FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

PT722E Marriage and Family Care: Foundations for Church Carers

Lecture 2-2: Expectations, Family Background and Faith

Contents 31
PT722E Marriage and Family Care: Foundations for Church Carers
Chapter 0 · Introduction: Beside Two People
  1. Lecture 0: Introduction: Beside Two People
Chapter 1 · Week 1: Marriage and the Carer's Place
  1. Lecture 1-1: Marriage in Scripture
  2. Lecture 1-2: How Traditions Understand Marriage
  3. Lecture 1-3: Many Kinds of Households
  4. Lecture 1-4: The Carer's Place and Limits
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: What We Say About Marriage
Chapter 2 · Week 2: Before the Wedding
  1. Lecture 2-1: The Shape of Preparation Conversations
  2. Lecture 2-2: Expectations, Family Background and Faith
  3. Lecture 2-3: Money, Work and Roles
  4. Lecture 2-4: Intimacy and Sexuality, Spoken with Restraint
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: One Page of Preparation Questions
Chapter 3 · Week 3: Conflict in Marriage
  1. Lecture 3-1: Where Couples Collide
  2. Lecture 3-2: The Basics of a Conflict Conversation
  3. Lecture 3-3: In-Laws, Wider Families and Cultures
  4. Lecture 3-4: Roles and Authority
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: The First Conversation in a Conflict
Chapter 4 · Week 4: Forgiveness and Repair
  1. Lecture 4-1: What Forgiveness Is and Is Not
  2. Lecture 4-2: When Trust Is Broken: After Unfaithfulness
  3. Lecture 4-3: Separation and Repeating Conflict
  4. Lecture 4-4: Knowing When and How to Refer
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Three Cases, Three Responses
Chapter 5 · Week 5: Safety, and When Couples Part
  1. Lecture 5-1: Recognising Abuse: Safety Comes First
  2. Lecture 5-2: Responding When Someone Tells You
  3. Lecture 5-3: Divorce and Remarriage: The Positions
  4. Lecture 5-4: Beside Those Who Part
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: A Referral Map and a First Reply
Chapter 6 · Week 6: Households of Many Shapes, and the Carer's Own
  1. Lecture 6-1: Children, Blended Families and Single Parents
  2. Lecture 6-2: Distance, Migration, Childlessness, Singleness and Widowhood
  3. Lecture 6-3: The Carer's Own Household and Boundaries
  4. Lecture 6-4: A Church That Supports Households Over Years
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab: A One-Page Household Care Policy

Jump to the key points ↓

26 min

Every person who marries arrives with a picture of what married life will be like. Most of the picture was never decided. It was absorbed: from the house they grew up in, from the marriages they watched, from the stories their culture tells, and from what their church taught or did not say. Two people in love often assume that their pictures match. Many discover after the wedding that they do not.

This lecture is about bringing those pictures into the light before the wedding. It looks at expectations that nobody has spoken, at the habits each person carries from the family they grew up in, and at faith: what each person believes, how they practise it, and what happens when the two come from different traditions or one holds no faith. It offers questions and a way of asking them, and it keeps one rule throughout: the carer opens the conversation; the two people have it.

This course is not marriage therapy and not legal advice. Talking about family background is not an exploration of anyone's childhood wounds. If a deep hurt comes to light, the carer listens, thanks the person, and helps them find a qualified helper. And questions of law, such as the form of the marriage, nationality or the religion of children as law may treat it, go to a lawyer: check locally.

What these 26 minutes give you

  • Ask open questions that bring unspoken expectations into the open without leading the couple to an answer.
  • Explain how family-of-origin habits shape a marriage, and why they should be named without blame.
  • Describe how a carer can talk about faith with a couple who share a tradition, who differ in tradition, or who differ about whether to believe.
  • Say what a carer should not do when a couple differ in faith: no pressure, no verdicts, no promises.
  • Recognise when a conversation about background should stop and a professional be sought.

