FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

PT722E Marriage and Family Care: Foundations for Church Carers

Lecture 5-3: Divorce and Remarriage: The Positions

Contents 31
PT722E Marriage and Family Care: Foundations for Church Carers
Chapter 0 · Introduction: Beside Two People
  1. Lecture 0: Introduction: Beside Two People
Chapter 1 · Week 1: Marriage and the Carer's Place
  1. Lecture 1-1: Marriage in Scripture
  2. Lecture 1-2: How Traditions Understand Marriage
  3. Lecture 1-3: Many Kinds of Households
  4. Lecture 1-4: The Carer's Place and Limits
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: What We Say About Marriage
Chapter 2 · Week 2: Before the Wedding
  1. Lecture 2-1: The Shape of Preparation Conversations
  2. Lecture 2-2: Expectations, Family Background and Faith
  3. Lecture 2-3: Money, Work and Roles
  4. Lecture 2-4: Intimacy and Sexuality, Spoken with Restraint
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: One Page of Preparation Questions
Chapter 3 · Week 3: Conflict in Marriage
  1. Lecture 3-1: Where Couples Collide
  2. Lecture 3-2: The Basics of a Conflict Conversation
  3. Lecture 3-3: In-Laws, Wider Families and Cultures
  4. Lecture 3-4: Roles and Authority
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: The First Conversation in a Conflict
Chapter 4 · Week 4: Forgiveness and Repair
  1. Lecture 4-1: What Forgiveness Is and Is Not
  2. Lecture 4-2: When Trust Is Broken: After Unfaithfulness
  3. Lecture 4-3: Separation and Repeating Conflict
  4. Lecture 4-4: Knowing When and How to Refer
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Three Cases, Three Responses
Chapter 5 · Week 5: Safety, and When Couples Part
  1. Lecture 5-1: Recognising Abuse: Safety Comes First
  2. Lecture 5-2: Responding When Someone Tells You
  3. Lecture 5-3: Divorce and Remarriage: The Positions
  4. Lecture 5-4: Beside Those Who Part
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: A Referral Map and a First Reply
Chapter 6 · Week 6: Households of Many Shapes, and the Carer's Own
  1. Lecture 6-1: Children, Blended Families and Single Parents
  2. Lecture 6-2: Distance, Migration, Childlessness, Singleness and Widowhood
  3. Lecture 6-3: The Carer's Own Household and Boundaries
  4. Lecture 6-4: A Church That Supports Households Over Years
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab: A One-Page Household Care Policy

Jump to the key points ↓

26 min

Sooner or later a carer is asked: "Is divorce allowed? May I marry again?" The question is rarely abstract. It comes from a person who is in pain, who has often already thought about it for months, and who is afraid of the answer.

Christians have given different answers for a very long time, and sincere, well-read people hold each of them. This lecture does not choose between them. It sets out the main positions in their strongest honest form, reads the two central passages with care, and says what this course requires of every carer whatever position they or their church hold. It also says what a carer should do when asked, and what a carer should never do: use any position to shame a person who is divorced or remarried.

The central claim to which every week returns is this: a church carer is neither marriage therapist nor lawyer. The carer listens, helps people prepare, bears difficulty alongside a couple, and connects to professionals when needed. Where there is violence or abuse, the safety of the person harmed comes before reconciliation. Households differ in shape and every person has dignity, and the carer has limits and a household of their own.

This course is not marriage therapy and not legal advice. Divorce, custody, property and immigration status are matters of law. A carer does not advise on them and sends the person to a lawyer, with the reminder to check locally, because law differs by country and region.

What these 26 minutes give you

  • Read Matthew 19:3-9 and 1 Corinthians 7:10-16 with attention to what each says and to the questions it leaves open.
  • State, fairly and without mockery, four common positions on divorce and remarriage.
  • Say what this course requires of a carer, whatever position the carer or their church holds.
  • Explain how a carer answers a person who asks "May I divorce?" or "May I marry again?" without giving their own verdict as the church's rule.
  • Say why a person who has left a marriage because of violence or abuse is not to be treated as someone who has simply chosen to break a vow.

