FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

LM106E The History and Practice of Prayer

Lecture 3-2: Common Prayer, Quiet Gatherings, and the Examen

Contents 31
LM106E The History and Practice of Prayer
Chapter 0 · Introduction: A Conversation the Church Has Learned Together
  1. Introduction: A Conversation the Church Has Learned Together
Chapter 1 · Week 1: Roots — Scripture, the Early Church, the Desert
  1. Lecture 1-1: How Scripture Shows Us Prayer
  2. Lecture 1-2: The Early Church at Prayer
  3. Lecture 1-3: The Desert and the Monastery
  4. Lecture 1-4: Praying the Psalms with the Church
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: The Lord's Prayer, Slowly
Chapter 2 · Week 2: East and West
  1. Lecture 2-1: The Eastern Way: The Jesus Prayer and the Quiet
  2. Lecture 2-2: The Western Middle Ages: Hours and Holy Reading
  3. Lecture 2-3: The Mystics and the Dark Nights
  4. Lecture 2-4: Praying with Mary and the Saints?
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Holy Reading
Chapter 3 · Week 3: Reformation and Devotion
  1. Lecture 3-1: Luther and Calvin at Prayer
  2. Lecture 3-2: Common Prayer, Quiet Gatherings, and the Examen
  3. Lecture 3-3: Puritans, Pietists, Moravians, Wesley
  4. Lecture 3-4: Brother Lawrence and Prayer in Daily Work
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Praying with a Frame
Chapter 4 · Week 4: Revival, Korea and the Global Church
  1. Lecture 4-1: Revival and Mission
  2. Lecture 4-2: Prayer in Korea and Elsewhere
  3. Lecture 4-3: The Twentieth Century: Many Streams
  4. Lecture 4-4: Disagreements in Today's Praying
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: A Daily Rhythm
Chapter 5 · Week 5: Prayer Practices Today
  1. Lecture 5-1: A Map of Prayer
  2. Lecture 5-2: Asking, Answers, and Unanswered Prayer
  3. Lecture 5-3: Dryness, Distraction and Silence
  4. Lecture 5-4: Praying Together
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: A Prayer Log and a Prayer Partner
Chapter 6 · Week 6: Prayer and Life for the Long Run
  1. Lecture 6-1: Prayer in Ordinary Life and for the Neighbour
  2. Lecture 6-2: When Prayer Is Misused
  3. Lecture 6-3: Hard Seasons
  4. Lecture 6-4: Praying for the Long Run
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab: A Three-Month Plan

Jump to the key points ↓

20 min

When the Reformation moved prayer out of the monastery and the Latin choir, it raised a practical question. What would ordinary people pray, and in what form? Different groups gave different answers in the 1500s and 1600s. One answer was a shared book in the people's language. Another was silence and plain speech. A third, from within the Catholic Church at the same time, was a short daily review of the day before God.

This lecture looks at three of those answers: the English Book of Common Prayer, the quiet gatherings of the Anabaptists and Quakers, and the Examen of Ignatius Loyola. It then looks at an old and lasting argument: whether prayer is better with fixed words or with words made up as one goes.

The aim is not to choose one. The aim is to understand what each gives and what each risks, so that you can use what helps and describe the rest fairly.

What these 20 minutes give you

  • Describe what the *Book of Common Prayer* was, when it appeared, and how a lay person could use its morning and evening prayer.
  • Describe the silence of the Quaker meeting and the plainness of Anabaptist prayer, without claiming more than is known.
  • Name the steps of the Examen and say what it is for.
  • State the case for fixed prayer and the case for spontaneous prayer, each in the words its own supporters would accept.
  • Choose one pattern to try this week and say why you chose it.

Guard your steps when you go to God’s house; for to draw near to listen is better than to give the sacrifice of fools, for they don’t know that they do evil. Don’t be rash with your mouth, and don’t let your heart be hasty to utter anything before God; for God is in heaven, and you on earth. Therefore let your words be few." — Ecclesiastes 5:1-2

World English Bible

Let my prayer be set before you like incense; the lifting up of my hands like the evening sacrifice." — Psalm 141:2

WEB

Search me, God, and know my heart. Try me, and know my thoughts. See if there is any wicked way in me, and lead me in the everlasting way." — Psalm 139:23-24

WEB

Each passage speaks for one of the patterns in this lecture. Ecclesiastes speaks for restraint and listening. Psalm 141 speaks of prayer offered at set times, like an evening offering. Psalm 139 is a prayer to be searched, which is close to what the Examen asks.

1. The Book of Common Prayer

In 1549 the Church of England published a single book of worship in English, for use throughout the country. Thomas Cranmer, then Archbishop of Canterbury, was its chief author. It was revised in 1552 and again in later years, and the edition of 1662 became the standard in England for a very long time. Churches of the Anglican Communion and some others have since made their own editions and revisions.

Why "common"? The word means shared. The same words were to be used in every parish, so that a farmer in one county and a merchant in another prayed the same prayers, in a language both understood.

