Lecture 5-3: When the Church Speaks About Injustice
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: The Law and the Prophets: Gleaning, Sabbath, Jubilee and the Cry for Justice
- Lecture 1-2: Jesus and the First Churches: Presence, Sharing and the Neighbour
- Lecture 1-3: How the Church Has Remembered: Almsgiving, Deacons, Hospitals and Hospitality
- Lecture 1-4: Why People Are Poor: Many Causes, One Neighbour
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: My First Reaction
- Lecture 2-1: Dignity and the Shape of a Gift
- Lecture 2-2: Relief, Recovery, Development and Change
- Lecture 2-3: Choosing Fairly, Keeping Confidence, Keeping Records
- Lecture 2-4: Telling the Story: Pictures, Appeals and Consent
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: Reviewing How We Receive a Request
- Lecture 3-1: Listening First: Needs and Gifts in the Same Street
- Lecture 3-2: Public Services, Charities and the Systems Around Us
- Lecture 3-3: Working Together: Other Churches, Agencies and Neighbours of Other Faiths
- Lecture 3-4: Knowing Our Limits: Noticing, Referring and Staying Beside
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Drawing a Neighbourhood Map
- Lecture 4-1: Food, Housing, Work and Learning
- Lecture 4-2: Older People, Disabled People, Single Parents and Carers
- Lecture 4-3: On the Street, in Prison and Coming Home
- Lecture 4-4: Neighbours of Other Faiths and None: Serving a Plural Neighbourhood
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Designing One Small Service
- Lecture 5-1: Volunteers: Choosing, Training and Boundaries
- Lecture 5-2: Mercy and Witness: Without Conditions, Without Hiding
- Lecture 5-3: When the Church Speaks About Injustice
- Lecture 5-4: A Church With Many Voices: Keeping Together, and Justice at Home
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: Our Words and Our Deeds
A church that serves its neighbours for long enough begins to see patterns. The same families lose their homes for the same reasons. The same people are turned away from the same office. A road, a rule, a lender or a landlord seems to be the cause of trouble that no amount of Thursday suppers can remove. Sooner or later a thoughtful person on the team says: we keep treating the result; should we not say something about the cause?
This is a serious question, and it is not easily answered. Some Christians hold that a church has a duty to speak, as the prophets did. Others hold that speech about public matters belongs to citizens and not to the pulpit, and that a church which speaks will soon be a party in everything but name. Others say that silence is itself a way of taking a side. Each of these has real people behind it, and each can point to times when it was right.
This lecture does not settle the larger debate; that belongs to the course on public theology, which asks about church, state, politics and economics. Here the question is about practice. When and how should a local church speak about an injustice that its neighbours suffer, so that it speaks for the weak and does not use them, listens before it talks, and never turns belonging into a matter of party?
The answer the lecture gives is three questions to ask before speaking, and a few habits that follow. The central claim of the course sits behind it: justice is the shared responsibility that Scripture lays on a whole community for the weak among them. A church that speaks in that spirit is carrying a share of that responsibility, not claiming to own it.
What these 30 minutes give you
- Describe the difference between speaking for the weak and using the weak, with an example of each.
- Ask and answer the three questions before speaking: whom are we serving by speaking, whom did we listen to first, and what does Scripture, not a party, say?
- Explain why a church that speaks should also act, and why the pulpit may need restraint.
- State the cost of silence and the cost of speech, and why a church should not make belonging depend on a party.
- State the three views on whether and how a church speaks on justice, and say what this course requires whichever is held.
For I know how many your offenses, and how great are your sins— you who afflict the just, who take a bribe, and who turn aside the needy in the courts." — Amos 5:12
World English Bible
Hate evil, love good, and establish justice in the courts. It may be that Yahweh, the God of Armies, will be gracious to the remnant of Joseph.”" — Amos 5:15
WEB
Open your mouth for the mute, in the cause of all who are left desolate." — Proverbs 31:8
WEB
Open your mouth, judge righteously, and serve justice to the poor and needy.”" — Proverbs 31:9
WEB
Learn to do well. Seek justice. Relieve the oppressed. Judge the fatherless. Plead for the widow.”" — Isaiah 1:17
WEB
So, then, my beloved brothers, let every man be swift to hear, slow to speak, and slow to anger;" — James 1:19
WEB
for the anger of man doesn’t produce the righteousness of God." — James 1:20
WEB
Why do you see the speck that is in your brother’s eye, but don’t consider the beam that is in your own eye?" — Matthew 7:3
WEB
Or how will you tell your brother, “Let me remove the speck from your eye;” and behold, the beam is in your own eye?" — Matthew 7:4
WEB
You hypocrite! First remove the beam out of your own eye, and then you can see clearly to remove the speck out of your brother’s eye." — Matthew 7:5
WEB
The prophet Amos speaks in the setting of a court, where bribes and a turning aside of the needy are the charge. Proverbs 31:8-9 is the counsel a mother gives a king, not a slogan for a movement. James puts a brake on speech: swift to hear, slow to speak. And Jesus's words about the speck and the beam ask a speaker to look at their own eye first. The verses push in both directions. They tell us to speak, and they tell us to be careful how.
