Lecture 6-1: Recovering People in Ministry: Welcome and Boundaries
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: What We Mean by Addiction
- Lecture 1-2: Substances and Behaviours: One Pattern, Many Faces
- Lecture 1-3: Body, Mind, Relationships, Spirit: Why One Lens Is Not Enough
- Lecture 1-4: Stigma and Grace
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: Listening to Our Own Words
- Lecture 2-1: The Family as a System
- Lecture 2-2: Codependency, Helping and Enabling
- Lecture 2-3: Children and Others Standing Close
- Lecture 2-4: The Carer Who Is Also Hurt
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: First Words to a Family
- Lecture 3-1: Recovery as a Long Road
- Lecture 3-2: The First Conversation and Readiness
- Lecture 3-3: Relapse: Meeting It Without Despair or Denial
- Lecture 3-4: A Whole Life Rebuilt: Work, Sleep, Friends, Faith
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: The Day of a Relapse, First Conversation
- Lecture 4-1: How Mutual-Help Groups Are Built
- Lecture 4-2: The Spiritual Side of the Steps and the Church's Own Gospel
- Lecture 4-3: Hosting a Recovery Group: Space, Welcome, Boundaries
- Lecture 4-4: Confidentiality and the Church's Talk
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: A One-Page Hosting Agreement
- Lecture 5-1: Medicine, Treatment and the Church: Who Does What
- Lecture 5-2: Withdrawal and Emergencies: Connecting to Medical Help
- Lecture 5-3: Referring Well and Walking Alongside
- Lecture 5-4: Tangled Troubles: Other Health Needs, Money, Law
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Drawing a Referral Map
Sooner or later, in most congregations, a person who is walking the road of recovery says some version of this: "I would like to be useful." They may offer to stack chairs, to lead a song, to visit the sick, to teach children, to count the offering, or to help with the next person who is struggling. The church has to answer. A "yes" given too fast may put a heavy load on a fragile person. A "no" given out of fear may tell that person, again, that they are a problem and not a member.
This lecture asks how a church can welcome a recovering person into service without making them a showpiece, a risk or a project. It sets out a staged path, the part of a responsible person, the ordinary safeguards that apply to everyone, and a way back that carries no shame. It also states the fifth point on which readers will not agree: when a recovering person may hold a position of responsibility or office. The central claim returns: a church does not replace the treating professional; it is a community that stays beside people without stigma, connects, and waits. Waiting is part of the work, and so is trusting.
This course is not treatment. It does not replace medical or treatment care. Where a person's body is in danger, medical help is needed at once.
What these 27 minutes give you
- Describe how serving can both help and burden a person in recovery.
- Explain a staged path into service, and name the questions a church asks at each step.
- Say what a responsible person does and does not do.
- Explain why ordinary safeguards apply to every volunteer and not only to the recovering person.
- Describe a way back after a relapse that protects dignity.
- State fairly three positions on when a recovering person may hold office, and what this course requires.
Blessed be the God and Father of our Lord Jesus Christ, the Father of mercies and God of all comfort;" — 2 Corinthians 1:3
World English Bible
who comforts us in all our affliction, that we may be able to comfort those who are in any affliction, through the comfort with which we ourselves are comforted by God." — 2 Corinthians 1:4
WEB
No, much rather, those members of the body which seem to be weaker are necessary." — 1 Corinthians 12:22
WEB
but I prayed for you, that your faith wouldn’t fail. You, when once you have turned again, establish your brothers.”" — Luke 22:32
WEB
not a new convert, lest being puffed up he fall into the same condemnation as the devil." — 1 Timothy 3:6
WEB
The first two verses describe a circle of comfort: God comforts, and those who have received comfort are able to comfort others. The third says that the members of the body who "seem to be weaker are necessary". The fourth is a word of Jesus to a friend who had failed: he prayed for him, and he expected him, after he had turned again, to strengthen the others. The fifth is a caution about haste in appointing a leader. It speaks of a "new convert", which is a matter of how new someone is to the faith. It says nothing about anyone's past struggles, and it must not be read as if it did. Used with care, these verses hold the whole tension of this lecture: the weak are needed, restoration is real, and haste can hurt.
