Lecture 6-4: Looking Back Without Counting Heads
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: More Than Minding Children
- Lecture 1-2: Many Shapes of Children's Ministry
- Lecture 1-3: Roles, Calling and Limits
- Lecture 1-4: What a Children's Ministry Is For
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: The Shape of Our Children's Ministry
- Lecture 2-1: Why Safety Comes First
- Lecture 2-2: Safe People
- Lecture 2-3: Safe Places and Safe Routines
- Lecture 2-4: When You Are Worried
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: A Safety Walk Round One Room
- Lecture 3-1: From Arrival to Going Home
- Lecture 3-2: Rooms, Spaces and Materials
- Lecture 3-3: Few Children, Mixed Ages
- Lecture 3-4: Choosing and Adapting Materials
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Our Hour on One Page
- Lecture 4-1: Telling a Bible Story to Children
- Lecture 4-2: Hard Stories
- Lecture 4-3: Praying, Singing and Worshipping With Children
- Lecture 4-4: Welcome Without Pressure
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Preparing One Story
- Lecture 5-1: Understanding Behaviour
- Lecture 5-2: Guiding Without Shame
- Lecture 5-3: Every Child Belongs
- Lecture 5-4: When a Child Is Struggling
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: The First Sentence in a Hard Moment
Every children's ministry looks back sooner or later. The question is whether it does so on purpose. A community that never looks back repeats the same hour for years, including the parts that do not work. A community that looks back only when the numbers fall, or when the committee asks, tends to look back in fear. Neither is the way to learn.
This lecture teaches a plain way of reviewing the work. It has one simple form, a small set of questions, an honest place for numbers and a firm limit on how much to change at one time. The limit is the most useful part: change at most three things.
The main idea comes from the central claim of this course. Children's ministry is not a time for minding children; it is the work of making a gathering in which children are welcomed, kept safe and given God's story, in step with their families. So the review asks about exactly these things, one by one. It does not first ask how many came.
What these 23 minutes give you
- State the questions of a review and explain why each follows from the purpose of the work.
- Explain how numbers can help a review, and how they can mislead it.
- Describe how a review can be held in a short meeting without judging any child or helper.
- Choose no more than three changes and name who will do them and when.
- Explain why a safety concern is never saved up for the review.
Which of you men, if you had one hundred sheep, and lost one of them, wouldn’t leave the ninety-nine in the wilderness, and go after the one that was lost, until he found it? When he has found it, he carries it on his shoulders, rejoicing. When he comes home, he calls together his friends and his neighbors, saying to them, ‘Rejoice with me, for I have found my sheep which was lost!’ I tell you that even so there will be more joy in heaven over one sinner who repents, than over ninety-nine righteous people who need no repentance." — Luke 15:4-7
World English Bible
Be careful that you don’t do your charitable giving before men, to be seen by them, or else you have no reward from your Father who is in heaven. Therefore when you do merciful deeds, don’t sound a trumpet before yourself, as the hypocrites do in the synagogues and in the streets, that they may get glory from men. Most certainly I tell you, they have received their reward. But when you do merciful deeds, don’t let your left hand know what your right hand does, so that your merciful deeds may be in secret, then your Father who sees in secret will reward you openly." — Matthew 6:1-4
WEB
The shepherd in Luke knows that there are a hundred, and also knows which one is not there. The count tells him something is wrong, and the name of the missing sheep tells him where to go. Matthew 6 is about giving to the poor, not about children, but its warning applies by comparison: work done for others should not be turned into a show. A review is for the children, and not for the applause of the congregation.
1. Why look back at all
A review does three things for a children's ministry.
It catches what is easy to miss. After the session, the team is tired. A child who sat alone, a door that was left open, a parent who looked displeased: each is gone from memory by the next week unless somebody asked.
It lets good things be named. A team that only notices problems gets discouraged. A team that says "Maria stayed with the newcomer for the whole hour" learns what to look for and does it again.
It keeps the work honest. The community can easily come to believe that the ministry is going well because it has always gone on. A review puts the question: is it going well for the children?
Notice what a review is not. It is not an inspection of individual helpers, which would damage the trust that the team needs. It is not an exercise to produce a report for the committee, although a short report may come from it. And it is not an occasion to find fault with the children.
2. The questions of a review
The questions follow the purpose of the work. There are six, and the first four are the heart.
