Lecture 4-3: Avoiding Further Harm in Church Life
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: What a Crisis Is and What a Church Can Do
- Lecture 1-2: People in Crisis in Scripture, and God's Nearness
- Lecture 1-3: The Caregiver's Own Steadiness and Safety
- Lecture 1-4: Preparing Before It Happens
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: A Readiness Sheet
- Lecture 2-1: Safety First and Steadying
- Lecture 2-2: Listening, and Words to Leave Unsaid
- Lecture 2-3: Prayer and Scripture Beside Someone
- Lecture 2-4: Differences in How Crisis Is Shown: Culture, Age, Setting
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Reading and Rewriting a Conversation
- Lecture 3-1: Warning Signs and Common Myths
- Lecture 3-2: Asking Directly: The Basic Questions
- Lecture 3-3: General Principles of a Safety Plan
- Lecture 3-4: Staying With Someone: Presence, Handover and Follow-Up
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Practising the Question
- Lecture 4-1: How People React to Overwhelming Events
- Lecture 4-2: Safety, Choice and Trust
- Lecture 4-3: Avoiding Further Harm in Church Life
- Lecture 4-4: Faith, Trauma and "Where Was God"
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: A Check of Our Practices
- Lecture 5-1: Beyond Stigma
- Lecture 5-2: Speaking Responsibly: Sermons, Prayers, Notices and Posts
- Lecture 5-3: After a Death by Suicide: Beside the Family
- Lecture 5-4: The Congregation as a Whole: Community After a Loss and Ongoing Prevention
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Checking What We Say
Most harm after an overwhelming event is not done by cruel people. It is done by well-meaning communities doing ordinary church things: asking for a testimony, telling a moving story from the pulpit, going round the circle in a small group, urging peace between people, or praying aloud about a member's trouble. Each of these can help. Each can also add to a burden that the person is already carrying, and the people doing it often never find out.
This lecture goes through five common practices and asks of each: who might be hurt by it, and what small change would let it help instead? It does not ask a church to stop speaking, praying or sharing. It asks the church to do these in ways that leave the person in charge of their own story.
This course gives no diagnosis, treatment, medication or medical advice, and it does not replace professional care. Nothing here is aimed at a particular person, and no one in the congregation should be treated as "the one this is for". The lecture is not legal advice; rules about recording, publishing and confidentiality differ by country, region and church, so check locally.
What these 18 minutes give you
- Name five practices of church life that can add to a person's burden after an overwhelming event.
- Say, for each practice, what small change makes it safer.
- Explain why a person should be asked privately and given a real option to say no.
- Review one practice of your own community with the questions given.
Rejoice with those who rejoice. Weep with those who weep." — Romans 12:15 (World English Bible) "He won’t break a bruised reed. He won’t quench a dimly burning wick. He will faithfully bring justice." — Isaiah 42:3 (WEB) "So, then, my beloved brothers, let every man be swift to hear, slow to speak, and slow to anger;" — James 1:19
WEB
Romans 12:15 asks believers to weep with those who weep, which is not the same as asking them to say why. Isaiah 42:3 is the picture of a gentleness that does not press on a bruise. James 1:19 asks for quick hearing and slow speech, which is a good rule for a leader who has a microphone. These lines set the spirit. The details that follow are practical.
One test for every practice
Before looking at five practices, here is one test to put to each. Does this practice leave the person who has been hurt in charge of what is said, to whom, and when? If the answer is no, even a kind practice may do harm. If the answer is yes, it is likely to be safe.
A second question follows. Who in the room might be carrying something that no one knows about? In any congregation of reasonable size there are likely to be people who have lived through overwhelming events, and the leader will not know who. So a church does not wait to learn who is hurt. It arranges its practices so that anyone in the room is protected.
1. Testimony requests
Testimony is precious. A person who says "God brought me through" strengthens others. But a request for testimony can go wrong in several ways.
- A public request, with no private step first. A person asked in front of everyone has little chance to say "no".
- A request that assumes a happy ending. "Tell us how God delivered you" assumes that deliverance has come and that the person has words for it.
- A story told too soon. A person may feel obliged to stand up before they have understood it themselves.
- A story used as an illustration. Once told, it can be repeated by others as an example, a sermon point or a fundraising story.
- No way back. Once said before the church, it cannot be unsaid.
What to change:
- Ask privately, and ahead of time. Say who would hear it, how it would be used, and how long it would be.
- Make "no" an easy answer. "Please say no if you would rather not. Nobody will ask why."
- Let the person write it, and review it. The person decides what is left out. No detail is needed. A testimony about God's help does not require a description of the event.
- Give the right to withdraw at any point, including afterwards, if it was recorded or posted.
- Never ask a person to give a testimony to prove that a programme or a leader works.
2. Sermon illustrations
A preacher wants a story that moves. Stories of violence, loss or abuse move people, and so they tempt preachers. Three cautions.
- Do not tell a member's story without asking, even with the name removed. In a small church everyone will know whose story it is, and so will the person.
- Do not describe an event in detail to make a point. A vivid retelling can bring the event back to a person in the room who has lived through something like it. The point can nearly always be made without it.
- Do not tell a person in the pews that they should be over it, by phrases such as "just trust God", "let go", "move on", or by stories in which suffering ends neatly. A story that suggests that real faith brings quick relief puts a heavier weight on the person for whom relief has not come.
What to change:
- When a sermon will touch a hard subject, say so at the start, in a calm sentence, and say that a person may leave the room at any time without explanation, or that someone will be at the back after the service. Do not make a show of this.