1. Why the question comes
A person in recovery often wants to give something back. This is not vanity. After a time of taking, of hiding, of being the one others worried about, being useful feels like standing up straight. Many congregations also have real needs: too few hands, too few visitors, too few people who can sit with someone in trouble and not flinch. The wish to serve and the need for help meet in the same hall.
So the question is not whether a recovering person can ever serve. The Bible's picture of the body does not allow the church to sort members into those who give and those who only receive. The question is how to make service a good thing for the person and for the community, at a pace the person's recovery can bear.
2. How serving can help
Serving can do real good in a recovering person's life.
- Belonging. A task says "you are expected here." It turns a person who is looked after into a person who is counted on.
- Purpose and structure. A weekly duty gives a shape to the days. Many people find that unstructured time is hard.
- Dignity. To give is to be an adult among adults. Shame lessens when a person can see they are of use.
- Comfort passed on. Second Corinthians 1:4 describes a pattern: comfort received becomes comfort given. A person who knows from the inside what it is to be afraid of one's own mind is sometimes the one who can sit beside another, and say little, and be believed.
3. How serving can burden
Serving can also do harm, and the harm is usually quiet.
- Too much, too soon. A new duty, added to the work of rebuilding relationships, work and health, may be one load too many. A person who cannot say "no" to a church that is grateful may carry it silently.
- A task that brings the old struggle near. Some jobs put the old trouble within reach, or among reminders of it. A person who has struggled with gambling may not be well placed to handle the cash. A person recovering from a life of long nights may struggle with a late-evening rota. This is not a verdict on the person. It is the same good sense that keeps a person with a bad back from lifting.
- The pedestal. A church can be so pleased with a story of change that it asks the person to tell it again and again, or to lead before they have found their feet. The person becomes a banner for the church's success. The weight of being a good example is a heavy thing to carry, and a relapse becomes, in the person's mind, a betrayal of everyone. Lecture 3-3 returns to relapse. For now, hold this: people are not material. A person's story belongs to the person. It is told when, where and to whom they choose, and never because the church needs a good example.
- The unspoken test. If every task is a kind of examination, the person cannot relax. Service then becomes another place in which to hide.
Both lists are true at once. Good keeps both in view.
4. Two mistakes at the ends
It helps to name the two mistakes that sit at either end.
The first is the closed door: "People like that should not be given responsibility." It sounds careful. In practice it tells a person that the church holds their past against them without end, and it removes from the community some of its most useful members. The "weaker" members "are necessary," says 1 Corinthians 12:22. A church that never lets a recovering person serve has decided, without saying so, that some members are not necessary.
The second is the open floodgate: "Wonderful, you're better now, so you'll lead the whole ministry." It sounds generous. In practice it can swamp a fragile person and leave them alone at the front.
Between them lies a staged path.
5. A staged path
A staged path is not a ladder of worthiness. It is a way of letting a person's roots go down before the branches carry weight. It has no timetable, because people differ. Stages overlap, and a person may move forward in one area and stay put in another.
- Belonging first. The person comes, sits, eats, is known by name, and is greeted. There is no task. This is not a waiting room; it is the first form of membership.
- Shared tasks. The person does small jobs alongside others: setting out chairs with two others, serving tea in a team, helping prepare a meal. Nobody is alone in the task, and nothing important depends on it.
- A steady role. The person takes a regular duty, with a named person who knows them well and is ready to talk about how it is going. They have the right to say "this is too much."
- Wider responsibility. Teaching, leading, handling money, caring for the vulnerable, representing the church. Here the church decides case by case, with the person, with the support of the responsible person, and under the church's own order for such roles.
At each step the church asks the same questions, with the person and not about them:
- What does this person want to do, and why now?
- How is their life outside the church, in the sense that they themselves are willing to tell us?
- What does this task put within reach, or near?
- What do the person and their support person say?
- What would we do if it stopped being good? (We settle that before we start. See "A way back" below.)
