Lecture 7-3: The Sacraments/Ordinances Across Traditions
목차 34
- Lecture 1-1: Revelation and Theological Epistemology
- Lecture 1-2: Inspiration and Inerrancy
- Lecture 1-3: Speech-Act Theory and Biblical Authority
- Lecture 1-4: The Sufficiency of Scripture and the Scripture-Tradition Question
- Lecture 2-1: The Nicene-Constantinopolitan Settlement
- Lecture 2-2: The Filioque Controversy
- Lecture 2-3: Eternal Relations of Authority and Submission
- Lecture 2-4: Rahner's Rule, Social Trinitarianism, and the Church's Life
- Lecture 3-1: Divine Decree and Human Freedom — Compatibilism and Libertarian Freedom
- Lecture 3-2: Open Theism and Process Theology — Challenges to Classical Providence
- Lecture 3-3: Divine Impassibility — Classical and Revisionist Accounts
- Lecture 3-4: Theodicy at the Doctrinal Level — Privation and Soul-Making
- Lecture 4-1: The Image of God — Structural, Relational, and Functional Readings
- Lecture 4-2: Original Sin and Federal Headship
- Lecture 4-3: The Bondage or Freedom of the Will After the Fall
- Lecture 4-4: The Soul-Body Question, and Transhumanism's Challenge
- Lecture 5-1: The Hypostatic Union and the Extra Calvinisticum
- Lecture 5-2: Kenotic Christology
- Lecture 5-3: Christ's Sinlessness and Obedience
- Lecture 5-4: The Extent of the Atonement
- Lecture 6-1: Union with Christ as an Integrating Motif for Soteriology
- Lecture 6-2: Election
- Lecture 6-3: Justification and Its Contemporary Challenges
- Lecture 6-4: Sanctification and Perseverance
- Lecture 7-1: Christological Pneumatology and the Spirit's Cosmic Work
- Lecture 7-2: The Church's Identity and Marks
- Lecture 7-3: The Sacraments/Ordinances Across Traditions
- Lecture 7-4: The Church and Culture/Society
No single lecture in this course carries more directly contested, practically consequential material than this one. Baptism and the Lord's Supper are not peripheral rites traditions differ on incidentally; they are where each tradition's whole account of grace, covenant, and Christ's presence becomes visible in concrete, weekly or occasional practice. This lecture states two baptismal positions and four distinct positions on the Lord's Supper, in each case naming the actual theological reasoning behind the practice, not merely describing what different churches do with water, bread, and wine. The word choice itself is a small marker of the underlying disagreement: traditions that call these rites sacraments generally hold that they convey grace by their proper administration in some real sense (ex opere operato in the strongest Catholic form, or through faith in a Reformed and Lutheran sense); traditions that call them ordinances generally hold that Christ commanded them as acts of obedience and testimony rather than as vehicles that themselves confer grace. This lecture uses both terms throughout, deliberately, rather than picking the vocabulary of one side.
This is advanced material; you already know from introductory study that these two rites exist and carry biblical warrant. The task here is depth on exactly where and why serious theologians disagree about what each rite does.
이 25분으로 얻는 것
- State the paedobaptist (infant-baptizing) position's actual covenantal and pneumatological rationale — not merely the practice of infant baptism — as held across Reformed, Lutheran, Catholic, and Orthodox traditions, and identify at least one point on which these paedobaptist traditions differ from each other.
- State the credobaptist (believer's-baptism) position's rationale, grounded in its doctrine of the church and the nature of the baptismal sign, as held across Baptist and much of evangelical and Pentecostal tradition.
- State all four positions on the Lord's Supper — transubstantiation, Lutheran sacramental union, Reformed spiritual presence, and Zwinglian/Baptist memorialism — accurately enough that a proponent of each would recognize their own view in your statement of it.
- Explain how the Reformed-Lutheran disagreement over the Supper connects to the *extra Calvinisticum* Christological debate from 5-1.
