Lecture 1-4: The Carer's Place and Limits
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: Marriage in Scripture
- Lecture 1-2: How Traditions Understand Marriage
- Lecture 1-3: Many Kinds of Households
- Lecture 1-4: The Carer's Place and Limits
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: What We Say About Marriage
- Lecture 2-1: The Shape of Preparation Conversations
- Lecture 2-2: Expectations, Family Background and Faith
- Lecture 2-3: Money, Work and Roles
- Lecture 2-4: Intimacy and Sexuality, Spoken with Restraint
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: One Page of Preparation Questions
- Lecture 3-1: Where Couples Collide
- Lecture 3-2: The Basics of a Conflict Conversation
- Lecture 3-3: In-Laws, Wider Families and Cultures
- Lecture 3-4: Roles and Authority
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: The First Conversation in a Conflict
- Lecture 4-1: What Forgiveness Is and Is Not
- Lecture 4-2: When Trust Is Broken: After Unfaithfulness
- Lecture 4-3: Separation and Repeating Conflict
- Lecture 4-4: Knowing When and How to Refer
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Three Cases, Three Responses
- Lecture 5-1: Recognising Abuse: Safety Comes First
- Lecture 5-2: Responding When Someone Tells You
- Lecture 5-3: Divorce and Remarriage: The Positions
- Lecture 5-4: Beside Those Who Part
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: A Referral Map and a First Reply
- Lecture 6-1: Children, Blended Families and Single Parents
- Lecture 6-2: Distance, Migration, Childlessness, Singleness and Widowhood
- Lecture 6-3: The Carer's Own Household and Boundaries
- Lecture 6-4: A Church That Supports Households Over Years
- Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab: A One-Page Household Care Policy
A woman stops the elder after the service. "Can I talk to you about my husband?" she says. She looks over her shoulder. "Please do not tell anyone." The elder has known her for years. He is fond of her husband too. He is not a counsellor, a lawyer or a doctor. He has about twenty minutes before the next meeting. What does he say?
This lecture is about the answer to that question, and about all the questions like it. Lecture 1-1 asked what Scripture says about marriage, lecture 1-2 how traditions understand it, and lecture 1-3 how many shapes households take. Now the course turns to the person who is asked to help: the church carer. It says what a carer is, what a carer is not, what a carer can do well, and where a carer must stop and hand over. The central claim to which every week returns is this: a church carer is neither marriage therapist nor lawyer. The carer listens, helps people prepare, bears difficulty alongside a couple, and connects to professionals when needed. Where there is violence or abuse, the safety of the person harmed comes before reconciliation. Households differ in shape and every person has dignity, and the carer has limits and a household of their own.
Let this be plain: this course is not marriage therapy and it is not legal advice. It does not train anyone to be a marriage therapist, and it does not make anyone a lawyer. It teaches the foundations that a pastor, elder, deacon, small-group leader or lay volunteer needs in order to walk beside people well and to know when to connect them to someone with training.
What these 28 minutes give you
- Say plainly what a church carer is not, and what a church carer can do well.
- Explain why a carer takes no side and does not judge a marriage from one partner's account.
- State the general principle of confidentiality and say why its limits must be explained at the start (check locally for the rules).
- Describe at least three conflicts of interest or dual relationships that can trouble a carer.
- Explain in one sentence the principle about violence and abuse that later weeks will develop.
Bear one another’s burdens, and so fulfill the law of Christ." — Galatians 6:2
World English Bible
Rejoice with those who rejoice. Weep with those who weep." — Romans 12:15
WEB
So, then, my beloved brothers, let every man be swift to hear, slow to speak, and slow to anger;" — James 1:19
WEB
He who gives answer before he hears, that is folly and shame to him." — Proverbs 18:13
WEB
When one member suffers, all the members suffer with it. Or when one member is honored, all the members rejoice with it." — 1 Corinthians 12:26
WEB
Paul's call to bear one another's burdens is the heart of care, but a burden is "borne" together; it is not taken from the person and carried away. The phrase "weep with those who weep" asks for presence before solutions. James and Proverbs ask for speed in listening and slowness in speaking, and warn against giving an answer before hearing. The picture of the body in 1 Corinthians 12 is a reminder that no one member does everything: when one suffers, all suffer, and each part has its own work. A carer is one member of the body, not the whole of it.