Pharisees came to him, testing him, and saying, “Is it lawful for a man to divorce his wife for any reason?”" — Matthew 19:3

World English Bible

He answered, “Haven’t you read that he who made them from the beginning made them male and female," — Matthew 19:4

WEB

and said, ‘For this cause a man shall leave his father and mother, and shall join to his wife; and the two shall become one flesh?’" — Matthew 19:5

WEB

So that they are no more two, but one flesh. What therefore God has joined together, don’t let man tear apart.”" — Matthew 19:6

WEB

They asked him, “Why then did Moses command us to give her a bill of divorce, and divorce her?”" — Matthew 19:7

WEB

He said to them, “Moses, because of the hardness of your hearts, allowed you to divorce your wives, but from the beginning it has not been so." — Matthew 19:8

WEB

I tell you that whoever divorces his wife, except for sexual immorality, and marries another, commits adultery; and he who marries her when she is divorced commits adultery.”" — Matthew 19:9

WEB

But to the married I command—not I, but the Lord—that the wife not leave her husband" — 1 Corinthians 7:10

WEB

(but if she departs, let her remain unmarried, or else be reconciled to her husband), and that the husband not leave his wife." — 1 Corinthians 7:11

WEB

But to the rest I—not the Lord—say, if any brother has an unbelieving wife, and she is content to live with him, let him not leave her." — 1 Corinthians 7:12

WEB

The woman who has an unbelieving husband, and he is content to live with her, let her not leave her husband." — 1 Corinthians 7:13

WEB

For the unbelieving husband is sanctified in the wife, and the unbelieving wife is sanctified in the husband. Otherwise your children would be unclean, but now they are holy." — 1 Corinthians 7:14

WEB

Yet if the unbeliever departs, let there be separation. The brother or the sister is not under bondage in such cases, but God has called us in peace." — 1 Corinthians 7:15

WEB

For how do you know, wife, whether you will save your husband? Or how do you know, husband, whether you will save your wife?" — 1 Corinthians 7:16

WEB

Two things should be said before the lecture begins. First, these are the verses on which the positions below are built. Each position reads them with great care, and each has to explain the parts of them it finds hardest. Second, neither passage is a manual for a counselling room. In Matthew, Jesus is answering a test question about the law. In Corinthians, Paul is answering a church's letter about particular households. Both speak to the people in front of them, and both leave questions that later Christians have answered differently.

1. What the two passages say, and what they leave open

Matthew 19:3-9. The Pharisees ask a question about grounds: may a man divorce his wife "for any reason"? Jesus does not start with grounds. He goes back to creation: God made them male and female, and the two become one flesh. "What therefore God has joined together, don’t let man tear apart." When they point to Moses, Jesus says that Moses allowed divorce because of the hardness of their hearts, and that from the beginning it has not been so. Then he says that whoever divorces "except for sexual immorality" and marries another commits adultery.

Questions the passage leaves open, which readers answer differently: What did "sexual immorality" mean to those who first heard it? Does the exception apply to the remarriage, or only to the divorce? Is the statement about what is right, or a sharp warning meant to protect a vulnerable wife from being put out for any cause? How does a concession to hard hearts relate to a rule from creation?

1 Corinthians 7:10-16. Paul distinguishes two cases. To the married he gives what he calls the Lord's command: a wife should not leave her husband, and a husband should not leave his wife; and if a wife departs she should remain unmarried or be reconciled. Then, "to the rest", about marriages in which only one partner believes, he gives his own judgment: if the unbelieving partner is content to stay, the believer should not leave. But "if the unbeliever departs, let there be separation. The brother or the sister is not under bondage in such cases, but God has called us in peace."

Questions the passage leaves open: What does "not under bondage" mean, a freedom to be apart or also a freedom to marry again? Does the principle reach beyond the case of an unbelieving partner? What does "God has called us in peace" mean for a person in an unpeaceful home? How should we read verse 16, which can be heard either as hope for the partner or as a warning against staying in the hope of saving them?

These are not trick questions. They are the places where honest readers part.

2. The positions

The following are the main positions. Each is held by thoughtful people. They are given here in their strongest honest form.

Position one: marriage, once validly made, cannot be dissolved. Those who hold this read Jesus's return to creation as the centre of the passage: what God joins, a human court cannot undo. A civil divorce may end the legal arrangements, but it does not end the marriage before God. Remarriage while a former spouse lives is therefore not permitted. Some traditions that hold this also teach that a marriage may be examined, through the church's own process, to ask whether a valid marriage existed at the start; if it did not, the person was never bound. Those who hold this view point to the seriousness of vows, to the protection it gives the weaker party, and to the witness that a lifelong faithfulness gives in a world of broken promises. They would add that it is held with sorrow, and with for those who live apart and alone.

Position two: divorce and remarriage are permitted only on the grounds Scripture names. Those who hold this read the "except" in Matthew 19:9 and Paul's "not under bondage" in 1 Corinthians 7:15 as the two grounds the New Testament gives: sexual unfaithfulness, and desertion by an unbelieving partner. Outside these, the original bond remains. They point out that the plain words of Scripture should bind us more than our sympathy, and that to widen the grounds is to put human feeling above Christ's own words. They also hold that a person who has divorced on a ground Scripture names is free, and should be received without stigma.