Colossians 2:11-12 — "in whom you were also circumcised with a circumcision not made with hands, in the putting off of the body of the sins of the flesh, in the circumcision of Christ; having been buried with him in baptism, in which you were also raised with him through faith in the working of God, who raised him from the dead." (World English Bible)
1 Corinthians 11:23-26 — "For I received from the Lord that which also I delivered to you, that the Lord Jesus on the night in which he was betrayed took bread. When he had given thanks, he broke it, and said, 'Take, eat. This is my body, which is broken for you. Do this in memory of me.' In the same way he also took the cup, after supper, saying, 'This cup is the new in my blood. Do this, as often as you drink, in memory of me.' For as often as you eat this bread and drink this cup, you proclaim the Lord's death until he comes." (WEB)
3.1 Baptism: the paedobaptist case
Paedobaptist traditions — Reformed, Lutheran, Catholic, and Orthodox, a remarkably wide coalition that otherwise disagrees on a great deal else in this chapter — baptize the infant children of believers, but do so from more than one distinct theological rationale, and it matters which rationale a given tradition actually argues from.
The Reformed covenantal argument, most fully developed from Calvin onward, grounds in the continuity of the covenant of grace across the Old and New Testaments. Circumcision, the Old Testament covenant sign administered to Abraham's infant sons (Genesis 17:9-14) on the basis of the covenant promise rather than the infant's own prior faith or understanding, is read as the type that baptism fulfills as its New Testament counterpart — precisely the connection Colossians 2:11-12 draws explicitly, baptism a "circumcision made without hands." On this argument, since the covenant of grace remains fundamentally one across both testaments (its administration changes; its substance does not), and since the covenant sign was administered to covenant children under the old administration, it should continue to be administered to covenant children — the children of at least one believing parent — under the new, absent a New Testament text that explicitly narrows the sign's proper recipients to professing adults only. The sign is understood to mark the child's membership in the visible covenant community and to function as a claim on the covenant promises to be embraced personally in later, professed faith — not as a guarantee of the child's or , which Reformed theology continues to insist depends on grace received through personal faith.
The Lutheran argument shares the covenantal instinct but grounds infant baptism somewhat differently, placing more direct weight on baptism's own, immediate efficacy: Luther's Small describes baptism as itself "effecting forgiveness of sins, delivering from death and the devil, and giving eternal salvation to all who believe this, as the words and promises of God declare" — and Lutheran theology holds that infants are, in fact, capable of a real, Spirit-given faith at baptism (fides infantium), rather than baptism functioning primarily as a covenant sign awaiting a later, cognitively mature profession. This is a genuine difference in emphasis from the Reformed covenantal argument, even though both traditions baptize infants and both appeal to some of the same texts.
Catholic and Orthodox theology baptize infants on a related but distinct ground again: baptism as the ordinary, instituted means by which (chapter 4's Western or Eastern account, respectively) is remitted and the child incorporated into Christ's body, the church, prior to and apart from any question of the child's own subsequent, personal profession, which is expected and required later (through confirmation/chrismation and ongoing catechesis) but is not what baptism itself is held to accomplish. Catholic sacramental theology describes this in terms of baptismal regeneration operating ex opere operato ("by the very fact of the action being performed") when the is validly administered — the sacrament's efficacy does not depend on either the minister's or the infant's own subjective disposition, though it does depend on the recipient (or, for an infant, the church on the recipient's behalf) not placing a deliberate obstacle in grace's way. Orthodox theology baptizes and chrismates (confirms) infants together in a single rite, incorporating the child fully and immediately into the church's sacramental life, including reception of the Eucharist, considerably earlier than Western practice typically allows.
3.2 Baptism: the credobaptist case
Credobaptist ("") traditions — Baptist churches and much of the wider evangelical and Pentecostal world — baptize only those who have made a personal, credible profession of faith, and root this practice in a specific, considered account of both the baptismal sign and the nature of the church, not merely a preference for a different order of ceremony.