What a carer is not
The list of what a carer is not should come first, because it protects both the couple and the carer.
A carer is not a marriage therapist. A therapist is trained for years to understand how couples and families work, to assess what is happening, and to use methods that have been studied and tested. A therapist is held to professional standards and is accountable to a professional body. A church carer has none of this training. A carer who tries to act as a therapist, however kindly, can do harm: by misreading a situation, by giving advice that does not fit, by using a method half-remembered from a book, or by making a couple feel they have been treated when they have only been talked at.
A carer is not a lawyer. Marriage, separation, divorce, custody, property, inheritance and immigration status are all matters of law, and the law differs by country, region and sometimes religion. A carer who says, "In a divorce you will get half," or "He cannot take the children," or "You must not sign that," is giving legal advice and may be wrong. When these questions arise, the carer says, "That is a question for a lawyer, and the answer will depend on where you live: please check locally." The carer does not guess.
A carer is not a doctor, a judge, or a referee. A carer does not diagnose anyone, does not decide who is right in a quarrel, and does not impose a settlement.
A carer is not a rescuer. Many people who go into care do so because they cannot bear to see suffering. This is a good thing, and it carries a danger. A rescuer takes over: decides what the couple should do, carries the load that belongs to them, and in the end feels crushed when the couple do not follow. The carer's work is to stand beside, not in front.
What a carer can do well
A long list of "nots" can make a volunteer feel there is nothing left to do. There is a great deal. Four tasks are at the heart of this course.
- Listening. To listen well is rare, and it is worth more than most advice. It means giving time, not interrupting, not fixing, and letting a person hear their own words said back. Another course in this series covers basic listening; this course assumes you are learning it, and it comes back to it throughout.
- Accompanying. To accompany is to stay beside someone in a hard time without being able to remove it. The couple find that someone is there. This, too, is worth a great deal, and Paul's call to weep with those who weep describes it.
- Preparing. Before a wedding, the carer helps a couple talk about things they might otherwise avoid: their hopes, their families, their faith, their money, their way of settling disagreements. Week 2 teaches this.
- Connecting. When a situation is beyond what a carer can safely do, the carer connects the person to someone with the right training: a counsellor, a doctor, a lawyer, an advice service, a specialist support service, the emergency services. A good connection is not a way of getting rid of someone. It is a way of caring more fully, and the carer stays beside the person afterwards. Week 4 teaches this in detail.
These four tasks, listening, accompanying, preparing and connecting, are the carer's work. Each of them is easier to do well when the carer knows what the carer is not.
A summary of the carer's place
| The carer does | The carer does not | The carer connects to |
|---|---|---|
| Listens, without hurrying to fix | Diagnose or treat | A counsellor or therapist for the couple's relationship difficulties |
| Stays beside the couple through a hard time | Give legal advice | A lawyer, for law: check locally |
| Helps a couple prepare to marry | Take a side | A doctor, for medical needs |
| Prays with those who wish it | Promise outcomes | Specialist services and emergency services, where there is danger |
| Knows the referral list in advance | Carry messages between partners | The pastor or the person responsible in the church |
Both partners, and no side
A carer is often approached by one partner. It is natural. The one who hurts most is usually the one who seeks help first. The carer listens, and that is right. But there is a trap in it.
What one partner tells you is one partner's account. It is real to them. It may be true in what it says and incomplete in what it leaves out. It may be coloured by hurt. It may, in some cases, be accurate in every detail. The carer cannot know from one conversation. The carer's task is not to decide who is right, but to listen, to take the person seriously, and to remember that there is another person in the marriage who has their own account and their own dignity.
Some practical habits follow.
- Do not judge the other partner on the strength of one account. "He sounds impossible" or "she is clearly the problem" may feel like support, but it removes the carer's ability to help both.
- Do not pass messages. "Tell him I said..." turns the carer into a go-between, and a go-between can be used as a weapon by either side.
- Do not promise to take their side. The carer can say, "I am on the side of your marriage and of both of you," or, better, "I am not here to take a side; I am here to listen and to help you find help."
- Offer to speak with both, where it is safe. In many situations, it is useful for the carer to hear both partners, separately or together. But in a situation where there may be abuse, this is not safe, and a carer does not arrange a joint meeting.
