Lecture 5-4: The Marks of the Church and Modern Ecumenism
Contents 33
- Lecture 1-1: What "History of Doctrine" Is, and What Newman and Pelikan Add to It
- Lecture 1-2: Three Theories of How Doctrine Develops
- Lecture 1-3: How the New Testament Canon Was Formed
- Lecture 1-4: Creeds Before the Creeds — The Rule of Faith
- Lecture 2-1: The Arian Controversy and the Council of Nicaea
- Lecture 2-2: From Nicaea to Constantinople — The Cappadocian Settlement
- Lecture 2-3: The Filioque and Medieval Trinitarian Theology
- Lecture 2-4: Post-Reformation Challenges and the Twentieth-Century Trinitarian Revival
- Lecture 3-1: Before Chalcedon: What Each Side Was Trying to Save
- Lecture 3-2: After Chalcedon: The Definition That Did Not End the Argument
- Lecture 3-3: Medieval to Reformation Christology
- Lecture 3-4: Modern Christology
- Lecture 4-1: The Pelagian Controversy
- Lecture 4-2: Grace in the Medieval Church
- Lecture 4-3: The Reformation and Justification by Faith
- Lecture 4-4: The Arminian Controversy
- Lecture 5-1: The Donatist Controversy and Augustine's Answer
- Lecture 5-2: Medieval Ecclesiology — Seven Sacraments and the Rise of Papal Primacy
- Lecture 5-3: The Reformation Splits Over the Lord's Supper
- Lecture 5-4: The Marks of the Church and Modern Ecumenism
- Lecture 6-1: Theopneustos — The Early Church's Doctrine of Inspiration
- Lecture 6-2: Scripture and Tradition in the Medieval Church — A Dispute About the Dispute
- Lecture 6-3: Sola Scriptura and Trent's Answer — What Each Side Actually Claimed
- Lecture 6-4: Scripture Under Modern Criticism, and the Contemporary Inerrancy Debate
- Lecture 7-1: The Earliest Millennium — Papias, Justin, and Irenaeus
- Lecture 7-2: Augustine and the Church-Age Reading
- Lecture 7-3: Puritan Hope and the Rise of Postmillennialism
- Lecture 7-4: Dispensationalism and the Modern Landscape
Every Sunday, congregations that recite the Nicene Creed confess belief in "one holy catholic and apostolic church" — four adjectives, agreed at Constantinople in 381, that every major branch of Christianity still formally accepts. And yet those same congregations, in a world where the church has fractured into thousands of separate bodies that do not recognize each other's ministries, do not share each other's tables (as 5-3 has just shown in painful detail), and in some cases do not consider each other saved, keep confessing a church that is one. This lecture asks what work those four words are actually doing, how the Reformation supplied a narrower, more operational test for identifying a true church when the medieval institutional unity the creed had assumed broke apart, and how seriously the last century's organized ecumenical movement has taken the gap between the creed's confession and the church's visible, scandalous disunity.
This is not a triumphant closing lecture. It closes the chapter's argument — that every controversy from Donatism to the Reformation's Eucharistic split has been the same question in new clothes — by asking the largest version of that question: what, at minimum, makes a body of Christians recognizably the church Christ founded, when Christians running that body have disagreed for sixteen centuries about almost everything except that question's importance. The honest answer includes real, hard-won convergence and real, still-open wounds, and this lecture will name both plainly rather than rounding either one off.
What these 21 minutes give you
- State the Nicene Creed's four marks of the church (one, holy, catholic, apostolic) and explain what each term originally meant to the bishops who confessed it in 381.
- Explain why the Reformation, confronted with a divided Western church, developed narrower, more operational marks (word rightly preached, sacraments rightly administered, and for some traditions, church discipline) and how these relate to, without replacing, the Nicene marks.
- Describe what the Second Vatican Council's *Lumen Gentium* and *Unitatis Redintegratio* actually changed in the Catholic Church's relationship to other Christian bodies.
