FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

PT725E Understanding Mental Health for Church Leaders: Noticing, Staying Beside, Connecting

Lecture 4-4: Confidentiality and Consent in General Terms

Contents 31
PT725E Understanding Mental Health for Church Leaders: Noticing, Staying Beside, Connecting
Chapter 0 · Introduction: Notice, Stay, Connect
  1. Lecture 0: Introduction: Notice, Stay, Connect
Chapter 1 · Week 1: The Church, Mental Health and the Leader's Place
  1. Lecture 1-1: Two Mistakes in the Church's Story
  2. Lecture 1-2: Stigma: Words, Looks and Silence
  3. Lecture 1-3: Prayer and Treatment Do Not Replace Each Other
  4. Lecture 1-4: The Leader's Place: Notice, Stay, Connect
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: What We Say About Mental Health
Chapter 2 · Week 2: Noticing
  1. Lecture 2-1: Noticing Is Not Diagnosing
  2. Lecture 2-2: Low Mood and Anxiety at a General Level
  3. Lecture 2-3: After a Shock: Reactions and Sleep
  4. Lecture 2-4: Eating Struggles and the Body
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Observe, Ask, Connect
Chapter 3 · Week 3: Other Kinds of Difficulty
  1. Lecture 3-1: Swings of Mood and Unusual Experiences
  2. Lecture 3-2: Attention, Learning and Memory
  3. Lecture 3-3: Spiritual Language and Medical Language
  4. Lecture 3-4: When Prayer Will Not Come: Guilt, Doubt and Darkness
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Caring Spiritually and Connecting Medically
Chapter 4 · Week 4: Staying Beside and Connecting
  1. Lecture 4-1: The First Conversation
  2. Lecture 4-2: Connecting to Professionals
  3. Lecture 4-3: Beside Someone Who Is Getting Help
  4. Lecture 4-4: Confidentiality and Consent in General Terms
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: A First Conversation and a Referral
Chapter 5 · Week 5: Families, Carers and the Leader's Own Mind
  1. Lecture 5-1: Families and Carers
  2. Lecture 5-2: The Leader's Own Mind
  3. Lecture 5-3: Burnout, Rest and Limits
  4. Lecture 5-4: When the Struggling Person Is a Fellow Leader
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: My Limits and a Question for a Colleague
Chapter 6 · Week 6: A Congregation Friendlier to Mental Health
  1. Lecture 6-1: Words, Preaching and Prayer
  2. Lecture 6-2: Small Groups and Gatherings
  3. Lecture 6-3: Access: Space, Time, Cost and Language
  4. Lecture 6-4: Systems and Many Contexts
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab: A One-Page Mental Health Care Policy

Jump to the key points ↓

30 min

A member of a small congregation tells her pastor something painful, and asks him not to tell anyone. The next Sunday another member says to the pastor, "I hear that she is not well. Is it true?" A care team of five volunteers is told by one of them about a person they are all visiting, and by evening the details are in a group message with sixty people in it. A staff member at a non-profit tells her manager of a struggle, and the manager is not sure whether she is allowed to keep it from the director. A person asks a leader, "If I tell you something, will you promise to keep it secret?" In every one of these a question of confidence is at stake, and in every one of them the answer is not simple.

This lecture is about confidentiality and consent, in general terms only. It does not give law. It does not say what any country, church, agency or profession requires. The rules differ greatly by country, by region, by role and by tradition, and a leader must find out the ones that apply: check locally. What this lecture gives is the principles that serve a leader almost everywhere: why trust matters, why a leader never promises absolute secrecy, how to ask for consent, what a narrow, honest sharing looks like, and what to do about the few cases where danger or duty means information must pass on. The deeper principles belong to the course on counselling ethics, confidentiality and referral, and this lecture does not replace that course.

The central claim to which every week returns is this: a church leader is not a diagnostician but someone who notices, stays beside, and connects. Prayer does not replace treatment, and treatment does not replace faith. The leader has a mind and limits too, and receives help. To stay beside someone, a leader must be safe to tell.

