Lecture 5-4: When a Child Is Struggling
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: More Than Minding Children
- Lecture 1-2: Many Shapes of Children's Ministry
- Lecture 1-3: Roles, Calling and Limits
- Lecture 1-4: What a Children's Ministry Is For
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: The Shape of Our Children's Ministry
- Lecture 2-1: Why Safety Comes First
- Lecture 2-2: Safe People
- Lecture 2-3: Safe Places and Safe Routines
- Lecture 2-4: When You Are Worried
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: A Safety Walk Round One Room
- Lecture 3-1: From Arrival to Going Home
- Lecture 3-2: Rooms, Spaces and Materials
- Lecture 3-3: Few Children, Mixed Ages
- Lecture 3-4: Choosing and Adapting Materials
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Our Hour on One Page
- Lecture 4-1: Telling a Bible Story to Children
- Lecture 4-2: Hard Stories
- Lecture 4-3: Praying, Singing and Worshipping With Children
- Lecture 4-4: Welcome Without Pressure
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Preparing One Story
- Lecture 5-1: Understanding Behaviour
- Lecture 5-2: Guiding Without Shame
- Lecture 5-3: Every Child Belongs
- Lecture 5-4: When a Child Is Struggling
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: The First Sentence in a Hard Moment
Some weeks a child simply is not herself. A girl who is usually chatty sits at the edge of the group and says nothing. A boy who loves the singing will not stand. A child comes in tired and stays tired, three weeks in a row, and ate nothing at the snack table as if it were the first food of the day. A child begins to cry when the door opens, and nobody can say why.
Lecture 5-1 taught us to read behaviour as a message. This lecture takes up the messages that are quiet and sad. Children go through grief, moves, family change, hunger, long tiredness and fear, as adults do, and they have fewer words for it. A children's worker is not the answer to any of these. But a children's worker is often the one adult outside the family who sees the child every week, and what that adult does in the room matters.
The posture of this lecture is the one the whole course uses for hard things: notice, stay, pass on. Notice that something is different. Stay with the child, calmly and kindly, without questions that press. Pass on what you have noticed to the person responsible, and let those with the right skills and standing take it further. The lecture does not teach methods of care, and it does not teach how to recognise harm. It teaches how to be a steady, safe adult for a child who is going through something.
What these 23 minutes give you
- Name some of the circumstances that can make a child struggle, and say why a children's worker does not question the child about home.
- Describe what a steady adult does for a child who is upset, without pressing.
- Give a short, honest answer to a child's question about death that does not frighten and does not lie.
- Explain why signs are not a diagnosis, and say what to do instead of naming a cause.
- State when to tell the person responsible, when the family should be told, and when to call the emergency number.
Yahweh is near to those who have a broken heart, and saves those who have a crushed spirit." — Psalm 34:18
World English Bible
When Jesus therefore saw her weeping, and the Jews weeping who came with her, he groaned in the spirit, and was troubled, and said, “Where have you laid him?” They told him, “Lord, come and see.” Jesus wept. The Jews therefore said, “See how much affection he had for him!”" — John 11:33-36
WEB
Rejoice with those who rejoice. Weep with those who weep." — Romans 12:15
WEB
The psalm speaks of God's nearness to the broken-hearted. John gives a scene in which Jesus, facing grief, is troubled and weeps, and the people who watch say what they see. Paul's short sentence, "Weep with those who weep", gives the helper's first task in a hard moment: to be with.
1. What children go through
Here are some of the things that can make a child struggle. The list is not complete, and a helper will usually know of only a few of them at any time.
- Grief. A grandparent, a parent, a sibling, a friend, a pet. Children grieve, often in short bursts that look like play, and then in sudden bursts of sadness at an odd moment.
- A move. A new home, a new school, a new country, the loss of a friend. The church may be the one place that has stayed the same.
- Change in the family. Parents separating, a new baby, a new partner, a parent leaving to work abroad, a parent who is ill or out of work. The child may be told little and understand a lot.
- Hunger and want. Some children come hungry, and some come in the same clothes every week. The reasons are the family's own business, and we notice and respond without questions and without embarrassing anyone.
- Tiredness. A child who stays up late because of a crowded home, a shift-working parent or a noisy night.
- Sadness and worry. A child may be low or anxious for reasons that nobody can name, perhaps for a long time.
- Illness, in the child or someone close.
- Fear, of something at school, of a person, of a place or of a thing that happened.
Notice two things. First, most of these are part of ordinary family life in every country, and a children's worker should not leap to the worst explanation. Second, a few are signs of something more serious, which the helper cannot judge from outside. The way of acting is the same for both: do not question; be steady; pass on.
