Lecture 5-3: The Reformation Splits Over the Lord's Supper
Contents 33
- Lecture 1-1: What "History of Doctrine" Is, and What Newman and Pelikan Add to It
- Lecture 1-2: Three Theories of How Doctrine Develops
- Lecture 1-3: How the New Testament Canon Was Formed
- Lecture 1-4: Creeds Before the Creeds — The Rule of Faith
- Lecture 2-1: The Arian Controversy and the Council of Nicaea
- Lecture 2-2: From Nicaea to Constantinople — The Cappadocian Settlement
- Lecture 2-3: The Filioque and Medieval Trinitarian Theology
- Lecture 2-4: Post-Reformation Challenges and the Twentieth-Century Trinitarian Revival
- Lecture 3-1: Before Chalcedon: What Each Side Was Trying to Save
- Lecture 3-2: After Chalcedon: The Definition That Did Not End the Argument
- Lecture 3-3: Medieval to Reformation Christology
- Lecture 3-4: Modern Christology
- Lecture 4-1: The Pelagian Controversy
- Lecture 4-2: Grace in the Medieval Church
- Lecture 4-3: The Reformation and Justification by Faith
- Lecture 4-4: The Arminian Controversy
- Lecture 5-1: The Donatist Controversy and Augustine's Answer
- Lecture 5-2: Medieval Ecclesiology — Seven Sacraments and the Rise of Papal Primacy
- Lecture 5-3: The Reformation Splits Over the Lord's Supper
- Lecture 5-4: The Marks of the Church and Modern Ecumenism
- Lecture 6-1: Theopneustos — The Early Church's Doctrine of Inspiration
- Lecture 6-2: Scripture and Tradition in the Medieval Church — A Dispute About the Dispute
- Lecture 6-3: Sola Scriptura and Trent's Answer — What Each Side Actually Claimed
- Lecture 6-4: Scripture Under Modern Criticism, and the Contemporary Inerrancy Debate
- Lecture 7-1: The Earliest Millennium — Papias, Justin, and Irenaeus
- Lecture 7-2: Augustine and the Church-Age Reading
- Lecture 7-3: Puritan Hope and the Rise of Postmillennialism
- Lecture 7-4: Dispensationalism and the Modern Landscape
In October 1529, the two most prominent Reformers in Europe sat down together at a castle in the German town of Marburg, at the invitation of a political ruler who badly needed them to agree. Philip of Hesse wanted a united Protestant political and military front against the Catholic emperor Charles V, and he calculated, reasonably, that a united Protestant theology would have to come first. Martin Luther and Huldrych Zwingli, together with a supporting cast that included Philip Melanchthon and Martin Bucer, worked through fourteen articles of Christian doctrine and found themselves in substantial agreement on nearly all of them — the Trinity, the person of Christ, original sin, justification by faith. Then they reached the fifteenth article, on the Lord's Supper, and did not agree. Luther is reported to have chalked the Latin words hoc est corpus meum — "this is my body" — on the table in front of him and refused to move from their literal sense. Zwingli argued the words must be a figure of speech, as when Christ elsewhere calls himself a door or a vine. Neither man yielded. Philip's united Protestant front never fully materialized, and the Reformation, from that day forward, has never spoken with one voice on what happens at its own central meal.
This lecture states, as fairly as it can, four serious and still-living answers to the same question — the Lutheran, the Zwinglian, the Calvinist (which is not simply the same as Zwingli's), and the Catholic transubstantiation that all three Reformers, in their different ways, were reacting against. This is one of the places in this course where the syllabus genuinely does not, and should not, tell you which side is correct.
What these 20 minutes give you
- Narrate what happened at Marburg in 1529 and explain, precisely, what Luther and Zwingli agreed on and what specific point broke their agreement.
- State the Lutheran doctrine of the real presence ("in, with, and under" the bread and wine) in its own strongest terms, distinguishing it from the transubstantiation it is often confused with.