- Prefer stories from Scripture, from history, or from invented composites that are plainly marked as such.
- End with presence and hope, not with an instruction to feel better.
- Do not use the pulpit to call out a person or a family.
3. Group sharing
Small groups are among the best things churches do. They are also a place where a person can feel trapped.
- Going round the circle puts a person on the spot, and silence is hard to bear when every eye reaches you.
- A leader who wants everyone to share "openly" may press the quiet ones.
- One person's long story may take over the evening, and may be more than the group can hold.
- Cross-talk and advice-giving can wound. "Have you tried...?" and "You should..." come from care, and they land as judgement.
- What is said in the room travels, because groups are usually not as private as people assume.
What to change:
- Say, every time: "You may pass. You may listen only. What is said here stays here, except that if someone is in danger we may have to tell someone who can help."
- Do not go round the circle. Invite whoever wishes to speak.
- Agree a small set of rules: one at a time, no advice unless asked, no interrupting, no discussing outside the group.
- Keep the group for what it is. A fellowship group is not a place for a detailed account of an overwhelming event. If a person begins to tell more than the group can hold, the leader gently ends it ("Thank you. I would like to talk with you after, if you are willing") and arranges a better setting with the person later.
- Know your limits. A small group is not therapy, and a leader who tries to turn it into therapy does harm.
4. Pressure to reconcile
Churches love peace, and with good reason. But this love can turn into pressure on the person who has been hurt to make peace quickly, to meet the other person, to shake hands, to "put it behind us" or to sit in a "reconciliation service."
- Reconciliation asks something of two people. When one has harmed the other, it cannot be done by the one harmed alone, and it cannot begin until the harmed person is safe.
- A person who is pressed to forgive or reconcile before they are ready may comply to keep the peace, and be left feeling unheard.
- Forgiveness and reconciliation are different things. Lecture 4-4 comes back to this.
What to change:
- Never ask a harmed person to meet the person who harmed them unless the harmed person asks for it, and then only with safeguards, in a setting prepared with professionals.
- Do not hold a public "healing" or "peace" event that puts people face to face by design.
- Do not make forgiveness a condition of belonging, of communion, of ministry or of support.
- Where there is harm in the present, protection comes first, and policy and local law apply (lecture 4-2).
5. Public prayer requests
Praying for one another is basic. But a prayer request that is read out or sent round a message group can expose a person.
- Detail. "Please pray for the C. family; their daughter was..." may give away what the person wanted to keep private.
- Names. Even without a name, a small church can guess.
- Speculation. The prayer chain becomes a source of gossip, and gossip about trouble can be a second harm.
- Not asked. A person who has told a friend in confidence may find it in the prayer list the next week.
What to change:
- Ask first: "May I pray for this with others? How much would you like me to say?"
- Pray in general words if the person has not agreed: "for the family who are going through a hard time". Give no detail, even with the name left out.
- Keep the prayer list short and checked. Two people, and a clear rule that nothing goes on it unless the person has agreed.
- In a message group, send nothing that you would not read aloud in front of the person.
- Let the person take the request down whenever they wish.
Two sizes of church
(an invented example) Kestrel Valley Community Church has about four hundred people on a Sunday and records its services and shares them online. Its "Testimony Night" had been a success for years. A member, Carmela, asked the pastor privately whether her story could be left out of the recording and not retold by anyone else. The pastor found that the church had no rule about this, and no one had ever been asked. The team now writes down how each testimony will be used, asks permission for each use, and agrees that anything may be withdrawn from recordings and posts on request.
(an invented example) In a house church of nine people, the issue is the reverse: nothing is recorded, but everyone knows everything. The leader, Mateo, adopted two habits. Nothing is shared outside the room, and for any prayer request he says, "Say as much or as little as you want." After a few weeks, the room is calmer, and people say more, not less. It did not need a policy. It needed a leader who changed one habit and kept it.
Using the questions
For any practice in your church, ask:
- Is the person asked privately and ahead of time, and is no an easy answer?
- Does the person decide what is said, to whom and when, and may they withdraw it?
- Could someone in the room be hurt by it who is not known to us?
- Is anything described in detail that need not be?
- Is anyone pressed toward telling, forgiving, sharing or "moving on"?
- What is the smallest change that would make it safer?
4-1. Five practices, one change each
4-2. Six questions for any practice
In short
- Most harm in church life after an overwhelming event is done by ordinary practices carried out without thinking.
- Test each practice: does it leave the person in charge of what is said, to whom and when?
- Ask for testimony privately, make "no" an easy answer, and let the person withdraw.
- Do not tell a member's story or describe events in detail; do not call anyone to "get over it".
- Never press a harmed person to forgive or meet the one who harmed them; ask first before praying aloud.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| The test | Does the practice leave the person in charge of what is said, to whom and when? |
| Five practices | Testimony requests, sermon illustrations, group sharing, pressure to reconcile, public prayer requests. |
| Testimony | Ask privately and ahead of time, make "no" easy, let the person write it and withdraw it. |
| Group sharing | Do not go round the circle; say "you may pass"; keep it as fellowship, not therapy. |
One sentence to remember Let the person who was hurt stay in charge of the story.
This week's action Choose one practice in your community and put the six questions to it, writing down the smallest change you would make.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Which of the five practices does your community use most? Who in the room might be hurt by it without anyone knowing?
- When has a person in your community been asked to share and found it hard to say no? What would have made no easier?
- How does your community decide what goes on a prayer list or in a message group, and who checks?
- What is the difference between a leader who protects a story and a leader who hides it?
- Which of the six questions is hardest for your community to answer honestly?