2. Do not question the child about home
It is natural to want to know. The child is sad, and you would like to help, and the quickest way seems to be to ask: "What's wrong? Is something happening at home? Who made you sad?" Please do not.
There are four reasons.
First, a child who is pressed may say what the child does not mean, or may say less than is true, to please or to escape the adult. Children are quick to see what an adult hopes to hear.
Second, a question about home puts the child in the middle. The child may love someone who is the cause of the sadness. To speak against a parent, even gently, can feel like a betrayal, and a child may be punished at home for what is said at church.
Third, the helper is not trained to question. The people whose work it is to ask careful questions have training and standing. Questions asked by someone else, however kind, can make it harder for them later.
Fourth, it is not the helper's place to investigate the family. The ethic of this course is to notice and pass on; the helper is not a detective, a counsellor or a rescuer.
What can be said, then? Something simple and open, said once and not repeated. "You seem a bit quiet today. I'm glad you're here." Or: "I'm here if you want to tell me anything. You don't have to." If the child says nothing, that is an answer, and it is respected. If the child speaks, the helper listens, and then follows the guidance for a child who tells you something (lecture 2-4).
3. A steady adult
What does a struggling child need from the adult in the room? Mostly, a steady presence. The following habits give it.
Be calm. Your voice, your face and your hands tell the child whether the room is safe. If you are anxious, the child will catch it.
Be near. Sit beside the child, not facing; kneel to the child's level. Offer a hand or a place by you, and accept a "no".
Be ordinary. Keep the session as usual. A predictable hour is a gift to a child whose week has not been. Do not make a fuss that tells everyone the child is in trouble.
Offer something small and concrete. A drink of water. A job to do with the hands. A soft toy or a book. A place to sit near the door. A drawing. A walk to look at the garden with another adult near.
Don't force a feeling. Don't say, "Cheer up", or, "Be brave", or, "Big boys don't cry." Don't say, "You mustn't be sad because she's with God now." A child is allowed to be sad.
Name a feeling gently, if the child seems to want it. "It looks like today is a sad day." This helps some children and not others; watch the child's face.
Keep a few minutes at the end. A child may stay close at the end of the session. Do not hurry the child away to the door. Let the parent see a calm adult and a calm child.
Keep your own boundaries. You may hold a hand or sit beside a child, in the open, in line with the community's policy. You do not take the child aside to a private room, and you do not promise to keep a secret. You also do not take the child's burden home with you. Tell the person responsible and let it go.
John 11 shows what this looks like in a harder scene. Jesus meets Mary and the mourners and "groaned in the spirit, and was troubled". He asks where the dead man was laid, and he weeps. He does not hurry to a lesson. The onlookers say, "See how much affection he had for him!" The scene teaches that being moved and being present come before explanation. The helper's work is similar, though on a very different scale: to be with before saying anything.
4. Short, honest words about death
Sooner or later, in most children's groups, a child will ask about death. A pet dies, or a grandparent, or a child hears of a death in the news. A helper may be the first adult to be asked. The helper should know what to say, and what not to say.
Say short, plain, true things, in simple words.
- "Yes, she died. That means her body stopped working, and she cannot come back."
- "It's all right to be sad. I am sad too."
- "A lot of people love you, and we are here."
- "Christians believe that God holds those who die. I believe that, and I am still sad."
Avoid these.
- Euphemisms that confuse. "She went to sleep" may make a child afraid of bed. "We lost him" may make a child look for him. "God took her" may make a child afraid of God. Use the word "died".
- Lies to comfort. "He will come back soon." "She's just on a trip." The child will find out, and the lie damages trust.
- Claims you cannot make. Communities differ in what they teach about the dead, and the helper should say what the church holds, as the leader has agreed, and not add private certainties. If the child asks something you do not know, say, "I don't know. That's a good question; I'll ask." And ask the leader, and tell the parent, because the family may have its own words.
- Pressing to talk. A child who wishes to talk will. A child who plays instead of talking is also grieving.
- Details of illness or accident that the child has not asked for, and that the family may not wish told.
A rule worth keeping: a helper tells the parent when a child has asked about death. The family may wish to follow it up, or may be glad of the opening. And if the death is within the child's own family or the community's, the leader should agree with the family beforehand what will be said to the other children, and who will say it.
5. Signs are not a diagnosis
A helper sometimes sees things that suggest a pattern: a child who is always tired, who seems low for weeks, who flinches at a loud noise, who is hungry, who is withdrawn, who clings to a helper. It is tempting to explain. "This child must be depressed." "She's obviously being neglected." "That's trauma."
