FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

PT720E Crisis, Trauma and Suicide Prevention: Standing Beside, Staying Safe, Connecting to Help

Lecture 3-2: Asking Directly: The Basic Questions

Contents 31
PT720E Crisis, Trauma and Suicide Prevention: Standing Beside, Staying Safe, Connecting to Help
Chapter 0 · Introduction: Beside, Not Instead
  1. Lecture 0: Introduction: Beside, Not Instead
Chapter 1 · Week 1: Standing Beside
  1. Lecture 1-1: What a Crisis Is and What a Church Can Do
  2. Lecture 1-2: People in Crisis in Scripture, and God's Nearness
  3. Lecture 1-3: The Caregiver's Own Steadiness and Safety
  4. Lecture 1-4: Preparing Before It Happens
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: A Readiness Sheet
Chapter 2 · Week 2: First Response
  1. Lecture 2-1: Safety First and Steadying
  2. Lecture 2-2: Listening, and Words to Leave Unsaid
  3. Lecture 2-3: Prayer and Scripture Beside Someone
  4. Lecture 2-4: Differences in How Crisis Is Shown: Culture, Age, Setting
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Reading and Rewriting a Conversation
Chapter 3 · Week 3: Asking About Danger
  1. Lecture 3-1: Warning Signs and Common Myths
  2. Lecture 3-2: Asking Directly: The Basic Questions
  3. Lecture 3-3: General Principles of a Safety Plan
  4. Lecture 3-4: Staying With Someone: Presence, Handover and Follow-Up
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Practising the Question
Chapter 4 · Week 4: Trauma and Care That Avoids Further Harm
  1. Lecture 4-1: How People React to Overwhelming Events
  2. Lecture 4-2: Safety, Choice and Trust
  3. Lecture 4-3: Avoiding Further Harm in Church Life
  4. Lecture 4-4: Faith, Trauma and "Where Was God"
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: A Check of Our Practices
Chapter 5 · Week 5: Suicide Prevention and Those Left Behind
  1. Lecture 5-1: Beyond Stigma
  2. Lecture 5-2: Speaking Responsibly: Sermons, Prayers, Notices and Posts
  3. Lecture 5-3: After a Death by Suicide: Beside the Family
  4. Lecture 5-4: The Congregation as a Whole: Community After a Loss and Ongoing Prevention
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Checking What We Say
Chapter 6 · Week 6: Referral and Connection
  1. Lecture 6-1: Whom to Connect, and When
  2. Lecture 6-2: A Warm Referral
  3. Lecture 6-3: Confidentiality, Records and Its Limits
  4. Lecture 6-4: Caring for Caregivers and Learning After
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab: A One-Page Crisis Response Plan

Jump to the key points ↓

26 min

Lecture 3-1 ended with a caregiver who has noticed, gone near and decided not to carry the worry alone. This lecture is about the moment of the question. For most people it is the hardest moment in the whole course. The words feel too large. The fear is that the question will do harm, or that the answer will be more than the caregiver can bear.

The aim here is small. It is to give you a few calm, plain sentences, to say what comes next whichever answer you hear, and to be honest about what is not your job. Your job is not to finish an assessment. Your job is to ask, to stay, and to connect the person to people who are trained.

This lecture is not treatment and gives no diagnosis, medical advice or professional help. It does not replace professional care, and you must not use any question here to label or rate a person. Rules, services and reporting systems differ by country and region.

What these 26 minutes give you

  • Say, in your own plain words, a calm and clear question that asks whether a person is thinking of ending their life.
  • Describe what to say and do when the answer is yes, including the three basic questions about how close the danger is.
  • Explain why the caregiver does not ask for, or accept, any detail of how, and what to say instead.
  • Describe what to do when the answer is no.
  • State fairly where readers differ on how directly to ask, and what this course requires.

While they talked and questioned together, Jesus himself came near, and went with them." — Luke 24:15

World English Bible

He said to them, “What are you talking about as you walk, and are sad?”" — Luke 24:17

WEB

Counsel in the heart of man is like deep water; but a man of understanding will draw it out." — Proverbs 20:5

WEB

Jesus asked him, “What do you want me to do for you?” The blind man said to him, “Rabboni, that I may see again.”" — Mark 10:51

WEB

On the road to Emmaus the risen Jesus did not begin by explaining. He came near, walked with two people who were sad, and asked what they were talking about. In Mark 10:51 he asks a man who has already called out for help, "What do you want me to do for you?", though the answer might have seemed plain. These verses do not give a method. They show a manner: a question asked from beside a person, with time to hear the answer. Proverbs 20:5 says that what is in a person's heart is like deep water, and that someone with understanding can draw it out. We do not use these verses as a text to quote to a person in distress. They give the caregiver a picture of the posture to hold.

