Lecture 4-1: Revival and Mission
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: How Scripture Shows Us Prayer
- Lecture 1-2: The Early Church at Prayer
- Lecture 1-3: The Desert and the Monastery
- Lecture 1-4: Praying the Psalms with the Church
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: The Lord's Prayer, Slowly
- Lecture 2-1: The Eastern Way: The Jesus Prayer and the Quiet
- Lecture 2-2: The Western Middle Ages: Hours and Holy Reading
- Lecture 2-3: The Mystics and the Dark Nights
- Lecture 2-4: Praying with Mary and the Saints?
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Holy Reading
- Lecture 3-1: Luther and Calvin at Prayer
- Lecture 3-2: Common Prayer, Quiet Gatherings, and the Examen
- Lecture 3-3: Puritans, Pietists, Moravians, Wesley
- Lecture 3-4: Brother Lawrence and Prayer in Daily Work
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Praying with a Frame
- Lecture 4-1: Revival and Mission
- Lecture 4-2: Prayer in Korea and Elsewhere
- Lecture 4-3: The Twentieth Century: Many Streams
- Lecture 4-4: Disagreements in Today's Praying
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: A Daily Rhythm
- Lecture 5-1: A Map of Prayer
- Lecture 5-2: Asking, Answers, and Unanswered Prayer
- Lecture 5-3: Dryness, Distraction and Silence
- Lecture 5-4: Praying Together
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: A Prayer Log and a Prayer Partner
Up to now this course has looked at prayer as it grew in monasteries, in prayer books, in homes and in private rooms. This week it travels. In the 1700s and after, many Christians began to pray in a new way: in large numbers, on a schedule, for something far beyond their own street. They prayed for a revival of faith in their own church, and they prayed for people on the other side of the world.
This lecture looks at three things that belong together: the "concert of prayer" of the eighteenth century, the link between prayer and the mission movement, and the songs of enslaved African Americans, which were prayers set to music. It also asks a hard question that every revival raises. When prayer becomes intense and emotional, what is gained, and what is risked?
The lecture does not say that revival prayer is the best kind of prayer. It does not say it is a lesser kind either. It describes what people did, in what they themselves would accept as an honest account, and it asks what a reader may take from it today.
What these 22 minutes give you
- Describe the "concert of prayer" and say what it asked ordinary believers to do.
- Explain why the prayer of Acts 4 asks for boldness and not for safety.
- Say how prayer and the modern mission movement were joined, without claiming more than the evidence shows.
- Describe the spirituals as prayer in song, and state one careful limit on what we can say about them.
- State one strength and one risk of emotional intensity in prayer, and give Edwards' test for telling them apart.
When they heard it, they lifted up their voice to God with one accord, and said, “O Lord, you are God, who made the heaven, the earth, the sea, and all that is in them;" — Acts 4:24
World English Bible
Now, Lord, look at their threats, and grant to your servants to speak your word with all boldness," — Acts 4:29
WEB
When they had prayed, the place was shaken where they were gathered together. They were all filled with the Holy Spirit, and they spoke the word of God with boldness." — Acts 4:31
WEB
Those who sow in tears will reap in joy." — Psalm 126:5
WEB
He who goes out weeping, carrying seed for sowing, will certainly come again with joy, carrying his sheaves." — Psalm 126:6
WEB
If you then, being evil, know how to give good gifts to your children, how much more will your heavenly Father give the Holy Spirit to those who ask him?”" — Luke 11:13
WEB
The first three verses are one prayer from the earliest church, said by a group under threat. The two verses from Psalm 126 speak of tears and sowing, which is the language later revival and mission praying often used. The verse from Luke is the promise those who prayed for revival held onto.
1. A prayer said by a group
Begin with a scene from Scripture, because the people in this lecture began there too.
In Acts 4 Peter and John have been questioned by the leaders in Jerusalem and told to stop speaking about Jesus. They are released. They go back to their friends, report what was said, and the whole group prays "with one accord". Notice what they ask for. They do not ask that the threats be taken away. They say, in the words of verse 29, "look at their threats", and then ask for boldness. They ask for something to be given to them, so that they can keep speaking.
Two features of this prayer return again and again in the history of revival and mission. It is a prayer said together, by people who agree on what they are asking. And it is about the work of God in the world, not only about the needs of the people praying. Neither feature is the only way to pray. Jesus also told his followers to pray in a private room (Matthew 6:6, which comes up again in lecture 4-4). The church has always had both. This week looks at the shared, outward-facing side.
