Lecture 4-4: Welcome Without Pressure
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: More Than Minding Children
- Lecture 1-2: Many Shapes of Children's Ministry
- Lecture 1-3: Roles, Calling and Limits
- Lecture 1-4: What a Children's Ministry Is For
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: The Shape of Our Children's Ministry
- Lecture 2-1: Why Safety Comes First
- Lecture 2-2: Safe People
- Lecture 2-3: Safe Places and Safe Routines
- Lecture 2-4: When You Are Worried
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: A Safety Walk Round One Room
- Lecture 3-1: From Arrival to Going Home
- Lecture 3-2: Rooms, Spaces and Materials
- Lecture 3-3: Few Children, Mixed Ages
- Lecture 3-4: Choosing and Adapting Materials
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Our Hour on One Page
- Lecture 4-1: Telling a Bible Story to Children
- Lecture 4-2: Hard Stories
- Lecture 4-3: Praying, Singing and Worshipping With Children
- Lecture 4-4: Welcome Without Pressure
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Preparing One Story
- Lecture 5-1: Understanding Behaviour
- Lecture 5-2: Guiding Without Shame
- Lecture 5-3: Every Child Belongs
- Lecture 5-4: When a Child Is Struggling
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: The First Sentence in a Hard Moment
At the end of a summer club, a leader asks the children to close their eyes. "If you want to follow Jesus, put up your hand. Nobody is looking." Eleven hands go up in a room of fourteen. Three children keep their hands down, and the leader notes that. A girl of seven who put hers up whispers afterwards to her friend, "I did it because everyone else did." The leader writes eleven on the report.
Nobody in that room meant any harm. The leader loved the children and wanted them to know God. And yet something went wrong. A child gave an answer to please, a number was produced, and three children learned that they were the ones who did not.
This lecture is about the difference between welcoming a child and pressing her. It follows lecture 4-3, where we saw that children are worshippers and not performers. Here the question is what a community may ask of a child in response to the story, and what it must never ask. The central claim says that safety comes first, the story is at the centre, and we walk with the family. A child who feels pressed is not safe; a child whose parents are left out is not walked with.
What these 21 minutes give you
- State the strongest case for urgency in inviting children to respond, and say what goes wrong with it.
- Offer children ways to respond to a story that do not press for a decision or a performance.
- Explain why a child's words, testimony and photograph are not used to impress or to raise money.
- Say what to do when a child says she wants to follow Jesus or to be baptised.
- Welcome a child from another faith or none, honestly and without hiding who you are.
but whoever causes one of these little ones who believe in me to stumble, it would be better for him that a huge millstone should be hung around his neck, and that he should be sunk in the depths of the sea." — Matthew 18:6
World English Bible
But when Jesus saw it, he was moved with indignation, and said to them, “Allow the little children to come to me! Don’t forbid them, for the Kingdom of God belongs to such as these. Most certainly I tell you, whoever will not receive the Kingdom of God like a little child, he will in no way enter into it.”" — Mark 10:14-15
WEB
Walk in wisdom toward those who are outside, redeeming the time. Let your speech always be with grace, seasoned with salt, that you may know how you ought to answer each one." — Colossians 4:5-6
WEB
The first passage is a severe warning from Jesus about causing a child who believes in him to stumble; a teacher takes it as a reason for care. The second shows Jesus indignant that children were held back from him, and welcoming them. The third is a rule for speaking to those outside the faith: wisdom, grace, and answers fitted to each person.
1. The case for urgency
Many who work with children believe that early response matters, and the belief deserves its strongest form. Faith is personal. Many people first turned to God as children. Childhood is a time when hearts are open, and if the invitation is not given, the chance may pass. Jesus welcomed children and said the kingdom belongs to them. A teacher who has told the story of Jesus and does not invite a response is withholding the very thing the story is for. And a clear invitation is a kindness: it tells children what is possible, and it honours a child who does want to give her life to God.
That view is right about three things. Children can respond to God, and sometimes with real depth. Faith is not only a family inheritance but a person's own answer. And a story with no door at the end can leave a child wondering what she is meant to do with it.
What goes wrong is not the invitation but the pressure around it. Four things tend to happen when a decision is pressed on children.
