Lecture 1-3: When Theology Blames: Sin, Testing and Miracle
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: What Scripture Says About Bodies and Belonging
- Lecture 1-2: Models of Disability and the Words We Use
- Lecture 1-3: When Theology Blames: Sin, Testing and Miracle
- Lecture 1-4: Why We Come: Honest Motives and First Impressions
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: My Church's First Impression and My Own Heart
- Lecture 2-1: Moving and Sensing: Mobility, Sight, Hearing and Speech
- Lecture 2-2: Learning, Development and Autism
- Lecture 2-3: Mental Health, Chronic Illness and Hidden Disabilities
- Lecture 2-4: Asking First: How to Offer Help and Take a No
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Questions I Can Ask
- Lecture 3-1: Paths, Doors and Seats: The Building and the Room
- Lecture 3-2: The Service Itself: Order, Words and Sacraments
- Lecture 3-3: Screens, Print and Online Worship
- Lecture 3-4: Hospitality That Goes Beyond the Door
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Walking Through a Service
- Lecture 4-1: Children and Youth Ministry: Inclusion Within It
- Lecture 4-2: Small Groups and Adult Learning
- Lecture 4-3: Serving: Volunteers, Companions and Roles
- Lecture 4-4: Money, Time and the Small Church
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Opening One Group to Everyone
- Lecture 5-1: Beside the Family
- Lecture 5-2: Supporters, Professionals and Warm Referral
- Lecture 5-3: Dignity, Consent and Keeping People Safe
- Lecture 5-4: Privacy, Prayer Lists and Photographs
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Who Do I Tell? A Participation Plan
Some of the most painful words that disabled people and their families hear in church are not rude words. They are religious words, said gently and meant as comfort. "God has a plan for this." "She is a special gift." "If only you had more faith." "In heaven he will be whole." The speaker is often trying to bring God near. The listener often hears that their life has been explained, and that the explanation is a verdict.
This lecture looks at where those sentences come from. They come from real questions that Scripture itself asks, and from real answers that Scripture sometimes refuses. We read John 9, Job, Luke 13, the "thorn" of 2 Corinthians 12 and Moses' answer to God in Exodus 4. We state the explanations in their strongest form first, because a lecture that makes the people who hold them look foolish teaches nothing. Then we ask what the passages actually do, and what a church can say instead.
The lecture also contains the course's one long paragraph on healing prayer, a subject on which Christians sincerely disagree. The aim is to teach you to hold your own tradition's practice in a way that does not become a burden on the person in front of you.
What these 36 minutes give you
- Name the common religious explanations that blame (sin, testing, divine plan, weak faith, a miracle waiting to happen) and say how each lands on a disabled person or a family.
- Explain what Jesus does with the question "who sinned?" in John 9, and what the story shows about the man himself.
- Explain God's verdict on Job's friends (Job 42:7) and what it teaches about explaining another person's suffering.
- Say why 2 Corinthians 12:7-10 cannot be used to explain anyone else's impairment, and what the passage does say.
- State fairly where readers disagree about healing prayer, and say what this course requires whatever a community believes.
His disciples asked him, “Rabbi, who sinned, this man or his parents, that he was born blind?”" — John 9:2
World English Bible
Jesus answered, “Neither did this man sin, nor his parents; but, that the works of God might be revealed in him." — John 9:3
WEB
It was so, that after Yahweh had spoken these words to Job, Yahweh said to Eliphaz the Temanite, “My wrath is kindled against you, and against your two friends; for you have not spoken of me the thing that is right, as my servant Job has." — Job 42:7
WEB
Jesus answered them, “Do you think that these Galileans were worse sinners than all the other Galileans, because they suffered such things?" — Luke 13:2
WEB
He has said to me, “My grace is sufficient for you, for my power is made perfect in weakness.” Most gladly therefore I will rather glory in my weaknesses, that the power of Christ may rest on me." — 2 Corinthians 12:9
WEB
Yahweh said to him, “Who made man’s mouth? Or who makes one mute, or deaf, or seeing, or blind? Isn’t it I, Yahweh?" — Exodus 4:11
WEB
Each of these passages answers a question about why a person suffers or is impaired. Notice, as you read, which ones answer the question and which ones decline it.
1. What people have heard
This course does not report how many disabled people have heard a certain thing, because we do not have honest numbers and the numbers would not change the point. What can be said is that many disabled people and many parents and carers say they have heard sentences like these in church, and that they remember them for years:
- "God gave her this to teach us."
- "Everything happens for a reason."
