FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

PT722E Marriage and Family Care: Foundations for Church Carers

Lecture 4-3: Separation and Repeating Conflict

Contents 31
PT722E Marriage and Family Care: Foundations for Church Carers
Chapter 0 · Introduction: Beside Two People
  1. Lecture 0: Introduction: Beside Two People
Chapter 1 · Week 1: Marriage and the Carer's Place
  1. Lecture 1-1: Marriage in Scripture
  2. Lecture 1-2: How Traditions Understand Marriage
  3. Lecture 1-3: Many Kinds of Households
  4. Lecture 1-4: The Carer's Place and Limits
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: What We Say About Marriage
Chapter 2 · Week 2: Before the Wedding
  1. Lecture 2-1: The Shape of Preparation Conversations
  2. Lecture 2-2: Expectations, Family Background and Faith
  3. Lecture 2-3: Money, Work and Roles
  4. Lecture 2-4: Intimacy and Sexuality, Spoken with Restraint
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: One Page of Preparation Questions
Chapter 3 · Week 3: Conflict in Marriage
  1. Lecture 3-1: Where Couples Collide
  2. Lecture 3-2: The Basics of a Conflict Conversation
  3. Lecture 3-3: In-Laws, Wider Families and Cultures
  4. Lecture 3-4: Roles and Authority
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: The First Conversation in a Conflict
Chapter 4 · Week 4: Forgiveness and Repair
  1. Lecture 4-1: What Forgiveness Is and Is Not
  2. Lecture 4-2: When Trust Is Broken: After Unfaithfulness
  3. Lecture 4-3: Separation and Repeating Conflict
  4. Lecture 4-4: Knowing When and How to Refer
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Three Cases, Three Responses
Chapter 5 · Week 5: Safety, and When Couples Part
  1. Lecture 5-1: Recognising Abuse: Safety Comes First
  2. Lecture 5-2: Responding When Someone Tells You
  3. Lecture 5-3: Divorce and Remarriage: The Positions
  4. Lecture 5-4: Beside Those Who Part
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: A Referral Map and a First Reply
Chapter 6 · Week 6: Households of Many Shapes, and the Carer's Own
  1. Lecture 6-1: Children, Blended Families and Single Parents
  2. Lecture 6-2: Distance, Migration, Childlessness, Singleness and Widowhood
  3. Lecture 6-3: The Carer's Own Household and Boundaries
  4. Lecture 6-4: A Church That Supports Households Over Years
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab: A One-Page Household Care Policy

Jump to the key points ↓

18 min

Some couples quarrel about the same thing for years. Some have a bad season and decide to live apart for a while. Some separate and come back. Some separate and do not. A church carer will meet all of these and will often be asked the question: "Should we separate?" Or: "Should I tell her to come back?"

This lecture gives a carer a way to think and a way to stay beside a couple when conflict repeats, or when living apart is in question. It is not marriage therapy and not legal advice, and it does not tell any couple what to do. Divorce, custody, property and immigration status are for a lawyer, and the law differs by place: check locally.

The central claim of the course applies at once: a church carer is neither marriage therapist nor lawyer. The carer listens, helps people prepare, bears difficulty alongside a couple, and connects to professionals when needed. Where there is violence or abuse, the safety of the person harmed comes before reconciliation. Households differ in shape and every person has dignity, and the carer has limits and a household of their own.

What these 18 minutes give you

  • Tell the difference between a repeating pattern of conflict and signs of danger, and respond to each.
  • Name three reasons a couple may live apart for a time: safety, cooling and deciding.
  • Explain what the carer does and does not do when separation is in question.
  • Explain how to keep children out of the middle of a parents' conflict.
  • Say when to refer, and point to the crisis course once.

A gentle answer turns away wrath, but a harsh word stirs up anger." — Proverbs 15:1

World English Bible

If it is possible, as much as it is up to you, be at peace with all men." — Romans 12:18

WEB

Yahweh is near to those who have a broken heart, and saves those who have a crushed spirit." — Psalm 34:18

WEB

Two are better than one, because they have a good reward for their labor." — Ecclesiastes 4:9

WEB

For if they fall, the one will lift up his fellow; but woe to him who is alone when he falls, and doesn’t have another to lift him up." — Ecclesiastes 4:10

WEB

A gentle answer calms a quarrel, and a harsh word stirs it. Paul's words are honest about limits: "if it is possible, as much as it is up to you." Sometimes it is not possible, and the verse admits it. The Teacher reminds us that no one should carry a hard time alone, and the Psalm that God is near to the broken-hearted. These verses are comfort and direction for the carer. They are not a rule that a couple must stay under one roof at any cost.