Notice that nobody in this list is asked to prove that they have "arrived." Recovery does not end like a course. The question is not "are they finished?" but "is this the right next step, and is somebody beside them?"
6. The responsible person
Every stage from the second onward is helped by a responsible person: someone in the church who is named, known to the recovering person, and ready to talk. This is not a guard or an inspector. It is a companion who is also responsible to the church for the shape of the person's service.
What the responsible person does:
- meets the person regularly and briefly, and asks how the task is going;
- helps the person say "I can't do this at present" without shame;
- helps the church see when a task needs changing;
- keeps what the person says confidential within what the person has agreed (lecture 4-4), and tells the person plainly where confidentiality has limits, which differ by country, region and role: check locally.
What the responsible person does not do:
- treat, diagnose or manage the person's recovery (that belongs to medical and treatment professionals);
- hold every detail of the person's life, or become the only person they talk to;
- decide alone, or report to the congregation what the person has told them.
One good habit: the person who supervises the task and the person who hears the struggles are better kept separate. If the rota leader also holds the person's secrets, the person may feel they cannot say "no" to a duty without telling why. Two people, two roles, one person's dignity.
7. The same safeguards for everyone
Some roles carry a risk to others: handling money, being alone with children, being with vulnerable adults. Churches rightly have rules for these. The important principle is this: the rule applies to everyone in the role, not only to the recovering person.
(an invented example) In a congregation of about sixty, Bram, who is in recovery from gambling, would like to help with the money after services. The church has a rule that two people always count and record the offering together, and that no one person ever holds it alone. The rule is not a special rule for Bram. It was made years ago, for everyone, after a muddle. Bram counts with Naledi, as everyone does. He is not watched; he is joined. The same rule protects the church and, in a way, protects Bram.
When a church makes a special rule for one person, the person knows it. A rule that applies to all treats everyone with dignity. Child protection and the protection of vulnerable people belong to the safe church course, which deals with them properly; this lecture only says that those safeguards are not set aside for anyone, and not turned against anyone.
8. A way back
Many roads of recovery include a relapse (lecture 3-3). A church that has a service role for a recovering person should decide, before anything happens, what a hard time would mean.
A good way back has these marks:
- Agreed in advance. "If things get very hard, we will talk about a lighter load, and you can step back for a while. It will not be announced, and you will not be asked to explain to anyone."
- A rest, not a punishment. Stepping back is a form of care. The place can wait where it is possible.
- No public account. The congregation need not be told why. "Beatriz is taking a break from the rota" is enough. Gossip dressed as a prayer request is what stigma looks like (lecture 1-4).
- A door that stays open. Belonging, the first stage, never closes. A person who steps back from a task is still at the table.
- Link to care. Where the person is unwell or in danger, the first step is medical help, not a rota. A person who cannot be woken, who is badly confused, or who is gravely ill after stopping heavy use needs medical help at once. After that, the church stays beside them.
Some roles are, in the end, closed for a time for good reasons: for example, where the safety of others requires it. If so, the church says so plainly and kindly to the person, keeps what it says between those who must know, and shows a way forward.
9. This is a point where readers will not agree
This is a point where readers will not agree: when may a recovering person serve in a position of responsibility or hold office?
Some hold that grace means soon. In their strongest form, they argue that the gospel does not make a person prove themselves before they are restored, that Peter, who failed badly, was told by Jesus to strengthen his brothers (Luke 22:32), and that to make people wait a long time says to them that their past is stronger than God's forgiveness. They add that service is part of healing, and that a church which keeps recovering people out of responsibility for years teaches them to hide.
Others hold that the church should allow ample time. In their strongest form, they argue that positions of responsibility carry great weight and public trust, that recovery is fragile, and that a person placed too early in a high-pressure role may fall hard and take others with them. They may point to 1 Timothy 3:6, which warns against placing a "new convert" in oversight, and they hold that it is a kindness to let roots go down first. Waiting, in this view, is protection and not punishment.