- Give an honest, specific account of what the World Council of Churches and its Faith and Order movement have accomplished and where the deepest remaining divisions still stand.
There is one body, and one Spirit, even as you also were called in one hope of your calling; one Lord, one faith, one baptism, one God and Father of all, who is over all, and through all, and in us all." — Ephesians 4:4-6
World English Bible
Paul lists seven "ones" as an argument for unity he is urging on a real, divided, imperfect first-century church — not a description of a unity Christians could take for granted without effort. Every appeal to Christian unity across the sixteen centuries this lecture surveys, including the twentieth century's own organized , is in some sense an attempt to take Paul's list seriously against a church that keeps failing to embody it visibly.
1. The Nicene Creed's four marks
The Nicene-Constantinopolitan Creed (381) confesses "one, holy, catholic, and apostolic" church, and each word carried a specific meaning to the bishops who wrote it, not merely a vague compliment.
One does not mean uniform in every practice — the fourth-century church already contained real liturgical, linguistic, and cultural variety across its patriarchates. It means a single body united by a single faith and, in the theology of the time, by communion between its bishops, who were understood to be in visible fellowship with one another as a sign of the underlying unity.
Holy does not mean composed only of morally perfect members — this chapter's 5-1 has already shown Augustine insisting the visible church contains wheat and tares together until the final judgment. It means set apart, consecrated, and indwelt by the Holy Spirit as Christ's own body, holy in its source and even where its members visibly fail that calling.
Catholic, from the Greek katholikos, "according to the whole," means universal — the whole church, in every place, holding the whole faith, as opposed to any local or partial version of Christianity. Ignatius of Antioch had already used the term this way as early as the early second century, well before Nicaea, in his letter to the Smyrnaeans: "wherever Jesus Christ is, there is the catholic church."
Apostolic means both a claim of historical continuity with the apostles (through the succession of bishops and through the churches the apostles themselves founded) and, more fundamentally, a claim of doctrinal continuity — that the church still teaches what the apostles taught. The relative weight given to institutional succession versus doctrinal fidelity in that second sense is itself a place where Catholic, Orthodox, and Protestant ecclesiology diverge, though all three confess the word.
2. The Reformation's narrower, more operational marks
The medieval church had one obvious, visible answer to "which body is the true church": the institution in communion with the bishop of Rome, whose authority 5-2 traced climbing to Unam Sanctam. The Reformation's break with Rome removed that simple institutional answer for the churches that broke away, and they needed a working test for identifying a true church that did not simply beg the question by pointing to institutional continuity with Rome.
The Reformers' answer, stated across several confessional documents with small variations, generally named two marks as decisive: the word of God rightly preached and the sacraments rightly administered according to Christ's institution. The Augsburg Confession (1530), Article VII, states it this way: it is enough for the true unity of the church that the gospel be preached in harmony and the sacraments administered according to the divine word, and that human traditions or ceremonies need not be identical everywhere. Some Reformed confessions, notably in the Belgic Confession (1561), added a third mark, the exercise of to correct sin, on the ground that a church that preaches truly and administers the sacraments correctly but tolerates unrepentant sin without discipline has failed a real test of faithfulness that the first two marks alone do not capture.
These narrower marks were never meant to replace the 's four — every Reformation confession that states them also confesses the Nicene Creed's older language, usually explicitly. They function instead as a practical test for a specific sixteenth-century problem: when institutional continuity with Rome is no longer available as the test, and the visible church has fractured into competing claimants, how does an ordinary believer identify a faithful church to belong to? The Reformers' answer looks to the content of what is taught and practiced rather than to an unbroken chain of institutional succession — itself a significant and consequential shift in where authority is located, connecting directly back to 5-2's conciliarist question of where final church authority actually rests.
3. Vatican II: a real shift in how Rome describes other Christians
The Second Vatican Council (1962-1965) marks the most significant twentieth-century change in how the Catholic Church officially describes its relationship to other Christian bodies, and it is worth being precise about what changed and what did not.