1. Was each child welcomed? Think of the children one at a time, using first names in the meeting. Did every child have an adult who greeted them? Was any child alone, left out, or overlooked? Was a new child helped to find a place? Was a child who finds it hard to come made to feel that the door was open? Was a child's difference part of the ordinary picture (lecture 5-3)?
2. Was each child safe? Not only "did anything go wrong?" but "did the routines hold?" Were two adults always present? Was collection done as planned? Were allergies and medicines remembered? Did anyone have a near miss, something that could have gone wrong and did not? A near miss is a gift, because it shows a weakness before a child is hurt by it.
3. Was each child given the story? Did the children hear the Bible story told in a way they could take in? Did every child, including the quiet one and the one who needs more time, have a chance to respond? Was God at the centre of the telling, or did the hour drift into activities that had little to do with the story? (Chapter 4.)
4. Were the parents informed? Did parents hear what they needed to, the same day? Was a complaint answered? Was a worry shared with care? Did any parent not know what the group was doing (lecture 6-1)?
5. Were hard moments handled with respect? Was there a child who struggled this month? How was the moment met? Was there any shaming, any raised voice that should not have been, any case where a helper acted out of tiredness? Was the child left with their dignity? (Chapter 5.)
6. Were the helpers cared for? Did anyone work too many weeks without a break? Did a new helper have a steady partner? Did someone say thank you? Was anyone showing signs of weariness (lecture 6-2)?
These questions can be asked in any community. In a large parish with several groups, each group's team asks them for its own room, and the coordinator gathers the answers. In a small assembly with three children, they can be asked over a cup of tea in ten minutes. The size of the community changes the form. It does not change the questions.
3. Where numbers help and where they mislead
It is natural to want numbers. They are easy to write down, and they seem to answer the question how are we doing? In fact, numbers can help a review a little, and can mislead it a good deal.
Numbers that help include:
- Attendance by name. Who came, who did not, and for how long. A list of names tells you who is missing. A total tells you nothing about who.
- The number of helpers and how often each serves. It shows at once whether the load is shared.
- The number of near misses and accidents recorded. If the number is zero for a long time, ask whether things are not being written down.
- The time between a complaint and a reply.
Numbers that mislead include:
- A rise in attendance. It may mean that the children are well served. It may also mean that a more attractive programme has drawn them from another place, or that a school holiday ended.
- A fall in attendance. It may be a failure of welcome. It may also be that families moved, or a group of older children grew up, or a hard winter came.
- A comparison with another community. The size of a community's children's work depends on how many children live near it, what the families need and what other things are on offer. A small group that is doing its work well is not a failure.
- Any count made to impress. A figure prepared for a meeting, a report to a larger body or a newsletter tends, over time, to shape the work towards the figure. This is the warning of Matthew 6:1-4 by comparison: the aim is to be seen. Children are not a display of the community's success.
The rule that holds across all of these is this: a number is useful only if it leads to a name. The shepherd in Luke 15 counts, because the count shows that something is missing. But the count is not what he cares about. He goes after the one sheep. If the register shows that eleven children came last month and eight this month, the question is not "why has our attendance fallen?" but "which three are not here, and does anyone know why?" Perhaps a family moved. Perhaps a child was hurt by something. Perhaps no one rang to say they were missed.
(An invented example.) A small assembly meets in a rented hall. Four children come: Joy, Peter, Anna and Samuel. Over a term, Samuel stops coming. In the review, the helper Grace notices his name on the list and asks the others. Nobody knows. She decides to ask his mother how the family is, without pressing. His mother says that the Sunday morning has become difficult since her working hours changed, and that Samuel misses the group. The assembly arranges a short Saturday session once a month, and Samuel returns. A count of four, three, three would have said only that the numbers were low. The name led to a family and a change.
4. How to hold the meeting
The form of the review matters as much as the questions. Here is a simple way that suits most communities.
Hold it regularly and briefly. Once a term is a good rhythm for a full review, and thirty to sixty minutes is enough. A shorter version can follow each session, as lecture 6-2 describes.
Bring a small amount of material. The register by name, the accident and incident notes, any complaints and replies, and the helpers' rota. Nobody needs to prepare a report.
Start with the good. Ask each person to name one thing that went well. This sets the tone and also tells the team what to repeat.
Take the questions in order. Spend more time on the ones that need it.
Speak of children by first name, and of helpers without blame. The review is about what happened and what to do, not about who is at fault. A sentence such as "the door was left open" is better than "Tomas left the door open". If a pattern concerns one person's conduct, the person responsible speaks to that person privately and not in the meeting.