No side, but danger is not neutral. Taking no side in a quarrel is right. Taking no side where one person is being hurt by another is not neutrality. It is abandonment of the person hurt. The carer learns to tell a quarrel from a danger.
One sentence about abuse, foretold
Later weeks will teach in detail how to recognise abuse and how to respond when someone tells you. Week 5 is given to it. But a carer should hear the principle on the first week, so that it is not forgotten when needed. Here it is in one sentence.
Where there is violence or abuse, the safety of the person harmed comes before reconciliation or "saving the marriage", and a carer does not arrange a joint meeting or a reconciliation where abuse is present or suspected.
That is all for now. If something you hear in a conversation, in this week or any week, makes you afraid for someone's safety, do not wait for week 5. Take it seriously now, and see the section below on what to do.
Confidentiality and its limits
When a person tells a carer something in confidence, it matters a great deal what the carer does with it. A person who fears being gossiped about will not come back, and will tell no one else. Confidentiality is a form of respect, and in many churches it is a form of trust built up over years.
Here is the general principle, in four parts.
- What is told in confidence is kept. The carer does not tell other members, the congregation or friends. This includes "prayer requests" which are really news. If the carer wishes to ask others to pray, the carer asks the person first, and says exactly what will be said.
- The limits are told at the start. A person should know, before they speak, that there are some things a carer cannot keep to themselves. A simple sentence will do: "What you tell me stays with me, except if I am afraid that you or someone else is in danger, or if I need to ask for help from someone senior or from a professional. If that happens, I will tell you first where I can."
- The limits differ by country, region and role. Some places have laws that require certain people to report certain things, such as harm to a child. Some churches have their own rules. A pastor, a and a volunteer may have different duties. This course gives no rule, because the rules are not the same everywhere. Check locally. Find out, before you need to, what applies to you.
- Seek help for yourself, with care. A carer sometimes needs to talk to someone about a hard case. This can be done by speaking in general terms, without names or details that could identify the person, to a trusted senior person who is bound by the same confidentiality. Another course in this series, on counselling ethics, confidentiality and referral, goes into this.
If the carer is not sure whether something must be reported, the carer asks the responsible person in the church or the proper authority, without naming anyone if possible, and does not decide alone. If a child may be at risk, the course on safe church policy and child protection explains what a community must do.
Conflicts of interest and dual relationships
A carer is rarely a stranger. In churches, the person who helps is often also a friend, a colleague, a relative, a neighbour or an employer. These overlapping roles are called dual relationships, and they are a normal part of church life. They are also a source of difficulty.
Consider some examples, all invented.
- (an invented example) The carer is the couple's friend. Anselm has known Petra and Gideon for ten years. When they come to him with trouble, he finds it hard to be fair. He loves them both, and he has heard Gideon's side at a barbecue and Petra's in the car park. If one of them says something that surprises him, it is difficult to hear it without bias.
- (an invented example) The carer is the employer. Mrs Ogunbanjo owns a small shop, and her shop assistant, Lucia, is a member of her house group. Lucia's marriage is in trouble. Lucia cannot easily tell her employer, and Mrs Ogunbanjo cannot easily set her authority aside.
- (an invented example) The carer is related to one spouse. An is the uncle of a husband. His niece-in-law comes to him in distress. She cannot trust that he is neutral, and he cannot be sure he is.
- The carer has a stake in the outcome. A pastor may feel that a couple's divorce will hurt the church's reputation, or that a prominent family's trouble will divide the congregation. Such feelings are human, and they can quietly tilt the carer's advice.
- The carer's own marriage is troubled. A carer who is struggling at home may see their own conflict in everyone else's, or may avoid hard conversations that remind them of their own. Lecture 6-3 returns to this.
What should a carer do? The first step is simply to notice. The second is to say so honestly, to the person and to a senior person in the church: "I am close to both of you, and that may make it hard for me to be fair. Would you like me to help you find someone else?" The third is to arrange for someone else to take the case, where possible, and to stay in a supporting role. A carer who does this is not failing. It is an act of respect for the couple.
The carer's own limits of time and strength
A carer has a body, a household and a week with a fixed number of hours. A volunteer who gives every evening to other people's troubles will soon have little left for the people at home, and will become tired and short-tempered. This is no sin, but it is a danger. The carer's own limits are not a weakness in the work; they are part of the work. Lecture 6-3 gives them a full treatment, and a later course on volunteer care and burnout goes further.