Lumen Gentium ("Light of the Nations," 1964), the council's dogmatic constitution on the church, contains a phrase that generated enormous theological discussion in the decades since: that the one church of Christ "subsists in" (subsistit in) the Catholic Church, rather than the earlier, simpler formula that would have said the church of Christ is the Catholic Church without qualification. The change in wording was deliberate and is genuinely significant — it allows the council to affirm that "elements of and truth" exist outside the Catholic Church's visible boundaries, in other Christian communities, while still maintaining that the fullness of the means of salvation subsists uniquely within the Catholic Church itself. Catholic theologians have continued to debate exactly how much room this formula opens; it is neither a claim that all Christian bodies are equally "the church" in the fullest sense, nor a simple repetition of the pre-conciliar exclusive formula.
Unitatis Redintegratio ("Restoration of Unity," 1964), the council's decree on ecumenism, went further in practical terms: it acknowledged that the ongoing division among Christians is a real scandal that obscures the gospel before the world, recognized that other Christian communities possess genuine, if to varying degrees "imperfect," elements of the true church (validly celebrated sacraments in the case of Orthodox churches, whose orders Rome recognizes as valid, in a way it has not historically recognized most Protestant ordinations), and committed the Catholic Church for the first time officially to participation in the ecumenical movement rather than standing apart from it as it largely had since the Reformation. This was a genuine and consequential shift, not a cosmetic one — Catholic-Orthodox and Catholic-Protestant dialogue commissions of a kind that had not existed before became a normal feature of church life after 1965.
4. The World Council of Churches and Faith and Order: what has and has not been achieved
The World Council of Churches (WCC), founded in 1948 in Amsterdam and drawing together the earlier Faith and Order and Life and Work ecumenical movements that had begun in the 1920s, brings together most of the world's Orthodox and mainline Protestant churches (the Catholic Church has never become a full member, though it participates as an observer and works closely with the WCC's Faith and Order Commission). Its Faith and Order commission does the specifically theological work of trying to identify genuine doctrinal convergence across traditions, and its most significant single document remains the Baptism, Eucharist and Ministry text (the "Lima document," 1982), which achieved a remarkable level of convergence — not full agreement, but a shared theological vocabulary and identified areas of real agreement — on exactly the sacramental questions this chapter has traced dividing Christians since Donatus.
An honest account has to state plainly what this movement has and has not achieved. On the achievement side: the Lutheran-Catholic Joint Declaration on the Doctrine of (1999), later joined by the World Methodist Council (2006) and the World Communion of Reformed Churches (2017), represents a real and formally signed agreement that the core Reformation dispute over justification — a controversy 5-3 in the chapter on sin and grace, chapter 4, addressed in detail — no longer constitutes church-dividing doctrinal disagreement between the signing bodies, though it does not resolve every remaining difference in emphasis or vocabulary. Bilateral dialogues like ARCIC (Anglican-Roman Catholic International Commission, since 1970) have produced genuine convergence statements on ministry, authority, and the Eucharist that would have been unthinkable before Vatican II.
On the unresolved side: the Lord's Supper controversy 5-3 described remains formally unreconciled between the Catholic Church and the Protestant traditions descending from Luther, Zwingli, and Calvin — the Lima document produced convergence, not agreement, and Catholic and most Protestant bodies still do not practice open eucharistic sharing with each other except in limited, exceptional circumstances. Questions of ministry and ordination remain deeply divided, including whether women may be ordained (a live division not only between but within denominational families) and whether episcopal succession in the historic, tactile sense is necessary for a valid ministry at all — a question on which Catholic and Orthodox churches largely agree against most Protestant churches, while disagreeing with each other over the scope of papal authority within that shared conviction, a live continuation of the very dispute 5-2 traced from Gregory VII to the conciliarists. And full, visible, structural reunion of any kind between Rome, the Orthodox communion, and the major Protestant families remains, after a century of organized effort, further off than the movement's mid-twentieth-century founders may have hoped.