- State Zwingli's memorial view and Calvin's distinct "spiritual real presence" view accurately enough that a Zwinglian and a Calvinist would each recognize their own position in your account.
- Explain what all three Reformation positions were responding to in Catholic transubstantiation, and why this dispute, alone among most this course covers, still visibly divides confessing Christians who sit in church pews today.
For I received from the Lord that which also I delivered to you, that the Lord Jesus on the night in which he was betrayed took bread. When he had given thanks, he broke it, and said, 'Take, eat. This is my body, which is broken for you. Do this in memory of me.' In the same way he also took the cup, after supper, saying, 'This cup is the new covenant in my blood. Do this, as often as you drink, in memory of me.' For as often as you eat this bread and drink this cup, you proclaim the Lord's death until he comes." — 1 Corinthians 11:23-26
World English Bible
Every position in this lecture claims to be the most faithful reading of exactly this text, and of the parallel words in the Gospels (Matthew 26:26-28, Mark 14:22-24, Luke 22:19-20). Read it slowly before the lecture explains how four serious traditions of biblical interpretation reached four different conclusions from words all four accept as Christ's own.
1. What actually happened at Marburg
The Marburg Colloquy of October 1-4, 1529, is one of the best-documented theological meetings of the Reformation era precisely because so much rode on its outcome. Philip of Hesse's political motive was real and understandable: a Protestant movement fractured into mutually excommunicating camps could not present a united front to an emperor who wanted it destroyed. The participants worked through the Marburg Articles, a document of fifteen points, and reached genuine agreement — not polite diplomatic language, but substantive theological agreement — on the first fourteen, covering the , Christ's person and work, , and by faith.
The fifteenth article, on the of the altar, records the agreement they did reach (that the sacrament should be received in both kinds, bread and wine, by the laity; that the Mass is not a work that earns grace; that a spiritual reception of Christ by faith is essential) and then states plainly that they had not been able to agree "whether the true body and blood of Christ are bodily present in the bread and wine." Luther's insistence on the literal force of "this is my body" and Zwingli's insistence that Christ's ordinary human body cannot be simultaneously, physically present in bread on altars throughout the world (Zwingli argued from Christ's and session at the Father's right hand, cf. Acts 1:9-11, that his human body is now located in heaven, not omnipresent on earth) proved unbridgeable in four days of face-to-face argument between two of the sharpest theological minds of the century. They parted, by most accounts, without Luther extending to Zwingli the full hand of Christian fellowship the meeting had hoped to seal.
2. The Catholic position they were all reacting against: transubstantiation
Lecture 5-2 already introduced as the Fourth Lateran Council's (1215) technical vocabulary, later given its fullest philosophical defense by Aquinas and formally reaffirmed by the 's Decree on the Eucharist (Session 13, 1551) directly against the Reformers. The doctrine holds that at the priest's consecration, the whole substance of the bread and the whole substance of the wine are converted into the whole substance of Christ's body and blood, while the accidents — the appearances of bread and wine, everything the senses can detect — remain unchanged. Every serious Reformation-era account of the Eucharist, including the three that follow, defines itself in part against this claim, though each rejects it for a different reason and replaces it with a different alternative.
3. This is a point where readers will not agree.
Four serious positions on the Lord's Supper divided Christians at the Reformation and continue to divide them today. State each fairly, in a form its own holders would recognize.
Lutherans hold to the , often summarized as Christ's body and blood being present "in, with, and under" the bread and wine — a formula meant to affirm a genuine, objective, bodily presence without adopting the Aristotelian substance-and-accident mechanism of transubstantiation. Lutherans have historically resisted the later label "consubstantiation" (the bread's substance and Christ's body coexisting side by side) as an inaccurate simplification of their own position; the Lutheran claim is not a philosophical account of how the presence occurs but a confession, resting on the literal force of Christ's own words, that it does occur, extending even to how the presence relates to the physical elements — Lutheran theology has historically affirmed that the unworthy as well as the worthy receive Christ's actual body and blood when they eat and drink (the manducatio impiorum, "eating by the impious"), precisely because the presence is grounded in Christ's word of institution and not in the recipient's faith. This is Luther's own consistent argument from Marburg onward: God's word does exactly what it says, and no philosophical difficulty about ubiquity should be allowed to explain away a plain scriptural statement Christ himself made. The Augsburg Confession (1530), Article X, and later the Formula of Concord (1577) state this position as confessional Lutheran doctrine.