2. The 1740s: a concert of prayer
The eighteenth century saw a series of religious revivals, often called the , in Britain and in the North American colonies. They began in different places and had different leaders. Jonathan Edwards (1703-1758), a pastor in Northampton, Massachusetts, wrote an account of a local revival there in the mid-1730s. The preacher George Whitefield travelled widely in the 1730s and 1740s. Scholars still argue about how far these events were one movement and how far they were many.
In the 1740s a particular practice developed. Ministers in Scotland, in the middle of the decade, invited believers to set aside fixed times to pray for revival. It became known as a "concert of prayer": many people, in many places, praying at the same agreed time for the same thing. In 1747 Edwards published a long book supporting the idea. Its title was long, and it is usually remembered by its first words, An Humble Attempt. It urged Christians in different churches to agree to pray, at set times, for the spread of true religion.
Look at the shape of this practice, because it is different from much of what this course has covered.
- It was agreed in advance. Nobody was waiting for a mood. A time was fixed.
- It crossed local boundaries. People who would never meet prayed together across a distance. The "together" was in the time and in the request, not in the room.
- It asked for a shared outcome. The prayer was not "give me peace today". It was a request for something that could only be shared.
- It was open to ordinary people. You did not need to be a pastor or a monk. You needed to know the time and the request.
A modern reader may think of a worldwide prayer chain, or of a congregation that prays on the same day for a country. The idea is the same. What the eighteenth century added was a sense that regular, agreed prayer for a large goal was a normal duty and gift of the lay believer.
3. Prayer and the mission movement
The same pattern runs into the mission movement of the late 1700s and the 1800s. We must be careful here, because it is easy to tell this story as a neat line from prayer to mission, and the evidence does not support a neat line.
What we can say with confidence is this. In England in the 1780s, groups of Baptist ministers promoted regular prayer meetings for revival, and one of them, in the Midlands, issued a call for monthly prayer in 1784. A few years later, in 1792, a society was formed to send missionaries, and William Carey (1761-1834) went to India the next year. Many people involved in these events spoke of prayer as part of what had prepared them. In the United States a story is told about students at Williams College in Massachusetts who, in 1806, sheltered from a storm and prayed about sending missionaries. The story is well known in American mission history, though historians disagree about how much it should carry. After about 1800, a "monthly concert of prayer for missions" was common in many churches.
Careful historians would add two other points. First, prayer was not the only cause. Politics, trade, travel and the growth of empires all shaped the mission movement, and a number of missionaries were closely tied to colonial powers. Many Christians, including many mission historians, now see this entanglement as a serious problem, and it should not be hidden behind the word "prayer". Second, people on the receiving end were not passive. In many places the faith was carried forward mainly by local believers who prayed, taught and translated in their own languages, and who are often missing from the old reports.
For a reader today, the practical point is modest. A mission that is prayed for is not thereby a good mission. The prayer needs to be matched with honesty, humility and care for the people it speaks about. Still, the habit of praying regularly for people far away is an old one, and it is worth recovering. It trains the person who prays to look beyond their own life.
4. Songs as prayer: the spirituals
Now move to a different place and a different history. In the American South, enslaved people created a large body of religious songs, now called spirituals. They were sung at worship, in the fields, in the home and in gatherings away from the eyes of those who held them. After the end of slavery, in 1865, groups such as the Fisk Jubilee Singers, who began touring in the 1870s, brought them to wide audiences.
We should be careful with generalisations. Enslaved Christians were not one community. They prayed in many ways, in different regions, in different churches, and in different languages and dialects. Much of what we know of their songs was written down by outsiders, sometimes long afterwards. So the following statements are about the songs that survive, and not about everyone's inner life.
With that limit stated, three things can be said.
- Many spirituals are prayers. They speak to God, directly or in the form of a story told to God. Some lament ("Nobody knows the trouble I've seen" is the title of a well-known one). Some ask for deliverance. Some give thanks, or rest in a hope beyond present suffering.
- They are prayer in the body. Singing together, with clapping, movement and the call-and-response of a leader and a group, makes the prayer a shared act. Nobody prays alone.
- They show that prayer can be a way of staying human. In a system that denied the dignity of enslaved people, to pray was to say, before God, who one was.
Scholars disagree about one popular claim: that certain songs were secret codes giving directions to escape. Some songs may have carried such messages on particular occasions. Others do not seem to have. The honest answer is that the evidence is limited, and no one should teach it as settled. What is not in doubt is the plain religious content of the songs, which stands without the codes.
There is also something here for readers who were not shaped by this history. Listen to the lament in them before you listen to anything else. They are one of the church's great examples of prayer that does not hide pain, which is the same thing the Psalms of lament teach (lecture 1-4).
5. Strength and risk: what happens when prayer becomes intense
Every revival prays with strong feeling: tears, loud voices, long meetings, a sense that God is very near. This was true in the eighteenth century and it has been true since. Is that a good thing or a bad one?