1. The prophets, and why they are not a licence
When a church thinks about speaking out, it usually thinks of the prophets. Amos stands at the gate and names bribes and unjust courts. Isaiah calls his people to seek justice for the fatherless and the widow. These are powerful texts, and a church should not pretend they are not in the Bible.
But the prophets are easy to misuse, and three cautions keep us honest.
First, the prophets spoke to their own people, about their own people's courts, in the name of a that those people had accepted. Amos does not rebuke a distant government for things done far away. He speaks to those who share the law and the God he names. A modern church has no covenant of that kind with the town hall or the parliament. It is a part of the community, a body of citizens among others. What it says carries the weight of that membership and no other.
Second, the prophets were called, and most of them were not comfortable men. A church that rushes to speak because it feels good to be bold may have borrowed the prophet's voice without his burden. Many prophets spoke because they could not stay silent, and they paid for it. A church that speaks should ask whether it is speaking because it has been burdened by the cry of people it knows, or because it wishes to be seen to be on the right side.
Third, the prophets did not only say; their words are inseparable from a life of obedience that the whole community was meant to share: gleaning, sabbath, honest weights, fair courts (lecture 1-1). The people were not simply told that injustice was wrong; they were told what a just community does. A church that only says, without doing, is a prophet without a field.
So the prophets give us permission to speak, and also a warning about when and how. They do not give us a ready-made script.
2. Speaking for the weak and using the weak
Proverbs 31:8 asks us to "open your mouth for the mute". The word matters. The mute are those who cannot speak, or whose speech will not be heard. To speak for them is to carry their cry to places where it would not otherwise be heard.
But there is an old and quiet danger. A church can say "we speak for the poor" while saying what it wished to say already, and using the poor as the proof. The neighbour is then a case in somebody's argument. They have not been asked what they want said, or whether they want it said at all. They may fear what will happen to them if their name, or their street, is mentioned. They may disagree with the church's stance. They may have a plan of their own.
There is a simple way to tell speaking for from using. If the neighbour were in the room, would they recognise what is being said, and would they agree that it should be said? If the answer is yes, the church is speaking for them. If the answer is no, or if nobody has asked, the church is using them.
A second test follows: who is the speech for? A statement that makes the church feel brave, makes its members feel united or pleases a friendly newspaper may be doing nothing for the people it names. The prophetic question is whether the speech helps the weak person, not whether it helps the speaker's image.
(An invented example.) The town of Pell Cross had one bus route that took people from the Marsh Lane estate to the clinic. The town decided to end it. A women's group at the Marsh Lane Fellowship, a small church near the estate, drew up a strong letter the decision "an act of cruelty by those who do not care". Before it was sent, a member named Bashir asked whether any of the people who used the bus had read it. Nobody had. When two bus users were asked, one said she was glad someone was speaking, but that the word "cruelty" would make the council defensive and would cost her the friendly clerk who had been helping her with a form. The other said he had been trying for a month to get the council to hear a simple request: keep the route for two mornings a week. The church rewrote the letter: it described the facts as told by the bus users, with their agreement, asked the council to meet them, and offered the church hall for the meeting. The letter was shorter, quieter and more useful.
Nobody in this example is a villain. The women's group acted from compassion, and the council may have had reasons. The change was that the church listened first.
3. Three questions before speaking
A church deciding whether to speak can ask three questions. They are not a formula that guarantees wisdom, but they keep a church from the two common mistakes, speaking too quickly and never speaking at all.
1. Whom are we serving by speaking?
Name the people. Not "the poor" in general, but these people, in this place, with this problem. Then ask: would our speech help them? Would it make anything better, or only make us feel heard? What might it cost them? Is anyone likely to be harmed by being named, by a counter-attack, or by a loss of goodwill with the very people who help them now? Who else may be hurt, including people whose view we do not share?