1. Two different pictures

Lecture 3-1 said that conflict is not itself a sickness. Most couples quarrel, and many quarrel about the same few things. A repeating quarrel is not necessarily a danger. But two pictures can look alike from outside and be very different inside. See the second diagram.

A repeating pattern. The same argument returns: about money, in-laws, the children, who does what. Both partners can say what it is about. Both can stop when they choose, even if stopping is hard. Neither is afraid of the other. The pattern is painful and tiring, and it can wear a marriage down, but it is the kind of difficulty couples can work with, with time, small agreements and sometimes a professional.

Signs of danger. One partner is afraid to speak. One controls the other's money, phone, friends or movements. There are threats, harm to a person, or harm to belongings, and quarrels end in fear or force. Here the picture is different. This is not a conflict between equals, and it is not something that a calmer conversation will fix. Where there is violence or abuse, the safety of the person harmed comes before reconciliation, and Week 5 sets out how to respond in full.

If a carer cannot tell which picture they are looking at, the safe course is to treat it as possible danger until it is clear. Ask each person alone, quietly and kindly, whether they feel safe at home. A joint meeting is not the place to ask.

2. Reasons for living apart

When a couple, or one partner, raises the question of living apart, there are usually three different reasons behind it. They need different responses. See the first diagram.

Safety. One person is afraid or at risk. Nothing else comes first. This is not a time for joint talks or a reconciliation meeting, and a carer who suggests one may put a person in danger. The carer believes the person, helps them think about where they can go, connects them to specialist services and, if there is danger now, to emergency services. A carer should research in advance and keep a list at hand of local specialist services; the list is kept, not memorised, and no number is given in this course. Lecture 4-4 and Week 5 return to this.

Cooling. Anger is so high that every conversation makes it worse. A short, agreed pause, for example a few days at a relative's house, may allow breathing space. Such a pause works best when it is agreed by both, when it has a plan for meeting again, and when contact with the children is kept steady. It is not a punishment, and it is not a step towards a legal ending unless the couple decides so.

Deciding. Some couples need room to think about whether they can continue. They may agree on a time and terms. Legal and practical questions arise, such as who pays what, where the children sleep, and what happens to a home. These belong to a lawyer or other qualified person, and the rules differ by place: check locally. The carer does not advise on them.

In practice these reasons overlap, and what began as cooling can become deciding. The carer does not need to label it. The carer needs to keep asking, kindly, "How are you doing? How is it at home? Are you safe?"

3. What the carer does, and does not do

The carer does:

  • ask about safety first, and ask each person alone;
  • listen to both partners, one at a time, without taking a side;
  • say that the carer cannot tell them whether to separate or to stay together, and does not think it is the carer's place to do so;
  • help the couple think about practical things in general terms: who will care for the children, how they will keep in touch, where each will stay, who else can help;
  • encourage them to see a lawyer for legal questions and a professional for the marriage, if both are willing;
  • stay a friend to both, whatever they decide.

The carer does not:

  • tell a couple to separate, or tell them to stay together at any cost;
  • use Scripture to say that separation is always wrong or always right;
  • quote Scripture to a frightened person to say that they must go back;
  • pass messages between them as a go-between where there is fear;
  • keep a secret that a person is in danger or a child is at risk (rules differ by country and role: check locally);
  • take a side on who is to blame.

This is a point of real difficulty for carers, who often hold deep convictions about marriage. Your conviction is yours, and you may hold it. Your role in the room is different. If your church has a rule about separation, such as a stage when the leaders must be told, explain that rule honestly, and do not use it to hold someone in danger.

4. Children out of the middle

A child can be harmed by conflict that nobody means to be about them. Some general principles follow. These are about care, and they are not a method.

  • Do not use children as messengers. "Tell your mother that..." puts the child in the middle.
  • Do not ask a child to choose. A child loves both parents, and a question such as "Who do you want to live with?" is a weight that is too heavy.
  • Do not speak against the other parent in front of the child. Adults may need to say hard things, but not within the child's hearing.
  • Keep routines. Meals, school, worship, bedtimes. A child can bear a great deal when the day still has a shape.
  • Keep the child informed in plain words suited to their age, without blame: "Mum and Dad are having a hard time. It is not your fault. You are loved."
  • Offer another trusted adult. A grandparent, a teacher or a youth leader may be a listener.

If a child seems afraid, is harmed or is at risk, that belongs to the course on safe church policy and child protection. Reporting duties differ by country, region and role: check locally.

