Lecture 4-3: The Twentieth Century: Many Streams
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: How Scripture Shows Us Prayer
- Lecture 1-2: The Early Church at Prayer
- Lecture 1-3: The Desert and the Monastery
- Lecture 1-4: Praying the Psalms with the Church
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: The Lord's Prayer, Slowly
- Lecture 2-1: The Eastern Way: The Jesus Prayer and the Quiet
- Lecture 2-2: The Western Middle Ages: Hours and Holy Reading
- Lecture 2-3: The Mystics and the Dark Nights
- Lecture 2-4: Praying with Mary and the Saints?
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Holy Reading
- Lecture 3-1: Luther and Calvin at Prayer
- Lecture 3-2: Common Prayer, Quiet Gatherings, and the Examen
- Lecture 3-3: Puritans, Pietists, Moravians, Wesley
- Lecture 3-4: Brother Lawrence and Prayer in Daily Work
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Praying with a Frame
- Lecture 4-1: Revival and Mission
- Lecture 4-2: Prayer in Korea and Elsewhere
- Lecture 4-3: The Twentieth Century: Many Streams
- Lecture 4-4: Disagreements in Today's Praying
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: A Daily Rhythm
- Lecture 5-1: A Map of Prayer
- Lecture 5-2: Asking, Answers, and Unanswered Prayer
- Lecture 5-3: Dryness, Distraction and Silence
- Lecture 5-4: Praying Together
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: A Prayer Log and a Prayer Partner
In the twentieth century the ways of praying that earlier chapters described did not disappear. They met each other. A Catholic could read an Orthodox book on prayer. A Protestant pastor could spend a week with monks. A student in one country could sing a chant written in another. At the same time, new streams of prayer opened, and some of them grew very quickly.
This lecture follows six streams in outline: Pentecostal prayer, Catholic liturgical renewal, Orthodox communities moving abroad, the community of Taizé, Dietrich Bonhoeffer's teaching on the Psalms, and Thomas Merton with the beginnings of centering prayer. It does not try to cover the century. It does not rank the streams. It asks of each: what was the gift, and what can a reader of any tradition try?
The theology of the Holy Spirit and of spiritual gifts belongs to a later course, Systematic Theology VI: Pneumatology (ST6E). Here we say only how each tradition understands its own prayer.
What these 22 minutes give you
- Describe in outline how Pentecostal and charismatic communities understand prayer, in their own terms.
- Explain what the Catholic liturgical renewal wanted for lay people's prayer.
- Say how the Jesus Prayer and Orthodox prayer became known beyond Orthodox communities.
- Describe the way of praying at Taizé and the reason for its short repeated chants.
- Summarise Bonhoeffer's reason for praying the Psalms, and name where centering prayer began.
Now when the day of Pentecost had come, they were all with one accord in one place." — Acts 2:1
World English Bible
They were all filled with the Holy Spirit, and began to speak with other languages, as the Spirit gave them the ability to speak." — Acts 2:4
WEB
Your word is a lamp to my feet, and a light for my path." — Psalm 119:105
WEB
In the same way, the Spirit also helps our weaknesses, for we don’t know how to pray as we ought. But the Spirit himself makes intercession for us with groanings which can’t be uttered." — Romans 8:26
WEB
He who searches the hearts knows what is on the Spirit’s mind, because he makes intercession for the saints according to God." — Romans 8:27
WEB
Acts 2 stands behind the Pentecostal stream, which sees in it a pattern for the church's life and prayer. The verse from Psalm 119 praises God's word as a guide, and Bonhoeffer asked his students to pray with the Psalms as a school of prayer. Romans 8:26-27 speaks of the Spirit helping us pray when we do not know how, and it is read by several of the streams in this lecture, in different ways.
1. Pentecostal prayer
The Pentecostal movement is usually dated from the early years of the twentieth century. A well-known early centre was a gathering on Azusa Street in Los Angeles, which began in 1906 under the leadership of William J. Seymour, a Black preacher, and drew people of many backgrounds. From there, and from other places at about the same time, the movement spread widely and quickly. It is now present on every inhabited continent and takes many forms.
Pentecostal and charismatic Christians understand prayer in the light of Acts 2, where the Spirit comes on the believers at Pentecost and they speak in other languages. They do not all say the same thing, but several features are common.
- Prayer expects God to act and to be present now. The believer is not only remembering what God did long ago. Many Pentecostal prayer meetings expect healing, guidance or a word from God during the meeting.
- Prayer is often spoken aloud and together, with the body involved: raised hands, kneeling, movement.
- Some believers pray in tongues. This is understood as a prayer language given by the Spirit, which may be used in private prayer and, in some settings, in the gathered church. Those who hold this view point to Romans 8:26-27 and to 1 Corinthians 14:14-15.
- Prayer is shared by the whole body. Laypeople lay hands on each other and pray for one another, and the prayer of the community does not depend on the clergy alone.
