FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

CH401E The History of Christian Doctrine

Lecture 3-2: After Chalcedon: The Definition That Did Not End the Argument

View as cards (3 min)
Contents 33
CH401E The History of Christian Doctrine
Chapter 0 · Introduction: What the History of Doctrine Is, and Why a Doctrine Has a History
  1. Introduction: What the History of Doctrine Is, and Why a Doctrine Has a History
Chapter 1 · Chapter 1: Method, Canon, and Creed
  1. Lecture 1-1: What "History of Doctrine" Is, and What Newman and Pelikan Add to It
  2. Lecture 1-2: Three Theories of How Doctrine Develops
  3. Lecture 1-3: How the New Testament Canon Was Formed
  4. Lecture 1-4: Creeds Before the Creeds — The Rule of Faith
Chapter 2 · Chapter 2: The History of Trinitarian Doctrine
  1. Lecture 2-1: The Arian Controversy and the Council of Nicaea
  2. Lecture 2-2: From Nicaea to Constantinople — The Cappadocian Settlement
  3. Lecture 2-3: The Filioque and Medieval Trinitarian Theology
  4. Lecture 2-4: Post-Reformation Challenges and the Twentieth-Century Trinitarian Revival
Chapter 3 · Chapter 3: The History of Christological Doctrine
  1. Lecture 3-1: Before Chalcedon: What Each Side Was Trying to Save
  2. Lecture 3-2: After Chalcedon: The Definition That Did Not End the Argument
  3. Lecture 3-3: Medieval to Reformation Christology
  4. Lecture 3-4: Modern Christology
Chapter 4 · Chapter 4: Sin and Grace — The History of Soteriology
  1. Lecture 4-1: The Pelagian Controversy
  2. Lecture 4-2: Grace in the Medieval Church
  3. Lecture 4-3: The Reformation and Justification by Faith
  4. Lecture 4-4: The Arminian Controversy
Chapter 5 · Chapter 5: The Church and Its Sacraments
  1. Lecture 5-1: The Donatist Controversy and Augustine's Answer
  2. Lecture 5-2: Medieval Ecclesiology — Seven Sacraments and the Rise of Papal Primacy
  3. Lecture 5-3: The Reformation Splits Over the Lord's Supper
  4. Lecture 5-4: The Marks of the Church and Modern Ecumenism
Chapter 6 · Chapter 6: The Doctrine of Scripture
  1. Lecture 6-1: Theopneustos — The Early Church's Doctrine of Inspiration
  2. Lecture 6-2: Scripture and Tradition in the Medieval Church — A Dispute About the Dispute
  3. Lecture 6-3: Sola Scriptura and Trent's Answer — What Each Side Actually Claimed
  4. Lecture 6-4: Scripture Under Modern Criticism, and the Contemporary Inerrancy Debate
Chapter 7 · Chapter 7: The History of Eschatology
  1. Lecture 7-1: The Earliest Millennium — Papias, Justin, and Irenaeus
  2. Lecture 7-2: Augustine and the Church-Age Reading
  3. Lecture 7-3: Puritan Hope and the Rise of Postmillennialism
  4. Lecture 7-4: Dispensationalism and the Modern Landscape
Chapter 8 · Chapter 8: The Modern Doctrinal Landscape
  1. Lecture 8-1: The Enlightenment's Challenge and the Rise of Liberal Theology
  2. Lecture 8-2: Neo-Orthodoxy's Answer
  3. Lecture 8-3: Twentieth-Century Diversification
  4. Lecture 8-4: The Evangelical Tradition, and the Task Still Ahead

Jump to the key points ↓

22 min

Most readers meet the Council of Chalcedon (451) as a finish line: the church argued about Christ for a hundred years, and then it stopped arguing. That is not what happened. Chalcedon's own definition was accepted by Rome, by Constantinople, and by most of the sees represented at the council — but a substantial part of the church, especially in Egypt and Syria, judged that Chalcedon's language, however carefully worded, had actually reopened the Nestorian door it claimed to have closed, by insisting on "two natures" in a way they heard as dividing Christ back into two. That disagreement produced a division that has never healed. It is still, today, the reason the Oriental Orthodox communion (the Coptic, Ethiopian, Eritrean, Armenian, and Syriac Orthodox churches, among others) and the Eastern Orthodox and Catholic and Protestant churches that accept Chalcedon are not in communion with one another — a genuinely live, sixteen-century-old wound, not a settled historical curiosity.

This lecture also covers two further disputes the church had to work through in the two and a half centuries after Chalcedon, both efforts to clarify — not undo — what Chalcedon had said: the Three Chapters controversy, resolved at the Second Council of Constantinople in 553, and the Monothelite controversy, resolved at the Third Council of Constantinople in 680–681 at a personal cost to one theologian, Maximus the Confessor, that is worth sitting with rather than rushing past.