5. When conflict does not ease

Some couples carry the same wound for years. The carer is not failing. At some point, say after a few meetings without movement, or sooner if the signs of danger appear, the carer says honestly, "I think you need help that I cannot give. Would you let me help you find it?" This is not abandonment. It is the carer's faithfulness. Lecture 4-4 gives the way.

If either partner speaks of despair or of ending their life, or if you fear for someone's safety, the course on crisis and suicide applies at once, with emergency help if there is danger now.

6. Three communities

(an invented example) In a small fellowship in a farming district, a couple, Hana and Piotr, had quarrelled about money for years. The group leader, Ruth, noticed that both could say what the quarrel was about and that both stopped when the other asked. She said, "This sounds like a pattern, not a danger. Would you like to try keeping a weekly time to talk about money, and shall I help you find someone who is trained if it stays stuck?" They chose to try, and the pattern eased slowly.

(an invented example) In a large church in a port city, a wife, Dalia, said quietly that she and her husband had agreed to live apart for a month "to stop shouting." The pastor said, "I am glad you have a plan. Would you like to think with me about how the children will see each of you?" He did not ask for a verdict on the marriage. A month later, the couple chose to meet with a professional. The month had worked as a cooling period, with an end date.

(an invented example) In a house church of nine people, a member, Joel, told the host that his wife "went to her mother's" and he did not know when she would come back. The host asked, "Is she safe? Are you safe?" Joel said that she had left because of fear. The host said, "I am glad you told me. I will not ask you to ask her back. Let us find someone who knows how to help her, and let us help you with whatever you need." The host did not argue for the marriage. The host kept a list of services for exactly this moment.

7. Your own limits

A carer who is too eager to keep a marriage together may press. A carer who is too eager to rescue a person may push a separation. Both are the carer's own wishes. A good carer checks, now and then, whose wish is driving the meeting. A carer who is tired, afraid or worried about the church's reputation is better replaced for a time by another carer; a course on volunteer care and burnout applies.


Diagram 1. Three reasons for living apart

Why a couple may live apart for a time Three different reasons, three different carer responses Safety Someone is afraid or at risk Nothing else comes first Not a time for joint talks Specialist services, emergency help if danger now Cooling Anger is so high that every talk makes it worse A short, agreed pause with a plan to meet Contact for children kept Deciding A couple needs room to think about the marriage Agreed time and terms Professional help Legal questions to a lawyer The carer's place Does not tell a couple to separate or to stay together. Asks about safety first, keeps both in view, keeps children out of the middle, and connects to professionals.

Diagram 2. Pattern or danger?

A repeating quarrel: pattern or danger? Two different pictures A repeating pattern The same quarrel, again and again Both can say what it is about Both can stop when they choose Neither is afraid of the other Help: listen, small agreements, a professional if it stays stuck Signs of danger One partner is afraid to speak One controls money, phone or movement; threats; harm Quarrel ends with fear or force Help: safety first; no joint talk; specialist services (Week 5) When unsure, treat it as possible danger Ask each person alone, kindly, whether they feel safe at home.

In short

  • A repeating pattern of conflict and signs of danger can look alike; treat unclear cases as possible danger and ask each person alone.
  • Couples may live apart for safety, for cooling or for deciding, and each needs a different response.
  • The carer does not tell a couple to separate or to stay together, and sends legal questions to a lawyer.
  • Where there is violence or abuse, safety comes first and there is no joint reconciliation meeting.
  • Keep children out of the middle: no messages, no choosing, no speaking against a parent.
  • When conflict does not ease, the carer says honestly that more help is needed.
Front Back
Pattern or danger A pattern: both can stop, neither is afraid. Danger: fear, control, threats or harm. When unsure, ask each person alone.
Three reasons for living apart Safety, cooling and deciding.
The carer's place Asks about safety, listens to both, does not tell a couple to separate or stay, sends legal questions to a lawyer.
Children No messengers, no choosing, no speaking against a parent, keep routines, offer another trusted adult.

One sentence to remember Ask about safety first, take no side on the marriage, and keep the children out of the middle.

This week's action Write down, without names, three questions you would ask a person alone to find out whether they feel safe at home.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • Why is it harder to tell "a repeating pattern" from "signs of danger" than it seems? What would you do if you were unsure?
  • Which of the three reasons for living apart (safety, cooling, deciding) does your community most often think of? Which is least often thought of?
  • Your tradition may have strong convictions about separation. What is one way to hold those and still not press a person in danger to return?
  • How do adults in your community put children in the middle of conflict without meaning to? What one change would help?
  • If you were asked tonight, "Should we separate?", what would you say? What would you say that you are not able to say?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.