The central argument runs from the New Testament's own pattern: every explicit baptismal narrative in the book of Acts describes the baptism of people who have first heard the gospel, believed, and then been baptized (Acts 2:38, 41; 8:12; 8:36-38; 16:14-15, 33; 18:8) — there is no unambiguous New Testament narrative of an infant being baptized, and credobaptist theologians argue the burden of proof properly rests on those who baptize infants to supply a positive New Testament warrant, rather than an inference from continuity with Old Testament circumcision. Credobaptist theologians typically read the sign's meaning itself as requiring a prior, conscious faith to signify: Romans 6:3-4's account of baptism as 's death and resurrection ("buried with him through baptism into death... that... we too might walk in newness of life") and Colossians 2:12's language of being "raised with him through faith in the working of God" are read as describing baptism as itself an act that presupposes and signifies a faith already present in the one baptized — not a sign given in expectation of a faith yet to come. On this reading, an infant, incapable of the conscious faith the sign is held to signify, is not yet an appropriate recipient of it, whatever else may be true about the covenant status of believers' children.
This connects directly to credobaptist ecclesiology, and this connection is the deeper reason the disagreement runs as deep as it does: credobaptist traditions typically hold to a regenerate-church-membership principle — that the visible church, so far as human judgment can discern it, should consist of professed, credible believers, with baptism marking entry into that visible, gathered, professing body specifically. Infant baptism, on this view, structurally requires the wider visible/invisible distinction described in 7-2 to do heavier theological work than credobaptist ecclesiology wants it to do, since it necessarily baptizes some who will never come to personal faith into a rite meant, on the credobaptist reading, to mark a faith-response already present.
3.3 What the baptism debate is not
What is not in dispute
This is a point where readers will not agree — but it is worth naming precisely what is and is not in dispute. No serious paedobaptist theologian claims that baptism alone, apart from any later personal faith, guarantees an individual's final salvation; no serious credobaptist theologian denies that the children of believers hold a real, special covenantal status and blessing (see, for instance, 1 Corinthians 7:14's language of children being "holy" through a believing parent, a text paedobaptist and credobaptist interpreters read rather differently). The actual disagreement is narrower and more precise than "does baptism matter" or "are covenant children special": it is about what the sign of baptism itself is held to require of its recipient — evidence of the covenant promise given before a personal response (paedobaptist) or the accompanying reality of a faith already present (credobaptist) — and, downstream of that, about what the visible church fundamentally is a gathering of.
3.4 The Lord's Supper: four distinct positions
The Lord's Supper generates, if anything, an even more precisely differentiated set of positions than baptism, because the central question — in what sense, if any, is Christ present in the bread and wine — admits of several genuinely distinct, carefully worked-out answers, not a simple spectrum from "very present" to "not present at all."
(Catholic, formally defined at the Fourth Lateran Council, 1215, and given its classical philosophical statement by Thomas Aquinas) holds that at the words of consecration, the bread and wine's entire substance — their underlying metaphysical reality, in Aristotelian terms — is converted into the substance of Christ's body and blood, while their "accidents" (appearance, taste, texture, chemical composition) remain unchanged. This is not, on Catholic understanding, a claim that Christ's presence is merely symbolic, spiritual, or figurative; it is a claim about a real, objective, substantial change in what the elements actually, metaphysically are, such that what is received is, in full reality, Christ's own body and blood, however unchanged its appearance. The (Session XIII, 1551) formally defined this doctrine against the Reformation's rejection of it, and it grounds Catholic eucharistic adoration, reservation of the consecrated host, and the Mass's character as itself a propitiatory (though not repetitive) re-presentation of Christ's one sacrifice.