Others hold that the answer is staged and case by case: that no rule about time fits every person, every role or every church, and that the right pace comes from honest conversation between the person, a responsible person and the church's leaders, role by role. They point out that "office" means different things in different traditions: an ordained ministry, an eldership, a diaconate, a teaching post, a rota of lay readers. Some traditions have written conditions for such posts, and these are for that tradition to keep.
This course does not choose, and it does not tell any tradition how to order its own offices. It requires three things of everyone. First, a staged path that protects both dignity and recovery: no one is kept out of belonging, no one is rushed into weight, and the steps are talked through with the person. Second, support from a responsible person, named and ready, at every stage that carries weight. Third, a way back without stigma after a relapse: stepping back is care, not exile, and the congregation is told nothing that the person has not agreed to. A church that holds a firm rule about office must also show the person, kindly, what the road ahead looks like, and it must apply the same rule to every candidate, not only to this one.
10. Small and large communities
(an invented example) In a house church of fourteen that meets in a flat, there are no "roles" in the sense of a rota. Everyone washes up, everyone brings something. Sofia, who is in recovery, is already doing a hundred small things by simply being there. The staged path here is mostly a matter of attention: noticing whether the one task she has taken on, making the tea, has become a chain she cannot leave, and making sure someone says, "You may rest this week; we will manage."
(an invented example) In a large city parish with rotas, committees and a paid staff, a man called Rustam, in recovery, asks to serve on a visiting team. The parish has a coordinator for visitors and a care team. Here the risk is the opposite: a form, a meeting and a decision process may make him feel he is applying for a post. The coordinator keeps the process short and warm, names one person as his support, and starts him on shared visits with an experienced member.
(an invented example) In a mission agency, an administrator called Imelda has been in recovery for some time and is asked to lead a team. The agency has a written policy that every leader has a yearly conversation about workload and wellbeing with a senior person, and Imelda's conversation is the same as everyone else's. Nobody has to "explain" anything.
11. The limits of this lecture
This lecture does not say that every recovering person should serve, or that every church can always find a suitable place. It does not claim that service brings recovery. A person may do all things well and still struggle, and a person may need to rest entirely for a season. It also does not claim that the church can predict the future: no staged path removes risk, and no rule makes a community safe from pain. What it offers is a way of staying beside people and letting them be useful, at a pace they can bear.
Diagram 1. A staged path into service
Diagram 2. Office: three positions, three requirements
In short
- Serving can bring belonging, structure, dignity and comfort passed on; it can also bring too much too soon, a task near the old struggle, and the pedestal.
- Two mistakes sit at the ends: the closed door and the open floodgate. A staged path lies between them: belonging, shared tasks, a steady role, wider responsibility.
- A named responsible person walks beside the person; the one who supervises the task and the one who hears the struggles are better kept separate.
- Safeguards for money, children and the vulnerable apply to everyone in the role, not only to the recovering person.
- A way back is agreed in advance, treated as rest, not punishment, and told to no one without the person's consent.
- Readers differ on when a recovering person may hold office; the course requires a staged path, a responsible person and a way back without stigma.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Staged path | Belonging first, then shared tasks, a steady role and wider responsibility, with no timetable and no test to pass. |
| Responsible person | A named companion who asks how it is going; does not treat, does not hold every secret, does not report to the congregation. |
| Same safeguards for all | A rule for money or children applies to every volunteer in the role, so no one is singled out. |
| A way back | Agreed in advance, a rest and not a punishment, with no public account, and the door of belonging stays open. |
One sentence to remember Let a person be useful at a pace their recovery can bear, and keep the door open both ways.
This week's action Write down, without names, the smallest shared task in your community that a person at the first steps of service could do, and who would be beside them.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Think of a task in your community that someone could do alongside others, with nothing important depending on it. Who is invited to do it today, and who is never asked?
- The lecture names two mistakes: the closed door and the open floodgate. Which is your community more likely to make? What shows it?
- Who in your community could be a responsible person, in the sense of this lecture? What would they need so that they do not become the only one who knows?
- Does your community's rule about money or children apply to everyone, or only to people it worries about? How would you tell?
- State the three positions on office as their holders would, in the strongest form you can. Which requirement of the course is hardest for your tradition to keep?