Lecture 3-2: Factory and City
Contents 31
- Lecture 1-1: What Do We Mean by Technology?
- Lecture 1-2: Fill the Earth, Keep the Garden
- Lecture 1-3: Makers in Genesis and Exodus
- Lecture 1-4: Babel and the Idol: When Making Goes Wrong
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: The Tools in My Hands
- Lecture 2-1: Voice, Scroll and Codex
- Lecture 2-2: Copying by Hand: Monasteries and Care for the Book
- Lecture 2-3: The Press and the Word on the Move
- Lecture 2-4: One Book in Every Language: Translation and the Printed Bible Beyond Europe
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: How the Word Reaches Me
- Lecture 3-1: The Clock and the Calendar
- Lecture 3-2: Factory and City
- Lecture 3-3: Steamship, Railway, Telegraph and the Spread of the Gospel
- Lecture 3-4: Rest in a Machine Age
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: The Shape of My Time
- Lecture 4-1: Wires and Waves: When Distance Shrinks
- Lecture 4-2: The Medium and the Message
- Lecture 4-3: Broadcast Worship: Watching and Gathering
- Lecture 4-4: The Voice and the Body: What Words Need
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Where I Hear the Word
- Lecture 5-1: The Promise of Connection
- Lecture 5-2: Online Worship and the Sacraments
- Lecture 5-3: Attention, Speed and Sabbath
- Lecture 5-4: Gathered and Scattered: What the Local Church Is For
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: My Screen and My Gathering
In the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries, in a series of changes that began in Britain and spread, machines driven by water and steam moved much work out of homes and small shops into factories, mines and mills. Towns grew into cities, and millions of people moved to them. This lecture tells that change in general terms and asks one question: what did the church do, and what did it fail to do?
We shall not tell a story of heroes and villains. Christians were found on every side. Some stood beside workers and worked for laws that limited the hours of children. Some taught that the factory-owner was God's steward and the worker's duty was to obey. Many did both in turn. The lecture sets out the range of answers, names what was wise in them and what came late, and then reads three Scripture texts about work.
What these 20 minutes give you
- Describe in general terms how factory work and the growth of cities changed work, family and neighbourhood.
- Name at least three kinds of answer that churches and Christians gave to these changes.
- Summarise the main points of *Rerum Novarum* (1891) on the dignity of work, just wages and rest.
- Give an honest account of where churches were late, or sided with owners, without turning the story into a verdict on all Christians.
- Separate what Genesis 2:15, Colossians 3:23 and James 5:4 say from how traditions have read them, and from our own judgement.
Yahweh God took the man, and put him into the garden of Eden to cultivate and keep it." — Genesis 2:15
World English Bible
And whatever you do, work heartily, as for the Lord, and not for men," — Colossians 3:23
WEB
Come now, you rich, weep and howl for your miseries that are coming on you. Your riches are corrupted and your garments are moth-eaten. Your gold and your silver are corroded, and their corrosion will be for a testimony against you, and will eat your flesh like fire. You have laid up your treasure in the last days. Behold, the wages of the laborers who mowed your fields, which you have kept back by fraud, cry out, and the cries of those who reaped have entered into the ears of the Lord of Armies." — James 5:1-4
WEB
Genesis 2:15 puts work before : the man is placed in the garden to cultivate and keep it. Colossians 3:23 tells believers, in a letter that also speaks to slaves and masters, to work as for the Lord. James 5:1-4 speaks sharply to the rich who hold back the wages of the people who reaped their fields, and says that the cries of the workers have been heard. These texts do not describe factories. They give us three questions to bring to the factory: Is work good? What does it mean to work for the Lord? And what does God hear when wages are held back?
1. Work before the factory, and after
Before the great change, a large part of the world worked on land, in households and in small shops. A family might spin, weave, farm and sell from the same house. Work was hard, and often poor, and not everyone worked for themselves. But work and home were close. A child learned a trade by watching a parent, and the rhythm of work followed light, season and task, as we saw in lecture 3-1.
