FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

PT720E Crisis, Trauma and Suicide Prevention: Standing Beside, Staying Safe, Connecting to Help

Lecture 2-2: Listening, and Words to Leave Unsaid

Contents 31
PT720E Crisis, Trauma and Suicide Prevention: Standing Beside, Staying Safe, Connecting to Help
Chapter 0 · Introduction: Beside, Not Instead
  1. Lecture 0: Introduction: Beside, Not Instead
Chapter 1 · Week 1: Standing Beside
  1. Lecture 1-1: What a Crisis Is and What a Church Can Do
  2. Lecture 1-2: People in Crisis in Scripture, and God's Nearness
  3. Lecture 1-3: The Caregiver's Own Steadiness and Safety
  4. Lecture 1-4: Preparing Before It Happens
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: A Readiness Sheet
Chapter 2 · Week 2: First Response
  1. Lecture 2-1: Safety First and Steadying
  2. Lecture 2-2: Listening, and Words to Leave Unsaid
  3. Lecture 2-3: Prayer and Scripture Beside Someone
  4. Lecture 2-4: Differences in How Crisis Is Shown: Culture, Age, Setting
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Reading and Rewriting a Conversation
Chapter 3 · Week 3: Asking About Danger
  1. Lecture 3-1: Warning Signs and Common Myths
  2. Lecture 3-2: Asking Directly: The Basic Questions
  3. Lecture 3-3: General Principles of a Safety Plan
  4. Lecture 3-4: Staying With Someone: Presence, Handover and Follow-Up
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Practising the Question
Chapter 4 · Week 4: Trauma and Care That Avoids Further Harm
  1. Lecture 4-1: How People React to Overwhelming Events
  2. Lecture 4-2: Safety, Choice and Trust
  3. Lecture 4-3: Avoiding Further Harm in Church Life
  4. Lecture 4-4: Faith, Trauma and "Where Was God"
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: A Check of Our Practices
Chapter 5 · Week 5: Suicide Prevention and Those Left Behind
  1. Lecture 5-1: Beyond Stigma
  2. Lecture 5-2: Speaking Responsibly: Sermons, Prayers, Notices and Posts
  3. Lecture 5-3: After a Death by Suicide: Beside the Family
  4. Lecture 5-4: The Congregation as a Whole: Community After a Loss and Ongoing Prevention
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Checking What We Say
Chapter 6 · Week 6: Referral and Connection
  1. Lecture 6-1: Whom to Connect, and When
  2. Lecture 6-2: A Warm Referral
  3. Lecture 6-3: Confidentiality, Records and Its Limits
  4. Lecture 6-4: Caring for Caregivers and Learning After
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab: A One-Page Crisis Response Plan

Jump to the key points ↓

20 min

When safety has been checked and help is on its way, or when there is no immediate danger, what a caregiver says matters. Most people who help in a crisis do not fail by saying nothing. They fail by saying too much, and by saying the wrong things in a kind voice. A sentence meant to comfort can leave a person feeling judged, hurried or alone.

This lecture teaches two things: how to listen without judging, and which common sentences to leave unsaid. It then shows one conversation twice, before and after, so that the difference can be heard.

This course gives no diagnosis, treatment, medication or medical advice, and it does not replace professional care. Listening is not therapy, and you must not use what a person says to label them. The aim is to be a safe person to speak to, and then to connect the person to the right help.

What these 20 minutes give you

  • Describe what listening without judging involves, including reflecting back and tolerating silence.
  • Name at least five things not to say to a person in crisis, and explain why each one hurts.
  • Replace each of those sentences with something honest and gentle.
  • Explain why Job's friends are a warning and a model at the same time.
  • Say what to do when what you hear frightens you or is beyond what you can hold.

So they sat down with him on the ground seven days and seven nights, and no one spoke a word to him, for they saw that his grief was very great." — Job 2:13

World English Bible

So, then, my beloved brothers, let every man be swift to hear, slow to speak, and slow to anger;" — James 1:19

WEB

He who gives answer before he hears, that is folly and shame to him." — Proverbs 18:13

WEB

Rejoice with those who rejoice. Weep with those who weep." — Romans 12:15

WEB

The first verse shows the friends of Job at their best. They came, they sat on the ground beside him, and for seven days they said nothing, because they saw how great his grief was. Later in the book they speak at length and Job answers that he has heard many such speeches; he calls them wearying comforters (Job 16:2). The sequence is the lesson: presence helped, and explanation hurt. The other three verses point the same way. Hear first, answer afterwards, and stay with the person's feeling instead of correcting it.

1. Listening without judging

Listening is not waiting for your turn. It is giving attention in such a way that the person can say what is true for them, and finds that nothing bad happens when they do. Four habits make this possible.

Give your body to the listening. Turn towards the person. Put the phone away. Sit at the same height. Let your face be calm and your hands still. In some cultures steady eye contact is respectful; in others it is rude or frightening; follow the person's lead (lecture 2-4 returns to this).

