Lecture 2-3: Eternal Relations of Authority and Submission
목차 34
- Lecture 1-1: Revelation and Theological Epistemology
- Lecture 1-2: Inspiration and Inerrancy
- Lecture 1-3: Speech-Act Theory and Biblical Authority
- Lecture 1-4: The Sufficiency of Scripture and the Scripture-Tradition Question
- Lecture 2-1: The Nicene-Constantinopolitan Settlement
- Lecture 2-2: The Filioque Controversy
- Lecture 2-3: Eternal Relations of Authority and Submission
- Lecture 2-4: Rahner's Rule, Social Trinitarianism, and the Church's Life
- Lecture 3-1: Divine Decree and Human Freedom — Compatibilism and Libertarian Freedom
- Lecture 3-2: Open Theism and Process Theology — Challenges to Classical Providence
- Lecture 3-3: Divine Impassibility — Classical and Revisionist Accounts
- Lecture 3-4: Theodicy at the Doctrinal Level — Privation and Soul-Making
- Lecture 4-1: The Image of God — Structural, Relational, and Functional Readings
- Lecture 4-2: Original Sin and Federal Headship
- Lecture 4-3: The Bondage or Freedom of the Will After the Fall
- Lecture 4-4: The Soul-Body Question, and Transhumanism's Challenge
- Lecture 5-1: The Hypostatic Union and the Extra Calvinisticum
- Lecture 5-2: Kenotic Christology
- Lecture 5-3: Christ's Sinlessness and Obedience
- Lecture 5-4: The Extent of the Atonement
- Lecture 6-1: Union with Christ as an Integrating Motif for Soteriology
- Lecture 6-2: Election
- Lecture 6-3: Justification and Its Contemporary Challenges
- Lecture 6-4: Sanctification and Perseverance
- Lecture 7-1: Christological Pneumatology and the Spirit's Cosmic Work
- Lecture 7-2: The Church's Identity and Marks
- Lecture 7-3: The Sacraments/Ordinances Across Traditions
- Lecture 7-4: The Church and Culture/Society
The dispute this lecture examines is unlike the filioque in one important respect: it did not divide two ancient communions across a linguistic and cultural border a thousand years ago. It divided contemporary evangelical theologians - many of them colleagues, some of them co-authors of earlier books together, most of them agreeing on complementarian church and family order - from one another, in journal articles, monographs, and public exchanges over roughly the past three decades. The Eternal Relations of Authority and Submission position (ERAS, sometimes called the "eternal functional subordination" or EFS view) holds that the Son is eternally, and not merely during the incarnation, in a relationship of submission to the Father's authority, while remaining fully equal to the Father in essence and deity. Its most prominent defenders - Wayne Grudem and Bruce Ware chief among them - connect this claim explicitly to complementarian arguments about gender: if the Son can be eternally equal in being yet eternally subordinate in role and authority to the Father, the reasoning goes, then a wife's submission to a husband's authority (on a complementarian reading of texts like Ephesians 5:22-33) is not in itself a claim about her lesser worth or equality as a human being, since the Trinity itself supposedly displays the same pattern: equal in being, differentiated in role and authority.
That argument drew sustained, sharp criticism - not chiefly from egalitarian theologians who reject complementarianism outright, though some of those criticisms exist too, but notably from other committed complementarians, including Liam Goligher, Carl Trueman, and Mark Jones, who argued in a widely read 2016 exchange that ERAS is not a permissible development of Nicene trinitarianism but a departure from it, regardless of what one believes about gender roles in marriage and the church. This is a point where readers will not agree, and unlike 2-2's ancient East-West division, this is a live dispute inside the same theological family, still being argued out, with serious, orthodox, Nicene-affirming theologians on more than one side. This lecture does not declare a winner.
이 20분으로 얻는 것
- State the ERAS position precisely, including its distinction between eternal equality of essence and eternal differentiation of authority and role.
- Explain the argument ERAS's proponents draw from it to contemporary complementarian debates about gender, and why that connection is part of what makes the dispute higher-stakes than a purely academic disagreement.
- State the critics' argument that ERAS risks compromising Nicene equality of the persons, and identify specifically which classical trinitarian commitments they argue it puts under pressure.
- Explain why this is classified as a live, internal evangelical dispute rather than a settled question, and identify at least one theologian on each side.
Jesus therefore answered them, "Most certainly, I tell you, the Son can do nothing of himself, but what he sees the Father doing. For whatever things he does, these the Son also does likewise.
who, existing in the form of God, didn't consider equality with God a thing to be grasped,
John 5:19 (World English Bible)
Philippians 2:6 (WEB)
Both texts sit at the center of this debate, and both are read by serious theologians on each side as supporting their own position, which is itself instructive about how the argument actually proceeds. ERAS's defenders read John 5:19 - the Son does nothing of himself, only what he sees the Father doing - as describing an eternal pattern of the Son's dependence on and submission to the Father's initiative, not a statement confined to the days of Jesus's earthly ministry. Their critics read the same verse as describing precisely the incarnate Son's mode of operation in his state of humiliation, consistent with (and required by) his full, unqualified divine equality with the Father stated in the very next verses of that chapter (John 5:20-23), where Jesus claims the Father's own prerogatives - raising the dead, judgment, and receiving the honor due to the Father - as his own. Philippians 2:6, likewise, states that the Son, in his pre-incarnate state, existed "in the form of God" and did not consider "equality with God a thing to be grasped" - a phrase both sides read as affirming the Son's genuine, unqualified equality, but which the two sides connect very differently to what "equality" turns out to mean once eternal submission of authority is added to it.