- "Tarrying" is an older Pentecostal word for waiting on God in prayer, sometimes for a long time, for an experience of the Spirit.
From the late 1960s a related movement, often called the charismatic renewal, appeared in the Catholic Church and in many Protestant and Anglican churches. It carried some of these practices, especially praying aloud in a group, praise and prayer for healing, into traditions that had not used them before. In each tradition people understood and regulated it differently.
Other Christians hold other views about the gifts of the Spirit, and some of the questions are discussed in lecture 4-4. For now it is enough to say that people on every side agree about this much: Pentecostal prayer is not a mere style. For those who pray this way, it is a way of asking, listening and depending on the Spirit.
2. Catholic liturgical renewal and the hours for the laity
In the nineteenth and twentieth centuries, a Catholic movement for liturgical renewal sought to help ordinary people take a fuller, more understanding part in the church's public worship, which in the Roman rite had long been in Latin, and in which many lay people took a quiet part. The Second Vatican Council, which met from 1962 to 1965, approved a document on the in 1963. It encouraged the use of local languages and a more active participation of the people.
For prayer, one result was a stronger invitation to lay Catholics to join in the Liturgy of the Hours, the cycle of morning, evening and other prayers built from the Psalms (lecture 2-2), which had been prayed mainly by priests, monks and nuns. The prayer book for the hours was revised after the council. Today in many places parishes pray morning or evening prayer together, and many lay people use a shorter book or an app for their own use.
Why does this matter beyond the Catholic Church? Because it shows a movement that took an ancient practice, the prayer of the Psalms at set hours, and asked how ordinary working people could share it. The Anglican tradition's Book of Common Prayer (lecture 3-2) had done something similar in its own way four centuries earlier. The Catholic renewal also did not stop all discussion. Within the Catholic Church, and between Catholics and others, there are different views about how the liturgy should be celebrated, and this lecture does not take a side.
3. Orthodox communities abroad
In the twentieth century, especially after the revolution of 1917 in Russia and later after wars and political changes in other countries, many Orthodox Christians left their homelands. They settled in Western Europe, North America and Australia and built parishes there. Teachers and writers from these communities, working in places such as Paris, helped Western readers to meet Orthodox prayer.
One book played a particular part. The Way of a Pilgrim is a Russian work of the nineteenth century, an account of a wanderer who learns to pray the Jesus Prayer (lecture 2-1). Its English translation appeared in 1930 and has been read by many Christians who were not Orthodox. Another work, the Philokalia, a collection of Eastern writings on prayer from many centuries, was translated into English in the second half of the twentieth century. Through such books, and through the parishes and monasteries that welcomed visitors, the Jesus Prayer became known to many Western Christians.
Orthodox teachers have often added a caution, and it is worth hearing. They stress that the Jesus Prayer belongs inside the life of the Church: its services, its fasts, its confession and its guidance by an experienced spiritual father or mother. A person who takes only the short prayer, without the rest, may take something very different from what the tradition means. A reader who is not Orthodox can respect that caution and can still learn from the tradition in a modest way, as lecture 2-1 suggested.
4. Taizé
Taizé is a village in Burgundy, France. In 1940 a young Swiss Protestant, Roger Schütz, known as Brother Roger, settled there. A community of brothers grew up over the following years, with members from Protestant and Catholic backgrounds and from several countries. Over the second half of the century Taizé became a place where a great many young people from many countries came to spend a week praying, singing and sharing in simple work.
The prayer at Taizé is distinctive. It is built from a few simple parts:
- Short sung chants, repeated many times. The words are brief, often a line from Scripture or a short prayer, and are sung in many languages. Many were written by the composer Jacques Berthier. Repetition is meant to let the words settle, so that the singer can pray without having to think about what comes next.
- Scripture read aloud, and silence. After a reading there is a period of silence, usually some minutes, which anyone may use as they wish.
- A simple, welcoming setting. Candles and low light, no complicated order of service, and a place open to people who are not sure what they believe.
The gift of Taizé is that it makes group prayer available to people who find words difficult. A guest who does not know the language can still sing a chant after a few repetitions. A guest who has no faith, or has little, can sit in silence without being asked to say anything. The tradition also asks a good question of louder forms of prayer: what if prayer needed fewer words?
A fair note on limits. Taizé is a particular kind of community, with a rhythm designed for a week away. A person who tries to take it into daily life will need to adapt. And some Christians would want more explicit teaching than Taizé's quiet manner gives. These are differences of emphasis. The chants themselves are now sung in many parishes of many traditions, and can be used on any day.
5. Bonhoeffer and the Psalms
Dietrich Bonhoeffer (1906-1945), a German Lutheran pastor and theologian, led a seminary for the Confessing Church, a church group that opposed Nazi control, at Finkenwalde in the 1930s. The authorities closed it. He wrote two short books from that period which are still read today for what they say about prayer. One, Life Together (1939), describes how a Christian community lives with daily prayer and Scripture. The other, The Prayerbook of the Bible, was published in 1940. It is a small book on the Psalms.
