Lecture 5-2: Asking, Answers, and Unanswered Prayer
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: How Scripture Shows Us Prayer
- Lecture 1-2: The Early Church at Prayer
- Lecture 1-3: The Desert and the Monastery
- Lecture 1-4: Praying the Psalms with the Church
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: The Lord's Prayer, Slowly
- Lecture 2-1: The Eastern Way: The Jesus Prayer and the Quiet
- Lecture 2-2: The Western Middle Ages: Hours and Holy Reading
- Lecture 2-3: The Mystics and the Dark Nights
- Lecture 2-4: Praying with Mary and the Saints?
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Holy Reading
- Lecture 3-1: Luther and Calvin at Prayer
- Lecture 3-2: Common Prayer, Quiet Gatherings, and the Examen
- Lecture 3-3: Puritans, Pietists, Moravians, Wesley
- Lecture 3-4: Brother Lawrence and Prayer in Daily Work
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Praying with a Frame
- Lecture 4-1: Revival and Mission
- Lecture 4-2: Prayer in Korea and Elsewhere
- Lecture 4-3: The Twentieth Century: Many Streams
- Lecture 4-4: Disagreements in Today's Praying
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: A Daily Rhythm
- Lecture 5-1: A Map of Prayer
- Lecture 5-2: Asking, Answers, and Unanswered Prayer
- Lecture 5-3: Dryness, Distraction and Silence
- Lecture 5-4: Praying Together
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: A Prayer Log and a Prayer Partner
Almost everyone who prays asks for something. Almost everyone who asks has, at some time, not received it. This is the place where prayer is most tender, and where careless teaching has done the most harm.
This lecture does three things. First, it looks at how Christians have practised asking: keeping lists, naming people, and protecting the stories of others. Second, it sets out, fairly, the different ways Christian traditions understand what an "answer" is. Third, it speaks honestly about the times when no answer comes, and about praying for healing, where prayer and medical care belong together.
It does not promise results, and it does not say that a person's faith decides the outcome. Neither of those is in the Scriptures this lecture reads.
What these 23 minutes give you
- Describe two or three practical ways of keeping intercession (lists, names, set times) and the care owed to other people's stories.
- State fairly at least three ways in which Christians understand answers to prayer.
- Explain why an unanswered prayer must never be blamed on the weakness of the person who prayed.
- Explain why prayer for healing and medical care are not opposed.
In nothing be anxious, but in everything, by prayer and petition with thanksgiving, let your requests be made known to God." — Philippians 4:6
World English Bible
Concerning this thing, I begged the Lord three times that it might depart from me. He has said to me, “My grace is sufficient for you, for my power is made perfect in weakness.” Most gladly therefore I will rather glory in my weaknesses, that the power of Christ may rest on me." — 2 Corinthians 12:8-9
WEB
Is any among you suffering? Let him pray. Is any cheerful? Let him sing praises. Is any among you sick? Let him call for the elders of the assembly, and let them pray over him, anointing him with oil in the name of the Lord, and the prayer of faith will heal him who is sick, and the Lord will raise him up. If he has committed sins, he will be forgiven." — James 5:13-15
WEB
Confess your offenses to one another, and pray for one another, that you may be healed. The insistent prayer of a righteous person is powerfully effective." — James 5:16
WEB
Philippians invites us to bring our requests. Paul's own prayer about his "thorn" went unanswered in the way he first asked. James speaks of prayer for the sick. All three belong to the same Bible, and a teaching that uses only one of them will mislead.
1. Asking is an invitation
Paul does not say to ask only for large and holy things. He says that in everything we may make our requests known to God. Christians have taken this to mean that a request for a safe journey, a quiet night or a hard exam is not too small to bring. The Lord's Prayer itself asks for bread.
Asking also has a shape. In the Lord's Prayer, requests come after the address to the Father and after the prayer that his name be honoured and his kingdom come. Some teachers have read this as an order of attention: first look at God, then at my needs. Others have simply noticed that the prayer asks for both. Either way, the Lord's Prayer shows that request is welcome and that it sits inside a bigger conversation.
2. Keeping a list of those you pray for
The church has long prayed for others, and many believers have found it hard to remember. Several practical habits are common.
A written list. A notebook or a card with names, kept in a place where you pray. Some people divide the names across the days of the week, so that each person is remembered once a week and the list does not become a burden.
A pattern of circles. Family, then friends and neighbours, then church, then the town or country, then the world. Some people pray for one circle each day.
A set time. Intercession often survives better when it is tied to something already regular: after a meal, on a walk, before sleep. Lecture 4-5 considered how to build a rhythm around a real schedule.
A short form. A single sentence per person, "Lord, be with Tomas today," is often better than a long prayer that is hard to keep up. Quantity of words has never been the measure of intercession.
