Lecture 4-2: Safety, Choice and Trust
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: What a Crisis Is and What a Church Can Do
- Lecture 1-2: People in Crisis in Scripture, and God's Nearness
- Lecture 1-3: The Caregiver's Own Steadiness and Safety
- Lecture 1-4: Preparing Before It Happens
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: A Readiness Sheet
- Lecture 2-1: Safety First and Steadying
- Lecture 2-2: Listening, and Words to Leave Unsaid
- Lecture 2-3: Prayer and Scripture Beside Someone
- Lecture 2-4: Differences in How Crisis Is Shown: Culture, Age, Setting
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Reading and Rewriting a Conversation
- Lecture 3-1: Warning Signs and Common Myths
- Lecture 3-2: Asking Directly: The Basic Questions
- Lecture 3-3: General Principles of a Safety Plan
- Lecture 3-4: Staying With Someone: Presence, Handover and Follow-Up
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Practising the Question
- Lecture 4-1: How People React to Overwhelming Events
- Lecture 4-2: Safety, Choice and Trust
- Lecture 4-3: Avoiding Further Harm in Church Life
- Lecture 4-4: Faith, Trauma and "Where Was God"
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: A Check of Our Practices
- Lecture 5-1: Beyond Stigma
- Lecture 5-2: Speaking Responsibly: Sermons, Prayers, Notices and Posts
- Lecture 5-3: After a Death by Suicide: Beside the Family
- Lecture 5-4: The Congregation as a Whole: Community After a Loss and Ongoing Prevention
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Checking What We Say
An overwhelming event takes something away from a person: the sense of being safe, of having a say in what happens, and of being able to trust what comes next. A good deal of care for a person afterwards, therefore, is a matter of giving those three things back in small, ordinary ways, and of not taking them away again by accident. The caregiver does this by how she or he behaves, much more than by anything she or he says.
This lecture sets out four principles for a church caregiver: safety first, choice returned, things predictable, and no pressure to tell the story. It also says what to do when a caregiver suspects that a person is being harmed or has been harmed by someone, which is a different matter from a general kindness.
This course gives no diagnosis, treatment, medication or medical advice, and it does not replace professional care. It teaches how a caregiver avoids adding to the harm. It does not teach how to treat the effects of an event. This lecture is also not legal advice: reporting rules, child and vulnerable-person protection and church policy differ by country, region and church, so check locally.
What these 20 minutes give you
- Explain why safety, choice, predictability and privacy matter to a person after an overwhelming event.
- Offer a person real choices in small matters such as place, company, timing and touch.
- Explain why a caregiver does not press for the story and does not make a person repeat it.
- Describe what to do when a person tells you something that suggests abuse or violence, without investigating it yourself.
God is our refuge and strength, a very present help in trouble." — Psalm 46:1 (World English Bible) "A friend loves at all times; and a brother is born for adversity." — Proverbs 17:17 (WEB) "a time to tear, and a time to sew; a time to keep silence, and a time to speak;" — Ecclesiastes 3:7 (WEB) "“Come to me, all you who labor and are heavily burdened, and I will give you rest." — Matthew 11:28
WEB
Psalm 46:1 speaks of refuge, which is first of all a place of safety. Proverbs 17:17 describes a friend who is there in adversity. Ecclesiastes 3:7 names a time to keep silence and a time to speak, and a caregiver learns which is which by watching the person, not the clock. Matthew 11:28 is an invitation, and an invitation leaves the other person free to come. These verses are not given here to be recited to anyone. They describe the kind of company this lecture asks a caregiver to be.
Safety first
Before anything else: is the person safe now? Lecture 2-1 gave four checks (place, people, consciousness, body). A further question belongs here. Is the person safe from the people and circumstances around them? Someone may be living with the person who harmed them. A child may be in a home that is not safe. A person may have been threatened. No other kind of care works until this is settled.
If you think a person is in danger now, stay with them and contact emergency services at once. If the danger is not immediate but real, the next step is protection: a safe place to be, a trusted adult, and the people whose work is protection. Do not try to resolve a situation of harm by yourself, by talking to the person causing it, by arranging a meeting, or by promising that you will keep everything secret.
