Lecture 4-2: Prayer in Korea and Elsewhere
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: How Scripture Shows Us Prayer
- Lecture 1-2: The Early Church at Prayer
- Lecture 1-3: The Desert and the Monastery
- Lecture 1-4: Praying the Psalms with the Church
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: The Lord's Prayer, Slowly
- Lecture 2-1: The Eastern Way: The Jesus Prayer and the Quiet
- Lecture 2-2: The Western Middle Ages: Hours and Holy Reading
- Lecture 2-3: The Mystics and the Dark Nights
- Lecture 2-4: Praying with Mary and the Saints?
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Holy Reading
- Lecture 3-1: Luther and Calvin at Prayer
- Lecture 3-2: Common Prayer, Quiet Gatherings, and the Examen
- Lecture 3-3: Puritans, Pietists, Moravians, Wesley
- Lecture 3-4: Brother Lawrence and Prayer in Daily Work
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Praying with a Frame
- Lecture 4-1: Revival and Mission
- Lecture 4-2: Prayer in Korea and Elsewhere
- Lecture 4-3: The Twentieth Century: Many Streams
- Lecture 4-4: Disagreements in Today's Praying
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: A Daily Rhythm
- Lecture 5-1: A Map of Prayer
- Lecture 5-2: Asking, Answers, and Unanswered Prayer
- Lecture 5-3: Dryness, Distraction and Silence
- Lecture 5-4: Praying Together
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: A Prayer Log and a Prayer Partner
Many Christians around the world have heard of Korean prayer: early-morning prayer meetings, a whole room praying aloud at once, all-night prayer, and prayer on a mountain. Some admire it. Some find it hard to understand. Some have only seen it in a short film. This lecture tries to explain it fairly, as the people who practise it would, and then places it beside forms of prayer in other parts of the world.
The lecture has a second purpose. It asks what we can learn from one region's way of praying without turning that way into a rule for everyone. A form of prayer may carry great gifts. It may also carry costs for certain people. A form of prayer is never the measure of anyone's faith.
This is a lecture about prayer, not about Korean church history. The history of the Korean church belongs to the church-history courses. Here we take only what we need to see how prayer took its shape.
What these 21 minutes give you
- Describe the Pyongyang revival of 1907 and the practice of praying aloud together, without claiming more than the sources allow.
- Explain what dawn prayer, all-night prayer and mountain prayer are, and what the people who practise them say they are for.
- State fairly the gifts and the risks of these forms.
- Explain why a form of prayer is not a measure of faith, and name groups of people who cannot always take part.
- Describe, in outline and without stereotype, one or two prayer practices from other regions.
Early in the morning, while it was still dark, he rose up and went out, and departed into a deserted place, and prayed there." — Mark 1:35
World English Bible
Yahweh, in the morning you shall hear my voice. In the morning I will lay my requests before you, and will watch expectantly." — Psalm 5:3
WEB
My soul longs for the Lord more than watchmen long for the morning; more than watchmen for the morning." — Psalm 130:6
WEB
The first verse shows Jesus praying early, in a quiet place, before the day made demands on him. The second is a psalm of the morning. The third is a psalm of waiting through the night for the morning to come. Early prayer and night prayer are both in Scripture. That fact does not settle any question about how a church should pray today, but it explains why these forms feel natural to many readers.
1. A short note on method
Anyone writing about the prayer of a whole country risks two mistakes. One is to treat the most visible form as the only form. Not every Korean Christian prays aloud with others, rises before dawn or goes up a mountain. Korean Catholics, Orthodox and Protestants of many kinds pray in different ways, and many individuals pray quietly and alone. The other mistake is to treat a form as foreign or strange because it is unfamiliar. Every community's prayer looks odd to someone from outside.
So this lecture describes what is common and well known, says what is uncertain, and does not claim that these forms stand for a whole nation.
2. The winter of 1907
In January 1907 a large gathering of Christians took place in the city of Pyongyang, now in North Korea, during a period of Bible study that was held each winter. Missionaries and Korean church leaders who were present wrote accounts, and these have been read and discussed ever since. Gil Seon-ju, a Korean church , is one of the leaders most often named. In the accounts, people confessed wrongdoing in public, wept and prayed. A feature that many of the reports describe is that large numbers of people prayed aloud at the same moment, each in their own words.