For lay prayer, the most important part of the book is the pair of daily services, Morning Prayer and Evening Prayer. They were made by gathering the many monastic hours (see lecture 1-3) into two. A parish could hold them in church, and a household could say them at home. In outline, each service has the following parts:

  1. A sentence of Scripture to open, and a prayer of confession with a word of forgiveness.
  2. Psalms, appointed so that the whole Psalter is prayed through in a regular cycle.
  3. Readings from the Old and New Testaments.
  4. Songs of praise taken from Scripture and the early church, called canticles.
  5. A creed, the Lord's Prayer, and a series of short prayers called collects, many of them translated from much older sources.

The book's authors also hoped that clergy and people would pray these services daily, and clergy were expected to. Today many Anglicans, Lutherans and others use short daily forms based on the same idea.

What does a lay person gain? Four things. The words are Scripture-rich. A beginner is carried by the pattern. The prayer joins the person to others who are praying the same words that day. And the prayers for others are already written, so you need not decide whom to include.

Now the concern. Some Protestants in England, called Puritans, held that a set form could harden into formality, with the lips moving and the heart elsewhere. In 1645 a Directory for Public Worship replaced the Prayer Book for a time in England and Scotland. It gave directions for prayer and worship, but not fixed words. Many Christians in the Reformed and free-church traditions have shared that concern since.

Anglican and Catholic readers would reply that a form is not what makes a prayer empty. A person can speak spontaneous words with their mind elsewhere, and a person can say a set prayer with all their heart. We return to that point at the end of this lecture.

2. Quiet gatherings

Other groups in the 1500s and 1600s shaped prayer differently. We must be careful here, because they were not one movement and their practices have changed.

. The word means "baptising again." The first Anabaptists appeared in the 1520s, in Switzerland, and held that baptism should be given to believers who profess faith. Their descendants include Mennonites, Amish and Hutterites. They shared a strong sense that the Christian life should be plain and that faith should show in daily conduct, and many were wary of display in worship. In prayer, their communities differed. In some communities today, prayer books with fixed prayers are used, and silent prayer before and after a meal is common. In others, prayer is spoken freely. We cannot say that "the Anabaptists prayed this way", and any claim of that kind should be doubted.

Quakers. The Religious Society of Friends began in England in the 1650s, around George Fox. It is not Anabaptist in origin, but it belongs in the same part of the story because of its stress on plainness and on waiting. In the form often called unprogrammed, Friends gather in silence. They have no appointed preacher. Anyone who feels moved by God may speak, and often no one does. The silence is not an absence of prayer. It is prayer as listening, and Friends describe it as waiting for God to speak to the whole group. The silence is a gift for many, and it is a difficulty for others. Some people find a long silence restful; others find it empty or even frightening. Both are normal.

What can a reader outside those traditions take? The point of Ecclesiastes 5:2, "let your words be few", is that talking is not the only way to pray. A short, planned silence after reading a Psalm, or before you start your request, lets you listen. If silence is hard for you, it is fine to skip it, or to keep it very short. Nobody has to sit in silence to be a person who prays.

3. Ignatius and the Examen

Ignatius of Loyola (1491-1556) was a Basque soldier who was badly wounded in 1521. While he recovered, he read about the life of Christ and the lives of saints, and his life changed course. He later gathered a group of companions, and in 1540 the pope approved them as the Society of Jesus, whose members are called Jesuits. Ignatius also wrote the Spiritual Exercises, a manual of prayer and reflection, usually given by a guide over weeks. It is a Catholic work with a sacramental setting, and we will describe only one small part of it.

That part is the Examen, a short review of the day. Ignatius gave it great weight. Tradition says he asked the first Jesuits to keep it even when other prayers had to be shortened. The Examen is not a long confession. In outline it has five steps, which later teachers have adapted in slightly different ways:

  1. Give thanks. Begin with gratitude for what the day has held.
  2. Ask for light. Ask God to show you the day as it was, not as you would like it to have been.
  3. Look back over the day. Go through it hour by hour, noticing what happened and what you did.
  4. Ask forgiveness. Name what you did wrongly, in plain words, and ask for pardon.
  5. Look to tomorrow. Ask for help with the next day, and make one small resolve.

Many people who use it today, in several traditions, add a question in the spirit of Ignatian teaching on noticing where one is drawn toward God or away from God: Where did I feel close to God today, and where did I turn away? That question is a way of noticing, not a test.

Here is a very short example of how it might sound (an invented example):

Thank you for the soup my neighbour left at the door. Show me today as it was. I was short with my daughter before school, and I did not call my mother. I am sorry. Tomorrow, help me to call her before noon.

That is the whole prayer. It takes about a minute. Notice that it is specific, and it ends with a small, doable step.

A Protestant reader may ask whether this fits their tradition. The words of Psalm 139:23-24, "Search me, God, and know my heart", are close in spirit. The Examen as described here is a private prayer, not a , and nothing in it requires a priest. A Reformed reader might also want to add a closing thanks for forgiveness already given in Christ. That fits the practice.