Position three: the grounds are wider, because the aim of the texts is to protect people, and abuse and other grave harm break a marriage in fact. Those who hold this read Jesus's answer as a defence of the person who is put out and wronged, and Paul's "God has called us in peace" as a principle that a marriage ruined by violence, cruelty or abandonment has already been broken by the one who does the harm. They hold that the texts name examples, not a complete list; that the spirit is care for the vulnerable; and that a person should not be bound to a partner who endangers them. They hold this with grace, not carelessly: they too grieve every ended marriage, and they ask for repentance and wisdom when remarriage is considered.

Position four: the decision belongs to the church's own process, not to the individual or to the carer. Those who hold this accept that the texts leave open real questions and that the church has an ordered way of judging cases: a pastor and elders, a bishop, a tribunal, a body of the wider church. They hold that a person does not decide alone whether they may marry again, and that a carer does not decide for them. They value order, shared discernment and the protection of both the person and the congregation from arbitrary rulings. Some who hold this combine it with one of the other three, because the process itself applies one of them.

3. The point where readers will not agree

This is a point where readers will not agree. Some hold that marriage cannot be dissolved and that remarriage is not permitted while a former spouse lives. Some hold that divorce and remarriage are permitted only on the grounds the New Testament names. Some hold that the grounds are wider, because the texts aim to protect people and abuse and grave harm break a marriage in fact, and they hold this with grace and ask for repentance and wisdom. Some hold that the decision belongs to the church's own process and that neither the individual nor the carer decides. Each of these is held by faithful, serious people, and each can say what it protects: faithfulness, the plain words of Scripture, the vulnerable, or order and shared discernment. This course requires the following of every carer. No single conclusion is to be presented as the Christian answer, and the carer does not give their own verdict as the church's rule. No stigma may fall on a person who is divorced or remarried: they are not second-class members, not objects of gossip, and not a warning to others. The carer explains the rule of their own church or tradition honestly, as the rule of that body, and checks it if unsure, instead of guessing. Questions of law are for lawyers, and the carer says so.

4. What a carer says when asked

A carer is often asked a direct question. Here is a pattern that respects the person and the limits of the carer.

  1. Listen first. "Tell me what has brought you to ask." Before any rule is explained, the carer needs to know whether the person is in danger, whether they are afraid, whether children are involved. If there is abuse, lectures 5-1 and 5-2 govern, and a conversation about permission is not the first thing.
  2. Say what your church teaches, as its teaching. "In our church, the rule is this." Do not say "the Bible says" as if it were the only reading, and do not present your own view as the church's.
  3. Say honestly if you are not the person to answer. In many churches the decision belongs to a pastor, bishop or body. "That is not for me to decide. I can tell you who decides, and I can go with you."
  4. Do not promise a result. Do not say "of course God will allow it" or "you will not be allowed". The answer may depend on a process.
  5. Send questions of law to a lawyer. Divorce, custody, property, immigration status: "That is a matter of law, and it differs here and there. A lawyer can tell you what applies. Check locally." The carer does not draft, advise or predict.
  6. Stay. Whatever the answer, the person is not dismissed. The carer's company does not depend on the rule being kept in the way the person hoped.

5. A person who has left because of harm

A person who has left, or wishes to leave, because of violence or abuse is not to be treated as one who has merely broken a promise. Whatever position a church holds, the first question in such a case is safety, and the first duty is to protect the person (lecture 5-1). Many who hold positions one or two would also say, on reflection, that a person who has separated to be safe has not done wrong, and that a separation for safety is not the same as a divorce for convenience. This course requires at least this: a carer never urges a person in danger to return, never uses a position on divorce as a reason to require them to stay, and never tells them that to protect themselves is to sin. Whether the person later divorces, and whether they may marry again, are questions for the church's own process and for a lawyer, after safety is secure and with no pressure of time.

6. An example from a small community

(an invented example) A rural congregation of about thirty, led by a part-time pastor, has a clear rule: members may marry again only after the congregation's elders have heard the case. Sunil has been separated for two years. His wife left the district. He asks the pastor, Ruvimbo, whether he may marry a widow he has come to love. Ruvimbo does not give her own view. She says: "Our rule is that the elders hear it. I will go with you and tell them what you tell me. I cannot tell you what they will say." She also tells him that a lawyer must confirm his legal position, and offers to help him find one. She is kind to the widow, and she does not mention the case outside the elders. The small church's strength is that the rule is known; its danger is that everyone watches. Ruvimbo's care is to keep it private.