This course is not medical or psychological advice, not legal advice and not a guide to any rule or duty, and it does not replace professional care or proper advice about the law. Where this lecture says "check locally," it means that someone who knows your place must be asked.

What these 30 minutes give you

  • Explain why a leader's trustworthiness is central to care, and why gossip does harm even when it is dressed as a prayer request.
  • Explain why a leader never promises absolute secrecy, and say a sentence that is honest instead.
  • Describe consent in plain terms: asking who, what, why and for how long, and treating consent as something the person may withdraw.
  • Describe, in general terms, the kinds of situation in which information may have to pass on, and what a leader does about them.
  • Name the everyday places where confidence is lost, such as group messages, notes, prayer lists and conversations between leaders, and say how to guard them.

One who brings gossip betrays a confidence, but one who is of a trustworthy spirit is one who keeps a secret." — Proverbs 11:13

World English Bible

He who goes about as a tale-bearer reveals secrets; therefore don’t keep company with him who opens wide his lips." — Proverbs 20:19

WEB

But let your ‘Yes’ be ‘Yes’ and your ‘No’ be ‘No.’ Whatever is more than these is of the evil one." — Matthew 5:37

WEB

Therefore putting away falsehood, speak truth each one with his neighbor. For we are members of one another." — Ephesians 4:25

WEB

The way of a fool is right in his own eyes, but he who is wise listens to counsel." — Proverbs 12:15

WEB

each of you not just looking to his own things, but each of you also to the things of others." — Philippians 2:4

WEB

Bear one another’s burdens, and so fulfill the law of Christ." — Galatians 6:2

WEB

Proverbs knows the harm of the tale-bearer who reveals secrets, and the worth of one of a trustworthy spirit who keeps a confidence. Jesus asks that a person's "Yes" be "Yes" and "No" be "No", which for a leader means saying only what can honestly be kept. Paul asks the church to put away falsehood and to speak truth, each with their neighbour, because we are members of one another. These pull in two directions at once: keep what is trusted, and do not lie. A leader who promises more than can be kept breaks both. Paul also asks each person to look not only to their own things but to the things of others, and says to bear one another's burdens. A leader's care for a person's privacy is a form of that love.

1. Why trust matters

A person who is struggling in mind or mood often carries shame, and is deciding, sometimes for a long time, whether anyone can be told. If a leader proves safe, the person may say more, accept help sooner, and come back. If a leader proves unsafe, even once, the person is likely to stop speaking to anyone in the church. And word travels. A congregation in which a story has been passed along teaches everyone that it is not safe to be honest.

This is why the book of Proverbs treats the keeping of a confidence as a sign of character: "one who is of a trustworthy spirit is one who keeps a secret" (Proverbs 11:13). The tale-bearer is to be avoided (Proverbs 20:19). A leader who wants to care for people must first be someone people can tell.

2. Gossip dressed as prayer

The commonest breach of confidence in a church is not malice. It is a request for prayer.

"Please pray for Rosa; she is going through a terrible time with her nerves." "Let me tell you so that you can pray for him." "I'm only sharing so that we can help." These may be said with love, and may sound pious. But if the person has not agreed to be named and described, the sharing is a breach, and it is a breach carried out in the name of care. The person may find out and feel betrayed by the very people who prayed.

The simple rule is this: a prayer request about another person's struggle belongs to that person to give. Ask them what may be said, to whom, and in what words. If they say "just say I need prayer", that is all that is said. If they say "please do not say anything", nothing is said, and the leader can still pray quietly alone. A leader can also say, in public, "If you would like prayer, you can ask me or anyone on the care team," which invites without exposing anyone.

3. Never promise absolute secrecy

Sooner or later someone will say, "Promise you won't tell anyone." The temptation is strong to say "I promise", because it seems the loving thing to say, and because the person is frightened. Do not.

There are three reasons.

  1. You may not be able to keep it. There are situations, discussed below, in which a leader may have a duty, or may in conscience feel bound, to pass something on. A promise of absolute secrecy would then be broken, and the person would feel betrayed at the worst moment.
  2. It is not honest. Jesus's words about "Yes" and "No" (Matthew 5:37) and Paul's about speaking truth (Ephesians 4:25) apply to a promise too. Do not say what you may not be able to do.
  3. It can trap the leader. A leader who has promised and then learns of danger faces a terrible choice, and may stay silent when speaking was needed.