Let there be silence. A person in distress often stops, starts again, stops again. The gap feels long to the helper and is usually not long to the person. If you rush in with a question or a verse, you interrupt something that was forming. Count slowly in your head before you speak. Ecclesiastes says there is a time to keep silence and a time to speak; in a crisis the time for silence is longer than most helpers expect.

Reflect back what you hear. Say a short piece of what the person has said, in their own words, and leave it with them. "You have not slept since Tuesday." "You are frightened of going home." "You feel there is no one you can tell." Reflecting does not agree or disagree; it shows that you heard. It also corrects you: the person may say, "No, not frightened, ashamed," and now you both understand better. Do not add interpretation. Do not move from "you said you feel alone" to "so you must be depressed." That would be a label, and the label is not yours to give.

Ask open, gentle questions, and not many. "What is it like right now?" "What would help in the next hour?" "Who would you like with you?" Avoid a string of questions in a row. Avoid "why" questions, which sound like a demand for a defence. Never demand reasons ("Why would you feel like that?" "Why didn't you tell anyone?").

Listening without judging also means listening without correcting. A person may say something untrue or harsh about themselves, about God or about another person. You do not need to argue in the moment. Your task is not to win a point. If what the person says suggests they or someone else is in danger, the next lectures (especially Week 3) show you how to ask and what to do; for now remember that you take every such sentence seriously and do not carry it alone.

2. Words to leave unsaid

Here are some sentences that helpers say often, nearly always with good intentions. For each one, notice what the person is likely to hear, and what you might say instead.

Often said What the person may hear A gentler, honest alternative
"Be strong." "Your feeling is a weakness and I want it to stop." "You do not have to be strong with me."
"Others have it worse." "Your pain is small and you are ungrateful." "This is heavy for you. I am here."
"It is God's will." "God did this, and you must accept it." "I do not know why this has happened. I am sorry, and I am not going anywhere."
"You must have little faith." "You are to blame, even for this." "Your questions are allowed here."
"I know exactly how you feel." "Your experience is the same as mine and I have stopped listening." "I cannot know exactly, but I want to understand. Tell me what you can."
"Why did you let it come to this?" "It was your fault." "Thank you for telling me."
"At least you have..." "Your loss does not count." (Say nothing; stay.)
"Everything happens for a reason." "Your pain has a neat answer, and I have it." "I am sorry. This is not right."
"You should pray more." "You are not doing it correctly." "Would you like me to pray with you, or would you rather sit quietly?"
"Don't cry." "Your tears make me uneasy." "Cry if you need to. I am here."
"It will all be fine." "I am not listening, and I can't promise that." "I do not know how this will turn out. I will help you take the next step."

These sentences belong on a list of things not to say, and we have written them here only so that you can recognise them. Several are not wrong in themselves in every setting; "God is in control" can be a true comfort said by a person to themselves, in their own time. The trouble is that said by a helper to a person in the middle of a crisis, they close a door. They explain when the person needs to be accompanied.

What these sentences have in common is that each one is mostly about the helper. They calm the helper. They give the helper an answer, a way of ending an uncomfortable moment, or a feeling of having done something. A good test, before you speak: Am I about to say this for the person, or for me?

3. Job's friends: a warning and a model

The book of Job offers the best-known picture of what can go wrong, and of what goes right first. For seven days the three friends sat with Job in silence. That is the model: they came, they stayed, they did not rush. When they began to speak, they explained. They told Job his suffering must have a cause that he could find, and that if he repented all would be well. Job answered them with anger, and the book ends with God saying the friends had not spoken rightly.

It would be easy to say "Do not be like Job's friends," and stop there. But the friends are in us. The wish to explain suffering is natural. It makes the world feel ordered. Every helper has to notice the moment when they stop sitting on the ground and begin to say why. The lesson is not that the friends were bad people. It is that they began well and then could not bear the silence.

4. Before and after: one conversation twice

(an invented example) Ngozi leads a youth group in a rented hall in a large city. A seventeen-year-old, Kwame, stays behind after the meeting. His father has told him that morning that the family must move away within the month.

Before.

Kwame: I can't believe it. We have to leave. I haven't even told anyone. Ngozi: Oh, Kwame. Be strong. God has a plan for you in the new place. Kwame: I don't want a plan. Ngozi: I know exactly how you feel. When my family moved I was very upset too, and look at me now. Many young people have it much harder. Kwame: Okay. Ngozi: Why don't you pray about it? You should trust more. Kwame: I have to go.

Ngozi's intention was love. Each sentence closed a door: a plan, a comparison, her own story, a command to pray. Kwame left feeling less heard than when he arrived.

After.

Kwame: I can't believe it. We have to leave. I haven't even told anyone. Ngozi: You have kept this to yourself all day. Kwame: Yes. Ngozi: (waits) Kwame: I don't want to go. Everything is here. Ngozi: Everything is here. Your friends, the group, your school. Kwame: And my grandmother. Who will go and see her? Ngozi: You are worried about her too. Kwame: Yes. (silence) Thank you for sitting here. Ngozi: I am glad you told me. Is there someone you would like me to tell, or someone you would like with you tonight?