If the honest answer is that the speech would serve the church's image more than the neighbour, the church should stop. If the answer is that the speech might serve them but might also put them at risk, then the church should ask them, not decide for them.
2. Whom did we listen to first?
James 1:19 says swift to hear, slow to speak. Before speaking, a church should have heard from the people most affected, and should have heard from at least one person who sees the matter differently: an official, a landlord, a business owner, a neighbour who disagrees. Not so that the church will end up with a bland middle, but so that it knows what the facts are, what the other side says and where its own account might be wrong. Proverbs 18:13 says that to answer before hearing is folly and shame.
A church that has listened first will usually speak more modestly, more accurately and with more credibility. It may also discover that the matter is more complicated than it looked, or that the thing that looked like malice was a mistake.
3. What does Scripture say, and what does a party say?
This question is the hardest. Most of us hold political opinions, and many of those opinions have been shaped by the groups we belong to. The church's task, when it speaks as a church, is to say what Scripture says: that the weak are not to be oppressed, that courts are not to be bent, that wages are to be paid, that the stranger and the widow are to be protected. How a society achieves those things is usually open to debate among people of good will, and a church that has bound its voice to one party's method has tied the gospel to that party's fortunes.
So the church asks: Could a faithful believer of another party say amen to what we are about to say? If a church's statement goes beyond what Scripture requires, to a particular law, a particular candidate or a particular side in an argument on which believers differ, the church should ask whether this is its place, or whether it belongs to members as citizens. Matthew 7:3-5 gives a final check: before we remove the speck from the neighbour's eye, what is in our own? A church that is about to speak about the treatment of workers might first look at how it treats its cleaner (lecture 5-4).
4. A church that does as well as says
A statement without a deed is cheap, and the neighbours know it. If a church speaks about housing but runs no help for those who are evicted, or speaks about hunger and has no table, or speaks about the treatment of strangers and has never welcomed one, its words will sound like an opinion, and a safe one.
By contrast, a church that serves, and then speaks, speaks with earned weight. It knows these people. It has sat at tables with them. It can say, "We see this every week." This is why a local church often has more to say than a distant organisation, and also why it must be careful: it knows details that belong to the neighbours, and it must not spend them carelessly.
The same church may also learn that its action alone is enough. A church that helps a family find a better place, and a landlord who changes a practice because a volunteer asked him over a cup of tea, has done something no statement could. Speech is one tool among several. Others include an introduction, a quiet request, a letter to a particular person, a shared meeting, a petition signed by neighbours, or the simple act of accompanying someone who is afraid to go to an office alone. A church may choose the least public means that can work, and move to a more public one only when the quieter ways have failed and the neighbours agree.
5. The cost of silence and the cost of speech
Both have costs, and a church should count both.
The cost of silence. If a church sees injustice every week and says nothing, its neighbours may conclude that it does not care, or is afraid, or is comfortable. Silence may protect the church from conflict, and it may leave the weak without an ally where an ally was possible. In some places, silence also protects the powerful. A church that never speaks may find that, one day, it has no words when they are needed.
The cost of speech. Speech costs relationships with people who disagree, and sometimes costs the good will on which the church's help depends. It can divide the congregation (lecture 5-4). It may bring attention to the very neighbours the church wishes to protect, or draw a response on them. In some places it is dangerous for the church itself, and the decision to speak or not speak must take account of the safety of members and neighbours. A church in such a place may serve by quiet means, and may choose to wait, and there is no shame in a careful choice.
Neither cost settles the matter. The point is to count them honestly, in the open, with those who would bear them.
6. The pulpit's restraint
The pulpit has a special weight. A congregation comes to hear what God says, and it is hard to disagree with a pastor in the middle of a service. This gives a pastor a power that should be used lightly on public matters on which believers differ.
A pastor or priest may preach what the text says about justice, wages, the stranger and the poor. Most congregations would be poorer if the pulpit never did. But where a sermon moves from "Scripture says that courts must not be bent" to "so vote for this person" or "so oppose this particular law", the pastor has stepped from the text to a political judgement, and a member who disagrees must either stay silent or leave. A congregation is better served if the pulpit teaches the principle and the church provides places, outside the sermon, where members who differ may talk, ask and disagree (lecture 5-4).
The church's own rules, and the law of your place, may also limit what a church or its leaders may say about parties, candidates and elections, and what a church may do and keep its legal status. Find out in advance what applies to you, write it down and follow it. This lecture is not legal advice, and the rules differ greatly between places. In some places a church may say nothing about a candidate; in others the question does not arise; in others a church is a political body whether it wishes to be or not. A church should not break the law of its place, and should ask a qualified person where it is unsure.