- "God gives special children to special parents."
- "If you had more faith, you would be healed."
- "He is in God's hands; it is God's will."
- "She will be whole in heaven" (said as comfort, in place of listening).
- "God needs her to suffer for his purposes."
It helps to say why each one hurts, because the speaker usually does not intend the hurt.
"God gave her this to teach us" makes the person a lesson for the people who speak. The person's life is explained by what it does for others. "Everything happens for a reason" claims a knowledge nobody has, and it tells the listener not to be sad. "God gives special children to special parents" flatters the parents and weighs on them; it also implies that parents who struggle are failing to be the special ones they were meant to be, and it says nothing about the child. "If you had more faith" turns the lasting impairment into a sign of a spiritual defect in the person, which is a harsh thing to say to anyone and a cruel thing to say to a person who has prayed for years. "It is God's will" and "God needs her to suffer" make God the cause of the suffering and invite the person to be grateful for it. "She will be whole in heaven," thrown as comfort, tells the person that their present body is incomplete, and that the speaker would rather not stay in the present.
None of these sentences was invented by cruel people. Each is a fragment of something that has a real place in Christian thought. That is why they are hard to give up, and why this lecture takes them seriously before it asks you to put them down.
2. The explanations in their strongest form
The explanation of sin. Much of the Old Testament assumes a moral order in which God rewards the faithful and the unfaithful meet trouble. Blessings and curses run through Deuteronomy. The prophets warn that wrongdoing will bring ruin. A person who believed that God is just might reason: if a man is blind from birth, someone has sinned. This is a genuine attempt to take God's justice seriously in a world where bad things happen. It is the reasoning the disciples use in John 9:2.
The explanation of testing. The Bible does speak of testing: "God tested Abraham", Israel in the wilderness, the refining of silver. A person who has been through a trial and can say, looking back, that it formed them, is describing something many people truly report. That kind of speech has been a lifeline for many.
The explanation of divine plan. The Bible says that God knows us before we are born (Psalm 139) and that God is not surprised. A believer who holds that nothing falls outside God's purpose finds it hard to say that a life's shape is an accident. Many Christians in the Augustinian and Reformed traditions have taught about with great care and pastoral warmth, including toward the suffering.
The explanation of weak faith. The Gospels do link faith and healing. Jesus says to a woman, "Your faith has made you well" (Luke 8:48), and in his home town "He didn’t do many mighty works there because of their unbelief" (Matthew 13:58). A tradition that prays expectantly for healing has these verses in view.
The miracle waiting to happen. Jesus healed many people. The apostles healed. A church that believes God still heals will find it natural to hope, and to pray with hope, for every sick or impaired person it meets.
Each of these has something true in it. And in each case, the trouble is the same: the claim is made about someone else, from outside, to explain a life that the speaker has not lived. A believer may say to themselves, "I think this trial made me wiser." The same sentence said to another person becomes a ruling on a stranger's life. That move, from first person to third, from my story to your story, is where the harm is done. Keep it in mind through the rest of the lecture.
3. John 9: the question, the answer and the man
The story begins as Jesus sees a man who has been blind from birth. His disciples ask the standard question: "Rabbi, who sinned, this man or his parents, that he was born blind?" (John 9:2). It is not a foolish question for people who believe what the disciples believed. They ask it as people who want an account.
Jesus' answer cuts through it:
"Jesus answered, “Neither did this man sin, nor his parents; but, that the works of God might be revealed in him." — John 9:3 (WEB)
The first half is clear. Neither. The link between this man's blindness and anyone's sin is refused. The second half has been read in more than one way, and the difference matters.
On the most common reading, Jesus says that the man was born blind in order that God's works might be shown in him, so that God, in some sense, arranged the blindness for the display of healing. This is the reading that has done the most harm. It makes the man a stage prop. A parent hears it and thinks: is my child's disability for something?
Some translators and commentators point out that the original Greek of the sentence had no punctuation marks, as ancient manuscripts did not, and that the sentence can be divided differently. On the other division, Jesus says: Neither this man nor his parents sinned. But in order that the works of God might be revealed in him, we must do the works of the one who sent me while it is day. On this reading, the blindness has no purpose assigned to it at all. The purpose belongs to the action of Jesus and his followers toward the man: what is being revealed is God at work, and the question is what we do. Scholars discuss which division is better, and readers should not pretend the matter is settled. This course does not need to decide. It needs only to say what both readings share: Jesus refuses the cause-and-guilt question, and he turns at once from explanation to action.