A worked example. Here is a week-card of the kind many people use. Names are invented.
| Day | Who | One sentence |
|---|---|---|
| Monday | Family | Lord, keep each of them in your care. |
| Tuesday | Neighbours | Lord, bless the family next door. |
| Wednesday | My church | Lord, strengthen the leaders and the new members. |
| Thursday | Those who are ill | Lord, be near those who are in pain tonight. |
| Friday | My town | Lord, help those who have no work or no home. |
| Saturday | The world | Lord, bring peace where there is fighting. |
| Sunday | Thanks | Lord, thank you for the answers I have seen. |
3. Other people's stories are not yours to tell
Intercession puts us close to other people's sorrows. A friend tells you her husband is ill and asks you to pray. If you then say to the whole group, "Please pray for her husband, he has cancer," you may have shared something she meant for you alone.
Here are some simple guards that many small groups and churches have adopted.
- Ask first. "May I ask others to pray for this?" A yes can be limited: "only the prayer team," or "only first names."
- Pray without the details. "Lord, be with Anna's family this week" is a full prayer. God already knows the details. Nothing is lost if the group does not.
- Do not pass on a request as news. Prayer requests can become gossip with a pious label. If you would not say it outside the prayer meeting, think before saying it inside.
- Keep silence about what you were told in confidence, including what was told to your pastor.
- Never share the story of a child, or of someone who has been harmed, without the clear permission of those who are responsible for them.
None of these makes prayer weaker. They protect the person who trusted you.
4. What is an "answer"?
Christians agree that God hears prayer. They explain in several ways what it means for a prayer to be answered, and it is worth stating each fairly.
The answer is the thing asked for, given. Many believers keep records of requests granted and give thanks for them. The Scriptures contain many such stories, and this view takes them at face value. The strength of this view is its simplicity and its gratitude. Its danger, if held alone, is that it can make unanswered prayer look like a failure of the person praying.
The answer is "yes," "no" or "wait." This is a popular and often helpful way of speaking. It reminds us that silence from God may not be absence. Its limit is that it can sound tidy when someone is in pain, and "no" can sound cold if offered too quickly to a person who is grieving.
The answer is God himself, and a closer walk, more than the thing asked. Many mystics and pastors have said that prayer changes the person who prays and draws them nearer to God. Paul's "thorn" is often read this way: the thorn stayed, and Christ's grace was given in its place. This view has comforted many people. Its danger is that it may be used to excuse a refusal to help someone, or to tell a suffering person that they should be satisfied.
God's purposes are settled, and prayer is a way we are brought into them. Some Christians, including many in the Reformed tradition, emphasise God's sovereign care of all things and see prayer as a means God uses, which also teaches trust.
God truly responds, and what happens can depend on whether we ask. Some Christians emphasise that God acts in response to the prayers of his people, and take James' words about the powerful effect of a righteous person's insistent prayer at their plain sense.
It is a mystery. Many Christians of every tradition hold that these emphases cannot all be reconciled in this life, and that it is better to pray, give thanks, and not claim to know how God's care and our prayers fit together.
You do not have to choose among these to take this course. You do need to avoid the two mistakes that appear at the edges: the belief that prayer is a machine that delivers results, and the belief that prayer does nothing.
5. When no answer comes
Sooner or later most people pray hard for something and it does not happen. A parent does not recover. A marriage ends. A job is not found. The first thing to say is plain: the lack of an answer is not a verdict on the person who prayed.
Here are some things that are said to the person in that place and that this course asks you never to say.
- "You did not have enough faith."
- "There must be sin in your life."
- "God needed another angel."
- "Everything happens for a reason."
- "You should be grateful it was not worse."
Each of these may be said with kindness. Each has hurt people. None of them is taught in the passages we have read. Paul asked three times, with a man's whole heart, and the thorn stayed. Nobody in the letter says he had too little faith.
What can be said? Often, less. "I am so sorry." "I am here." "I will pray for you, and I will also bring you a meal." A friend sitting beside you is a better answer to many griefs than an explanation. The Psalms give words for this place too, and lecture 6-3 returns to them.
For the person who is praying, some honest steps may help:
- Say it to God plainly. Lament is allowed (lecture 5-1).
- Keep asking, if you can, and also rest. Jesus told a story that we should pray and not give up (Luke 18:1). This is a story about persistence, not a promise about outcomes, and it does not forbid rest.
- Look for what is still being given. This is not a duty to feel better. It is an invitation to notice, when you are able.
- Do not carry it alone. Tell a pastor, a priest, a friend or a counsellor.
6. Praying for healing
This is a point where readers will not agree. Christians hold differing views about prayer for the sick, and each view has serious roots.
Catholic and Orthodox Christians have a sacramental practice, the anointing of the sick, which draws on the passage in James 5 and is offered to those who are seriously ill. Many Anglican and some Lutheran and other churches have rites of anointing or laying on of hands. Pentecostal and charismatic Christians pray for healing in the expectation that God heals today and may do so in the moment, and many testify to experiences of it. Many Reformed and other Christians pray for the sick with confidence in God's power while stressing that God heals as he chooses, often through ordinary means, and that he sometimes does not heal in this life. Some Christians hold that miraculous healing was given for the early church and is not to be expected on demand; others disagree strongly.