This way of praying is often called, in Korean, tongseong gido, which can be put into English as "praying aloud together". It should be said at once that historians do not agree on the exact origin of the practice. Some believe the 1907 gathering was a turning point. Others say it was already growing in Korean churches before that, and that the revival gave it a lasting place. What is not in doubt is that this form became a familiar part of Korean church life.
Two honest remarks about the sources. First, the accounts came from people who wrote in the language and framework of their time, and some were written to encourage readers abroad. A careful reader keeps that in mind. Second, the same accounts also record that the events were met with questions, even by some missionaries, about whether the feeling was healthy. We saw the same debate in lecture 4-1.
What does the practice mean to those who take part? Several things are usually said.
- Everyone prays at once, so nobody is a spectator. A person who is shy of being heard by the room is hidden among the other voices. A person who has no gift for speaking in front of others is still praying fully.
- The prayer is shared but not uniform. Each person speaks their own need. The room has one sound, and inside it a thousand private requests.
- It is prayer of the body. Voice, breath and sometimes tears are part of it. For people who have little education, or who live with hardship, this can be the form that is easiest to enter.
- It echoes Acts. Many point to Acts 4, where the believers lifted their voice "with one accord", as the pattern.
3. Dawn prayer
Dawn prayer, in Korean saebyeok gido, is a meeting held very early in the morning, often before sunrise, in the church building. It is common in Korean churches, in Korea and among Korean communities abroad, and in some other places where the practice has been adopted. A service may include a short reading of Scripture, a brief message and a time of prayer, sometimes aloud together.
Tradition links the beginning of the practice with early leaders of the Korean church, among them Gil Seon-ju. Writers differ on how, and exactly when, it became a regular church-wide custom, and this lecture does not give a date. What matters for a reader is what it is for.
Those who value it say it gives the first part of the day to God before work, family and worry begin. They also say the church that gets up together gets to know one another. The pattern echoes Mark 1:35 and Psalm 5:3. For the poor and for those who work long hours, it can be one of the few times when the day is not already spoken for.
4. All-night prayer and mountain prayer
All-night prayer, in Korean cheolya gido, is a gathering that lasts through the night. Many churches hold such gatherings on a weekly or occasional basis, often on a Friday evening, and sometimes for a special need or season. Those who take part speak of the freedom of a long, unrushed time with God, and of the sense of keeping watch together, as in Psalm 130:6. Jesus is said to have spent a night in prayer before choosing his twelve apostles (Luke 6:12).
Mountain prayer means going to a mountain, often to a prayer retreat house that has been built for the purpose, to pray for a day, several days or longer. Some people go alone and some in groups. The mountain is a place of quiet away from the city's noise. Jesus also went up a mountain to pray (Matthew 14:23). Some writers note that going to mountains for religious purposes has a long history in Korean culture before Christianity arrived, and they ask how Christians should think about that. Different Korean Christians answer that question differently, and this lecture will not answer it for them.
5. Other regions, in outline
Korea is one place among many where prayer has taken a local shape. A short survey cannot be fair to any of them, and one example never describes a continent. Here are only a few, to show that the picture is wide.
- Catholic communities in Latin America and the Philippines have a rich tradition of the novena, a prayer repeated over nine days, of the rosary said at home or in the street, and of processions and prayer at shrines. These forms involve the family and the neighbourhood, and not only the church building.
- The Ethiopian Orthodox Church has a long tradition of set prayers, fasts and standing in worship, with its own music and language of the church. It is one of the oldest Christian traditions in Africa. (Fasting belongs to a later course, and a Rule of Life (LM107E), and it carries health risks for some people.)
- Churches in many parts of Africa hold night vigils, in which people pray, sing and sometimes testify through the night. These happen in churches of several traditions and are not limited to any single one.
- Christians in India of the Syriac tradition, some of whom trace their faith to ancient times, have kept a pattern of set prayers through the day in a language related to the one Jesus spoke.
These are brief sketches. If one of them is your own tradition, you know more than this lecture can say, and you should treat the lecture as incomplete.
6. Form of prayer: a point on which readers will not agree
This is a point where readers will not agree.
Some Christians hold that forms like aloud-together prayer, dawn prayer, all-night prayer and prayer on mountains are strong gifts to the church, and that other churches could learn from them. Their reasons are the ones above: they draw ordinary believers in, they put the first hours of the day under God, they give time that is long and unhurried, and they echo the pattern of Scripture. They add that critics sometimes mistake an unfamiliar form for an empty one, or compare it with their own at its best and with the other at its worst.