1. Why the question is hard

There are three common fears. The first is that asking will plant the idea; lecture 3-1 took that up. The second is that the caregiver will not know what to do if the answer is yes. The third is that asking is rude, or too forward, or against the way people speak in our community.

Each fear is understandable. The answer to the second is in this lecture and the next two: a yes does not call for a clever reply. It calls for staying and connecting, and you will not be alone in either. The answer to the third is partly a matter of wording and partly something readers disagree on, and we come to it below.

2. The question itself

Before the question, say why you are asking. A plain reason helps the person see that you are not examining them.

"I have noticed that you have not been yourself, and I have been worried about you."

Then ask. Here are some wordings. Choose the one that is yours and that your language and community allow, and practise it aloud until it can be said without a shake.

"Are you thinking about ending your life?"

"Are you having thoughts of suicide?"

"Sometimes when people have been through what you have, they think about not wanting to live. Is that something you have been thinking about?"

Notice what these have in common. They use clear words. They do not hide behind a phrase like "doing something silly" or "hurting yourself" that the person might not take to mean what you mean. They do not lead the person toward the answer you hope for. Compare:

"You are not thinking of doing anything foolish, are you?"

That sentence is not a question; it is a request to say no. A person who is in danger will usually say no to it, and the door will have closed. The better sentence leaves the person free to say yes.

A note on language. Many careful writers on this subject prefer to say "ending one's life", "thoughts of suicide" or "died by suicide", and to avoid words that make it sound like a crime. Use whatever words are used with respect in your language and community. The point is that the person knows exactly what you are asking.

Then do the hardest thing, which is to stop and wait for the answer. Do not rush to fill the silence with reassurance. A long pause may mean the person is deciding whether to trust you.

3. If the answer is yes

First, let your face and voice stay as they are. You are not shocked. Say something like:

"Thank you for telling me. I am glad you did. I am here, and I am staying with you."

Do not argue ("but you have so much to live for"). Do not praise or condemn. Do not say "you must not". Do not pray at once over the person. All of these, however well meant, can make a person feel that they must protect you from what they said. Let them know that they have been heard and that you are not leaving.

Then ask, gently, a few more questions. They are not an examination. Their only purpose is to help you decide how quickly to connect the person to help. There are three.

  1. "Are you thinking about it now, today?" This asks how close the danger is in time.
  2. "Have you made a plan, or begun to prepare?" This asks whether the thought has moved toward action. Ask it in exactly this way. It asks whether, not what or how.
  3. "Do you feel that you might act on it soon?" This asks how the person feels about their own safety.

If the answer to any of these is yes, or the person does not know, or you cannot tell: treat it as immediate danger. Stay with the person, do not leave them alone, and contact emergency services at once. One helper stays and one calls, as in lecture 2-1. Do not wait to finish the conversation, and do not wait for the person's agreement before you call if you believe their life is at risk. Tell the person what you are doing and why, in a quiet voice: "I am for help because I do not want you to be alone with this."

If the answers are clearly no to all three, the person is probably not in immediate danger. That does not mean the matter is small. You should still connect them to a professional or a crisis line the same day, and not leave them alone with the day's worry. Lecture 3-3 explains how.

If you are unsure what an answer means, then it is not for you to decide. Treat uncertainty as a reason to act, not a reason to wait.

4. What the caregiver does not ask

Do not ask for any detail of how. A caregiver does not ask what the person has thought of doing, with what, where or when. There are two reasons. The first is that you do not need to know in order to do the right thing, which is to stay and connect. The second is that talking in detail about a way of harming oneself can make it more vivid to the person and to you, and does no good. If the person begins to describe it, gently turn the conversation:

"You do not need to tell me the details. What matters to me is that you are safe, and I want to get help to you."

Say this without a rebuke. It is not a reproach; it is a way of keeping the conversation on the thing that helps.

Do not promise to keep it secret. A person may ask you, "Promise you will not tell anyone." You cannot promise this, and you should not pretend that you can. When a life may be in danger, some promises cannot be kept. You can promise something else: "I will not tell anyone who does not need to know, and I will tell you first before I do." Confidentiality and its limits are taken up in week 6, and the counselling-ethics course gives them fuller treatment. Rules differ by country, region and church policy; check locally.

