Lecture 2-3: Prayer and Scripture Beside Someone
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: What a Crisis Is and What a Church Can Do
- Lecture 1-2: People in Crisis in Scripture, and God's Nearness
- Lecture 1-3: The Caregiver's Own Steadiness and Safety
- Lecture 1-4: Preparing Before It Happens
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: A Readiness Sheet
- Lecture 2-1: Safety First and Steadying
- Lecture 2-2: Listening, and Words to Leave Unsaid
- Lecture 2-3: Prayer and Scripture Beside Someone
- Lecture 2-4: Differences in How Crisis Is Shown: Culture, Age, Setting
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Reading and Rewriting a Conversation
- Lecture 3-1: Warning Signs and Common Myths
- Lecture 3-2: Asking Directly: The Basic Questions
- Lecture 3-3: General Principles of a Safety Plan
- Lecture 3-4: Staying With Someone: Presence, Handover and Follow-Up
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Practising the Question
- Lecture 4-1: How People React to Overwhelming Events
- Lecture 4-2: Safety, Choice and Trust
- Lecture 4-3: Avoiding Further Harm in Church Life
- Lecture 4-4: Faith, Trauma and "Where Was God"
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: A Check of Our Practices
- Lecture 5-1: Beyond Stigma
- Lecture 5-2: Speaking Responsibly: Sermons, Prayers, Notices and Posts
- Lecture 5-3: After a Death by Suicide: Beside the Family
- Lecture 5-4: The Congregation as a Whole: Community After a Loss and Ongoing Prevention
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Checking What We Say
For most believers, prayer and Scripture are the heart of caring for a person. They are also among the easiest things to get wrong in a crisis. A verse spoken too early can sound like a dismissal. A long prayer can overrun the person it was meant for. A prayer used to end a hard conversation can be a way of leaving. And yet for many people in distress, a short prayer said gently at the right moment is exactly what they hope for.
This lecture asks how to bring prayer and Scripture beside someone without turning them into tools. The answer is not to avoid them. It is to ask permission, to keep them short and plain, to make room for lament, and never to let them stand in for safety and professional help.
This course gives no diagnosis, treatment, medication or medical advice, and it does not replace professional care. Prayer and Scripture are never a substitute for emergency services or professional help, and you must not use what you learn here to judge a person's faith or label them.
What these 22 minutes give you
- Explain why permission matters before praying or reading Scripture with a person in crisis.
- Describe a short, plain prayer, and name three ways a prayer can do harm.
- Explain what lament is and why it gives words to a person who has none.
- State fairly the main positions on the place of prayer and Scripture in a crisis.
- Say how prayer and Scripture sit alongside safety and professional help.
Yahweh is near to those who have a broken heart, and saves those who have a crushed spirit." — Psalms 34:18
World English Bible
Trust in him at all times, you people. Pour out your heart before him. God is a refuge for us. Selah." — Psalms 62:8
WEB
I pour out my complaint before him. I tell him my troubles." — Psalms 142:2
WEB
In the same way, the Spirit also helps our weaknesses, for we don’t know how to pray as we ought. But the Spirit himself makes intercession for us with groanings which can’t be uttered." — Romans 8:26
WEB
The Psalms are the Bible's own words for people in distress. Psalm 34:18 speaks of God's nearness to the broken-hearted. Psalm 62:8 and Psalm 142:2 invite the speaker to pour out the heart and to tell God the trouble, in plain words, with complaint included. Romans 8:26 says that when we do not know how to pray, the Spirit helps us. These are passages for a pastor or friend to hold quietly, and to use if the person welcomes them. They are not to be spoken at someone who has not asked, and they are never a quick remedy.
1. Why this needs care
Prayer and Scripture carry great weight for people who believe. That weight is exactly why they can hurt. When a person in crisis is told "Pray about it" or "The Lord is near," three things may go on in the person's mind at once. They may feel comforted. They may feel that they are being told their pain is a failure of faith. They may feel that the helper has stopped listening. The helper cannot tell which, unless they ask.
There is a second reason for care. A crisis is a moment when a person is unusually open, and also unusually unable to resist. Words said with authority can sink in more deeply than the speaker intends. A caregiver who prays for someone, or reads to them, holds a kind of power. The task is to hold it gently.
2. Ask permission, and accept the answer
Before you pray with someone or read to them, ask. Use a plain question that a person can say no to without difficulty.
- "Would you like me to pray with you, or would you rather we just sit?"
- "There is a psalm that has helped some people in hard times. Would you like me to read it, or not now?"
- "Is there a prayer that is yours, a saying or a psalm you know, that you would like said?"