There is also a caution. Ignatius himself struggled in his early years with scruples, the sense that he could never confess enough. A person who is prone to that kind of anxiety should be careful with any exercise that asks "what did I do wrong?" If the Examen increases fear, keep only the first and the last steps, and speak with a pastor, priest or counsellor.

4. Fixed prayer and spontaneous prayer

This is a point where readers will not agree. Some Christians, including Catholic, Orthodox, Anglican and Lutheran readers, hold that fixed prayers are a main way a person learns to pray. Their case, in its strongest form, is this. Jesus himself gave his disciples words to say, in Matthew 6:9-13. A fixed prayer carries a person when they have no words of their own, whether in grief, tiredness or dryness. It joins the person to the whole church, past and present. It protects prayer from becoming only a list of the person's own concerns. And a form said with attention is not "vain repetitions". It is a path worn smooth by many feet.

Other Christians, including many Baptist, Pentecostal, free-church and Quaker readers, hold that spontaneous prayer is the heart of prayer. Their case, in its strongest form, is this. A child speaks to a parent in their own words. Romans 8:26 says the Spirit helps us when we do not know what to pray. Jesus himself prayed in his own words in Gethsemane. A prayer that is made as it is spoken shows what the person truly means. And a long habit of fixed words can slide into a recitation in which no one is really present.

Each side has a fair worry about the other. The worry about fixed prayer is that it can be said by rote. The worry about spontaneous prayer is that it can be shapeless, or the same few phrases can be said over and over without notice, so that it too becomes a fixed form without the benefits of a written one.

You should not judge either by its worst case. A distracted person reading a Collect and a rambling person praying aloud both exist, and neither tells us what fixed or free prayer is at its best. What the course requires is small: that you can describe each as its supporters would, that you can name what you gain from each, and that you notice that most people end up using both. A person who prays the Lord's Prayer and then speaks to God in their own words has already crossed the line.


Diagram 1. Three shapes that prayer took

Three Shapes for Prayer, 1500s and 1600s Shared words, waiting, and a daily review Common Prayer English, 1549, Cranmer Morning and Evening Psalms, readings, collects Gift: shared words carry a tired person Risk: said without heart Quiet Gatherings Anabaptist plainness Quaker silence (1650s) Few words, waiting, listening together Gift: room to listen Risk: hard for some The Examen Ignatius Loyola Thanks, light, review, forgiveness, tomorrow Gift: a day seen honestly in a minute Risk: scruples, anxiety Not a ranking Each is a path that real people have walked for a long time. Any of them can be done well, and any can go empty.

Diagram 2. The Examen in five steps

Step A question to ask Possible sentence
Give thanks What was good today? Thank you for the meal and for the bus that came.
Ask for light Show me the day as it was. Help me to see without excuses.
Look back What happened, hour by hour? The morning went well; the afternoon I was impatient.
Ask forgiveness What should I name? I was sharp with a colleague. I am sorry.
Look ahead What is one step for tomorrow? Help me to speak kindly to him first thing.

In short

  • The Book of Common Prayer (1549) gave English-speaking people shared daily prayers in their own language, drawn from older hours into Morning and Evening Prayer.
  • Anabaptist and Quaker traditions valued plainness and, among Friends, silent waiting. These traditions differ from one another, and generalising about them is unsafe.
  • The Examen is a short daily review: give thanks, ask for light, look back, ask forgiveness, look ahead.
  • Supporters of fixed prayer value shared words and a path worn by many. Supporters of spontaneous prayer value honesty and the Spirit's help.
  • Neither fixed nor free prayer should be judged by its worst case; most people use both.
  • Silence and self-examination are invitations. Anyone may shorten or skip them, especially if they bring fear or shame.
Front Back
Book of Common Prayer English book of worship, 1549, Cranmer; Morning and Evening Prayer for parish and home.
Quiet gatherings Plainness and waiting; the Quaker meeting is held in silence from the 1650s.
The Examen Ignatius' short daily review: thanks, light, look back, forgiveness, look ahead.
Fixed or spontaneous Each has gifts and risks. Most people use both. Do not judge either by its worst case.

One sentence to remember Shared words, silence and a daily review are three tested ways to give prayer a shape, and each can help or go empty.

This week's action Try the Examen once in the evening for about a minute, using the five steps, and note only that you did it.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • Which of the three shapes (shared words, quiet, or the daily review) feels most natural to you? Which feels least natural? Do you know why?
  • Describe in your own words a time when a set prayer carried you. Then describe a time when a spontaneous prayer did.
  • Ecclesiastes 5:2 says, "let your words be few." What does that look like in a short prayer? What does it not require?
  • The Examen includes a step of looking at your failings. How could a person do this without sliding into shame?
  • A friend says, "Fixed prayers are empty; only spontaneous prayer is real." Another says the opposite. How would you answer each in a way that is fair to both?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.