What these 22 minutes give you

  • Explain why Chalcedon's definition satisfied neither strict Cyrillians (who heard "two natures" as a return to Nestorianism) nor committed Antiochenes, and describe the origin and present-day reality of the Oriental Orthodox/Chalcedonian split.
  • State what the Three Chapters controversy was actually about (three specific writers and writings judged Nestorian-leaning, condemned decades after their deaths) and what the Second Council of Constantinople (553) decided.
  • Define monothelitism (one will in Christ) as a seventh-century attempt at a compromise formula with the miaphysite churches, and explain why it failed on the same logic that had condemned Apollinarianism and Eutychianism.
  • Describe Maximus the Confessor's argument for two wills in Christ, the price he paid for it (his tongue and right hand, by imperial order, after the Third Council of Constantinople condemned monothelitism in 680–681), and why the church has remembered his mutilation as itself part of the theological argument.

He went forward a little, fell on his face, and prayed, saying, 'My Father, if it is possible, let this cup pass away from me; nevertheless, not what I desire, but what you desire.'" — Matthew 26:39

World English Bible

He, in the days of his flesh, having offered up prayers and petitions with strong crying and tears to him who was able to save him from death, and having been heard for his godly fear," — Hebrews 5:7

WEB

Read these two texts with the Monothelite controversy already in view, and you will see immediately why Maximus thought the stakes could not be higher. Gethsemane shows Jesus asking the Father for one thing — "let this cup pass" — and then submitting to another. If Christ has only a single will, shared identically with the Father's will, this exchange becomes theater: there was never a real human "I want" in tension with anything, only a divine will talking to itself through a human mouth. If Christ has a genuine human will, exercising genuine human agency in submission to the Father, then Gethsemane is what it appears to be: the human will of the incarnate Son, under real strain, freely conforming itself to the divine will he shares with the Father and the Spirit. Hebrews adds that this prayer was offered "with strong crying and tears" — the language of a will that felt the full weight of what it was asking and what it then chose to submit to.

1. Chalcedon's definition, and why it satisfied nobody completely

The , agreed by the assembled bishops in 451, confesses Christ as "one and the same Son... acknowledged in two natures, without confusion, without change, without division, without separation" — the four negative adverbs doing almost all the work, ruling out Eutyches's blending (without confusion, without change) and Nestorius's splitting (without division, without separation) without positively explaining how the union works philosophically. That restraint was deliberate. Chalcedon was not trying to solve the metaphysics; it was trying to draw a fence wide enough to keep the church inside orthodoxy while leaving room for real theological work to continue.

But a fence that keeps two groups inside the same field does not make them stop arguing about which corner of the field is best. Strict Cyrillians — theologians loyal to Cyril's preferred formula "one incarnate nature of God the Word," discussed in the previous lecture — heard "acknowledged in two natures" as a betrayal of the very language Ephesus had vindicated twenty years earlier, and suspected, not unreasonably given the history, that Chalcedon's Antiochene-leaning bishops had smuggled back in under cover of careful phrasing. Committed Antiochenes, for their part, thought Chalcedon had not gone nearly far enough to protect the distinctness of the human nature Christ. Both sides had signed the same document and read two different councils into it.

2. The miaphysite churches and a division still unhealed

The theologians and, more importantly, the entire regional churches of Egypt (centered on Alexandria) and much of Syria did not merely grumble about Chalcedon's wording — they rejected the council outright, judging that its two-natures language, whatever its authors intended, functionally divided Christ. Their own preferred formula, following the language they believed was Cyril's own (the source-attribution problem noted in the previous lecture notwithstanding), was mia physis — "one nature," but a single united nature that is itself both fully divine and fully human, not a human nature erased by the divine, which is why the more careful modern label for this position is miaphysite rather than the older, and in their own view unfair, "monophysite" (a term that lumps them together with Eutyches's actual heresy, which most miaphysite theologians explicitly rejected as strongly as Chalcedonian theologians did).

