. If the carer is asked directly, the carer says what their own church teaches, humbly, and sends the question to the pastor.
7. The children, and the questions they ask
Children ask, sometimes at odd times, "Where is Grandad?" or "Can he hear me?" The carer follows the family. If the family's tradition has an answer, the carer helps the adult to give it in simple words. The carer does not introduce a view of their own. Lecture 4-1 spoke of honest, simple words and of the confusion that some euphemisms cause. The same applies here: "He is in God's hands, and we are very sad he cannot be with us" is honest and simple, and does not claim to know more.
8. Hope as company
The deepest use of hope is not in an argument but in a presence. A carer who stands in the church's hope, quietly, will speak less about it than the carer might think. Often the best expression is small: reading a psalm slowly at the person's request; saying the Lord's Prayer together; keeping silence; singing a hymn the person loves; lighting a candle if the person's tradition does so. The carer does not need to say that the dead are happy or that the living will be consoled. The carer says, in words or without them, we are not alone, and neither are they.
And the carer lets the hope be theirs as well. The carer's own losses are part of this (lecture 6-1). A carer who has no hope for themselves will carry it badly. The carer may need to be carried too.
9. Small and large communities
(an invented example) A parish in a coastal town has a long custom of remembering the dead in November. The families come with photographs and the priest reads each name. Mrs Santiago's husband died in the spring, and she asked the parish nurse, Ms Okoro, "Is it all right if I pray for him at the grave every Sunday?" Ms Okoro, who belongs to the same parish, said, "Of course. Would you like me to come?" The question was easy because the parish and the widow shared a tradition. The same week, Ms Okoro was asked by a neighbour from a different church, whose own church did not pray for the dead, whether she had done wrong by whispering a prayer for her brother. Ms Okoro said, "I don't think your love for him is a wrong. Would you like to talk with your own pastor about it? I can come, or not." In a community with one strong custom, the carer's task is not to let that custom become the only way, and not to leave a neighbour from another tradition alone with the question.
(an invented example) A large city church has members from a dozen backgrounds. In the same week the bereavement team was asked by one family to include a prayer for the dead at a memorial, by another to leave all prayers for the dead out, and by a third to read from a psalm only. The team leader, Mr Brzezinski, did not try to find a single policy. He asked the minister to set out in advance the few things the church would do in every memorial, and the few things it would leave to each family, and he gave the team a one-page note with both lists. Each family was told what to expect before it chose. In a large community the risk is a single rule applied without listening; the strength is a clear, kind frame within which each family can choose.
10. The carer's own heart
Questions about the dead come close to the carer's own losses and fears. A carer may find that a question touches a doubt or a sorrow of their own. The carer does not need to hide this; the carer may say, "I don't know either, and I trust God's mercy", if that is true. The carer should also not pretend to a certainty that they do not have. If the questions of the person have left the carer unsteady, the carer talks with their own minister or a trusted friend. This is not a failure. Lecture 6-1 returns to it.
11. Summary of what to remember
Christians across traditions share a hope: the mercy of God, the resurrection of Christ, the belonging of the dead and living to the Lord, and the end of death and tears. Hope does not cancel grief, and the carer uses it as a lamp and not as a lid. The carer makes no assertion about any individual's salvation or the state of the dead, and entrusts the person to God. Traditions differ on prayer for the dead and on what lies between death and resurrection; the carer knows the differences fairly, respects the person's own tradition, and does not correct it beside a grieving person. When asked "May I pray for her?" the carer helps the person to ask their own pastor and does not rule. The deepest use of hope is company.
Diagram 1. The shared hope and the differences
Diagram 2. When someone asks, "May I pray for her?"
핵심 요약
- Christians share a hope: God's mercy, Christ's resurrection, the belonging of the dead and living to the Lord, and the end of death and tears.
- Hope does not cancel grief; the carer uses it as a lamp and not as a lid, and lets the weeping stay.
- The carer makes no assertion about any individual's salvation or the state of the dead, and entrusts the person to God.
- Churches differ on prayer for the dead and on what lies between death and the resurrection; the carer knows the differences fairly.
- The carer respects the person's tradition, does not correct it beside a grieving person, and sends deeper questions to the person's own pastor or priest.
- The deepest use of hope is company: a psalm, a silence, a prayer the person wishes.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Shared hope | God's mercy, Christ risen, dead and living belong to the Lord, resurrection, tears wiped away. |
| Hope and grief | Hope does not cancel grief; use it as a lamp, not a lid. |
| Where traditions differ | Whether to pray for the dead, and what lies between death and the resurrection. |
| What the carer does | No verdict on any individual; know the differences; respect the person's tradition; send questions to their pastor. |
One sentence to remember The carer stands on the hope the whole church shares, makes no verdict on anyone, and does not correct a grieving person's tradition.
This week's action Write down in two sentences the hope your own church holds about the dead, and ask your minister what your church teaches about prayer for them.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- What does it mean to say that hope does not cancel grief? Think of a sentence of hope said as a lid, and one said as a lamp.
- Why does the carer make no assertion about where a particular person stands before God? What can the carer say instead?
- How does your own church speak of prayer for the dead? What would you say if someone from another tradition asked you about it?
- A family is divided: the mother's church prayed for the dead, the son's does not. What could a carer suggest, and what must the carer not do?
- What do the traditions in your community have in common about death and the resurrection, and where could you say that plainly?