What can a leader say instead? Something like this, which echoes lecture 1-4:

"What you tell me matters to me and I will treat it with great care. I will not repeat it to anyone without talking to you about it first. There are a very few exceptions: if I thought that you or someone else was in danger, or if the law or my role required me to pass something on. The rules differ here, so I will find out what applies. If it ever came to that, I would tell you first wherever it was safe to."

That sentence is honest. It does not frighten the person away, because it gives a clear promise (to tell them first) and a clear limit. Many people find it easier to trust a leader who says where the limit is than one who promises everything.

If the person has already said something before the leader had a chance to say this, the leader may say it afterwards: "Before you go on, I should say clearly what I can promise and what I cannot," and then say it.

Consent in this lecture does not mean a legal document. It means asking the person, in plain words, before telling someone else, and respecting the answer. A good request for consent has four parts.

  • Who may know. "May I tell Pastor Elena?" (a named role, not "the leaders").
  • What may be said. "I would say only that you are going through a hard time and would value a visit; I would not say more." The narrower the better.
  • Why it would help. "She could arrange a lift to the appointment."
  • For how long. "Just for this week" or "until you tell me otherwise."

Then listen to the answer, and accept a "no". A person who says no today may say yes tomorrow.

Consent can be withdrawn. If the person says, "Please do not tell her any more," the leader says, "Of course," and does not.

Consent is specific. Permission to tell the pastor is not permission to tell the care team. Permission to tell the care team about a visit is not permission to say why.

Consent should be free. A person who feels they cannot say no, because a leader is powerful or because they are afraid of being thought difficult, has not freely consented. Make it easy to say no.

Where a person is very unwell and cannot decide, or is a child or young person, the position is not for a leader to settle alone. Others with proper responsibility, such as parents, guardians or professionals, are involved, and the rules differ locally. The course on safe church policy and child protection sets out what a community must do. Urgent danger means emergency services.

5. The few cases where information may have to pass on

This lecture does not list laws. It names the kinds of situation in which, in many places, a leader may have a duty or good reason to pass something on even without consent, so that the leader is ready and will not be surprised.

  • Danger to the person or to others. If a person is in danger now, or someone else is in danger from them, the first step is emergency services, and a leader stays with the person. The course on crisis, suicide and trauma response applies.
  • Harm to a child or a vulnerable person. Many places place duties on adults who learn of this. A community's safe church policy sets out what to do, and the proper authorities and not the leader investigate.
  • A legal duty. In some places and roles, the law requires certain information to be passed on, and a court or authority may require it. These rules differ greatly.
  • A professional or organisational rule. An employer, a mission agency or a non-profit may have its own rules about what a staff member must report.

In any of these, the leader does the following:

  1. Does not investigate or question the person to find out more than they have chosen to say.
  2. Tells the person first, wherever it is safe to, what is going to be passed on, to whom and why.
  3. Passes on only what is needed, to the proper person or authority, and not to the wider group.
  4. Stays beside the person afterwards. A person whose confidence has had to be broken needs a leader more, not less.
  5. Gets advice from someone who knows the local position, ideally before the situation arises.

A leader who does not know the local position should find it out now, not at the moment of crisis. Ask a trusted senior colleague, the church's or agency's policy, or an advisor who knows local rules, and write the answer where a care team can find it. This course cannot give it.

6. Traditions differ

Some traditions have a long and strong understanding of a seal of confession or of private spiritual conversation, and treat what is said in that setting as absolutely protected. Others have no such understanding, or view it differently. In some places the law recognises such protection for some roles and not for others, and the extent differs. In some settings, particularly mission agencies and non-profits, a staff member's conversation with a manager is not protected in the same way as a conversation with a pastor.

A leader should know, in advance and in writing: what their own tradition teaches about confidence, what the local law and any agency rules require, and what that means in practice. Do not assume that what you were taught in one place holds in another. For leaders who move between countries, this matters especially. Check locally.