Above all, a church never makes belonging depend on a party. Anyone, of any party, any view and none, may sit at the table and in the pew. A person who disagrees with the church's statement is still a member, still a neighbour and still a person to be served.
7. Where readers will not agree
This is a point where readers will not agree. The question is how, and whether, a church speaks on justice. One group holds that the church must speak as the prophets did, naming injustice in public, because the church is the body of the one who stood with the poor, and to say nothing while the courts are bent is to take the side of those who bend them. They would say that Christians in some times and places, in the struggles against slavery or against cruel regimes, spoke and were right to speak. A second group holds that the church's work is formation and mercy: it teaches, forgives, feeds and prays, and it forms members who then carry Christian conviction into public life as citizens. They fear that a church which speaks on policy will lose its unity, will mistake its own opinions for God's word and will make the pulpit a platform for the powerful of the day. A third group holds that silence is a form of taking sides: that a church which says nothing about a clear wrong has chosen the side of the wrong, and that neutrality is a luxury of the safe. These positions are not stupid on any side. The first risks confusing a prophet's calling with a party's agenda, the second risks leaving the weak without a voice, and the third risks reading every silence as guilt.
What this course requires is smaller than any of them: a church can say what Scripture says, listen first, and ask the three questions before it speaks; it never makes belonging depend on a party. Whether it should speak on this matter, in this place, at this time, is a decision for the church and its leaders, made with the neighbours and in the light of the law and of their own safety.
8. The same matter from other sides
From the neighbour's side, there are two quiet hurts. One is when a church speaks for them without asking. The other is when a church that knows them well says nothing while a wrong continues. A neighbour may wish the church to speak, may wish it not to, or may wish it to speak differently; the only way to know is to ask, and to accept the answer.
From the official's side, the person who runs the office, the scheme or the rule may be doing their best with little. A church that speaks in public as if every official were a villain may harden the person it wishes to move. A church that first asks, "Can we understand how this works?" may find an ally. Officials are also neighbours, and some are members of churches.
From the volunteer's side, a team that serves every week may feel anger more keenly than a leader who sits in meetings. This anger is often a gift: it shows that the volunteer cares. James 1:20 reminds us that the anger of man does not produce the righteousness of God. The leader's task is to help the anger become patient work, not to dismiss it.
From the church member's side, a person who votes differently from the pastor may wonder whether they are still welcome. A church that says clearly that it speaks from Scripture and not from a party, and that those who differ are still full members, keeps the door open.
Diagram 1. Three questions before a church speaks
In short
- The prophets give a church permission to speak and a warning: they spoke to their own people, were called, and lived what they said.
- Speaking for the weak means the neighbour would recognise and agree; speaking about them without asking uses them.
- Ask three questions first: whom are we serving, whom did we listen to first, and what does Scripture, not a party, say.
- A church that does something as well as says something is heard, and may try the least public means that can work.
- Count the cost of silence and the cost of speech; the pulpit shows restraint, and belonging never depends on a party.
- Find out what the law and your church's rules allow about parties, candidates and elections.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Speaking for or using the weak | For: the neighbour would recognise it and agree. Using: they were not asked, or the speech serves the speaker's image. |
| The three questions | Whom are we serving by speaking? Whom did we listen to first? What does Scripture, not a party, say? |
| Cost of silence and cost of speech | Silence may leave the weak without an ally; speech may divide the church or endanger a neighbour. Count both, with those affected. |
| The course's requirement | A church can say what Scripture says, listen first, ask the three questions, and never make belonging depend on a party. |
One sentence to remember A church speaks well about injustice when it has listened first, speaks for and not over the weak, and keeps the table open to every party.
This week's action Choose one injustice your neighbours face and write down your answers to the three questions in a few lines, without naming any person.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- Think of a time when someone spoke for you without asking. What would you have wanted them to do first?
- Apply the three questions to an injustice in your own place, in broad terms and without naming any person. Which question is hardest to answer honestly?
- Why does the lecture say that the prophets give a church permission to speak and also a warning? Name two of the warnings.
- What would be a quieter step than a public statement that a church could try first? When would a quiet step be wrong?
- State the three views on whether a church should speak on justice in the way a person holding each would state it. Which fear behind each seems most real to you?
- How might a pastor teach what Scripture says about justice without telling members how to vote? Write one sentence for the pulpit and one for a small group.
- If a member of your church disagreed with a statement it made, what would tell them that they still belong?