What happens next is not usually told in sermons on this chapter, and it matters more for our subject than the sentence about works. The man is questioned by the authorities. His neighbours argue about whether he is the same man. His parents are asked, and they answer that he was born blind and that they do not know how he sees now. They say:
"but how he now sees, we don’t know; or who opened his eyes, we don’t know. He is of age. Ask him. He will speak for himself." — John 9:21 (WEB)
The text explains their caution: they feared being put out of the synagogue (9:22). Whatever we think of their fear, their sentence gives the course one of its rules: He is of age. Ask him. The man is an adult with his own account. When the authorities press him to call Jesus a sinner, he answers, "One thing I do know: that though I was blind, now I see" (9:25). He argues, with some wit, with people who have more power than he has. In the end they say, "You were altogether born in sins, and do you teach us?" and they throw him out (9:34). The old question has come back. It is used as a weapon: your blindness proves your guilt.
And then the text says:
"Jesus heard that they had thrown him out, and finding him, he said, “Do you believe in the Son of God?”" — John 9:35 (WEB)
Jesus goes and finds the man who has been thrown out by a community that blamed him. This is the part of the story a congregation should reread. The man is not an object of a lesson. He is a person who speaks for himself, who is expelled for it, and who is found by Jesus afterwards.
4. Job and his friends
The Book of Job puts the question in its sharpest form. Job is a good man who loses his children, his property and his health. Three friends come to him. Their first action is the best thing in the book:
"So they sat down with him on the ground seven days and seven nights, and no one spoke a word to him, for they saw that his grief was very great." — Job 2:13 (WEB)
For seven days they said nothing. If they had stopped there, they would be a model for every visitor. Then they spoke. Their argument, in the strongest form, is a defence of God's justice: God does not punish the innocent. Remember, "whoever perished, being innocent?" (4:7). So Job must have done something. The friends are not cruel men. They cannot bear the idea that God might be unjust or that the world might be unreliable, and so they would rather find a fault in Job.
At the end of the book, God speaks to the friends, and the verdict is startling:
"It was so, that after Yahweh had spoken these words to Job, Yahweh said to Eliphaz the Temanite, “My wrath is kindled against you, and against your two friends; for you have not spoken of me the thing that is right, as my servant Job has." — Job 42:7 (WEB)
The friends, who defended the doctrine, were wrong. Job, who protested and complained and asked God to answer, was right "as my servant Job has". The friends must ask Job to pray for them (42:8). The book does not give a tidy reason for Job's suffering. It refuses the friends' reason. Job himself calls them "miserable comforters" (16:2).
The lesson here is not that all explanations of suffering are false. It is that a person who sits beside a sufferer and explains the suffering has taken on a position that the Bible itself judges harshly. The first seven days were right. The explanation was the mistake.
5. Luke 13: towers and Galileans
In Luke 13 some people tell Jesus about Galileans whom Pilate had killed. Jesus answers with a question: "Do you think that these Galileans were worse sinners than all the other Galileans, because they suffered such things?" (Luke 13:2). He gives his own answer: "I tell you, no" (13:3). He then recalls eighteen people killed when a tower fell, and asks again whether they were worse offenders than anyone else; again, "no" (13:4-5).
Be exact about what this shows. The passage is not about disability. It is about disasters. In both halves Jesus goes on to say, "unless you repent, you will all perish in the same way", so the point of the passage is a call to everyone and not a comment on the victims. But its logic is plain: the size of a person's suffering is not a measure of their sin. That logic cuts against the explanation of sin wherever it is used.
6. The thorn: why it cannot be lent to anyone else
In 2 Corinthians 12 Paul speaks of a "thorn in the flesh", given to him so that he would not be "exalted excessively". He says: "Concerning this thing, I begged the Lord three times that it might depart from me" (12:8). The answer he received is the verse at the head of this lecture:
"He has said to me, “My grace is sufficient for you, for my power is made perfect in weakness.” Most gladly therefore I will rather glory in my weaknesses, that the power of Christ may rest on me." — 2 Corinthians 12:9 (WEB)
The passage is used often. A church member says to a friend with a chronic condition: "Perhaps this is your thorn." Why is that risky?
First, Paul does not say what the thorn was. Scholars have suggested an illness, a physical weakness, a human opponent, and other things. The text leaves it open. Anyone who names it as an impairment is going beyond the text.