Keep the notes private. Write a short summary: what went well, what to change, who will do it. Do not put sensitive details about a child or family in a page that many people will read. Keep it with the other records (lecture 6-3).
Include the people who actually do the work. A review by a committee that does not enter the room misses what the helpers see. A review by helpers alone may miss the view of a parent or a minister. Where it can be done kindly, ask a parent or two, and in a liturgical community the priest or catechist, how it looks from their side. Use your discernment, and do not make any parent feel examined.
Ask the children, in a simple way. Children can tell you what they liked and what was hard if the question is easy to answer. "What was the best part? What did you not like?" A few minutes with a few children at the end of a session, or a drawing, tells the team a great deal. Do not press them, and do not make a child say something in front of others.
5. At most three changes
A good review produces a long list. Everyone has noticed something. The temptation is to write all of it down and begin on Monday. The result, usually, is that nothing is done, because a long list is a weight no one can lift.
So the rule: choose at most three changes. Here is how.
- Write down everything the review noticed. Don't edit yet.
- Put first anything about safety. A safety matter is not a candidate for the list; it is done at once and by the person responsible (see below).
- Of the rest, choose the three that matter most for the children. Ask: which will most help a child to be welcomed, safe or given the story? If two are equal, choose the easier.
- For each, name who will do it and by when. "We should improve the welcome" is a wish. "Rosa will greet each child by name at the door, starting this Sunday; Anil will check the new children's names on Friday" is a change.
- Keep the other items. They are not lost. Put them on a list for the next review.
- At the next review, begin by asking if the three were done. If they were, say so and give thanks. If they were not, ask why without blame: was the change too big, was the person overloaded, was it the wrong change?
Why three? Because a team that changes three things can remember them, practise them and feel the difference. A team that changes ten loses track of all of them. Because a child's week is shaped by small steady habits, and not by dramatic reforms. And because a review that ends with success, however small, makes the next review something the team looks forward to.
In a community of one or two helpers, the same rule applies. One change is also fine.
6. Safety is not saved for the review
One point must be very clear. A concern about a child's safety is never kept until the next review. If a helper sees a door left unlocked, a medicine not secured, an adult behaving in a way that troubles them, or hears something from a child, they tell the person responsible the same day, following the community's policy (lecture 2-4). The review is where the community looks at the patterns, such as the fourth missed collection check in a term. It is not where urgent matters wait their turn.
Equally, the review is not where an individual helper is judged for conduct. If a worry about a person has arisen, it is handled by the person responsible and the community's procedure, not in a team meeting.
7. In two kinds of community
A liturgical community with a priest, a catechist and a parish council may place the review within an existing structure: a meeting of catechists once a term, a report to the pastoral council. The danger is that the report becomes a set of figures. Keep it to the six questions and a short story. A free-church assembly may have no structure at all and rely on chat after the service. The danger there is that nothing is ever written, and the same difficulties return every year. Writing three lines after a review, and reading them next time, is enough.
Diagram 1. The review in one turn
In short
- A review catches what is easy to miss, lets good things be named and keeps the work honest. It is not an inspection of helpers or children.
- Ask six questions: was each child welcomed, safe, given the story; were parents informed; were hard moments met with respect; were helpers cared for?
- A number is useful only if it leads to a name; attendance by name helps, and comparisons and figures made to impress mislead.
- Hold the review regularly and briefly, begin with what went well, speak of children by first name and of helpers without blame.
- Choose at most three changes, each with a person and a date, and begin the next review by asking if they were done.
- A concern about a child's safety is never kept for the review; it goes the same day to the person responsible.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| The core questions | Was each child welcomed, safe and given the story, and were the parents informed? |
| Numbers and names | A number is useful only if it leads to a name; the shepherd counts in order to go after the one. |
| How many changes? | At most three, each with a person and a date; keep the rest for the next review. |
| Safety concerns | Never saved for the review: they go the same day to the person responsible. |
One sentence to remember Count if you must, but always ask who is missing.
This week's action Take your latest attendance list and, for each name that has not appeared lately, write down one kind way to find out how that child is.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- When did your children's ministry last look back on purpose? Who was in the room, and what changed because of it?
- Which of the six questions is hardest for your community to answer honestly? Why?
- What number does your community most often use to say whether the children's work is going well? What name could stand behind it?
- Is there a child whose name has been missing from the list for some time? Who could ask about the family, kindly?
- If your team could only change three things next term, what would they be? What would you leave for later?
- How can children be asked what they liked and what was hard, without pressing them?