Counsel in the heart of man is like deep water; but a man of understanding will draw it out." — Proverbs 20:5

World English Bible

Therefore a man will leave his father and his mother, and will join with his wife, and they will be one flesh." — Genesis 2:24

WEB

Do two walk together, unless they have agreed?" — Amos 3:3

WEB

Ruth said, “Don’t entreat me to leave you, and to return from following after you, for where you go, I will go; and where you lodge, I will lodge; your people shall be my people, and your God my God;" — Ruth 1:16

WEB

The proverb gives the carer's method: what lies in a person's heart is like deep water, and a person of understanding draws it out. It does not say pours it out or demands it. Genesis 2:24 is a plain sentence that the whole lecture rests on: a man leaves his father and mother and joins with his wife. Whatever each tradition makes of that sentence, it tells us that every marriage involves leaving one home and building another, and that this takes thought. Amos asks a question about walking together: it is easier when two have agreed where they are going. And Ruth's words to Naomi are a picture of a person who chose another people and another faith with open eyes and out of love. The verse is not a model for every couple. It is one story among others in which faith and family meet. None of these verses promises a particular result. Together they say that agreement is worth seeking and that it grows by honest speech.

1. Questions that open, and questions that close

Imagine two ways to begin a meeting.

Version one. "You both want to have children, don't you? And you both agree that the husband is the head of the home?" Both answers are yes, quickly, because the couple sees what answer is expected.

Version two. "Tell me about a meal in the house where you grew up. Who cooked? Who sat where? What was it like when someone was upset?" The couple tells stories. In the stories there are expectations nobody has put into a sentence.

The first version closes. It asks for assent. The second opens. It asks for a picture. A carer who wants to learn what is actually in the room asks the second kind.

Here are some general rules for the questions themselves.

  • Ask about pictures and ordinary days, not only about principles. "What would a good Sunday look like for you?" shows more than "How important is church?"
  • Ask each person first, and the other afterwards. If one speaks first, the second will often agree. Let each answer before the other hears.
  • Do not lead. "You don't want your mother-in-law living with you, do you?" is a trap. "Where do you imagine your parents living as they grow older?" is a question.
  • Welcome differences. A difference is not a flaw. Two people who have never found a difference have probably not talked enough. The carer's aim is that differences are spoken, not removed.
  • Do not interrogate. A list of fifty questions read in order is an examination. Choose two or three for each meeting and follow where the answers go.
  • Let a person pass. "You do not have to answer that." Some matters are tender, and they may be spoken another day or to another person.

2. Unspoken expectations

An expectation is a belief about how something will be that the believer has never examined. It is only noticed when it is broken. Here are common areas, in the form of questions a carer might use. They are not a checklist. They are a pool to draw from.

  • Days and time. What do you imagine you will do on an ordinary evening? On a day of rest? On a holiday, or a festival? Who will you spend it with?
  • Home. Where will you live, and who will live with you? How tidy or untidy is "normal"? Who will do which jobs, and who will notice when they are not done?
  • Closeness and space. When you are upset, do you want someone to stay with you or to leave you alone? When your partner is upset, which do you expect to do?
  • Speaking. In your family, how were disagreements handled? Raised voices, silence, jokes, a third person, a long walk? What did you take from that about what is normal?
  • Family. How often will you see each family? What will each family expect from you? What will happen when the two families want different things?
  • Children. Do you wish to have children, how many, and when? What do you imagine you would do if it did not happen, or happened differently? (A carer asks this gently, because some couples carry grief about it. Lecture 6-2 returns to childlessness.)
  • Work and money. Who works, how, and what do you each assume about it? Lecture 2-3 takes this up.
  • Care for others. Who will look after an ageing parent? Who will care if one of you is ill?
  • Where will you live, which country, which city? Some couples assume that the other will move without ever having said so.

(an invented example) Tomasz and Farida are in preparation in a rural parish. Tomasz says that on Sundays his family always gathers at his mother's table, as they have for as long as he can remember. Farida says that she looks forward to Sundays at home, quietly, without guests. Neither had mentioned it before, because each assumed that Sunday was simply Sunday. The carer, a married neighbour called Wilhelmina, does not decide who is right. She asks, "What does the Sunday meal mean to each of you?" Tomasz says it means belonging. Farida says that her family's quiet Sundays meant rest and peace. Now they are talking about what they each want to keep, not about who must give way. In the end they plan to go to his mother's on the first Sunday of each month, but the plan matters less than the talk.

3. Habits from the family you came from

Each person learned a great deal about marriage before they ever thought about marrying. They learned it by watching. A person who grew up seeing a mother and father who rarely raised their voices may think that any raised voice means danger. A person who grew up in a house where everything was said loudly and made up at supper may think that silence is the cruel thing. Neither is wrong. They have learned different things, and each assumes their own is normal.