Other Christians, including many in Korea, raise real concerns. A room in which everyone prays aloud may overwhelm a person who needs quiet or who is sensitive to noise. Dawn prayer is hard to attend for someone who works a night shift, who cares for a sick child or an elderly parent, who is ill, or who lives far from the church. All-night prayer may be too much for the old and for those who need regular sleep. A form that is held up as a sign of serious faith can, without anyone intending it, press people to take part for the sake of being seen. Jesus' warning in Matthew 6:5-6 about praying to be seen by others is relevant here, and so is his advice about the private room.
Each side has a real point. The first sees what the forms give. The second sees what the forms can cost, and for whom.
What does this course require? Less than either side asks. It requires that you do not treat any form of prayer as the measure of faith. A person who prays quietly at home for ten minutes, a night-shift nurse who says a short prayer between patients, a mother who prays while a baby sleeps, and a man who prays aloud on a mountain all pray. None is the model for the rest. It also requires that you do not condemn those who cannot take part, and that you do not condemn those who can. And it requires that you name the risks and the gifts of any form you adopt, and keep the stop-sign in view: you may leave, you may sit quietly, and you may pray in another way.
7. A practical question for every community
If your church has a form of prayer that takes a lot of time or energy, ask three questions of it.
- Who is in the room, and who is missing? If the missing are shift workers, carers, the sick or the old, ask whether there is another time or another way for them.
- Does anyone feel judged for not coming? If yes, say clearly, from the front, that attending is a gift and not a test.
- Is there a quiet option? A silent corner, a shorter slot, a written prayer to take home.
These questions do not weaken a strong practice. They protect the people it is meant to serve.
8. What a reader may take from this
You do not need to move to Korea, or rise at four o'clock, to learn from these forms. Here are four things you can take.
- Give the first minutes of your day to God before the day's demands arrive. If your "dawn" is eleven at night because you work through the night, then let your "dawn" be the first quiet minutes after you wake.
- Try praying aloud, by yourself, for a few minutes, if you normally pray silently. Notice whether it helps you stay attentive. If it does not help, stop. Nothing is lost.
- Set aside one longer stretch when you can, an hour, a day, a retreat, even if not a whole night. A long time gives prayer room to change its pace.
- Hold your own form lightly. Whatever your habit is, remember that another person's habit may be as honest as yours.
Diagram 1. Forms of prayer, and who they may leave out
In short
- In 1907 a large Bible gathering in Pyongyang became known for public confession and for many people praying aloud together. Historians disagree about where the practice began.
- Dawn prayer, all-night prayer and mountain prayer are well-known Korean forms, each with gifts that those who practise them describe.
- Other regions have their own shapes of prayer, such as novenas, vigils and set hours, and one example never describes a whole continent.
- These forms carry gifts and risks, and the risks fall most often on shift workers, carers, the sick and the old.
- A form of prayer is not a measure of faith. Do not condemn those who cannot take part, or those who can.
- A community can ask who is missing, whether anyone feels judged, and whether there is a quiet option.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Tongseong gido | Praying aloud together, each person in their own words, at the same moment. |
| Dawn prayer and all-night prayer | Early-morning and overnight meetings, valued for giving time to God and for the shared watch. |
| Who may be unable to take part | Shift workers, carers, the sick, the old, and those who need quiet. |
| The rule for any form | A form of prayer is a gift, never a measure of faith. |
One sentence to remember A form of prayer can carry great gifts and real costs, and it should never be used to measure anyone's faith.
This week's action Choose one of the three questions (who is missing, who feels judged, is there a quiet option) and ask it about a prayer meeting you know.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Why is it important to say what is uncertain about the origin of praying aloud together or of dawn prayer, instead of giving a simple story?
- Which of the four forms in the diagram is closest to the way you pray now? Which is furthest? What might you learn from the furthest?
- Who in your own community cannot attend the main prayer meeting? What could be done so that they are not left out or made to feel they have failed?
- Jesus prayed early in a quiet place (Mark 1:35) and also told his followers to pray in a private room (Matthew 6:6). How might those two pictures help a community that has both loud and quiet pray-ers?
- Think of another region's way of praying. What does it give, and what might it cost? How do you know what you know about it?
- How can someone adopt a practice from another tradition without either copying it blindly or dismissing it?