Factories changed this in several ways, and the changes did not come at the same speed everywhere. Work moved away from home. Workers were hired by the hour, day or week, and the pace was set by the machine and by the supervisor. Pay came as a wage. In the early cities, housing was often crowded and unsafe, water and air were poor, and people far from their villages found themselves among strangers. Children, women and men worked long hours, and in many places children worked in mills and mines. The goods were cheaper and more people could own them. Fabric, tools and books became easier to buy. Both of these are true. Some people gained a better life and some lost one, and many experienced both.
We must add one hard fact. The mills of some countries depended on raw cotton grown by enslaved people far away. The machine age and slavery were joined in the same economy. This does not mean that every factory worker or owner approved of slavery. It means that any honest account of the factory has to include the people whose forced labour fed it.
2. The first kind of answer: stay with people
Many congregations simply stayed with those who suffered. A parish in a mill town buried the dead, visited the sick and fed the hungry. Pastors and priests, and many lay people, taught reading and sums in Sunday schools and evening classes, because many working people had no other schooling. Churches and religious orders opened hospitals, orphanages and homes for the poor, and groups of believers raised money for the unemployed. This kind of care was not a plan to change the system. It was what Christians had always done: to feed, to visit, to bury. It was also often very costly to those who did it.
This answer had a weak point. Charity can help a person without asking why the person is in need. If a church gives bread to the family of a child who works twelve hours a day, and never asks why the child works twelve hours, then the bread is good and the silence is a failure. Many Christians at the time said so themselves.
3. The second kind of answer: change the law
Others worked to change the conditions of work. In Britain, for example, the Earl of Shaftesbury, a member of the Church of England who held strong evangelical convictions, took a leading part in campaigns for laws that limited the work of children and women in factories and mines. Similar movements arose in other countries, some led by Christians, some by others, and some by both together. Reformers asked for shorter hours, safer workplaces, schooling for children and the freedom of workers to join together.
These movements were not always popular with churches. Some church members who owned mills were against them. Some preachers said that suffering was a trial sent by God to be endured, and that it was not for the faithful to complain. There were also Christians who answered that to tell a hungry worker to be patient while the owner grew rich was to misread the Scriptures. We should record that disagreement as part of the history. The church did not speak with one voice, and its most public voices were often not the bravest.
4. The third kind of answer: teaching about work
In 1891 Pope Leo XIII published the letter Rerum Novarum, "of new things". It is usually seen as the start of a long line of Catholic social teaching. Without quoting it, we can summarise some of its main points as the tradition itself would put them. Work is not a mere commodity to be bought and sold; it expresses the dignity of the human person. A worker is owed a just wage, one that allows a person to live decently with a family, and agreement of both sides to a low wage does not by itself make it just. Workers have a right to form associations, such as unions, to protect themselves. Rest belongs to the worker, including rest on the Lord's Day and feast days. Children should not be set to work that is beyond their strength. At the same time, the letter defended private property and rejected the idea that the class struggle was the only truth about society, and it warned against socialism of a kind then spreading. The letter saw owners and workers as bound together by duties, and not as natural enemies.
How the letter was received differed. Some Catholics welcomed it as a charter for workers, and others used it to support limited reforms and nothing more. Many Protestants of the time had their own parallel movements. In the United States, for example, a stream of Protestant preaching and writing about the social duties of the church, often called the Social Gospel, drew attention to wages and housing. Other Protestants said that the church's task was to save souls and that the economy was for the market to settle. We describe these as positions, not as a scorecard. Orthodox communities also lived through these changes in several lands. This lecture does not describe their teaching on factory labour, because it cannot be summarised here with confidence, and a reader from that tradition is invited to bring it to the discussion.
5. Where the church was late, or on the wrong side
An honest lecture has to say where the story does not flatter the church. In some places churches were funded in part by mill owners, and the pastor was reluctant to bite the hand that paid. In some places the seats nearest the front were rented to the wealthy, and the poor sat at the back or stayed away. In some places preachers taught workers that God had placed them in their station, and that to wish for more was a sin. In some places the church supported the owners in disputes about wages. And in many places, workers came to think that the church was against them. Some left, and some began their own movements of worship and mutual help.