Zwinglians — following Huldrych Zwingli, the Reformer of Zurich, and giving the position later widely called — hold that "this is my body" is a figure of speech, exactly as Christ's other self-descriptions ("I am the door," "I am the true vine") are universally recognized as figurative rather than literal. On this reading, "is" functions as "signifies," a usage with precedent in ordinary Aramaic and Greek speech. The Supper is a genuine and important , but its content is chiefly remembrance and proclamation: the church gathers to remember Christ's death, as 1 Corinthians 11:26 itself says ("you proclaim the Lord's death until he comes"), and to publicly confess faith together, not to receive Christ's body in, with, or under anything physical. Zwingli's argument from the ascension — that Christ's human body, a real and therefore local human body, is now in heaven and cannot also be bodily present on every altar where the Supper is celebrated — is not a dismissal of Christ's presence altogether; Zwingli held that Christ is present by his divine nature everywhere, and specially present to the faith of the gathered congregation, but denied a bodily presence in the elements themselves. Zwinglians would object strongly to being characterized as believing the Supper is "merely" symbolic in a dismissive sense — for Zwingli the remembering itself is a genuine spiritual act of real importance, not an empty ritual.
Calvin, working a generation after Marburg and drawing on both Luther's and Zwingli's traditions while satisfying neither camp entirely, proposed what is often called a spiritual real presence or pneumatic presence — a position genuinely distinct from Zwingli's memorialism, though later popular usage sometimes flattens the two together in a way most historians and most Reformed Christians themselves would resist. Calvin agreed with Zwingli that Christ's human body, being a real body, remains in heaven and is not locally or bodily present in the bread and wine. But Calvin insisted that believers nonetheless truly and really feed on Christ's body and blood in the sacrament — not by Christ's body descending to earth, but by the Holy Spirit lifting believers, in a real if mysterious way, into a genuine communion with the ascended Christ in heaven. Calvin's Institutes of the Christian Religion, Book IV, chapter 17, works this out at length, insisting he is describing something more than a bare memorial and more than a merely mental or subjective act of remembering, while still avoiding both transubstantiation's substance-change and Luther's claim of a bodily presence "under" the elements themselves. This is sometimes called receptionism: the presence and the benefit are received by the believing communicant through faith and by the Spirit's working, rather than residing objectively in the elements themselves apart from reception, which is why Calvin, unlike Luther, denied that an unbeliever receiving the elements receives Christ's body at all.
Four views of the Supper
Table the four positions against each other honestly: transubstantiation changes the bread's substance entirely; Lutheran real presence affirms an objective bodily presence "in, with, and under" the unchanged bread without a substance-change mechanism; Calvin's spiritual real presence affirms a real but non-bodily, Spirit-mediated communion with the ascended Christ, received by faith; Zwinglian memorialism affirms a memorial and proclamatory ordinance without a special mode of Christ's bodily or spiritual presence beyond his general presence to faith. Each of the three Reformation positions can and does argue that it, not the others, is the more faithful reading of 1 Corinthians 11:23-26 and the words of institution — and each has a serious, biblically literate case for saying so. A reader from any of the four traditions represented here should recognize their own church's position stated in a form they themselves would sign.