Please do not. Each of those words is a judgement that belongs to trained people, and each can be wrong. The same signs may mean a hundred ordinary things. And a word said aloud, in the helpers' room or to a parent, can start something that cannot be taken back.
What the helper can do is describe and pass on. Write down, briefly, what you saw, when, and what the child said, if anything, in the child's own words. Leave out what you think it means. (Invented examples.) "Three Sundays running, Joy has not eaten the snack and has said she was hungry." "Last Sunday Luis said, 'My dad isn't coming back.'" These notes are for the person responsible, kept as the community's policy directs, and not shared with others.
6. Telling the right people
Three questions help the helper decide whom to tell.
Is a child in immediate danger? If a child is in danger now, or has said something that suggests immediate danger, tell the person responsible at once, and if it cannot wait, call the local emergency number. Do not wait for the end of the session. Do not try to deal with it alone.
Has a child said, or shown, something that worries me about safety? Follow lecture 2-4 and the community's written policy: listen, do not promise secrecy, write what was said, and tell the person responsible the same day. Duties to report differ by country and by role, and the leader will know what applies; the helper's part is to pass it on promptly.
Is the child sad, worried or in a hard season, with nothing to suggest danger? Tell the person responsible in an ordinary way, and ask whether the family should be told. The policy will say. Usually, a kind word to the parent is right (an invented example): "I've noticed Amara has been very quiet. We're glad she's here. Is there anything we can do to help?" It is said as care, not as a report. The family may not wish to share what is happening, and they do not have to.
In every case the helper does not carry the matter alone. That is the purpose of the person responsible: to carry what is too much for one volunteer.
7. Pointing to help
Sometimes the right thing is to say to the family: "There are people who help with this, and I can tell you where to find them." The leader will know of local services: a doctor, a school counsellor, a bereavement group, a food bank, a social worker, a pastor or priest. A children's worker does not give medical, legal or psychological advice. But a leader who knows where to point can give a family a number or a name. This is not rejection. It is care by someone who knows the limits of the role.
The community can also help in ways that are its own. A meal for a family where someone has died. A visit from the pastor. A card from the group. A place at the table for a child whose home is tense. The children's worker is one part of that, and need not be all of it.
8. Two kinds of community
In a large parish, there may be a pastoral team, a safeguarding officer, a parish nurse or a trained counsellor to whom the leader can turn, and the path of "pass on" is well marked. In a small assembly or house church, the person responsible may be the pastor or an , and the community may know the family well; here the risk is not secrecy but gossip, and the discipline is to say what you noticed only to the person responsible. In a liturgical community, the child's grief may be met in the rites for the dead and in the year's prayers for them; a helper may be asked by a child what the candle or the prayer means. In a free-church setting, the grief may be met in the prayer circle and the care of the group. In all of them, the helper's part is the same: be steady, be kind, pass on.
Diagram 1. Notice, stay, pass on
In short
- Children struggle with grief, moves, family change, hunger, tiredness and worry; most of this is ordinary family life.
- Notice, stay, pass on: do not question a child about home; be calm, near and ordinary.
- Speak of death in short, true words, use the word "died", tell no comforting lies, and tell the parent a child asked.
- Signs are not a diagnosis: describe what you saw and pass it on; never name a cause.
- Immediate danger: tell the person responsible and call the local emergency number; duties to report differ by country and role.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Notice, stay, pass on | See that something is different, stay calm and near without pressing, tell the person responsible. |
| Why not question about home? | The child may say what you hope to hear, be put between loved ones, or be harmed; it is not the helper's place. |
| Words about death | Short, plain, true; say "died"; no comforting lies; tell the parent. |
| Signs and diagnosis | Describe what you saw and pass it on; never name a cause. |
One sentence to remember Be the steady adult who sees, stays and tells, and leave the rest to those with the skill and the standing.
This week's action Find out who the person responsible is for children's matters in your community, and write down how to reach that person quickly.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Think of a time as a child when you were sad and an adult was kind. What exactly did the adult do?
- Why is it better to say "I'm here if you want to tell me anything" than to ask "What's wrong at home?"
- How would you answer a six-year-old who asks, "Is Grandpa dead for always?" in two or three plain sentences? What would you tell the parent afterwards?
- In your community, who is the person responsible? Do all helpers know the name and how to reach that person quickly?
- What does your community do for a family that is going through a hard time? Where does the children's worker fit in?
- What is the difference between describing a sign and diagnosing a cause? Why does it matter?