Then do what the person answers. If the answer is "not now," that is not a rejection of you or of God. It may be that the person has no strength for words, or that they are angry at God, or that they do not believe. It may simply be that they need quiet. Your own prayer can go on silently while you sit beside them.
Permission is not asked once and then forgotten. A person who welcomed a prayer an hour ago may find a second one too much. Notice the face, the shoulders, the breath. If in doubt, stop.
Permission also covers how a person likes to pray. Some want to hear a short spoken prayer. Others would rather have a set prayer of their tradition, a , the visit of a priest or minister, a hymn, a candle, the laying on of hands or a moment of silence. Some pray in their own language and not yours. Some would prefer you to pray alone later and not say anything. Ask what would help. You are not the owner of how this is done.
3. A short and plain prayer
If the person agrees, keep it short. A long, eloquent prayer places the helper at the centre. A short, plain one keeps the person at the centre.
(an invented example) "God, you know how heavy this is for Marisol tonight. Be near her. Give her rest, and help to take the next step. Amen."
A good prayer in a crisis is usually one or two sentences. It names the person and the heaviness in simple words. It does not tell the person what they ought to feel. It does not repeat the story. It does not instruct God what to fix. And it does not conclude with a lesson for the listener.
Three ways a prayer can do harm:
- It explains. "Lord, help her to see that this is part of your plan." The person has just been told that their pain has a purpose, and they were not asked.
- It preaches. "Lord, forgive her for forgetting you." The person has just been told they have sinned, and they were not asked.
- It ends the conversation. "Amen. Well, I must go." The prayer has been used as an exit.
Praying quietly, in your own heart, while the person speaks is also a form of prayer. Many caregivers find that this does more good than spoken words and does less harm.
4. Scripture: offered, not thrown
Scripture is not a weapon. A verse flung at a person in crisis, however true, can wound. Paul's encouragement not to be anxious (Philippians 4:6) was written in a letter to friends, and it is often said, without gentleness, to someone whose anxiety is part of a hard situation. The result is not peace but guilt.
Three habits guard against this.
Let the person lead. If the person asks for a verse, or mentions one, read it and sit with it. If not, hold the verses in your own mind, and let them shape how you listen rather than what you say.
Prefer the Psalms of the sufferer. The Bible gives suffering people their own words: complaint, pleading, fear and, sometimes, a turn to trust that arrives slowly. Reading a psalm of lament with someone says: your feeling is allowed here, and others have said it to God before you. Offer the psalm as company and not as a solution.
Do not use a verse to end a feeling. If the verse is followed by "so you see, there is nothing to worry about," it has become a tool. A verse is better received if it leaves the person free to say, "That does not help me today."
5. Lament: giving words to the speechless
Lament is prayer that includes pain. It says to God: this is not right, how long, why, where are you? Many of the Psalms are of this kind, and the prophets and Job are full of it. Lament has no need to reach a neat ending. Some laments end in trust and some in darkness.
Many believers, especially those taught that faith always looks cheerful, do not know that this kind of prayer is permitted. A caregiver can give permission by saying so: "You are allowed to say all of this to God. The Psalms do." A person who has felt that anger or despair were forbidden to bring to prayer can be released by this alone.
Elijah, in the story we read in lecture 2-1, is another picture. He told God he had had enough, under a tree, and God's response was not a lecture but bread and sleep. The care came first, and the conversation later. A caregiver who prays beside someone in despair does well to imitate that order.
6. The person who cannot pray, or does not wish to
Some people in crisis cannot pray, because they have lost the words, or the feeling, or the trust. Some are angry at God. Some do not believe, and some belong to another faith. A caregiver must be careful not to take any of these as a sign of a person's worth.
If the person says "I cannot pray," a reply might be: "That is all right. I can hold the prayer for you for a while." If the person says "Where was God?", do not answer quickly. Lecture 4-4 returns to this question at length. For now, it is enough to stay, to say that the question is allowed, and not to offer a defence of God on the spot.
If a person is of another faith or none, do not pray in a way that requires them to join. Ask what would be a comfort, and offer presence first.
7. This is a point where readers will not agree
This is a point where readers will not agree: what place prayer and Scripture should have when someone is in a crisis.
Some hold that prayer and the Word are the heart of Christian care, and that a caregiver who holds them back is withholding the best that the church has. On this view a believer in trouble needs to hear God's promises, and a caregiver who is shy of them has misunderstood their own task. Faith is not an extra to be brought in afterwards.
Others hold that practical safety and professional help must come first, and spiritual resources afterwards. On this view, a person who is in danger, or who needs medical or psychological care, is harmed by anything that delays it, and prayer offered in place of a call can cost a person their safety or their recovery. The spiritual help is real, but it follows.