This rejection produced a lasting institutional split. Imperial and ecclesiastical efforts across the following two centuries — including a document called the Henotikon ("act of union," 482), which tried to paper over the dispute by avoiding the contested vocabulary altogether — repeatedly failed to reunite the sides, and by the sixth and seventh centuries separate church hierarchies had solidified. The churches that trace their descent from this rejection of Chalcedon are known today as the Oriental Orthodox communion: the Coptic Orthodox Church of Egypt, the Ethiopian and Eritrean Orthodox Tewahedo Churches, the Syriac Orthodox Church, the Armenian Apostolic Church, and the Malankara Orthodox Syrian Church of India, among others — collectively numbering tens of millions of Christians. This is not a historical footnote. Formal theological dialogues between Oriental Orthodox and Eastern Orthodox (and separately, Catholic) representatives in the twentieth and twenty-first centuries have produced joint statements suggesting that much of the original dispute may in fact have been more a matter of terminology and mutual mistrust than substantive disagreement about who Christ actually is — but full ecclesial communion has still not been restored between these families of churches as of this writing. This is a point where readers will not agree, and it is worth naming plainly rather than passing over quickly: Oriental Orthodox Christians hold, with entire theological seriousness and their own unbroken tradition running back through Cyril himself, that Chalcedon's formula is not the necessary or even the best way to confess the very same Christ that Chalcedonian churches confess; Chalcedonian Christians (Catholic, Eastern Orthodox, and the great majority of Protestants) hold that Chalcedon's "two natures" language is the necessary safeguard against a real and historically demonstrated danger. A course on doctrinal history should not adjudicate this dispute; it should make sure a reader from either tradition can recognize their own church's position stated fairly.

3. The Three Chapters controversy and Constantinople II (553)

The next major episode is stranger to modern ears than either of the controversies already covered, because it is a fight over dead men's writings rather than a live heresy. In an attempt to win back the miaphysite churches after a century of failed reconciliation, Emperor Justinian I proposed condemning three specific pieces of writing associated with figures whose theology was judged, on reflection, too Antiochene and too close to Nestorius's own concerns: the person and writings of Theodore of Mopsuestia (already dead for over a century, and Nestorius's own teacher), certain writings of Theodoret of Cyrus written against Cyril, and a letter attributed to Ibas of Edessa. These three items became known as the Three Chapters.

The proposal was controversial precisely because Theodoret and Ibas had both been formally received back into communion, as orthodox, at Chalcedon itself — condemning their writings a century later looked to many Western bishops like undoing Chalcedon's own verdict under a different name, and Pope Vigilius's initial resistance, followed under enormous imperial pressure by his eventual (and much criticized) capitulation, is itself a case study in how far Byzantine emperors could lean on the papacy in this period. The Second Council of Constantinople (553) ultimately condemned the Three Chapters while explicitly reaffirming Chalcedon's own authority — the point was to prune what the council judged an excessively Antiochene reading of Chalcedon, not to reverse the council itself. It did not, in the end, win back the miaphysite churches it was designed to conciliate; the split named above had already hardened too far.

4. Monothelitism: one will, in the same shape as an old mistake

By the early seventh century, the Byzantine emperor Heraclius faced a Persian and then an Arab conquest sweeping through exactly the regions — Egypt, Syria — where miaphysite Christianity was strongest, and had every political reason to want theological reconciliation with those provinces. Patriarch Sergius of Constantinople proposed a new compromise formula, subtler than the Henotikon: grant Chalcedon's "two natures," but affirm that Christ, in acting, has only one energy (mode of operating), and — in the fuller and more consequential version of the same idea — one will (thelēma), since a single divine person acting must, on this view, act through a single unified will rather than two.

Watch the shape of the argument, because it is exactly the shape of Apollinarius's argument three centuries earlier, applied to the will instead of the mind. Apollinarius had reasoned: two complete rational centers would mean two persons, so let the divine Word's mind do the work a human mind would otherwise do. Monothelitism reasons: two complete wills would mean two persons (or at least two agents pulling in different directions), so let there be one will, belonging properly to the single divine person, expressed through the human nature but not itself a second, distinct human center of willing. It is Apollinarianism's logic, one faculty later.

Maximus the Confessor, a monk with no episcopal office and therefore very little institutional power, became the controversy's most determined and most costly opponent. His argument runs directly from the very Chalcedonian logic monothelitism claimed to honor: if Christ has a genuinely complete human nature, and will is a natural faculty belonging to a nature (something every complete nature has, the way every complete nature has an intellect), then Christ must have a genuinely human will alongside his divine will — not two wills fighting each other as two separate agents would, since the human will is always in perfect, freely willed conformity to the divine, but two wills nonetheless, because a nature without a will is not a complete nature. Take away Christ's human will, Maximus argued, and you have taken away something Gethsemane itself shows him actually exercising: a real human "let this cup pass," freely and without coercion brought into line with "not what I desire, but what you desire." A Christ with no real human will to submit has nothing to submit, and Gethsemane becomes a divine will performing a human-looking gesture rather than a genuine human act of obedience — which puts the same soteriological axiom from the previous lecture back on the table: a human will that was never truly Christ's own is a human will that was never healed.