Lutheran sacramental union (sometimes loosely called "consubstantiation," though Lutheran theologians themselves generally reject that term as imprecise and misleading about their actual position) holds that Christ's body and blood are truly, substantially present in, with, and under the bread and wine, without any change to the bread and wine's own substance — both realities are simultaneously, fully present together, rather than one being converted into the other. Luther insisted on Christ's real, bodily presence against the Zwinglian memorial view (below) largely on the strength of taking "This is my body" (1 Corinthians 11:24) in its plain, literal sense, famously refusing at the 1529 Marburg Colloquy to concede this point to Zwingli even for the sake of Protestant political unity against Rome. Lutheran theology explains how Christ's human body — a genuinely, fully human body, per Chalcedon — can be truly present at every altar simultaneously through its own distinct Christological resource: the doctrine, associated with Luther and later Lutheran Christology, that the (5-1) genuinely communicates the divine attribute of to Christ's human nature, so that his glorified humanity itself, not only his divinity, can be present wherever the sacrament is celebrated.
Reformed spiritual presence (Calvin's own formulation, distinct from both the Lutheran and Zwinglian positions though sometimes flattened into one or the other in popular summary) holds that Christ is truly, really present in the sacrament — not merely in the believing recipient's subjective memory or imagination — but present spiritually rather than bodily, and received by faith through the operation of the Holy Spirit, who lifts the believer's faith up to feed on Christ's body and blood in heaven, rather than bringing Christ's body down to the elements on the table. This is the direct outworking of 5-1's Reformed extra Calvinisticum: because the Son's human nature, even in the , remains a genuinely local, finite human body that cannot be present in more than one place (against the Lutheran Christological move that communicates omnipresence to the human nature), Christ's body cannot be substantially or bodily present on every communion table simultaneously — but the Spirit truly unites the believer, spiritually, to the whole Christ, present in heaven, in a real feeding that Calvin insisted was more than a bare memorial. Calvin himself considered this a real presence and objected strenuously to being classed with Zwingli as a mere memorialist, even though later, more Zwinglian-leaning strands of the broader Reformed and evangelical tradition have sometimes blurred this distinction.
Zwinglian/Baptist , associated with Huldrych Zwingli and the dominant view in Baptist and much of wider evangelical and Pentecostal practice today, holds that the Supper is a memorial — an act of remembrance, proclamation, and covenant renewal commanded by Christ ("do this in memory of me," 1 Corinthians 11:24-25) — in which Christ is present by the Spirit in the same general sense he is present wherever two or three gather in his name (Matthew 18:20), rather than present in the elements or the sacramental act in any distinct, additional sense beyond that. Zwingli read "This is my body" as employing a figure of speech (alloeosis, or simply metaphor: "this represents/signifies my body"), comparable to Jesus's other "I am" statements using ordinary objects ("I am the door," "I am the vine") that no interpreter takes with the crude literalism the realist positions apply to the Supper's words of institution. On this view, the Supper's importance is not diminished by denying a special metaphysical or spiritual presence distinct from Christ's ordinary presence with his gathered people; its importance lies in its function as the church's own act of proclaiming — "as often as you eat this bread and drink this cup, you proclaim the Lord's death until he comes" (1 Corinthians 11:26) — the gospel to itself and to the world, and in its role in genuine, examined self-reflection and covenant renewal (1 Corinthians 11:27-29).
3.5 Connecting back to Christology
The Lutheran and Reformed disagreement over the Supper is not a free-standing liturgical dispute; it is, as 3.4 above already showed, directly downstream of the Christological disagreement 5-1 named between the Lutheran and Reformed traditions over the extra Calvinisticum — whether the Son's human nature, in personal union with the divine nature, can receive the divine attribute of omnipresence (the Lutheran position, enabling Christ's body to be truly, bodily present at every altar) or whether the Son's human nature remains genuinely local and finite even in personal union with the eternal Son, who continues also to sustain the universe beyond and outside his incarnate humanity (the Reformed extra Calvinisticum, which rules out bodily omnipresence and requires the Spirit, not the body itself, to unite believer and Christ across distance). A student who has understood 5-1 should recognize that this is one of the clearest cases in the whole course of a seemingly separate, practical, liturgical dispute turning out to rest on a precise, technical, and genuinely prior Christological disagreement — which is exactly why this course placed the two lectures where it did.