1. The ERAS position, stated as its proponents state it
ERAS's proponents do not deny, and in fact insist upon, the full Nicene equality of essence between the Father and the Son established in 2-1: the Son is fully, eternally, unqualifiedly God, homoousios with the Father, in no way a lesser or derivative deity. Their claim is narrower and more specific: that alongside this equality of essence, the Father and Son stand in an eternal relationship in which the Father eternally holds a kind of primacy of authority and the Son eternally submits to that authority - not merely during the thirty-three years of the , and not merely in the economic sphere of God's action in creation and redemption, but as a feature of who the Father and Son eternally, immanently are, independent of and prior to any decision to create or redeem.
Wayne Grudem, in Systematic Theology (1994) and subsequent defenses, argues that this eternal authority-submission relationship is what actually distinguishes the Father from the Son as persons, given that both share identically the same undivided divine essence: if essence alone does not differentiate Father from Son (since it is numerically one essence, not two instances of a shared kind, as chapter 2-1 established), then some further, truly eternal and truly personal property must differentiate them, and Grudem argues authority and submission is scripturally warranted and theologically necessary to do that work, alongside (not replacing) the traditional relations of origin - the Father's begetting and the Son's being begotten. Bruce Ware, in Father, Son, and Holy Spirit: Relationships, Roles, and Relevance (2005), develops a parallel argument and explicitly extends the pattern to the Spirit's eternal submission to both Father and Son.
The connection to gender, which is what raised this debate's public profile well beyond academic theology, runs as follows in Grudem's and Ware's own stated reasoning: complementarian theology holds that men and women are fully equal in essence, dignity, and worth as image-bearers of God, while holding that Scripture assigns differentiated authority within marriage and the church (headship to the husband, restriction of the pastoral office to qualified men, on the complementarian reading of texts such as 1 Timothy 2:12 and Ephesians 5:22-33). Critics of complementarianism have long argued that "equal in being, different in role" is an incoherent or merely rhetorical formula, since (the objection runs) genuine equality and genuine, permanent, one-directional authority-submission cannot coexist without the submitting party's equality being compromised in practice, whatever is said in principle. ERAS's proponents present the as a positive theological counterexample to that objection: if the eternal, immanent Godhead itself displays full equality of essence together with a permanent, non-reciprocal relationship of authority and submission between two of its Persons, then the same combination cannot be, as such, incoherent when claimed of a husband and wife, because God's own life demonstrates the combination is possible at the highest possible level of reality.
2. The critics' case, stated as they state it
The critical response, most sharply articulated in a 2016 series of exchanges (prompted initially by Liam Goligher's blog posts, joined by Carl Trueman, Mark Jones, and others, with Grudem and Ware responding at length), makes a case with several distinct strands, and it is worth separating them because they carry different weight.
The first and most serious strand is a Nicene-orthodoxy argument, not merely a preference for older language: the critics argue that classical trinitarian theology, as chapter 2-1 stated it, differentiates the divine persons only by their eternal relations of origin - the Father unbegotten, the Son eternally begotten, the Spirit eternally proceeding - and by nothing else. Adding a further eternal differentiating property, authority-and-submission, alongside the traditional relations of origin is, on this argument, not a permissible addition to Nicene trinitarianism but a revision of what actually distinguishes the persons, one with no clear precedent in Nicene, Cappadocian, or Reformed-scholastic trinitarian theology (the critics, notably including Trueman, a historian of Reformed theology specifically, argue that classical Reformed sources such as the Westminster divines and Francis Turretin explicitly reject any eternal subordination of the Son's will to the Father's, precisely because a distinct, subordinate will implies a distinct center of willing, which risks a fourth thing beyond the one divine will the three persons share, potentially opening toward tritheism from a different direction than the Cappadocian settlement in 2-1 was built to close.
The second strand is more directly theological rather than historical: if the Son's will is eternally, necessarily submissive to the Father's in a way that constitutes who the Son eternally is, the critics argue this implies either two distinct wills in the Godhead (contrary to the classical doctrine that the one undivided divine essence has one undivided divine will, shared identically by all three persons) or, if there remains only one shared will, that "the Son submits to the Father's authority" cannot coherently describe an eternal, immanent relation at all - since a single will cannot, without contradiction, both command and be submitted to. On this argument, "eternal submission of the Son" is either quietly tritheistic (multiplying wills) or theologically empty once pressed (since with one shared will, talk of one Person "submitting" to another has no clear referent apart from the incarnation, where the Son does genuinely operate through a human will and human nature capable of obedience).