Do not try to treat or diagnose. You are not deciding what is wrong with the person. You are not offering a technique. You are not weighing whether they "mean it". Lecture 3-1 said it already: that is a trained person's work.

5. If the answer is no

Sometimes the person says, "No, I am not thinking of that. I am just tired." Believe them, and do not press. But do not hurry away, either.

"Thank you for telling me. I'm glad it's not that. I'm still worried about you, and I'd like to stay in touch. Can I come by again on Thursday?"

A "no" is not the end of care. The person is still carrying whatever you noticed, and may be more open next time. Name what you saw and offer to stay in contact. Let them know that if the thought ever comes, you are someone they can tell. Then keep your word and check back. If you are still worried, speak with the pastor or the person your community has named, and consider whether another kind of help, such as a doctor or a counsellor, might be right for the difficulty the person has described. A later lecture takes up how to make such a suggestion.

6. An example, before and after

(an invented example) Return to Bram, whom Yetunde and Gwen visited in lecture 3-1. Here is a first version of the conversation, in which things go wrong.

Gwen: You said something on Sunday about managing without you. Bram: Did I? I was joking. Gwen: Of course. You are not thinking of doing anything silly, are you? Bram: No, no. Nothing like that. Gwen: Good. You have so much to be thankful for. Let's pray and put it in God's hands.

Bram has said no because the question was built to be answered with no. The visit ends with a prayer and a door closing quietly.

Here is a second version, which is closer to what Yetunde and Gwen did.

Yetunde: I have been thinking about what you said on Sunday. I have been worried about you. Bram: I did not think anyone had heard it. Yetunde: I heard it. Can I ask you something plainly? Are you thinking about ending your life? (a long silence) Bram: Yes. Sometimes. Yetunde: Thank you for telling me. I am glad you did. I am staying right here with you. (she waits) Yetunde: Are you thinking about it now, today? Bram: Not today. I do not think so. Yetunde: Have you made a plan, or begun to get ready? Bram: I... have thought about it. I do not want to say. Yetunde: You do not have to tell me any details. What matters is that you are safe, and I want to get help to you. Do you feel that you might act on it soon? Bram: I do not know.

Here the caregiver does not argue and does not ask for detail. She also hears "I do not know" for what it is: a reason to treat the matter as immediate. Gwen stays with Bram. Yetunde steps into the passage and contacts emergency services by the route written in the church's list. When she returns she tells Bram what she has done and why. What happens next, and how Bram is handed to trained people, is the subject of lecture 3-4.

7. The same question in other places

(an invented example) A youth group in a small parish. A leader, Ilse, runs a Friday group of eight teenagers with a volunteer, Rafael. One girl, who has been quiet for weeks, sends Ilse a late message that says only, "I can't do this any more." Ilse does not answer by text with advice. She replies that she is glad the girl wrote, and asks if she can phone or visit with Rafael in the morning. Then she speaks with the parish priest at once, because a young person is involved and the parish has a written policy on how to speak with parents and who must be told. The next day she asks the question plainly and calmly, in a place where two adults are present and the room is open to view. She will need to follow the policy for talking with a young person, with the parents and with the church's safeguarding person; the safe church course covers all of that.

(an invented example) A fishing village with no resident minister. A lay leader, Hanneke, who leads the village's Sunday gathering, is told by a neighbour that an older man has stopped leaving his house. She goes with a second person. She knows the question will feel strange to say in a village where such words are rarely spoken, so she begins as she would on any visit, and in time says, in the dialect that she and the man share: "I am worried that things have got so heavy that you have thought of ending your life. Have you?" She has already written on a card, in the front of her Bible, how to reach the clinic in the nearest town, the person in the village who has a vehicle, and the way to reach emergency services. She had put it there months before.

In all three places the question is the same, the posture is the same, and the aim is the same: ask, stay, connect.

8. Where readers will not agree

This is a point where readers will not agree. Some hold that the right way is to ask directly and plainly, in clear words, as soon as there is a reason to wonder. They point to the guidance of widely used prevention programmes, which advises this, and to the cost of a vague question that the person can easily brush aside. Others hold that in many communities the plain word is heavy, even shaming, and that it is wiser to approach gently and indirectly first: to ask how heavy things have become, whether the person feels worn out or has wished it would all stop, and only then to name the thing. Some of them add that tact is a form of respect and that a question that humiliates helps nobody. A third view holds that the question is for trained people only, and that an untrained caregiver should pass any such worry to a professional or a prevention body without asking. This view is held out of care, not cowardice: the fear is that an untrained person will say the wrong thing.