Bonhoeffer's argument can be put in simple terms. We do not know how to pray, as Paul says (Romans 8:26). The Psalms give us words. And in the Psalms we pray together with Christ, who, as the church has always read them, prayed these same Psalms himself. So when we pray a lament, we do not have to find our own words for suffering. We join our voice to the voice of Christ and of the church. When we pray a psalm of praise, we may be praising before we feel like it, because the words carry us.
This connects the lecture back to the roots of the course. His view is close to that of the earlier teachers who held the Psalms to be the church's prayer book (lecture 1-4). He was executed in 1945, for his part in resistance to the Nazi government. The praying of Psalms that he taught was, for him and for his students, a way of praying in times of great danger. For us, it is a reminder that the most ordinary tool of prayer, a Psalm read slowly, has been enough in the hardest times.
6. Merton and the first steps of centering prayer
Thomas Merton (1915-1968) was a Trappist monk of the Abbey of Gethsemani in Kentucky. His writings, including Seeds of Contemplation (1949) and a later, rewritten version, New Seeds of Contemplation (1962), brought the old Christian tradition of contemplative prayer to a wide readership beyond the monastery. They drew on the desert fathers, the medieval mystics (lecture 2-3), and the idea that prayer could be a simple resting in God without many words.
In the 1970s, some Trappist monks in the United States, among them Thomas Keating at a monastery in Massachusetts, worked out a method of prayer drawn from this tradition, in particular from The Cloud of Unknowing (lecture 2-3). They offered it to lay people, and it came to be called centering prayer. It uses a single word chosen by the person praying, as a sign of their willingness to be with God. When the mind wanders, the person gently returns to the word.
Centering prayer is welcomed by many, and questioned by some. That discussion belongs to lecture 4-4, and nothing in this lecture requires you to take up the practice. It is described here, in outline, because it is part of the century's story.
7. What the six streams have in common
Look for a moment at what these streams share, while remembering that they are different from each other and that a neat summary can hide this.
- Each one began as a response to a felt need: a desire for the Spirit's presence, for a share in public worship, for roots in an older tradition, for simplicity, for the Psalms, for silence.
- Each one gave lay people a part. None of them was meant only for specialists.
- Each one drew on an older practice and recast it, rather than inventing from nothing.
- Each one has its own cautions. Pentecostal, Catholic, Orthodox, Protestant and monastic writers all warn about the misuse of their own practice.
If this seems too neat, it is partly because of how the lecture has been arranged. The six streams were chosen because they are well known and well documented, and many others (for example, Pentecostal and independent churches in Africa, Asia and Latin America) could have been chosen. The century's prayer was more varied than any list.
Diagram 1. Six streams of the twentieth century
In short
- Pentecostal and charismatic prayer expects God to act now and is often aloud, together and with the body. Some pray in tongues, which that tradition understands as a prayer language.
- The Catholic liturgical renewal invited lay people to share in the Psalms at set hours, which had been prayed mainly by clergy and religious.
- Orthodox communities abroad, and books such as The Way of a Pilgrim, made the Jesus Prayer known beyond the Orthodox world. Orthodox teachers add that it belongs within the Church's life.
- Taizé uses short repeated chants, silence and a simple welcome, making group prayer open to those who find words hard.
- Bonhoeffer taught that in the Psalms we pray together with Christ and the church, and that the Psalms give us words when we have none.
- Centering prayer was shaped in the 1970s by Trappist monks, drawing on the older contemplative tradition, and it is discussed further in lecture 4-4.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Pentecostal prayer | Expects God to act now; often aloud, together and bodily; some pray in tongues, which that tradition understands as a prayer language. |
| Liturgy of the Hours for lay people | The Psalms prayed at set hours, opened to all after the Second Vatican Council. |
| Taizé | A community in France whose prayer is made of short repeated chants, Scripture and silence. |
| Bonhoeffer on the Psalms | In the Psalms we pray with Christ and the church, and they give us words when we have none. |
One sentence to remember The twentieth century gave the church many streams of prayer, each born from a need, and each can teach us one small step.
This week's action Choose one stream you know least and read or listen to a short, fair description of it from someone who practises it.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Which of the six streams is closest to the way your own community prays? Which is furthest?
- Orthodox teachers warn that the Jesus Prayer belongs inside the life of the Church. What is the value of such a warning for a visitor to any tradition?
- Taizé uses repetition and silence to make group prayer open to people who find words difficult. Who in your community might find that helpful?
- Bonhoeffer says that in the Psalms we pray with Christ. What difference could that make when you pray a lament?
- The lecture says it chose six streams that are well known and well documented, and that others could have been chosen. Which stream, in your region, would you add?
- Each stream grew from a felt need. What need do you feel in your own prayer at present, and which stream seems to speak to it?