5. Closing the chapter's question
Return to where this chapter began: does the church's holiness depend on the holiness of the people running it? The honest modern ecumenical answer, taken across this whole chapter's history, is that the church has never fully agreed on how to answer that question, and has instead built, gradually and unevenly, mechanisms for living with the disagreement — Augustine's ex opere operato letting a compromised minister's still stand, conciliarism's attempt to locate authority somewhere a single corrupt or contested pope could not monopolize, Vatican II's careful language allowing "elements of the true church" to exist beyond Catholicism's own visible boundary, and the WCC's patient accumulation of convergence documents that narrow disagreement without eliminating it. None of these mechanisms has produced the single visible unity the Nicene Creed confesses in the present tense. All of them represent a serious, sustained refusal to give up on that confession simply because the church, in every century this chapter has covered, has kept giving the ecumenical movement fresh reasons to.
5. Going to the Sources
- Second Vatican Council, Lumen Gentium (1964), Chapter II ("On the People of God") and Unitatis Redintegratio (1964), both freely available at vatican.va — read the exact subsistit in wording in context rather than relying only on summaries of the debate it generated.
- World Council of Churches, Baptism, Eucharist and Ministry (the Lima document, 1982), freely available on the WCC's own website — a short, readable text that states, in the movement's own words, both how much convergence it found and how carefully it avoided claiming more than that.
- The Lutheran-Catholic Joint Declaration on the Doctrine of Justification (1999), freely available from the Vatican and Lutheran World Federation websites — read the actual text of what is, and is not, claimed to have been resolved.
In short
- The Nicene Creed (381) calls the church one, holy, catholic and apostolic. Each word had a specific meaning, and every major tradition still confesses all four.
- The Reformers added narrower, practical marks: the word rightly preached and the sacraments rightly administered. Some Reformed confessions, such as the Belgic Confession, added church discipline.
- These marks supplement the Nicene four and do not replace them. They shift the test from institutional succession to what is taught and practised.
- Vatican II said the church of Christ "subsists in" the Catholic Church. It also recognised "elements of sanctification and truth" elsewhere and committed Rome to ecumenism.
- The World Council of Churches, the Lima document, the 1999 Joint Declaration on Justification and ARCIC show real convergence. The Lord's Supper, ministry, women's ordination and papal authority remain divided.
Topic: This lecture asks what the Creed's four marks mean, how the Reformation narrowed the test for a true church, and how far modern ecumenism has closed the gap.
Remember: The church still confesses one church in the Creed, and the ecumenical movement has real achievements, yet visible unity has not been reached.
Caution: The lecture does not say all Christian bodies are equally "the church" in the fullest sense. It also declares no tradition the winner.
One line to carry into ministry: Take Ephesians 4:4-6 seriously: work patiently for unity, name real agreements and real wounds honestly, and do not give up on the confession.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- State, in your own words, what each of the Nicene Creed's four marks (one, holy, catholic, apostolic) originally meant. Has your own church tradition emphasized one of the four more than the others, and if so, why do you think that is?
- The Reformation's narrower marks (word rightly preached, sacraments rightly administered) were meant to supplement, not replace, the Nicene marks. Do you think a church could satisfy the Reformation's two marks while failing one of the Nicene Creed's four? Give an example to test your answer.
- *Lumen Gentium*'s shift from "the church of Christ is the Catholic Church" to "subsists in" the Catholic Church is a small change in wording with large theological consequences. Why might such a small linguistic change matter this much in ecclesiology, when 5-2 showed a whole council spending its opening canon on equally precise wording for the Eucharist?
- This lecture, and this chapter, close without declaring any tradition's ecclesiology the winner. Having read all four lectures, do you think the chapter's own principle — that every controversy asks whether the church's holiness depends on the holiness of the people running it — actually holds across all four moments, or did one of the four controversies feel like it was really asking a different question?