FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

PT710E Children's Ministry Foundations: Welcoming and Keeping Children Safe in the Church

Lecture 2-2: Safe People

Contents 31
PT710E Children's Ministry Foundations: Welcoming and Keeping Children Safe in the Church
Chapter 0 · Introduction: Welcoming Children, Not Minding Them
  1. Introduction: Welcoming Children, Not Minding Them
Chapter 1 · Week 1: The Place of Children's Ministry
  1. Lecture 1-1: More Than Minding Children
  2. Lecture 1-2: Many Shapes of Children's Ministry
  3. Lecture 1-3: Roles, Calling and Limits
  4. Lecture 1-4: What a Children's Ministry Is For
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: The Shape of Our Children's Ministry
Chapter 2 · Week 2: Safe Ministry
  1. Lecture 2-1: Why Safety Comes First
  2. Lecture 2-2: Safe People
  3. Lecture 2-3: Safe Places and Safe Routines
  4. Lecture 2-4: When You Are Worried
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: A Safety Walk Round One Room
Chapter 3 · Week 3: A Week of Children's Ministry
  1. Lecture 3-1: From Arrival to Going Home
  2. Lecture 3-2: Rooms, Spaces and Materials
  3. Lecture 3-3: Few Children, Mixed Ages
  4. Lecture 3-4: Choosing and Adapting Materials
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Our Hour on One Page
Chapter 4 · Week 4: Story and Worship
  1. Lecture 4-1: Telling a Bible Story to Children
  2. Lecture 4-2: Hard Stories
  3. Lecture 4-3: Praying, Singing and Worshipping With Children
  4. Lecture 4-4: Welcome Without Pressure
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Preparing One Story
Chapter 5 · Week 5: Behaviour and Care
  1. Lecture 5-1: Understanding Behaviour
  2. Lecture 5-2: Guiding Without Shame
  3. Lecture 5-3: Every Child Belongs
  4. Lecture 5-4: When a Child Is Struggling
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: The First Sentence in a Hard Moment
Chapter 6 · Week 6: Walking Together
  1. Lecture 6-1: Walking With Parents
  2. Lecture 6-2: Your Team of Helpers
  3. Lecture 6-3: Photographs, Records and Online
  4. Lecture 6-4: Looking Back Without Counting Heads
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab: A Review on One Page

Jump to the key points ↓

23 min

(An invented example.) A parish priest is short of helpers for the children’s class. A man who has been coming to the church for three weeks says he would love to help. He is friendly, he is good with the children, and he seems to need a place. The priest is tempted to say yes at once, because the need is real and the offer is kind. Another leader in the same parish, hearing of it, feels uneasy but cannot say why, and worries that it is unkind to ask questions of a person who has offered to help.

This lecture is about that moment. It asks how a community chooses the people who will be with its children. The answer has two sides that must be kept together. On one side, a community should not turn away willing helpers with cold suspicion. On the other side, a community must not set an unknown person alone with children because they are willing. The way between is a clear and fair process, the same for everyone, that a good person is glad to pass through.

This is not a legal manual. Laws about checks, references, training and reporting differ from country to country, and from one kind of community to another. This lecture gives the reasons and the habits, and tells you to follow your community’s written policy and local law for the details.

What these 23 minutes give you

  • Explain why helpers are chosen with care, and why willingness alone is not a qualification.
  • Name the steps a careful community may use (a recommendation, a conversation, checks, training, a first period alongside others).
  • Explain the two-adult principle and why it is a habit, not an accusation.
  • Say why teenage helpers are helpers and need supervision, and how to treat them fairly.
  • State fairly two views on how far to check a helper, and say what this course requires.

Defend the weak, the poor, and the fatherless. Maintain the rights of the poor and oppressed. Rescue the weak and needy. Deliver them out of the hand of the wicked.”" — Psalm 82:3-4

World English Bible

Let them also first be tested; then let them serve if they are blameless." — 1 Timothy 3:10

WEB

A prudent man sees danger, and hides himself; but the simple pass on, and suffer for it." — Proverbs 22:3

WEB

Psalm 82 speaks of the duty of those with power to protect the weak. First Timothy 3:10 is part of a passage about those who serve in the church as deacons; it shows that the early church did not set people to serve without first testing them. Proverbs 22:3 is the wisdom of looking ahead. None of the three is about children’s helpers in particular. Together they show a pattern the community has always known: serve with care, test before trust, and protect the weak.

1. Willingness is not a qualification

The first thing to say is a hard one for kind communities. A person’s willingness to help does not tell us whether that person is suitable. Most willing people are good people, and many of them are wonderful with children. But willingness is a fact about the person’s wish, and suitability is a fact about the person’s record, character and conduct. We cannot read the second from the first.

This matters because the people who most need to be stopped are not marked. A person who wishes to harm children does not look different. They are often warm, helpful, patient, and glad to give their time. A community that places people in its children’s work on warmth alone is relying on the one thing a harmful person can easily show.