Second, the passage is Paul's own report, about his own life, of what Christ said to him in answer to his own prayer. Paul interprets his own experience. It is a first-person word. Paul does not say it to anyone else, and he does not say that every weakness has the same meaning. When we hand it to another person as an explanation, we do what the lecture warned about earlier: we move from "my story" to "your story".
Third, notice what the passage does allow. Paul prayed that the thorn would be removed, three times. He did not think that asking was wrong. Christ's answer was not that praying for relief is faithless; it was that grace would be given. The passage does not forbid hoping for change. It does not tell the person with a disability to stop wishing things were different.
And fourth, "my power is made perfect in weakness" can turn into a demand. A church can say to a disabled member, in effect, be cheerful and strong in your weakness, so that we can see God's power. That puts the burden of the display on the person. The text offers it to Paul as a gift received. It does not tell a community to require it.
7. Moses and the mouth
Moses objects when God calls him that he is not eloquent and is "slow of speech, and of a slow tongue" (Exodus 4:10). God answers him in a way that has been read in two directions:
"Yahweh said to him, “Who made man’s mouth? Or who makes one mute, or deaf, or seeing, or blind? Isn’t it I, Yahweh?" — Exodus 4:11 (WEB)
One reading hears a claim about origins: God makes some people mute or blind, and so impairment is God's doing, perhaps for a purpose. That is the reading that has been used to say, "God made her this way for a reason." A second reading hears a claim about : the God who made Moses' mouth is not limited by Moses' mouth, and Moses' speech is not a reason for him to refuse. The context supports the second. The point is the commission, not a theory of why people differ.
Look at what happens next. Moses objects again, and God provides Aaron, who "will be your spokesman to the people" (4:16). In this account God does not heal Moses' speech. God gives him a companion for the task, and Moses goes on to lead. The text also says that God's anger was kindled against Moses at this further refusal (4:14), so the story is not only gentle. It can still be read as a story of shared leadership, with a support that Moses did not ask for at first. It is not a story of a disabled man cured and then used.
Psalm 139, which we met in lecture 1-1, is another text read in two directions: as a poem of dignity (each body is known), and as a claim that every feature of a body is a divine decision. The course takes the first reading and is cautious about the second, because the second goes beyond the poem.
8. When the hurry to heal becomes a weight
A last pattern deserves naming. In some communities there is a quiet expectation that a disabled member is waiting for a cure, and that the church's chief task is to arrange it. The expectation is often kind. But it can have effects the congregation does not see. The person may feel that they are always a project. A person who does not wish to be healed may feel that their wish is a kind of unfaith. A person who has prayed for years and has not been healed may be asked, in effect, to explain why. A parent may feel judged when a child does not change.
We are not saying that healing prayer is wrong. We are saying that when it is pressed on a person, it can become one more thing to carry. The next paragraph states the disagreement, and what the course asks.
This is a point where readers will not agree. Some Christians, including many Pentecostal, charismatic and other traditions, pray expectantly for healing and lay hands on those who ask, because they read the Gospels and Acts as showing that God still heals and that the church is sent to pray for the sick. In their strongest form, they say that to pray for healing is to take God's goodness and power seriously and to refuse to accept suffering as final. Other Christians, including many in the Reformed, Lutheran and other traditions, receive the body as it is and pray for comfort, strength and belonging, because they read the New Testament as promising God's presence in weakness (as in 2 Corinthians 12) and because they fear that a hurry to cure treats a person as a problem. In their strongest form, they say that the church is called to love the person, not to wait for a different one. Many Catholic, Orthodox, Anglican and other communities hold both: they pray for the sick, sometimes with anointing, and also for acceptance and for grace; traditions differ on whether a lasting disability is the kind of condition such prayer is for, and a pastor or priest should be asked. Most believers mix the two in practice. Among disabled people themselves there is no single view. Some regard their disability as part of who they are and do not want to be healed; some Deaf communities hold that Deafness is a culture and a language to be kept, not a lack to be mended. Others do hope for healing, and say so. Wrongly used, either position becomes a burden: the first when it is pressed on someone who does not want it, and the second when it is used to tell someone that hoping for change is faithless. Traditions also differ on the body in the resurrection and on disability. Some hold that the risen body is made whole, and some disabled Christians hear this as a hope and some as a verdict on their present body. Some theologians have pointed out that the risen Christ is shown with the marks of his wounds (John 20:27), and have asked what that means for a body described as "whole". This lecture does not settle that question. What this course requires is less than any one tradition teaches: ask before praying aloud over or touching anyone; pray what the person wants; never imply that a lasting disability shows sin or weak faith; and do not argue the resurrection body at a bedside. A congregation that does these four things is free to keep its own tradition's practice in all else.