Others hold that the person's own wish should decide. On this view the caregiver neither imposes nor withholds. Some people want a prayer; some want silence; some want a verse; some want none of it. The caregiver follows, and offers.
Each of these positions has a good reason behind it. The first protects the church from becoming a mere agency. The second protects the person from harm. The third protects the person's freedom. This course requires less than any of them asks. It requires only that you ask permission, never force prayer or Scripture on a person, and never let prayer or Scripture stand in for professional help or emergency services. Within that, traditions will differ about what a good prayer looks like, whether a sacrament is offered, who may pray aloud, and how much Scripture is read. The course does not rank those differences. A priest offering a sacrament, an laying on hands, a believer lighting a candle, a reading a psalm and a friend sitting in silence can all keep to the requirement.
8. What prayer and Scripture do not do
Prayer does not remove the need to check safety. It does not remove the need to call emergency services. It does not replace a doctor, a counsellor or a crisis line. It does not prove that a person is well. And it must not be said or implied that someone who does not recover quickly has prayed badly or believes too little.
When a caregiver prays and then also connects the person to professional help, there is no contradiction. The two belong together. Many believers hold that God works through the skill of those who are trained to help. A caregiver can say this plainly: "I will keep praying, and I would also like us to reach someone trained to help with this. Would that be all right?"
9. Three settings
(an invented example) A one-person church far from services. Pastor Isaiah leads a congregation of twelve in a mountain village. A woman in the church, Folasade, has just had terrible news by telephone. Isaiah has no colleague nearby. He asks her, "Would you like me to pray, or would you like to sit?" She says to sit. He sits and prays silently. After a while she asks him to read a psalm. He reads one short psalm and stops. Later he asks whether she wants him to call her sister in the next town. He has the number of the regional help line for emergencies on his wall, which he researched in advance, and he tells Folasade where it is, in case she needs it.
(an invented example) A hospital chaplaincy volunteer in a large city. Lucia, a volunteer, is asked by a nurse to sit with a frightened relative in a corridor. Lucia asks whether the man would like a prayer. He says he would not, and says he is not a believer. She says, "Then I will just sit with you." She does. Later, the man asks her whether she would say something at the bedside. She agrees, and asks what words he would like, and he gives her three.
(an invented example) A parish in an immigrant community. Fr. Dimitri visits a member who speaks little of the local language. He asks, through a relative, whether the member would like prayers in her mother tongue. She would. He says the set prayer from his tradition, slowly. He does not add commentary. At the end he asks whether he may call the family doctor with her, and she nods.
10. A small practice
A helpful rule for any caregiver is the order ask, offer, follow, stay.
- Ask: "Would you like a prayer or a reading?"
- Offer: one or two sentences, in the person's language and tradition if you can.
- Follow: stop if the person tires or looks uneasy. Do not add a second prayer.
- Stay: the prayer ends, and you are still there.
Diagram 1. Ask, offer, follow, stay
Diagram 2. Three positions, one requirement
In short
- Ask permission before praying or reading Scripture with a person in crisis, and accept "not now" without offence.
- A good prayer is short and plain, keeps the person at the centre, and does not explain, preach or end the conversation.
- Scripture is offered, not thrown; the Psalms of the sufferer give company and not a quick remedy.
- Lament gives words to those who have none, and a caregiver can say that it is allowed.
- Readers differ on whether prayer or practical help comes first; this course requires permission and that prayer never replaces professional help.
- Pray alongside connecting a person to help, not instead.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Ask, offer, follow, stay | Ask permission, offer one or two plain sentences, stop if the person tires, and remain after the prayer. |
| Three harms in prayer | It explains, it preaches, or it is used to end the conversation. |
| Lament | Prayer that includes pain, complaint and "how long?"; the Psalms give it to sufferers as company. |
| The course's requirement | Ask permission, never force, and never let prayer or Scripture stand in for professional help. |
One sentence to remember Ask first, pray short, stay after, and call for help as well.
This week's action Write down, in your own words, the sentence you would use to ask permission to pray, and say it aloud to a trusted friend.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- When have prayer or a Scripture verse comforted you in hard times? When have they landed badly, and what was the difference?
- How would you ask permission to pray in your tradition and language, so that "no" would be easy to say?
- Which of the three ways a prayer can do harm (explaining, preaching, ending the conversation) do you most need to watch in yourself?
- What does your community do with lament? Is there room for the prayer that says "how long?"
- Which of the three positions in the "readers will not agree" paragraph is closest to your own, and what does the strongest form of one of the others say to it?