There is also a gentler sense of safety, the felt kind. A person can be out of danger and still not feel safe. A room with a closed door, a dark church, a crowd, a loud sound or an unexpected touch can bring fear back. A caregiver cannot always know what will do this. So the caregiver gives the person ways to feel safer without asking why.
Choice returned
Overwhelming events often leave a person with the feeling that things happen to them and that what they want does not count. A caregiver can begin to give back a say, in small things first, by asking and by accepting the answer.
(an invented example) Stefan has been visiting Thandiwe, whom we met in lecture 4-1. He does not say, "Come to my office on Thursday." He says: "I would like to see you, if you would like that. Would you prefer to meet at the church, at your home, in the market, or by phone? Would you like someone else with you? You can change your mind." He lets her choose the day, the place, the length and the chair. When she says she would rather not meet at the church, he does not ask why.
Choices a caregiver can offer:
- Whether to talk at all. "We can talk, or we can just sit."
- Place. Somewhere the person is comfortable. For many people an open, ordinary and visible place is better than a closed office. The door open, or a window, or a seat near the exit, can help. Offer; do not assume.
- Company. Whether someone else is present, and who. A caregiver should usually not be alone with the person in a closed room (lecture 1-3). Two people from the team, or a person the one cared for names, often work well.
- Timing and length. "We can stop whenever you say."
- Touch. Ask before any touch, including a hand on the shoulder, a hug, laying on of hands, or a blessing. A person who flinched yesterday may welcome it today, or the reverse. "May I?" is a complete sentence.
- Prayer and Scripture. Lecture 2-3: ask permission; accept a no.
- Who else is told. See privacy, below.
Choice does not mean leaving the person alone with every decision. A person who is overwhelmed may say "I do not care, you decide." Then the caregiver makes a modest proposal and says that it can be changed. The aim is to keep the door open to choice, not to demand it.
Predictability
A person after an overwhelming event may be watchful, alert for anything unexpected. A caregiver helps by being predictable.
- Say what you will do before you do it: "I will phone on Tuesday afternoon." Then do it.
- Say how long a visit will take, and stop on time.
- Do not turn up unannounced. Do not change the arrangement without notice.
- Tell the person what will happen next in any process: who will come, what they will ask, what will be written down.
- Do not make promises you cannot keep. A small promise kept is worth more than a large one broken. Trust is rebuilt by a number of small kept promises.
Do not press for the story
This is the point caregivers find hardest.
When someone seems to be carrying something heavy, the urge to ask "What happened?" is strong. It comes from care. But a caregiver does not need the story to care for the person, and pressing for it can do harm.
Why pressing harms:
- The person may not be ready. Telling can bring the event back with force, and the caregiver is not trained to help the person through that.
- A person pressed may say more than they wish, then feel exposed, and may avoid the caregiver afterwards.
- It tells the person that what matters is the information and not themselves.
- The caregiver's own wish to understand, or to be useful, may be the real reason for asking.
What to do instead:
- Make clear that there is no need to tell. "You do not have to tell me anything. I would like to keep you company."
- Make clear that telling is also possible, at the person's own time. "If you ever want to tell someone, I will listen. If you would rather tell someone else, I will help you find them."
- If the person chooses to tell, listen. Do not ask for more detail than they offer. Do not ask "why", "how could that happen" or "why did you not...". Do not show shock or disgust. Thank them for trusting you. Ask what they would like to happen next.
- If the person starts to tell and then stops, let them stop. Do not go back to it.
Do not make a person repeat it. Every telling costs something. If more people need to know (for example, a professional, or a person responsible for protection), ask the person's permission, say who needs to know and why, and pass on only what is needed, so that the person does not have to go through it again with each new helper. Lecture 6-3 returns to this. Do not discuss with others, in the church or outside it, what you have been told.
Privacy
A person should be able to expect that what they have shared stays between the right people. In a small community, where everyone knows everyone, this is hard, and so it deserves thought.
- Do not speak about the person in the prayer meeting, the leaders' meeting, the women's or men's group or the youth group without their agreement, even with good intentions.
- Do not give details in a prayer request, a message group or a report, even when you leave the name out. In a small church people will guess.
- Keep any notes minimal and safe (lecture 6-3).
- Some promises cannot be kept. If a person tells you something that means someone is in danger, you may have to tell, and you should never promise secrecy beforehand. Rules differ by country, region and church (check locally). Lecture 6-3 and the counselling-ethics course cover this.