9. What to say, and what to do instead
A good deal of the work of this lecture is practical. A visitor who is afraid of saying the wrong thing may say nothing, and the person is left alone. The better choice is to say something small and true.
| Instead of | You might say or do |
|---|---|
| "God gave her this to teach us." | "I am glad you are here." Or say nothing about meaning; sit with the person. |
| "Everything happens for a reason." | "I do not know why. I am sorry that this is hard." |
| "God gives special children to special parents." | "How are you? How is the week been?" Then listen, and ask whether a meal or a lift would help. |
| "If you had more faith..." | Nothing. This sentence should not be said. If you hear it said, quietly stay with the person afterwards. |
| "It's God's will." | "I am here. Would you like me to pray with you? What would you like me to pray for?" |
| "She'll be whole in heaven." | Do not say it as comfort. If the person says something like it about themselves, listen. |
Notice the last line. A person may say, "I hope for a new body." That is their hope, and you may share it, if they have said it. The difference is between hearing a person's hope and assigning one.
(an invented example) Sipho is a lay minister in a large parish. He uses a wheelchair and leads the team that visits members at home. One afternoon he went along with a newer volunteer, Mrs. Okafor, to visit a mother whose son is autistic and often does not sleep well. At the door Mrs. Okafor said warmly, "God chose you for this boy because you are so strong." Sipho said nothing in the house. On the way back he asked Mrs. Okafor whether she would like to talk about the visit. He said that in his own experience this kind of sentence, said to a mother who is very tired, could sound as if she had no right to be tired. He suggested a different habit: ask first, and say what is true, such as "It sounds like it has been a hard few weeks. Is there something you would like us to do?" Mrs. Okafor said she had meant it as a compliment and was sorry. Sipho said that he had said the same kind of thing himself, once, in the first years of his ministry, and had been corrected by a member. At the next visit it was the mother who spoke first, and Mrs. Okafor asked about the boy's favourite food.
Diagram 1. What the passages do with "why?"
Diagram 2. Healing prayer: the requirement in one place
| Do | Do not |
|---|---|
| Ask before praying aloud over or touching anyone | Lay hands on a person who has not asked |
| Pray what the person wants | Pray what you want for them |
| Treat the person's hope for change, or wish for none, as theirs | Treat a person's wish not to be healed as unfaith |
| Keep your tradition's practice for those who ask | Imply that a lasting disability shows sin or weak faith |
| Leave the resurrection body alone at a bedside | Argue it with someone in distress |
In short
- Explanations of sin, testing, plan, weak faith and miracle each hold something true, and each harms when one person assigns it to another.
- In John 9 Jesus answers "who sinned?" with "neither", turns from cause to action, and later finds the man the community expelled.
- God's verdict on Job's friends (Job 42:7) shows that explaining another person's suffering is a mistake; their silent seven days were right.
- Paul's "thorn" is his own report of his own prayer and cannot be used to explain anyone else's impairment.
- This is a point where readers will not agree: traditions differ on healing prayer and on the resurrection body.
- The course requires: ask before praying aloud or touching; pray what the person wants; never imply sin or weak faith; do not argue the resurrection body at a bedside.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| John 9:2-3 | Asked "who sinned?", Jesus says "neither" and turns to action; the man speaks for himself and is later found by Jesus. |
| Job 42:7 | God judges the friends who explained Job's suffering; their first seven days of silence were right. |
| The thorn (2 Corinthians 12) | Paul's own report of his own prayer; it does not say what the thorn was and cannot be lent to anyone else. |
| Healing prayer: the requirement | Ask first; pray what the person wants; never imply sin or weak faith; leave the resurrection body alone at a bedside. |
One sentence to remember When we do not know why, the faithful thing is to stay beside the person and ask what they want, and not to explain.
This week's action Notice one religious sentence you tend to say about suffering, and decide how you would say it to the person's face if they were listening.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Which of the sentences in the list near the start of the lecture have you heard said, or said yourself? What do you think the speaker was trying to do?
- The lecture says the harm is done when a "my story" becomes a "your story". Can you think of a time when a sentence that helped you would have hurt if it had been said to someone else?
- In John 9 the parents say, "He is of age. Ask him." How might that sentence be used in your community when a decision is being made about an adult who has a disability?
- Job's friends were right to sit in silence for seven days. When is silence the best thing a visitor can bring? When is it not?
- How does your tradition pray for the sick? What would it take for that practice to include the four requirements of this course?