None of this is a reason to treat every volunteer as a suspect. It is a reason to have a process, so that nobody has to rely on a feeling. The process takes the weight of the decision off the individual leader’s gut. It makes the decision fair, and it makes it repeatable. The kind priest in our opening story does not have to ask himself, "Do I trust this man?" He can ask, "What is our process for a new helper?" and give the same answer he would give to anyone.

2. The steps a careful community may use

Communities differ, and the steps they use differ with them. Here is the range, from the simple to the more thorough. A community may use some or all of them, and the community’s written policy and local law decide which are required.

A recommendation. Someone the community trusts speaks for the person: a pastor from the person’s previous congregation, a former employer, a person who has worked with them. A recommendation is stronger when the person who gives it is asked specific questions ("Have you seen this person with children? Is there anything we should know?") and not merely a general one ("Is he a good person?").

A conversation. A leader sits with the person and asks about their reasons, their experience, their faith and their way with children. This is not a test of faith. It is a way of getting to know someone, and of letting the person ask questions too. A good conversation also lets the person hear what the community expects of them.

Checks required by law or policy. In some countries, and for some roles, the law or the community’s insurer requires a formal check of a person’s record. In others, no such check exists or it is not available to a small church. This course does not say which applies where you are. It says: find out what your community’s policy and your local law require, and do it.

Training. A new helper should be told, before they start, how the group is run: the habits of this chapter, the community’s policy, whom to tell if they are worried. Training can be an hour with a leader. It need not be a course. What matters is that nobody learns the rules by breaking them.

A first period alongside others. A new helper begins in company, not alone. For a few weeks, they work next to an experienced helper. This serves two purposes: the new person learns the work, and the community sees how they are with the children over time. The text in 1 Timothy 3:10 describes this pattern in plain words: tested first, then serving.

These steps are not a barrier set up to keep people out. They are an invitation to be known. A person with nothing to hide, and who cares for children, usually welcomes being asked.

3. The same standard for everyone

A process works only if it is the same for everyone. This is the hardest part to keep.

The pastor’s nephew, the whose family has been in the church for three generations, the retired schoolteacher, the person who is always there: each is tempted to be treated as an exception. "Everyone knows Margaret. We don't need to ask her." (an invented example) But the community cannot use a different rule for the person it likes. A rule that applies to strangers and not to friends protects no one: it tells a harmful person where to stand.

The same standard also protects the helper. When everyone has been through the same steps, no one is singled out as "the one we checked". A new person who is asked to do what the pastor himself has done will feel included, not suspected.

The same standard extends to clergy and to people with authority. A title does not make a person safe, and no one should be above the community’s habits. In many traditions, this is a moment for humility: the one who leads is the first to follow the rule. If a leader says "I do not need to follow it," the community has learned something about its leader.

4. The two-adult principle

One habit appears in nearly every safety policy: no adult should be alone with a child, out of sight of others. It is often called the two-adult principle, and it takes slightly different forms in different places: two adults in a room, or one adult in a room with an open door and others nearby, or two unrelated adults present whenever a group of children is.

Why does it matter?

  • It protects the child, because a harmful act needs privacy.
  • It protects the adult, because a false or mistaken accusation needs privacy too, and the second adult can say what happened.
  • It supports the adult, because looking after a group of children alone is tiring, and a second pair of eyes helps.

Notice what the principle does not say. It does not say that two adults will always notice. It does not say that a pair cannot do wrong together. It is a habit that makes harm harder and makes honest work visible. The next lecture shows how the same idea works for places, with open doors and clear lines of sight.

In a small community, the principle needs some thought. When there is one helper and three children, and no other adult is free, the community has to decide: invite a second adult, move the group into the main hall, keep the door open with others nearby, or join two groups. Lecture 3-3 returns to this. The point for now is that a shortage of helpers is a reason to adapt the arrangement, never a reason to leave an adult alone with a child.

5. Teenage helpers are helpers

Many communities rely on teenagers to help with younger children. They are often energetic, funny, close in age to the children, and glad to be trusted. This is a real gift, and it is also an obligation.

A teenage helper is a helper, and so the same care applies. They are also a young person, and so they need care themselves. Three things follow.

First, a teenager should not be left in charge. Their place is beside an adult, not in place of one. They may lead a game or read a story, with an adult present.

Second, a teenager needs the same briefing as any other helper, in plain words that suit their age: what the habits are, and whom to tell if something troubles them.

Third, a teenager should be thanked, supported and protected. They are not free labour, and they should not be given more than they can bear. They have school, family and their own faith to grow in. A teenager who is asked to carry too much will leave, and may leave with a sour taste.

The age at which a young person may help, and the rules about their duties, differ by country and by community. Follow your written policy and local law.

6. This is a point where readers will not agree

This is a point where readers will not agree about how far a community should check a helper before the helper serves.