Nothing dramatic was said, and no problem was solved. But Kwame was heard, he named what mattered to him and he was asked what he wanted next. Ngozi did not need to say anything wise. (Kwame's distress here is ordinary and sad, not dangerous. If he had said something that frightened Ngozi, her next step would have been to stay, take it seriously and ask plainly, as Week 3 teaches, and to bring in a second person and help from outside.)

5. When what you hear frightens you

Sometimes a person says something that makes your stomach drop: that they cannot go on, that they want to hurt someone, that something terrible was done to them or that they are in danger now. You may feel a pull to fix it at once, or to change the subject. Neither helps.

For now, three things. First, do not promise secrecy. You can say, "I want to help you, and I may need to bring someone else in to do that, but I will tell you first." Lecture 6-3 explains this. Second, do not carry it alone. Tell a second person from your care team, or your pastor or priest, as soon as you can; if there is danger now, contact emergency services. Third, stay with the person, calmly, until you know what the next step is.

How to ask plainly about danger is the subject of Week 3. Abuse and violence call for protection first and then the church's written policy and local law, which the safe church course covers.

6. Three communities, three kinds of listening

(an invented example) A house church of nine people. A woman, Beatriz, tells the leader on the walk home that she has been awake for days. The leader has no office and no care team, but she has a rule: she listens, she does not advise, and she tells her pastor, who lives in the next town, the next morning that she has been in touch with Beatriz and wants to bring in the neighbour who is a nurse. She has asked Beatriz first whether she may.

(an invented example) A parish with a priest and a team of lay visitors. Fr. Tomasz receives a call from a member who is frightened and talking quickly. He does not respond with a prayer or a reason. He says, "I am here. Tell me what is happening, as much as you wish." When the person has said what they can, he asks whether he may come with a second visitor, and says that the visitor will keep what is said to the team only.

(an invented example) A large urban church with a telephone line staffed by trained volunteers. The volunteers have a card by the phone with the words "Listen. Reflect. Ask. Do not argue. Do not diagnose. Connect." They rehearse it twice a year. The card is not a script; it is a reminder of what to leave out.

In all three, the listening was simple, and nobody tried to be a therapist.

7. What listening cannot do

Listening is not a cure. It does not remove the cause of a crisis, and it does not replace professional care. The point of the next lectures, and of Week 6 above all, is that a listener who has made a person feel safe is well placed to say: "I think there are people trained to help with this. Would you let me help you reach them?" That sentence is easier to say, and easier to hear, from someone who has just listened well.


Diagram 1. The listening habits

Four habits of listening without judging Not waiting for your turn Give your body to it Turn toward the person, put the phone away, sit at the same height, hands still. Follow the person's lead on eye contact. Let there be silence Count slowly before you speak. A gap is usually not long to the person. Do not fill it with a verse or a question. Reflect back Say a short piece of what you heard, in their words. Add no interpretation. "You have kept this to yourself all day." Ask few, open questions "What is it like right now?" "What would help in the next hour?" No string of questions. No demand for reasons.

Diagram 2. Sentences that close the door, and what to say

Closing a door, opening a door Before you speak: is this for the person, or for me? Often said (leave unsaid) "Be strong." "Others have it worse." "It is God's will." "You must have little faith." "I know exactly how you feel." "Why did you let it come to this?" "It will all be fine." Honest and gentle "You do not have to be strong with me." "This is heavy for you. I am here." "I do not know why. I am not going anywhere." "Your questions are allowed here." "I cannot know exactly. Tell me what you can." "Thank you for telling me." "I will help you take the next step." What frightens you: stay, do not promise secrecy, do not carry it alone. Danger now: contact emergency services. Not treatment, not diagnosis.

In short

  • Listening without judging means giving your attention, allowing silence, reflecting back and asking few open questions.
  • Many comforting sentences close doors: "be strong", "others have it worse", "it is God's will", "you must have little faith", "I know exactly".
  • Ask yourself before you speak: am I saying this for the person, or for me?
  • Job's friends help by sitting in silence and hurt by explaining; every helper has to notice the moment of change.
  • Do not promise secrecy, and do not carry alone what frightens you.
  • Listening prepares the way for connecting a person to professional help; it does not replace it.
Front Back
Reflecting back Say a short piece of what you heard in the person's words, and add no interpretation.
The test before you speak Am I saying this for the person, or for me?
Job's friends They helped while they sat silent for seven days; they hurt when they began to explain.
What frightens you Stay, do not promise secrecy, do not carry it alone, and contact emergency services if danger is now.

One sentence to remember Sit first; explain never, unless asked, and then gently.

This week's action Choose one sentence from the "often said" list that you tend to use, and practise the honest alternative aloud until it feels natural.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • Which of the "often said" sentences do you find yourself saying? When do you reach for it, and what is it protecting you from?
  • Recall a time when someone sat with you without trying to fix anything. What did they do, and what did they leave out?
  • Job's friends began well. At what point in a conversation do you feel the urge to start explaining?
  • In your community, who is a good listener? What do they do that others could learn?
  • What would you say to a person who tells you something that frightens you, so that you neither promise secrecy nor walk away?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.