Each has something true. The first has the support of guidance in many countries, which says that asking directly does not plant the idea and that vague questions often fail. The second knows that a question lands in a person, a language and a community. The third knows that the caregiver is not a professional and must not behave as one.

What this course requires is less than any of these demands. If you fear that someone is thinking of ending their life, ask calmly and plainly, in words the person will clearly understand. If your community's custom makes you begin gently, begin gently, but do not stop at a gentle hint that leaves the person unsure what you are asking. Do not carry it alone. Whatever answer you hear, connect the person to professionals or emergency services, and do not walk away. Widely used prevention guidance advises asking directly; check what your own national prevention body says, since the guidance is written for the services and rules where you live.

9. Who should be there

Where possible, ask in a place that is private but not hidden, with a second person nearby or aware. This protects the person and the caregiver. It does not mean a crowd. For a young person or a person who is vulnerable, the community's written policy on how adults meet them applies, and the safe church course covers it. If you are afraid, say so beforehand to a trusted colleague: it is better to ask while trembling than to not ask.


Diagram 1. The question and the road that follows

Ask, stay, connect Your job is not to finish an assessment Say why you are asking, then ask plainly "I have been worried about you. Are you thinking about ending your life?" Then wait. If YES Thank them. Stay. Do not argue or judge. Ask: Is it now, today? Ask: Is there a plan or preparation? (whether, never how) Ask: Might you act on it soon? Any yes or "I do not know": treat as danger now. If NO Believe them. Do not press. Name what you saw; say you are still worried. Offer to stay in touch and keep your word. Say they can tell you if the thought comes. A no is not the end of care. Danger now or unsure Stay with the person; do not leave them alone. One stays, one contacts emergency services at once. Not close, but still yes Connect to a professional or a crisis line the same day, from your researched list (lecture 3-3). Never ask for how, with what, where or when. Say: "You do not need to tell me the details." Never promise secrecy. Not treatment, not diagnosis, not a finished assessment. You are not alone in this: connect, and do not walk away.

Diagram 2. A question that can be answered yes, and one that cannot

Two ways to ask the same thing One leaves the person free to say yes. One asks for a no. Asks for a no "You are not thinking of doing anything silly, are you?" Vague words, built to be answered no. The door closes quietly. Leaves room for yes "I have been worried about you. Are you thinking about ending your life?" Clear words, a reason given, then a pause. The person is free to answer truly. Practise your own wording aloud until it can be said calmly.

In short

  • Say why you are asking, ask plainly in clear words, and then wait for the answer.
  • If the answer is yes, stay and thank the person; ask whether it is now, whether there is a plan or preparation, and whether they might act soon.
  • Any yes, or "I do not know", is treated as danger now: stay with the person and contact emergency services at once.
  • Never ask for, or accept, detail of how, with what, where or when; say "You do not need to tell me the details."
  • Do not promise secrecy; the caregiver's job is to connect, not to finish an assessment.
  • If the answer is no, believe the person, stay in touch and keep your word.
Front Back
The basic question A reason given, then a plain question: "Are you thinking about ending your life?" and a pause.
Three questions after a yes Is it now? Is there a plan or preparation (whether, never how)? Might you act soon?
Any yes or "I do not know" Treat it as danger now: stay, do not leave the person alone, and contact emergency services at once.
What the caregiver never asks Any detail of how, with what, where or when; never promise secrecy.

One sentence to remember Ask plainly, stay beside, and connect; do not try to finish the assessment yourself.

This week's action Write down the sentence you would use to ask the question, say it aloud three times, and say it to a trusted colleague.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • Which of the three fears (planting the idea, not knowing what to do after a yes, being rude or forward) weighs most with you? What in this lecture answers it, and what does not?
  • Why does the lecture say that "You are not thinking of doing anything foolish, are you?" is not a question? What would you say instead, in your own language?
  • Why does the caregiver ask *whether* there is a plan or preparation, and never *what* or *how*? What might go wrong if the caregiver asked for detail?
  • How should the direct, the gentle-first and the trained-only views each shape the way a church trains its caregivers? What does this course require beyond them?
  • How would the first sentence of the question change in a very small church far from services, and in a large church with many helpers? What stays the same?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.