First, children answer to please adults. A child of seven reads a room well. She knows what the leader wants and she knows what the other children are doing. Her raised hand may be a wish to belong, to be good, to please, to be like the others. It is a real wish, but it is not necessarily faith.
Second, a number takes the place of a child. "Eleven decisions" says nothing about the eleven. It does a great deal of harm to the three who kept their hands down, and to the seven-year-old who raised hers because the room did.
Third, the child learns that love depends on the right answer. The adults were warm when hands went up. A child who notices this concludes that warmth is the reward for performing the right feeling.
Fourth, the parents are out of the room. A decision for or against the faith belongs to the child and her family. A leader who invites a response before the family has been told has placed herself between a child and her parents.
The warning of Matthew 18:6 is not about a casual mistake. It is about causing one of the little ones who believe in Jesus to stumble. A teacher who presses, manipulates or frightens a child into a response risks that. It is a reason for care, and it should be read as one.
2. What an open response looks like
The alternative to pressure is not silence. It is an open door that nobody is pushed through. Some practical forms:
- A choice of responses, all equal. After the story: "You may pray, or draw something from the story, or sit quietly, or light a candle, or just keep thinking. All of these are good." No one response is more spiritual than another.
- An invitation to talk, with no urgency. "If you have a question about the story, or want to talk about God, I am glad to talk with you, and so would your parents be." The invitation can be repeated each week in the same words, and it is not a test.
- No raised hands, no standing, no walking forward as a public sign, unless the community's practice requires it, and then with great care. Where a community has a custom of coming forward for prayer or a blessing (an altar call or a prayer at the front), children may be invited to it, but never singled out, never pressed, and never counted.
- No counting. A leader who counts hands will begin to want a larger number. Lecture 1-4 and lecture 6-4 look at measuring in words and not heads.
3. When a child says she wants to follow Jesus
Sometimes a child does say it, in her own way and in her own time. "I want to be baptised." "I love Jesus." "I want to ask God to be my friend." Do not dismiss it, and do not inflate it.
- Listen and be glad. "Thank you for telling me. I am glad you told me."
- Do not press, correct or test her. Do not ask a series of questions to check her understanding.
- Do not make promises about what will happen next. The next step depends on the community's way: a conversation with the priest or pastor, a preparation class, a time of waiting. It is not for the teacher to arrange alone.
- Tell the child's parents, at collection or by a message, and tell the person responsible in your community. Say what the child said in her own words. Parents are the first to decide, with the leaders, what happens.
- Do not announce it publicly or to the other children, and do not mention it in a newsletter without the family's agreement.
In a sacramental community this leads to , to the path the parish has for children who are baptised or who are preparing for first communion. In a free-church community it may lead to a conversation with the pastor and parents about baptism and what comes next. In both, the child is walked with, not carried off.
4. No performances, no props
Lecture 4-3 asked four questions before a child performs. This lecture applies them to a child's faith itself.
A child's testimony is not material. A child's words about God are hers. They should not be written into a newsletter, read out to a visiting speaker, filmed for a website, or used in a fundraising letter without the family's knowledge and agreement, and a leader should ask herself whether a child's words need to be repeated at all. A child who said something touching in a quiet moment did not say it for an audience.
A child on a platform is on display. A platform can be the front of the church or a screen. A child standing before a crowd to show how well the children are doing is being used to give the adults something. The same is true of a photograph taken to attract members or donors. Ask the parents. Follow your community's written policy and local law about photographs and records, which differ widely, and lecture 6-3 will return to this. Here the rule is simple: a child is not a means.
A child's attendance is not a trophy. Prizes for bringing the most friends, charts of who prayed, and sweets for those who say a prayer teach children that faith is a competition and that her place depends on results.
5. Evangelism without manipulation
Telling children the good news is not manipulation. Colossians 4:5-6 asks believers to "walk in wisdom toward those who are outside" and to let speech be "with grace, seasoned with salt, that you may know how you ought to answer each one." The phrase each one is the point. A response fitted to this child, in this place, is not a method applied to the group.
A faithful way of sharing the faith with children has these marks.
- It tells the truth, including what is not known, and does not exaggerate what God will do for a child who prays.