A carer can invite a couple to look at their family's habits with a small number of questions.

  • What did you see between the adults in the house where you grew up, and what did you take from it?
  • What do you want to keep from it? What do you hope will be different?
  • When there was trouble in the family, who spoke, who did not, and who decided?
  • How did your family treat money, work, rest, illness and death?

Three cautions apply.

First, do not blame. The point is not to find fault with anyone's parents. A person who has just described a hard home may need to hear, "Thank you for telling me. That sounds like it was hard." The carer does not explain it, diagnose it or fix it.

Second, do not predict. It is not true that people from difficult homes always repeat what they saw, nor that people from loving homes always do well. People choose, learn, and change. A carer who says, "Because your father was like that, you will be like that" is guessing and doing harm.

Third, know where the line is. If a person describes violence, abuse or serious neglect in their past, a carer listens and does not probe for details. The carer thanks them and, if the person wants it, helps them to find a counsellor or other qualified helper. A church preparation session is not the place to work through such a history. If a child is now at risk, the safe church course sets out what a community must do, and the rules about reporting differ by country, region and role: check locally.

4. Faith and tradition

For many couples who come to a church, faith is the reason they come. For some it is one reason among others. For some, one of the two holds a faith and the other does not, or holds it differently. A carer who handles this part of the conversation well does not assume.

When the two share a tradition. Shared tradition does not mean shared practice. One may pray every day and the other only at services. One may expect grace before every meal and the other has never said it. One may expect to give a tenth of income to the church, while the other has never given anything. A carer can ask, "What does faith look like in an ordinary week in your home? Who prays, when, and what do you want it to look like when you are married?" The questions are practical.

When the two come from different traditions. A Catholic and a Baptist, an Orthodox and a Pentecostal, an Anglican and someone from an independent church: marriages like these are common in many places. Differences may be about worship, the sacraments, how Scripture is read, how a child is welcomed into the church, which church the family attends, how to keep festivals and fasts, and how much each family has welcomed or resisted the match. A carer can help the couple to name the differences and to ask what each person can live with and what each person cannot. A carer should not run down either tradition and should not suggest that one is the true one and the other lesser. Each tradition may also have rules about marriage between its members and members of another body. The carer should learn their own church's rules and describe them honestly. Where the carer's own tradition requires something from the couple, such as a promise concerning children or permission from a bishop or council, the carer should tell the couple clearly and early, not at the last meeting.

When one holds a faith and the other does not. The two may be believer and non-believer, or one may be practising and the other not, or one may be seeking. Traditions differ on what they teach about marriage between a believer and a non-believer, and some give weight to passages that speak of it directly. This course does not settle the question for any church. What it asks is that the carer:

  • listens to both without suspicion of the one who does not believe or has not decided;
  • does not pressure either to convert, to say words they do not mean, or to pretend, in order to be married;
  • does not predict that the marriage will fail or promise that the unbelieving partner will come to faith;
  • asks practical questions: how will you speak about faith at home? How will you raise children, if you have them? What do you each need from the other about your own practice? What happens at festivals, at funerals, at a child's baptism or dedication?
  • tells the couple honestly what their church's rule is, and, if the couple wishes to marry in a church that cannot accept the match, helps them to understand why and what the options are, without contempt for either.

(an invented example) In a small city church in a place where the believers are a minority, a young woman, Yewande, wants to marry a man, Daniel, who is not a believer and does not wish to become one but respects her faith. Their families are not happy. The pastor, Rev. Okonkwo, does not pressure Daniel or tell Yewande what to do. He asks each of them separately and then together what they hope faith will mean in their home, and what they fear. He explains the church's rule plainly, which asks for certain promises, and gives them time. He tells them the choice is theirs. He also tells them that the church will not abandon them whatever they decide.

When someone feels pressure. Sometimes a person says they are marrying in the faith because a family or community demands it, or marrying out of the faith despite a family's demand. The carer's concern is the same in both cases. Each person must be free to say what they believe and what they want. Where a person speaks of fear of their family's or community's response, the carer takes it seriously, because it may be a sign of control or danger, and the safety of that person comes before any wish for harmony or for the church's reputation.