The Third Council of Constantinople (680–681) ultimately vindicated exactly this argument, condemning monothelitism and affirming two wills in Christ, human and divine, the human will always freely subject to the divine and never opposed to it. But Maximus did not live to see full vindication in comfortable retirement. Tried for treason as much as heresy — resisting an emperor's official theology was, in this period, indistinguishable from resisting the emperor — he was, by imperial order in 662, subjected to the amputation of his tongue and his right hand, specifically so that he could neither preach nor write in defense of his position again. He died in exile shortly afterward, roughly two decades before the council that confirmed he had been right. The church has remembered this not as an unfortunate footnote to a theological debate but as part of the argument itself: a claim about how much two wills genuinely matter, made not only in Maximus's writing but in what the state judged worth silencing by force.

5. What this lecture asks you to carry forward

Two and a half centuries after Chalcedon, the church had refined its Christology twice more — once to clarify what Chalcedon meant against an over-Antiochene reading (553), once to close off a compromise that would have repeated Apollinarius's mistake in a new key (680–681) — and had still not healed the division Chalcedon itself provoked among those who judged its very language, however carefully meant, to divide the Christ it was written to unite. Notice that every party in every one of these disputes, across two and a half more centuries, is still protecting the same claim this chapter opened with. Nobody wanted less of Christ. They disagreed, sometimes at the cost of a theologian's hand and tongue, about which form of words actually protected what all of them agreed had to be protected.


After Chalcedon: The Argument Continues One split that never healed, and two councils that refined rather than reversed Chalcedon, 451 — "two natures... without confusion, without division" Egypt and much of Syria reject it as dividing Christ; the split becomes the Oriental Orthodox communion Still not in full communion with Chalcedonian churches today Three Chapters & Constantinople II (553) Condemns three writers judged too Antiochene, while reaffirming Chalcedon itself Did not win back the miaphysite churches Monothelitism & Constantinople III (680-681) Proposed "one will" compromise fails Apollinarius's own logic; council affirms two wills Maximus the Confessor's tongue and right hand, 662 A will with no complete nature to belong to is a will Christ never made his own Gethsemane: "not what I desire, but what you desire" (Matthew 26:39) This is a point where readers will not agree Oriental Orthodox and Chalcedonian Christians both confess the same Christ in different formulas

5. Going to the Sources

  • The acts of the Third Council of Constantinople (680–681), condemning monothelitism and affirming two wills and two operations in Christ "united without division, alteration, separation, or confusion" — echoing Chalcedon's own four negative adverbs applied now to the will. An English translation of the council's Definition is included among the acts of the seven ecumenical councils collected and translated in the Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, Second Series, vol. 14, freely available at ccel.org.

In short

  • Chalcedon (451) confessed one Christ "in two natures." Strict followers of Cyril heard this as a return to Nestorianism, while committed Antiochenes thought it did not protect Christ's humanity enough.
  • Egypt and much of Syria rejected Chalcedon. Their churches, now called the Oriental Orthodox communion, hold "miaphysite" belief: one united nature, both fully divine and fully human.
  • Modern dialogues suggest the split may owe much to wording and mistrust, yet communion is still not restored. The lecture states both sides fairly and does not judge between them.
  • The Three Chapters controversy (Constantinople II, 553) condemned three writers judged too Antiochene, and reaffirmed Chalcedon. It did not win back the miaphysite churches.
  • Monothelitism proposed one will in Christ. Maximus the Confessor answered that a complete human nature needs a human will, as Gethsemane shows. Constantinople III (680-681) agreed, after Maximus lost his tongue and right hand.

Topic: This lecture shows that Chalcedon did not end the argument about Christ, and follows the later councils of 553 and 680-681.

Remember: Christ has two wills, human and divine. The human will freely follows the divine, and a nature with no will would not be complete.

Caution: The lecture does not say who is right in the Chalcedonian and Oriental Orthodox division. It says both traditions confess the same Christ and should be stated fairly.

One line to carry into ministry: Be slow to make a form of words a test of communion, and speak fairly of churches that confess Christ differently.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • If the twentieth- and twenty-first-century theological dialogues are right that the Chalcedonian/miaphysite split may rest more on terminology and mistrust than on a real difference in what each side believes about Christ, what does that suggest about how careful the church needs to be before letting a doctrinal formula become a communion-dividing test?
  • The Three Chapters controversy condemned writers who had died decades, in one case over a century, earlier. Should a church ever revisit and condemn theology after the theologian is no longer able to explain, defend, or clarify it? What safeguards would you want in place if it does?
  • Monothelitism repeats, in the case of the will, the same argument structure Apollinarius used for the mind three centuries earlier. Why do you think the same underlying mistake kept recurring under new vocabulary rather than being permanently closed off after 381?
  • Maximus the Confessor lost his tongue and right hand for a position later vindicated by an ecumenical council. What should a modern reader do with the fact that being right, in this history, did not protect a theologian from paying a severe personal price for it?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.