- It does not use fear as the lever. "If you do not believe, something terrible will happen to you" can frighten a child for years. It is not the way the Gospel is told in the story of the lost sheep, where the shepherd goes looking.
- It does not bribe. Hospitality is not a bribe: a snack for every child is a welcome. A prize for those who pray is.
- It is honest about what the gathering is. Parents know that it is a Christian gathering with Bible stories and prayer, and what is said to children.
- It leaves the family in charge. A child is never asked to hide what she is learning from her parents, or told that her parents are wrong.
- It lets a child say no, without a sulk from the leader and without a change in warmth.
6. A child from another faith or none
Children of other faiths, or no faith, come to children's groups: a neighbour's child, a cousin visiting, a child whose parents want her to know the stories, a child from a family that practises another religion. They are welcome.
A teacher who welcomes them honestly does the following.
- Welcomes the child like any child. She has a place, a name, a seat, a snack.
- Talks to the parents about what the group does: stories, prayers and songs. If they would like their child not to join in a certain part, she can sit quietly, or draw.
- Does not correct the child's family in front of others. If a child says "my family does not pray like that", the answer is "that is all right; you are welcome here."
- Says plainly what the community believes, without hiding it and without speaking badly of anyone else. "In our church we believe that Jesus is the Son of God. Your family may believe differently, and you are welcome." Do not put a label of blame on another faith or on a present-day group.
- Does not use the welcome as a means of conversion. The child is welcome whether or not she ever becomes a Christian. The invitation to the faith is made the same way for every child: open, unpressed, and with the parents in mind.
This is also true in a parish where children from families with little connection to church come for preparation for first communion or confirmation. They are welcome now and they are not a project.
7. The same care in two kinds of community
(An invented example.) In a parish, a catechist named Peter notices that Lina, nine, has begun staying behind to ask about the saints. He tells her mother at collection, who says she wondered. Together with the priest they arrange for Lina to join the preparation class when the next one starts. Nothing is announced and nothing is promised in the meantime. In a small baptist-style assembly, a leader named Ruth finds that a seven-year-old, Kofi, wants to be baptised. She does not say yes or no. She tells his father and the pastor, and the three of them talk with him and then wait, with joy and without hurry. In both places the child said something real, and the adults walked with her.
Diagram 1. Invitation without pressure
In short
- The case for urgency is serious, but pressing children for a decision leads them to answer to please, turns a child into a number, and leaves parents out.
- Offer an open door: a choice of equal responses, an invitation to talk, and no count, no raised hands and no singling out.
- When a child says she wants to follow Jesus, listen and be glad, promise nothing, and tell her parents and the person responsible.
- A child's words, testimony and photograph are hers: not material for newsletters, platforms or appeals, and a child is never a means.
- Sharing the faith with children tells the truth, does not use fear or bribes, is honest about what the gathering is, and leaves the family in charge.
- A child of another faith or none is welcome now; say honestly what your church believes and speak badly of no one.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| What goes wrong with pressing for a decision | Children answer to please, a number replaces a child, warmth seems to depend on the right answer, and parents are left out. |
| An open door | Equal ways to respond, an invitation to talk with parents in mind, no count, no singling out. |
| If a child says she wants to follow Jesus | Listen, be glad, promise nothing, and tell her parents and the person responsible; announce nothing. |
| A child of another faith or none | Welcome her now, tell her parents what you do, say honestly what you believe, and speak badly of no one. |
One sentence to remember Leave the door open, never push a child through it, and walk with the family when a child steps toward it.
This week's action Check one part of your gathering that counts, rewards or displays children, and write a plainer way to do it.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Recall a time when you were asked to respond publicly to something religious as a child. Did you answer to please? How would you have liked to be asked?
- The strongest case for urgency says a story without a door leaves a child wondering what to do. How could you give a door without a push?
- Look at your children's gathering. Is a number, a prize or a public sign used anywhere? What could replace it?
- A child says she wants to be baptised. Write what you would say, and the two people you would tell.
- How does your community speak of families of other faiths? What would a visiting child from such a family hear in your room?
- Colossians 4:6 says to answer "each one". What would that mean for the child in your group who talks least?