7. An example from a large congregation

(an invented example) In a congregation of several hundred, the church's own body sets down the grounds on which a marriage may be considered at an end and a new one blessed, and a panel hears each request. Maribel's marriage ended years ago, and she was divorced in another country. She comes to the care team afraid that she will be turned away. A volunteer, Elias, listens, explains that the church has a process and that she may ask for it, and says that being divorced does not remove her from the table. He does not forecast the answer. He tells her that if the process requires papers, a lawyer can say which are needed. In a large church the danger is that the person is lost in a procedure. Elias's task is to stay beside her through it.

8. An example from an agency

(an invented example) A staff chaplain in a non-profit agency is asked by a divorced colleague whether she can still be part of a prayer group at the agency. The agency has members of many traditions who hold different positions. The chaplain says: "Different traditions hold different views on this, and I will not pretend there is only one. You are welcome here. If you want to know your own church's rule, I will help you find who can tell you." The workplace is not the place to settle the doctrine, and it is the place to avoid stigma.

9. Nobody is a warning to others

It must be said plainly. A divorced or remarried person is not a lesson. They are not to be pointed out, prayed about by name in public, kept off a rota in a way that others are not, or spoken of in a lowered voice. Lecture 5-4 continues this. Whatever a church holds about whether the marriage should have ended or may be begun again, the people involved are members, parents, children of God, and neighbours.


Diagram 1. 5-3-A. Four positions, side by side

Divorce and remarriage: four positions Each held by serious people; each protects something Not dissolved A valid marriage cannot be undone; no remarriage while a spouse lives. Protects: faithfulness, the weaker party Named grounds Only the grounds the New Testament names free a person; no stigma after. Protects: the plain words of Scripture Wider grounds The texts aim to protect people; abuse and grave harm break a marriage in fact. Protects: the vulnerable, with grace and wisdom Church's process The church judges each case by its own order; neither the person nor the carer decides alone. Protects: order, shared discernment What this course requires of every carer No single conclusion presented as the answer. No stigma for divorced or remarried people. Explain your own church's rule as its rule, and check it if unsure. Law is for lawyers: check locally. Safety first for anyone who left because of harm. Not marriage therapy and not legal advice.

Diagram 2. 5-3-B. When someone asks: May I divorce? May I marry again?

A carer's answer in six moves Honest about the rule, honest about the limits 1 Listen first Is there danger or fear? If so, lectures 5-1 and 5-2 come before any rule. 2 Say the rule as the rule "In our church, the rule is..." Not "the Bible says" as if there were one reading. 3 Name who decides Pastor, bishop, elders, a body. "I can go with you." 4 Promise no result Neither "it will be allowed" nor "it will be refused". 5 Law to a lawyer Divorce, custody, property, immigration: check locally. 6 Stay Company does not depend on the answer they hoped for. The carer is not a therapist and not a lawyer, and does not give a personal verdict as the church's rule.

In short

  • Matthew 19:3-9 and 1 Corinthians 7:10-16 are the central texts, and each leaves open questions on which faithful readers differ.
  • Four positions: marriage cannot be dissolved; only the named grounds; wider grounds including abuse, with grace; the church's own process decides.
  • No single conclusion is presented as the answer, and a carer does not give a personal verdict as the church's rule.
  • No stigma falls on divorced or remarried people; they are members and neighbours, not warnings.
  • A carer explains the rule of their own church as its rule, checks it if unsure, and sends questions of law to a lawyer.
  • A person who left because of harm is never urged to return or told that protecting themselves is sin.
Front Back
Four positions Not dissolved; only the named grounds; wider grounds with grace; the church's own process decides.
What the course requires No single answer presented as the answer, no stigma, the church's own rule explained as its rule, law left to lawyers.
When asked "May I marry again?" Listen first, say the rule as the rule, name who decides, promise no result, send law to a lawyer, and stay.
A person who left because of harm Safety first; never urged to return; separation for safety is not treated as a casual breaking of a vow.

One sentence to remember State each position fairly, give your own church's rule as its rule, and let no divorced or remarried person be made a warning.

This week's action Find out, in writing, what your own church's rule is and who decides, and check that you can explain it without adding your own view.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • Which of the four positions is closest to the teaching of your own church or tradition? Can you state the strongest honest form of a position that differs from it?
  • Matthew 19 turns from a question about grounds to a statement about creation. What does that turn suggest about how Jesus answers the question, and what do readers who hold different positions make of it?
  • In 1 Corinthians 7:15 Paul says the believer "is not under bondage in such cases". What do you think this leaves open, and how do the four positions each read it?
  • How would a carer in your community avoid giving a personal view as the church's rule? What would it cost to say, "That is not for me to decide"?
  • Where could stigma fall on a divorced or remarried person in your community, perhaps without anyone intending it? What would remove it?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.