7. Everyday places where confidence is lost

Most breaches are not dramatic. They happen in ordinary places.

Group messages. A message to a group goes to everyone in it, and can be forwarded. Do not put details of a person's struggle in a group message, even in a small group of trusted people, unless the person has agreed. A neutral line like "Please keep Thandi in your prayers" is not a neutral line if she did not wish it.

Prayer lists and bulletins. Name only what the person has agreed to name, in the words they have agreed. A vague line that everyone decodes ("pray for the Mwangi family at this time") may be a code for the very thing the person asked to keep private, as the Marlow Hill scene in lecture 1-5 showed.

Notes and records. Keep few. Write only what is needed, without diagnostic words or details of the person's story. Keep notes where others cannot read them: a locked drawer, or a protected file, not an open shared folder. Decide in advance how long to keep them, and who may see them. Local rules may say more (check locally).

Phones and devices. A phone left open on a table, a message on a locked screen, a family tablet with a shared account: all can reveal. Think before you text.

Conversations between leaders. Leaders talk with one another, and some talk is needed. But "sharing in order to pray" or "so that we are all informed" slides easily into gossip. Share only with those who need to know to help, only with consent, and say, "This is not to go beyond us."

Casual talk. At home, at a meal, with a spouse. A leader's family also hears things at the table. Do not tell them, even those you trust most, without the person's agreement.

Social media and photographs. Do not post about a person's struggle, or photographs taken at a time of difficulty, without clear consent. Even without a name, a post may be recognised.

8. Between a leader and a supervisor

A leader can and should talk about their work with someone, because carrying others' troubles alone is a danger to the leader (lecture 5-3). A conversation with a supervisor, a trusted senior colleague or a professional can be done without giving the person's name or details that would identify them. "I am caring for someone who is going through a hard time, and I am not sure how to go about it" is enough to get advice. Where that is not possible, ask the person's consent to speak with the supervisor. A good supervisor holds what they hear in confidence too.

9. Three examples

(an invented example) Tamarind Street Fellowship is a house church of eleven people, most of whom are related. A member, Lucia, tells the leader, Bayo, that she has been struggling, and asks him not to tell her cousin who is also in the group. Bayo says, "I will not repeat what you tell me without speaking to you first, apart from the rare cases of danger or duty. I will not tell your cousin." Later Bayo is at the cousin's house and the cousin asks, "Is Lucia all right?" Bayo says, "You could ask her yourself. She would like to hear you ask." He does not lie, and he does not say more. In a very small, related congregation, the honest sentence "that is for her to tell" protects the person without a falsehood.

(an invented example) St. Brannock's Church is a large congregation with a database of members that all staff can open. A pastoral assistant, Andile, records after a visit a line about what Mr. Okafor said of his health and of the treatment he has been given. The coordinator, Priyanka, sees this when a volunteer opens the file for another reason. She removes the entry and speaks to Andile kindly: "Let us write that we visited and what the next visit will be, and nothing about his health. If he wants more recorded, he can tell us." She then asks the staff to review who may open the files. Two lessons follow: a person's health, a label or a treatment should not appear in a general record, and in a large church, the system is part of the confidence.

(an invented example) A small non-profit that runs a night shelter has a policy. Any staff member who hears of a serious risk to anyone must tell the director the same day, and the director follows an agreed route. A volunteer, Mei, tells the manager, Dariusz, that she has been low for a long time and has been seeing a doctor. Dariusz says, "Thank you for telling me. I should tell you what I can and cannot keep private. The shelter's rule is that if I learn that anyone is at serious risk, I must tell the director. Otherwise this stays between us unless you want to share it. Would you like me to suggest lighter shifts for a while?" Mei decides what to share and what to ask. In an organisation with its own rules, the first act of confidence is to say what the rules are.

10. What to do when you are unsure

When a leader does not know whether to share or how, a safe pattern is:

  1. Pause. Do not decide in the middle of the conversation.
  2. Ask the person, if safe: "What would you like me to do with what you have told me?"
  3. Ask for advice without identifying the person, from a senior colleague, a policy or an advisor who knows the local position.
  4. If there is danger, act for safety first (emergency services), and sort out the rest afterwards.
  5. Write down what you did and why, briefly, in a safe place.