Here, as elsewhere, honest people disagree, and each side has a reason.
Those who value emotional intensity point out that Scripture is full of it. The Psalms weep and shout and dance. In Acts the place where the believers prayed "was shaken" (Acts 4:31). A prayer that never moves the feelings, they say, may not have reached the person. They also note that people who are poor, or not trained to read, often find that prayer with the whole body and voice is the form that is open to them.
Those who are cautious are not against feeling. They are worried about what happens when feeling becomes the test. In the same decade that revival swept parts of New England, Charles Chauncy, a Boston minister, wrote against what he saw as excess, arguing that strong emotion is not proof that God is at work. His book was published in 1743.
Edwards, the great defender of the revival, agreed with part of this. In 1741 he wrote The Distinguishing Marks of a Work of the Spirit of God, and in 1746 A Treatise Concerning Religious Affections. He argued that strong feeling is not in itself a sign of grace, because it can be stirred up by many causes. What matters, he said, is what the feeling produces over time in a person's life. Do they become more humble, more loving, more patient, more careful with other people? That is a test you can apply to your own praying without needing anyone else's opinion.
That gives us a way to state the strengths and risks fairly:
| Gift of intense, shared prayer | Risk of intense, shared prayer |
|---|---|
| Breaks the wall of politeness; people are honest about need | Strong feeling can be mistaken for the proof that God is present |
| Joins a crowd into one voice | Quiet people, or those who are tired or ill, can feel left out or judged |
| Opens prayer to people with little formal training | A leader can steer the feeling, and people can feel pressure to show it |
| Gives energy to long, hard work | The energy can fade, and the person may feel that God has left |
The right response to the table is not to pick one column. A healthy community can welcome the gift and watch for the risk. Edwards' test helps: the fruit over the years is a better guide than the temperature of one evening.
6. What a reader may take from this
You do not need to join a revival to learn from one. Four small steps come from this lecture.
- Pray at an agreed time with others. Choose one person or a small group and agree to pray at the same time on the same day, even from different places.
- Pray for something beyond yourself. A country, a mission, a people group, a neighbourhood. Keep a short list. Pray for the people, not only for the outcome you hope for.
- Pray a prayer that asks for what the situation needs, as Acts 4 does. Notice how often you ask for the threat to go, and how seldom you ask for courage to walk through it.
- Test intense experiences by their fruit. If an evening of strong prayer is followed by more patience and more care, that is a good sign. If it is followed by pride or by contempt for others, ask a trusted pastor or friend to help you look at it.
Someone who is tired, ill, grieving or shy is not praying less well than the person who weeps and shouts. Intensity is one form of prayer. It is not the measure of any.
Diagram 1. Prayer that travels, and what to watch
In short
- The prayer of Acts 4 is said together, and it asks for boldness to continue, not for the threat to be removed.
- A concert of prayer joined many people in many places at one agreed time, for a shared request, and it was open to ordinary believers.
- Prayer helped to shape the mission movement, but it was not the only cause, and mission was often tied to political power.
- The spirituals are prayers in song, many of them laments, and the claim that they were secret codes is disputed.
- Intense shared prayer brings honesty and energy, and also risks pressure and the mistaking of feeling for proof.
- Edwards advised judging strong feeling by its fruit over time, not by how strong it felt.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Concert of prayer | Many believers in many places agree to pray at the same time for a shared request, such as revival. |
| What Acts 4 asks for | Boldness to keep speaking, not the removal of the threat. |
| The spirituals | Songs of enslaved African Americans, many of them prayers of lament, hope or thanks, sung together. |
| Edwards' test of intense feeling | Look at its fruit over time: humility, love and patience, not the strength of the feeling itself. |
One sentence to remember Prayer travels well when it is shared, agreed in advance and aimed beyond ourselves, and strong feeling is judged by what it produces.
This week's action Ask one person to pray with you for the same request at the same time on one day this week, from wherever you are.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- The group in Acts 4 prayed for boldness rather than for the threats to end. What do you usually ask for when you are afraid? What would change if you asked for what Acts 4 asks for?
- A concert of prayer asks people to pray at the same hour for the same thing. What would it cost you to join one, and what might you gain?
- Why is it not enough to say "prayer started the mission movement"? What else was at work, and why should a reader know it?
- The spirituals pray from inside suffering. What can a person who is not suffering learn from them, and what should such a person be careful not to claim?
- Edwards said to judge strong feeling by its fruit over time. Think of a time of strong prayer in your life. What did it produce afterwards?
- How can a community welcome emotional prayer without making quieter people feel that their prayer is less?