The text we have from James is a hard light on all this. James 5:4 says that the wages kept back by fraud cry out, and that the cries of the reapers have reached the ears of the Lord of Armies. The verse does not say that all employers are guilty, and it does not give a method for setting wages. It says that unpaid and underpaid workers are heard by God. Christians who read the verse in the factory age sometimes turned it into a rebuke of owners, and sometimes avoided it. The fair question to ask is not "Did the church always fail?" It did not. The fair question is "When the church spoke for workers, why did it often speak late?"
We should avoid a simple lesson here. It would be easy to say that the church should always have sided with workers, or that the church's task was never economic. Neither is simple. Churches have a duty to the poor, and they also have a duty to speak the truth to all and to include the owner in the church. A church that does not know the facts of the workplace will speak foolishly. Yet silence in the face of cruelty is also a choice. We leave the question open and say only that the history gives us no safe ground for saying "that was not our business".
6. Three texts for work
Genesis 2:15 tells us that work was in the garden before sin. Man is placed there "to cultivate and keep it". Whatever has gone wrong with work since, work itself is not the curse. (Genesis 3 speaks of toil and pain in work after the fall, and we are not ignoring it.) So the factory age cannot be answered by saying that work is evil. A Christian view of work begins by saying that it is good, that it is part of how people care for the world, and that it can be done well.
Colossians 3:23 tells those who work to do it heartily, as for the Lord, and not for people. The verse has been used in different ways. Some have used it to encourage excellence, honesty and faithfulness in any trade, which is a good use. In the factory age and earlier, some also used it to tell the poor and the enslaved to obey without complaint, which is a use that deserves hard questions. Notice what the verse says: it points the worker to God as the one who sees. It does not say that the master is God, and it does not say the master may demand anything. The same letter says elsewhere that masters should treat their slaves justly and fairly, remembering that they too have a master in heaven. Reading Colossians 3:23 well means reading it with that balance, and not as a weapon for either side.
James 5:1-4, as we saw, gives the third question. The three together describe a stance: work is good, it is to be done as for God, and God hears the one who is cheated of the wages.
7. What this means for how we read today
This lecture does not argue that machines were wrong or that factories should not have existed. It does not argue that every Christian should have been a reformer. It argues something smaller. The change in work was fast and affected family, time, health and neighbourhood. The church had resources to meet it: care, teaching, the Sabbath and the voice of the prophets. It used them partly. When we meet new change in our own time, we can ask the same questions, in a plainer way: Who carries the load here? Who is paying for the gain? What does the church know that it is not saying, and who is it afraid to ask?
Diagram 1. From field and shop to factory and city
In short
- Factories and cities moved work away from home and put it under wages, hours and machine pace; some gained and some lost.
- The machine age was joined to slavery, because some mills depended on cotton grown by enslaved people.
- Churches answered by staying with the suffering, by pressing for changes in the law, and by teaching about work.
- Rerum Novarum (1891) taught the dignity of work, a just wage, the right to form associations and rest.
- In some places churches were late, depended on owners, or told workers to accept their station.
- Genesis 2:15, Colossians 3:23 and James 5:4 together say: work is good, do it as for the Lord, and God hears the cheated.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Three answers | Stay with the suffering (care and charity); change the law (reform); teach about work (dignity, wage, rest). |
| Rerum Novarum | A Catholic letter of 1891: work has dignity, wages must be just, workers may form associations, rest belongs to them. |
| Where the church was late | Dependence on owners, rented pews, teaching that the poor should accept their station, silence about cruelty. |
| James 5:4 | Wages kept back by fraud cry out, and God hears the cry of the workers. |
One sentence to remember The church had the resources to meet the factory age, and it used them partly: care came early, justice often late.
This week's action Think of one kind of work you rely on every day and ask who does it, under what conditions, and whether anyone has asked them.
Check yourself
Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.
Reflection and discussion
- How did factory work change the relation between home, work and time? What was gained and what was lost?
- Name three kinds of answer that Christians gave. What is the strength and the weak point of each?
- Summarise *Rerum Novarum* on work, wages and rest. Which of its points would a Protestant reader find familiar, and which might raise questions?
- Where was the church late, or on the wrong side? Why is it important to say this plainly, and also not to say "the church always failed"?
- How do Genesis 2:15, Colossians 3:23 and James 5:4 each add something to a Christian view of work? How can Colossians 3:23 be misused?