11. What a leader takes from this lecture

  1. Trust is the ground of care; a leader must be safe to tell.
  2. Gossip dressed as prayer is still a breach; a prayer request about a person's struggle is theirs to give.
  3. Never promise absolute secrecy; say instead what you will do, what the exceptions are, and that you will tell the person first wherever it is safe.
  4. Ask for consent: who, what, why, for how long; allow a "no"; allow withdrawal.
  5. Information may have to pass on where there is danger, harm to a child or vulnerable person, a legal duty or an organisational rule; do not investigate, tell the person first where safe, pass on only what is needed, stay beside.
  6. Know the local position in advance; check locally; traditions and agencies differ.
  7. Guard the ordinary places: group messages, prayer lists, notes, phones, conversations between leaders, social media.
  8. The deeper principles belong to the counselling ethics course; this lecture is not legal advice.

Diagram 1. What a leader says about confidentiality

What a leader says about confidentiality Honest, not absolute What I will do Treat what I am told with great care. Not repeat it without speaking to you first. The exceptions Danger to you or to someone else; harm to a child or vulnerable person; a legal duty or a rule of my role. The rules differ, so I will find out. If it comes to that I will tell you first wherever it is safe, pass on only what is needed, and stay beside you. Never Never promise absolute secrecy. Never gossip dressed as a prayer request.

Diagram 2. Where confidence is lost, and how to guard it

Where confidence is lost Ordinary places, not dramatic ones Messages and lists Group messages, prayer lists, bulletins, social media, photographs. Records and devices Notes, files, shared folders, open phones and screens. Talk Between leaders, at home, at meals, in "so that we can pray". How to guard them Ask who, what, why and for how long. Share the least needed. Keep little. Keep it where others cannot read it. Let the person withdraw consent.

In short

  • Trust is the ground of care; a leader must be safe to tell, and gossip dressed as a prayer request is still a breach.
  • A leader never promises absolute secrecy; the honest sentence promises to tell the person first and names the exceptions of danger, duty or role, and says the rules differ.
  • Consent means asking who may know, what may be said, why it would help and for how long; it can be refused and withdrawn.
  • Information may have to pass on where there is danger, harm to a child or vulnerable person, a legal duty or an agency rule; the leader does not investigate, tells the person first where safe, passes on only what is needed and stays beside.
  • Traditions, agencies and places differ; find out the local position in advance and write it down (check locally).
  • Guard everyday places: group messages, prayer lists, notes and records, phones, talk between leaders, social media.
  • The deeper principles belong to the counselling ethics course; this lecture is not legal advice and does not replace professional care.
Front Back
Honest sentence "I will not repeat what you tell me without speaking to you first, apart from danger or duty; the rules differ, so I will find out."
Consent Who, what, why, for how long; a "no" is accepted; consent can be withdrawn.
When information may pass on Danger, harm to a child or vulnerable person, a legal duty, an organisational rule; do not investigate; tell the person first where safe; pass on only what is needed.
Gossip dressed as prayer A prayer request about another's struggle belongs to that person to give.

One sentence to remember Promise what you can keep: to tell the person first, to share as little as needed, and to stay beside them.

This week's action Find out, and write down for your care team, what the local rules and your own church or agency require about information that may have to pass on, and who to ask if you are unsure. Do not write the answer here; write it where your team can find it.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • Think of a prayer request you have heard that said more than the person would have wished. How could it have been given differently?
  • Why does the course say never to promise absolute secrecy? What sentence will you use instead, in your own words?
  • In your community, where are the places where confidence is most easily lost: group messages, prayer lists, notes, meals at home? What one habit would you change?
  • What do you know, and what do you need to find out, about the local position on information that may have to pass on? Who could you ask?
  • Tamarind Street Fellowship is tiny and related, St. Brannock's Church is large with a database, and the shelter has its own rules. What is the first thing to put in order in your setting?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.