4. Why Marburg's failure mattered beyond one meeting
The practical consequence of the Marburg failure is still visible in the denominational map of world Christianity. Lutheran and Reformed (Zwinglian- and Calvinist-descended) churches developed as institutionally separate traditions from the sixteenth century onward, with their own confessions, their own catechisms, and, for long stretches, closed communion practices that prevented Lutherans and Reformed Christians from receiving the Supper at each other's tables — a division that persisted, in various forms, for centuries after the theological heat of the original dispute had cooled. Some modern Lutheran and Reformed bodies have since reached formal agreements of mutual recognition (the Leuenberg Agreement of 1973 among many European Lutheran and Reformed churches is the best-known example, and 5-4 will return to what agreements of this kind do and do not accomplish), but full, universal reunion on this specific question has not happened, and Roman Catholic transubstantiation remains, formally, unreconciled with all three Protestant positions despite decades of ecumenical dialogue. This is not a controversy this course can responsibly present as resolved, because it is not resolved — millions of practicing Christians today hold each of the four positions this lecture has stated, in good faith, from a serious reading of the same words of institution.
5. Going to the Sources
- The Marburg Articles (1529), a short document freely available in English translation in most Reformation sourcebooks and online — read Article 15 in full to see the disagreement stated in the participants' own careful, restrained language.
- The Council of Trent, Decree on the Eucharist, Session 13 (1551), available at papalencyclicals.net — the Catholic Church's formal, -by-canon response to the Reformers named in this lecture.
- John Calvin, Institutes of the Christian Religion, Book IV, Chapter 17 — Calvin's own extended argument for the spiritual real presence, freely available at ccel.org, and worth reading directly rather than only through later summaries, since Calvin himself works hard to distinguish his view from Zwingli's.
In short
- At Marburg (1529), Luther and Zwingli agreed on fourteen articles but not the fifteenth, on the Supper. Luther held to the literal "this is my body"; Zwingli argued Christ's body is in heaven.
- Catholic transubstantiation, reaffirmed at Trent in 1551, says the substance of bread and wine becomes Christ's body and blood while appearances stay. All three Reformation views define themselves partly against it.
- Lutherans teach Christ's body and blood are objectively present "in, with, and under" the bread and wine. They reject the label consubstantiation, and hold that even the unworthy receive Christ's body.
- Zwingli's memorialism reads "is" as "signifies" and sees real remembrance and proclamation, not mere empty symbol. Calvin taught a spiritual real presence: the Spirit lifts believers into communion with the ascended Christ, received by faith.
- The four views still divide churches. The Leuenberg Agreement (1973) reconciled some Lutheran and Reformed churches, but the Catholic view remains unreconciled with all three.
Topic: This lecture explains the Marburg split and states four serious views of the Lord's Supper: Catholic, Lutheran, Calvinist, and Zwinglian.
Remember: All four claim the same words of institution. They differ on how Christ is present and how his body relates to the bread and wine.
Caution: Calvin is not simply Zwingli, and the Zwinglian view is not "merely" symbolic in a dismissive sense. The lecture does not say which view is correct.
One line to carry into ministry: Before comparing Supper teachings, state each church's view in words its own members would sign.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Before this lecture, which of these four positions (or none of them) matched what you had been taught about the Lord's Supper? Has the lecture's statement of your own tradition's position matched how you would have stated it yourself?
- Zwingli argued from Christ's ascension that his human body cannot be bodily present on every altar at once. Luther argued that God's own word ("this is my body") should not be limited by a philosophical difficulty about ubiquity. Which argument do you find more persuasive, and can you state the other side's response to your own reasoning?
- The lecture distinguishes Calvin's "spiritual real presence" from Zwingli's memorialism, though the two are sometimes popularly confused. Restate that distinction in your own words. What is actually at stake in keeping them separate?
- Modern agreements like the Leuenberg Agreement (1973) have produced real, formal reconciliation between some Lutheran and Reformed churches. Does that kind of agreement change what you think is possible for the wider four-way division this lecture describes, or does it suggest the remaining gaps (especially with the Catholic position) run deeper?