Stories of healing are gifts to those who tell them, but they must never be used to pressure a sick person to stop treatment or to suggest that the one who is not healed has done something wrong. Each of these positions, at its best, prays with love for the sick. The Pentecostal is trying to take James seriously. The Reformed is trying to take Paul's thorn seriously. The Catholic and Orthodox are trying to honour the practice of the whole church across time. Each worries about something real: a lack of expectation, a promise God has not made, or a loss of the church's inherited practice.
What does this course require? Less than any of them. Three things:
- Do not set prayer against medicine. James says to call for the elders. Nothing in the passage says to refuse a physician. Christians have run hospitals and cared for the sick for many centuries, and Paul's friend Luke is called a physician. A person who is ill should pray and see a doctor, take the treatment, and follow medical advice. Prayer is never a reason to stop treatment, to delay emergency care, or to refuse medicine for a child. The same is true of illness of the mind: anxiety, depression and trauma are health conditions, and praying about them goes together with seeing a doctor or counsellor. If you think someone is in danger now, call your local emergency number.
- Do not put the outcome on the person's faith. If someone is healed, give thanks. If someone is not healed, do not say they lacked faith. The same James passage mentions sins being forgiven, but it nowhere says that every illness is caused by sin, and it does not say that a death means a failure of prayer.
- Accept that sincere believers will pray differently. If your community prays for healing in a way you find uncomfortable, or does not do so in a way you would expect, you may ask questions kindly. You do not need to condemn them.
An invented example
(an invented example) Ravi has a serious illness. His church prays for him by name each Sunday. A friend visits and tells him, "If you had more faith, you would be well." Ravi goes home upset. A week later another friend, Nadia, visits, brings a meal, drives him to his treatment and says, "I do not understand why this is happening, but I am praying and I am here." Ravi says Nadia's visit was what he needed. The prayer of both friends was sincere; only one of them added a burden.
7. Asking in a way that is honest
A final practical word. When you ask, ask what you actually want. Some people feel they must pray only polished, holy requests. The Psalms are not polished. Paul said he "begged." You may tell God that you are afraid, that you want the test result to be good, that you wish the problem would go away. After that, many Christians have followed the pattern of Jesus in Gethsemane, adding, in their own words, a willingness to accept what God wills. That is not required in every prayer, and it is never a way of pretending you do not mind. It is a form of trust that people reach in different ways and at different speeds.
Diagram 1. A week-card for intercession, and four guards for other people's stories
Diagram 2. Six ways of speaking about answers
| View | What it stresses | Its gift | Its risk if held alone |
|---|---|---|---|
| The thing asked, given | God acts in response | Gratitude, expectation | Blames the one who did not receive |
| Yes, no or wait | God's reply may be hidden | A simple picture | Sounds tidy in pain |
| God himself is the answer | Nearness and grace | Comfort in loss | Excuses refusing to help |
| Purposes settled; prayer joins them | God's care of all things | Trust | Can seem to make prayer pointless |
| God responds to our asking | Prayer matters | Courage to ask | Can turn into a technique |
| A mystery | Humility | Honesty | Can become an excuse not to think |
In short
- Asking is welcome. Paul invites us to make our requests known to God, and the Lord's Prayer itself asks for bread.
- Intercession can be kept with a written list, circles of people, a set time, or one short sentence for each person.
- Other people's stories are not ours to tell. Ask first, pray without details, and do not pass requests on as news.
- Christians understand answers in several ways, and each view has a gift and a risk; this course does not require choosing one.
- An unanswered prayer is never a verdict on the faith of the one who prayed, and Paul's own prayer about his thorn was not granted as he asked.
- Prayer for healing and medical care belong together; prayer never replaces treatment or emergency help.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Ways to keep intercession | A written list, circles of people, a set time, a short sentence for each person. |
| Care for others' stories | Ask first; pray without details; do not pass requests on as news; protect children and the harmed. |
| When no answer comes | It is not a verdict on the one who prayed; never say "you lacked faith." |
| Healing and medicine | Pray and see a doctor; prayer never replaces treatment. |
One sentence to remember Asking is welcome, an answer is not a reward for good praying, and the lack of one is never a punishment.
This week's action Make a one-week intercession card with one sentence per day, and before you share anyone's story with another person, ask permission.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Which of the habits for keeping intercession (a list, circles, a set time, a short form) could you try? What would make it easier to keep?
- Why is it a form of care to pray "Lord, be with Anna's family" without the details? When would you ask permission before sharing?
- Which of the six views of answers is closest to what you were taught? Which is furthest? What might a person who holds the one furthest from yours say in its defence?
- Why does this lecture forbid saying "you did not have enough faith" to someone whose prayer was not answered? What passage supports that?
- How would you speak to a friend who says that praying is enough and they will not see a doctor?