When a person tells you of abuse or violence
Sometimes a caregiver is told, or comes to suspect, that a person is being harmed by someone, or was harmed in the past, whether by a person in the family, in the church or elsewhere. This is not a communication matter or a pastoral matter alone. It is a matter of protection, and law and policy apply. Here is the minimum.
- Protection comes first. If anyone is in danger now, stay with the person and contact emergency services.
- Listen, and do not investigate. Listen to what the person chooses to say. Do not ask for detail, do not cross-examine, do not question a child, do not ask a second person to confirm.
- Do not confront the person accused. Do not arrange a meeting between the one harmed and the one accused. Do not ask the one harmed to forgive, and do not suggest that the church will "sort it out."
- Do not promise secrecy. Say honestly that you may need to tell people whose work is to protect them, and that you will tell the person first (lecture 6-3).
- Follow your church's written policy and local law. A church should have a written policy on abuse and protection before it is needed. Where a child or vulnerable adult is involved, there may be a legal duty to report. Check locally. The safe church course teaches this in full.
- Do not carry it alone. Tell the person in your church or organisation who is responsible for protection, or your senior leader, or a professional, as the policy says.
- Stay beside the person afterwards. The report is not the end. Keep visiting, keep your word and keep the person informed.
If your church has no written policy, that is itself a matter to raise with your leaders now, not after the day it is needed.
Small and large communities
(an invented example) Hillfoot Gospel Hall is a church of about twenty people. It has no policy, no office and one pastor, who is also a farmer. When a member's teenage daughter hints to a youth leader that something is wrong at home, the youth leader knows only two things: not to question her and not to promise secrecy. He tells her that he is glad she told him and that he must talk to someone who can help. The same evening he tells the pastor, who phones a senior leader in the regional body of the church and the local authority responsible for protection, as the regional body's guidance says. The church had no written policy, but the pastor had once been given a one-page guide. The next month the church wrote its own.
At the other end, a large parish with a safeguarding officer, a written procedure and trained volunteers follows the same steps, in the same order, but the officer takes the report and the volunteer does not have to decide alone. In both churches the person is told what will happen before it happens.
What this looks like in words
A pressing invitation, and a respectful one:
| Pressing | Respectful |
|---|---|
| "Tell me everything. I can only help if I know." | "You do not have to tell me anything. I would like to keep you company." |
| "Come to my office tomorrow." | "Would you like to meet? You choose where and when." |
| (reaching to hug the person) | "May I?" |
| "I'll tell the elders so they can pray." | "Would you like me to ask anyone else to pray, and what would you like them to know?" |
| "I promise I will tell nobody." | "I will keep this private as far as I can. If someone is in danger, I may need to tell people who can help, and I will tell you first." |
4-1. Four things to give back
4-2. When you suspect abuse or violence
In short
- Care after an overwhelming event restores safety, choice, predictability and privacy, mainly by how the caregiver behaves.
- Offer real choices in place, company, timing, touch and prayer, and ask "May I?" before any touch.
- A caregiver does not need the story, does not press for it, and does not make a person repeat it.
- If a person tells of abuse or violence, protect first, listen without investigating, promise no secrecy and follow written policy and local law.
- Do not confront the one accused, and do not press the one harmed toward reconciliation.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Four things to give back | Safety, choice, predictability, and no pressure to tell the story. |
| Before any touch | Ask: "May I?" A person may accept today what they refused yesterday. |
| Why not press for the story | You do not need it to care; pressing can harm, and each retelling costs something. |
| If a person tells of harm | Protect, listen without investigating, promise no secrecy, follow written policy and local law, stay beside. |
One sentence to remember Give back safety and choice, and do not ask for the story.
This week's action Ask whether your community has a written policy on what to do when someone tells of harm, and if it does not, name one person who could draft it.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Which of the four things (safety, choice, predictability, a say over the story) does your community give most readily, and which least?
- Think of the places where your community cares for people: an office, a home, a hall. Which of them let a person choose where to sit and how to leave?
- Why is "May I?" so hard to say for some caregivers, and what could make it ordinary?
- In a small community where everyone knows everyone, what practical steps protect a person's privacy?
- Does your community have a written policy for what to do when someone tells of harm? If not, who could begin it?