Some Christians, in many traditions, rely mainly on trust and recommendation. They say that the church is a family, that Jesus called us to receive people and not to screen them, and that asking for references and checks from a person who has offered their time is a cold way to treat a fellow believer. They fear that formal checks teach the community to look for risk before it looks for gifts, and that in small communities a formal process can feel like an insult to people who have been faithful for years. They also point out, rightly, that a formal check only finds those who have already been caught, and that a good community can often sense when something is wrong. This view often comes from a deep desire to be a place of welcome and grace.

Other Christians, in many traditions, favour a thorough process: references, an interview, official checks where they are available, training, and a trial period. They say that love for the weak is shown by taking trouble to protect them, that a community which fails a child fails them at the worst possible place, and that grace towards the helper does not require carelessness towards the child. They point out that the people who most need to be stopped often seek out trusting communities. They add that the process is fair to the helper, since it protects them from suspicion. This view often comes from a deep desire that no child will be harmed in the place that should have kept them safe.

Each of these views has a real concern behind it: welcome on one side, protection on the other. Each goes wrong in its own way if pressed too far. Trust without any process leaves the child exposed to the one person who hides well. A process without welcome can turn a church into an office and drive away the very people who would serve best.

What this course requires is less than either side asks, and it is firm: nobody unknown to the community is set alone with children, and the community follows its own written policy and local law. Beyond that, the community decides how many steps to use. A small house church that knows a person well may do a lot with a recommendation, a conversation and a first period alongside others. A large parish may need more. What the community must not do is leave the matter unwritten and unexamined, so that each leader decides case by case on feeling alone.

7. When someone is not suitable

Sometimes the process shows that a person should not work with children, or not yet. This is painful, and it needs to be done kindly.

Say it plainly and privately. Say that the decision follows the community’s process, which applies to everyone. Do not give details that would damage the person’s name. Where possible, offer another way to serve: with the adults, in the kitchen, at the door, or in prayer. A person who is turned away from one place can still be welcomed in many others.

Where there is a real concern, and not just a gap in the paperwork, the matter goes to the person responsible in the community and, as policy and law direct, to the proper authorities. The ordinary helper does not investigate. Lecture 2-4 covers what to do when you are worried.

8. In different kinds of community

In a large parish, the process may be run by a named coordinator or a safeguarding officer, with forms and a training evening. The risk is that the paperwork becomes the whole of the care, and nobody asks how the person is actually with the children.

In a small assembly, the process may be a conversation with the pastor and an elder, and the first few weeks beside someone experienced. The risk is that it is not written down, so the next leader does something different.

In an Orthodox or Catholic community with a long tradition of lay teachers, the process may include a conversation with the priest and a blessing before service. The risk is the same as everywhere else: the blessing is taken for the check.

In a house church with three children and one helper, the process may be as simple as this: two families who know each other agree on the habits, and a third adult is invited to attend. The principle is the same.


Diagram 1. The road a new helper walks

The Road a New Helper Walks The same road for everyone; the community's policy and local law set the exact steps 1. Offer A person says they would like to help 2. Recommend Someone trusted answers specific questions 3. Talk A conversation: reasons, experience, expectations 4. Check Whatever policy and local law require 5. Train The habits and whom to tell, before starting 6. A first period alongside an experienced helper Tested first, then serving. Never alone with children while still unknown to the community. Two adults Or one adult with open door and others near Teenage helpers Helpers beside an adult, never in charge alone Same standard for everyone, clergy and long-serving members included.

In short

  • Willingness is not a qualification; the people who most need stopping do not look different, so a community needs a process.
  • A careful process may include a recommendation, a conversation, checks the law and policy require, training, and a first period alongside others.
  • The same standard applies to everyone, including clergy and long-serving members; an exception tells a harmful person where to stand.
  • No adult is alone with a child out of sight of others; a shortage of helpers means changing the arrangement.
  • Teenage helpers are helpers and young people: beside an adult, briefed, thanked and not overloaded.
  • Readers disagree on how far to check; this course requires that nobody unknown is set alone with children.
Front Back
Why a process, not a feeling? Willingness shows a wish, not suitability, and a harmful person may look the warmest. A process is fair and repeatable.
The two-adult principle No adult alone with a child out of sight of others; it protects the child and the adult.
Teenage helpers They are helpers and young people: beside an adult, briefed, thanked, not overloaded.
What this course requires on checking Nobody unknown to the community is set alone with children; follow written policy and local law.

One sentence to remember Choose helpers by a fair process that is the same for everyone, because willingness shows a wish and not a record.

This week's action Find out what your community requires of a new helper, and write the steps on one page in the order they happen.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • Why is willingness a good sign about a person's heart but not a sign of their suitability for work with children?
  • Which of the five steps (recommendation, conversation, checks, training, first period alongside others) does your community already use? Which would be easiest to add?
  • Has anyone in your community been treated as an exception to a rule because everyone knows them? What does that teach a person who wants to avoid the rule?
  • How would you explain the two-adult principle to a helper who feels it shows distrust?
  • If you had only one helper and three children, what could you do to keep to the principle?
  • State the view that favours trust and recommendation, and the view that favours a thorough process, each as its supporters would. Which concern is the stronger in your own community, and why?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.