For now, three small rules.
- Decide beforehand how much time you can give, and say so kindly. "I can meet with you twice, and then I would like us to think together about who else can help."
- Do not be the only carer. In a church of any size, more than one person should know how to listen well, so that no one person carries all.
- Take your own troubles to someone. A carer is also a person who needs help. Another member of the body should be there for you.
Two settings
(an invented example) In Cedar Lane Fellowship, a house church of fourteen adults, there is no trained pastor. Tobias, the bookkeeper who leads the group, is the only person many members would think to ask. He knows too much about everyone and is a friend to all. He decides, with the group, on a simple practice: when anyone asks for private help, he will listen once, say what he can and cannot do, and then ask whether the person would like him to help them find someone outside the fellowship. The group agrees that two of its members, a nurse and a retired teacher, will learn the same practice, so that the load is shared.
(an invented example) Hollis Road Parish is a large congregation with a team of eight lay carers, trained by the parish and supervised by a pastor. Because the parish is large, a couple can ask for a carer who does not know them. The strength is that dual relationships can often be avoided. The risk is that because there is a team, each carer may assume someone else is keeping a list of who has spoken to whom. The team agrees to keep a shared record of the fact that contact was made, with no private details, and to meet monthly with the pastor to ask, in general terms, "Where did we reach the edge of what we can do?"
Back to the elder in the car park
What should the elder say to the woman who wants to talk about her husband?
He can say, kindly and plainly: "I am glad you asked me. I would like to listen. Before you tell me anything, I want you to know what I can and cannot do. I am not a counsellor or a lawyer, so I cannot advise you on those things. What you tell me stays with me, except if I am afraid that someone is in danger, or if I need to ask someone for help, and I would tell you first. Can we find a time and a quiet place where we can talk properly?"
Then he will do what he has been asked: listen. He will not take a side. He will not promise secrecy he cannot keep. He will ask her, near the end, what would help, and whether she would like him to help her find someone else to speak to, such as a counsellor. If anything she says makes him afraid for her safety, or her children's, he will not wait for a tidier moment. If she is in danger now, he will help her reach the emergency services. In the rare case where she speaks of ending her life, the course on crisis and suicide tells what to do, and this course does not repeat it.
That one conversation contains almost everything this lecture has said.
1-1. The carer's place
1-2. What to say before someone speaks
In short
- A church carer is not a marriage therapist, a lawyer, a doctor, a judge or a rescuer.
- The carer's work is listening, accompanying, helping people prepare, and connecting to someone with training.
- One partner's account is one account; the carer takes no side in a quarrel, but danger is not neutral.
- Where there is violence or abuse, the safety of the person harmed comes before reconciliation.
- Confidentiality is kept, its limits are told at the start, and the rules differ by country, region and role: check locally.
- Dual relationships and conflicts of interest are normal in churches; the carer names them and may hand the case on.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| The carer's four tasks | Listening, accompanying, helping people prepare, and connecting to professionals when needed. |
| What the carer is not | A marriage therapist, a lawyer, a doctor or judge, or a rescuer who takes over. |
| Confidentiality | Kept as a general principle; limits told at the start; rules differ by country, region and role: check locally. |
| The abuse principle | Where there is violence or abuse, the safety of the person harmed comes first; no joint meeting where abuse is present or suspected. |
One sentence to remember Stand beside people, take no side in a quarrel, and connect to someone with training when the matter is beyond you.
This week's action Write three plain sentences you could say before someone speaks to you in confidence (what you are, what you keep, where it stops), and find out one rule in your region that applies to your role.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Of the four "nots" (therapist, lawyer, doctor or judge, rescuer), which is hardest for you to keep? Why?
- Which of the four tasks (listening, accompanying, preparing, connecting) comes most naturally in your community, and which is neglected?
- Think of a role you hold that overlaps with another (friend and elder, employer and fellow member, relative and carer). What would you say to a couple if you needed to hand the case to someone else?
- Does your church have a clear sentence that carers say about confidentiality and its limits? If not, what would you want it to say? Who in your church or region would know the local rules?
- How would the elder's conversation in the car park differ in a house church of fourteen and in a large parish? What would be easier and what harder?