6. Further Reading
- Keith A. Mathison, Given for You: Reconsidering Calvin's Doctrine of the Lord's Supper (P&R Publishing, 2002) — a Reformed argument for recovering Calvin's own "real spiritual presence" against later, more Zwinglian evangelical practice.
- Hermann Sasse, This Is My Body: Luther's Contention for the in the Sacrament of the Altar (Augsburg, 1959) — the classical modern Lutheran statement.
- Edward Schillebeeckx, The Eucharist (Sheed & Ward, 1968) — a Catholic theologian's careful account of transubstantiation and its philosophical background.
- Alexander Schmemann, For the Life of the World: Sacraments and Orthodoxy, rev. ed. (St. Vladimir's Seminary Press, 1973) — an Orthodox sacramental theology.
- Stanley K. Fowler, More Than a Symbol: The British Baptist Recovery of Baptismal Sacramentalism (Paternoster, 2002) — a Baptist scholar's own complicating account of Baptist sacramental thought, useful against caricaturing Baptist practice as bare memorialism on every point.
- David F. Wright, ed., Baptism: Three Views (InterVarsity Press, 2009) — presents believer's baptism, infant baptism, and dual-practice positions in direct dialogue.
- Gordon T. Smith, ed., The Lord's Supper: Five Views (InterVarsity Press, 2008) — presents all four positions covered here, plus a fifth, in the authors' own words.
핵심 요약
- Traditions that say "sacraments" generally hold that the rites convey grace in some real sense. Those that say "ordinances" generally hold they are acts of obedience and testimony. The lecture uses both words.
- Paedobaptist (infant-baptizing) traditions argue differently. Reformed: baptism is the covenant sign fulfilling circumcision (Colossians 2:11-12). Lutheran: infants receive Spirit-given faith. Catholic and Orthodox: baptism remits original sin and incorporates the child.
- Credobaptist (believer's baptism) traditions cite the pattern in Acts of belief followed by baptism. They read the sign as signifying a faith already present, and tie this to regenerate church membership.
- The baptism debate is narrower than it looks. No one claims baptism alone guarantees salvation, and no one denies believers' children a special status. The question is what the sign requires of its recipient.
- Four views of the Lord's Supper are given: transubstantiation, Lutheran sacramental union, Reformed spiritual presence and Zwinglian or Baptist memorialism. The Lutheran-Reformed split rests on the extra Calvinisticum debate of 5-1.
Topic: This lecture sets out the main positions on baptism and the Lord's Supper and the reasoning behind each.
Remember: Each view of baptism and the Supper rests on a deeper account of grace, covenant, the church and Christ's presence. The Lutheran and Reformed disagreement over the Supper depends on how they understand Christ's human nature.
Caution: The lecture does not pick a winner. Calvin's view is a real presence, not bare memorial, and Lutherans reject the label "consubstantiation." Baptist thought is not always bare memorialism.
One line to carry into ministry: When members of other traditions practise baptism or the Supper differently, ask what each practice is trying to say about grace and Christ's presence before judging it.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- State the Reformed and Lutheran arguments for infant baptism side by side. What, precisely, is the difference in what each tradition holds baptism to accomplish for the infant?
- State the credobaptist argument for believer's baptism, including how it connects to a "regenerate church membership" ecclesiology. Why does this lecture say the disagreement runs deeper than a dispute about the proper age for baptism?
- Explain, in your own words, the difference between transubstantiation and Lutheran sacramental union — both of which affirm a real, objective presence of Christ's body, unlike the Reformed and Zwinglian positions. What, specifically, is each claiming that the other is not?
- Explain how the Reformed doctrine of the Lord's Supper depends on the *extra Calvinisticum* from 5-1, and what the Lutheran doctrine of the Supper depends on instead from that same Christological debate.