The third strand, raised by several critics though treated by ERAS's defenders as the weakest of the three, is that the position looks suspiciously convenient: it was developed, at least in its explicit form, specifically to support a preexisting complementarian conclusion about gender, which raises (for the critics) the concern named as a general trap for this entire course - that theology bent to fit a prior conclusion, however sincerely held, deserves extra scrutiny rather than less. ERAS's defenders reply that motivation is not the same as , and that an argument developed partly in response to a contemporary question can still be assessed on its own exegetical and historical merits rather than dismissed for its occasion - a reasonable methodological point that does not, by itself, settle whether the first two strands of the criticism are correct.
3. Where the disagreement actually sits
What is really disputed
It is worth being precise about what is, and is not, in dispute here, because the debate is sometimes summarized less carefully than it deserves. Every serious participant on both sides affirms the full, unqualified deity and equality of essence of the Son with the Father - no one in this debate is proposing anything like , and both sides would reject that characterization of the other as a caricature. The actual disagreement is narrower and more technical: whether "eternal relations of origin" (which every side affirms) exhausts what eternally differentiates the divine persons, or whether an additional eternal relation of authority and submission can be added to that without compromising the single, undivided divine will and the full equal honor owed to each person - a question chapter 2-1's vocabulary of ousia, hypostasis, and was developed, in part, to help state precisely. Both sides also agree the debate has real consequences beyond academic trinitarian theology, given its explicit connection to arguments about gender and authority in the home and church; they disagree sharply about whether that connection is a legitimate application of sound trinitarian theology or a case of theology reshaped to serve an argument it was never suited to carry. As of this writing, no evangelical denomination or confessional body has formally adjudicated the question, and serious, complementarian, Nicene-affirming theologians remain on both sides of it.
6. Further Reading
- Wayne Grudem, Systematic Theology: An Introduction to Biblical Doctrine, 2nd edition (Zondervan, 2020), chapter on the Trinity.
- Bruce A. Ware, Father, Son, and Holy Spirit: Relationships, Roles, and Relevance (Crossway, 2005).
- Liam Goligher and Carl R. Trueman, exchange of essays at Reformation21 (June 2016), collected and discussed in subsequent responses by Grudem and Ware.
- Kevin Giles, The Eternal Generation of the Son: Maintaining Orthodoxy in Trinitarian Theology (IVP Academic, 2012).
- Millard J. Erickson, Who's Tampering with the Trinity? An Assessment of the Subordination Debate (Kregel Academic, 2009).
- Scott R. Swain and Michael Allen, "The Obedience of the Eternal Son," International Journal of Systematic Theology 15.2 (2013), 114-134.
핵심 요약
- ERAS holds that the Son eternally submits to the Father's authority while fully equal in essence. Wayne Grudem and Bruce Ware are chief defenders. They say authority and submission help distinguish Father and Son.
- Proponents link this to complementarianism: equal in being, different in role. They say the Trinity shows this pattern is not incoherent. That raises the stakes beyond academic theology.
- Critics who are also complementarian, including Goligher, Trueman and Jones, say the persons differ only by relations of origin. They say ERAS departs from Nicene trinitarianism.
- A second critique says eternal submission implies two wills, or has no clear meaning outside the incarnation. A third says it was shaped to fit a gender conclusion. Defenders answer that motive is not justification.
- Both sides affirm the Son's full deity. The dispute is whether origin relations alone distinguish the persons. No denomination has settled it.
Topic: This lecture presents the debate among evangelicals over whether the Son eternally submits to the Father, and why it matters for gender teaching.
Remember: Both sides affirm the Son's full equality in deity. They disagree on whether eternal authority and submission can be added to the relations of origin.
Caution: Neither side is accused of Arianism. The lecture declares no winner, and it warns that the link to gender can make clear judgment harder.
One line to carry into ministry: Think carefully before resting teaching on marriage or church order on a disputed claim about the Trinity.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- State the ERAS position precisely enough to distinguish it from Arianism. What exactly does ERAS affirm about the Son's essence, and what does it add beyond that?
- Explain the "two wills" objection to ERAS in your own words. Why do the critics think eternal submission requires a distinct will, and why is a distinct will theologically costly on classical trinitarian terms?
- Both John 5:19 and John 5:20-23 come from the same passage. Explain how ERAS's proponents and its critics each use that same passage to support opposite conclusions.
- This dispute is explicitly connected to arguments about gender roles in marriage and the church. Why might that connection make some readers less able to evaluate the trinitarian argument itself on its own terms - in either direction?
- Chapter 2-1 stated that the church's creedal core is not contested across traditions. Is the ERAS debate a dispute about that creedal core, or about something built on top of it? Defend your answer with specific reference to what both sides in this lecture actually affirm.