5. What not to do

  • Do not use Scripture as a weapon or as a guarantee. "The Bible says you must not marry outside the faith" and "if you pray enough your differences will vanish" both claim what the text cannot support in a conversation. Read the text with the couple and let them hear what it says.
  • Do not decide for the couple. The carer may tell them what the church requires and what the carer honestly thinks, if asked, labelling it as an opinion. The carer does not tell them whom to marry.
  • Do not use the conversation to gather information to use against either of them. What is learned in preparation is not used for gossip, discipline or leverage.
  • Do not treat a difference as a defect. Difference in background, culture, class, race, age, tradition or temperament is part of what a marriage holds. A carer helps a couple to see it, not to be ashamed of it.
  • Do not take up debates the course does not take up. On contested questions about sexual orientation, traditions differ, and this course does not enter that debate. It asks only that every person who comes to a carer be treated with dignity.

6. A cross-cultural couple, briefly

When the two come from different countries or cultures, expectations differ in more places. Who should be addressed how? What do the families expect about the ceremony, gifts, dowry or bride price, where the couple will live, which language will be spoken at home, and what the children will be called? What is polite for one family may be rude to the other. A carer can ask each person what their family will expect and what they themselves want, and can help them to plan how to speak to their families together. The carer should avoid sentences beginning "People from your culture always..." because they are rarely true and often hurtful. People vary within every culture. Legal questions, such as whose country's law applies to the marriage, nationality for the spouse or the children, and visas, are for a lawyer: check locally.

7. When to stop

A conversation about background or faith should pause or stop when:

  • a person becomes distressed in a way that goes beyond sadness, such as panic, numbness, or talk of harming themselves (the crisis course gives the principles; call for help if there is danger now);
  • a person speaks of fear of the other partner, or of violence or control (the person harmed comes first; no joint meeting; connect them with those who know);
  • a person asks, "Can we talk about this somewhere else?" and the carer should always say yes;
  • the carer feels out of their depth. That is not a failure. It is the beginning of a referral.

Diagram 1. Pictures of married life

Two pictures, one conversation Each person arrives with a picture of married life that was absorbed, not decided My picture From the home I grew up in From the marriages I watched From my culture and my church What I hope to keep, what I hope is different What I have never put into words Their picture From another home, perhaps another country From other marriages, other habits From another culture or tradition What they hope to keep, what they hope changes What they have never put into words speak The carer opens with ordinary-day questions; the two people have the conversation. If fear or violence comes to light: stop, safety first, connect to specialists.

Diagram 2. Faith in the conversation

Three ways faith meets in a couple The same practical questions, without suspicion and without pressure Same tradition Shared name is not shared practice. Ask what an ordinary week of faith looks like. Different traditions Name the differences: worship, sacraments, children, festivals. Run down neither. One holds, one does not No pressure to convert or to pretend. No prediction, no promise. Say the church's rule. Scripture is not a weapon and not a guarantee. Read the text with the couple. Tell them honestly what your church requires, and early.

In short

  • Open questions about ordinary days bring unspoken expectations into the open better than questions that ask for agreement.
  • Each person learned about marriage by watching their own family; naming those habits without blame helps a couple choose what to keep and what to change.
  • Do not predict that a hard home will be repeated or that a good home will not need care.
  • With faith, ask practical questions, tell the couple the church's rule honestly and early, and apply no pressure to convert or to pretend.
  • A difference is not a defect; the aim is that differences are spoken, not removed.
  • Stop and seek help if a person is distressed beyond the conversation, speaks of fear, or the carer is out of depth.
Front Back
Open question Asks for a picture or a story, such as "What would a good Sunday look like for you?"
Family-of-origin habits Learned by watching; named without blame; neither repeated nor escaped by fate.
Faith differences Ask practical questions; state the church's rule early; no pressure, prediction or promise.
When to stop Distress beyond the talk, fear of the partner, a request to speak elsewhere, or a carer out of depth.

One sentence to remember The carer opens the conversation; the two people have it.

This week's action Write three open questions about an ordinary day that you could use with a couple, and cross out any that ask for a yes or no.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • Which of the questions in this lecture would you find hardest to ask, and which hardest to answer? What does that tell you about how you might run the conversation?
  • Think of a custom in your own family that you assumed everyone shared. How did you discover that other people did not?
  • How does your church describe marriage between people of different traditions, or between a believer and a non-believer? Is the rule explained to couples early and kindly? What could be improved?
  • Why does the lecture say never to predict, in either direction, that someone from a hard home will repeat it? What does a prediction do to a person who hears it?
  • A person says quietly, "My family will not allow it." How would you respond, and what would you listen for?

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.