FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

STEL7E Theology of Technology: From the Printing Press to AI

Lecture 6-4: Discernment: Questions for Any New Tool

Contents 31
STEL7E Theology of Technology: From the Printing Press to AI
Chapter 0 · Introduction: Why Think Theologically About Technology?
  1. Lecture 0: Introduction: Why Think Theologically About Technology?
Chapter 1 · Week 1: Seeing Technology
  1. Lecture 1-1: What Do We Mean by Technology?
  2. Lecture 1-2: Fill the Earth, Keep the Garden
  3. Lecture 1-3: Makers in Genesis and Exodus
  4. Lecture 1-4: Babel and the Idol: When Making Goes Wrong
  5. Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: The Tools in My Hands
Chapter 2 · Week 2: From Handwriting to the Printing Press
  1. Lecture 2-1: Voice, Scroll and Codex
  2. Lecture 2-2: Copying by Hand: Monasteries and Care for the Book
  3. Lecture 2-3: The Press and the Word on the Move
  4. Lecture 2-4: One Book in Every Language: Translation and the Printed Bible Beyond Europe
  5. Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: How the Word Reaches Me
Chapter 3 · Week 3: Clocks, Factories and the Church
  1. Lecture 3-1: The Clock and the Calendar
  2. Lecture 3-2: Factory and City
  3. Lecture 3-3: Steamship, Railway, Telegraph and the Spread of the Gospel
  4. Lecture 3-4: Rest in a Machine Age
  5. Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: The Shape of My Time
Chapter 4 · Week 4: Telegraph, Radio, Television
  1. Lecture 4-1: Wires and Waves: When Distance Shrinks
  2. Lecture 4-2: The Medium and the Message
  3. Lecture 4-3: Broadcast Worship: Watching and Gathering
  4. Lecture 4-4: The Voice and the Body: What Words Need
  5. Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: Where I Hear the Word
Chapter 5 · Week 5: The Internet and Digital Communities
  1. Lecture 5-1: The Promise of Connection
  2. Lecture 5-2: Online Worship and the Sacraments
  3. Lecture 5-3: Attention, Speed and Sabbath
  4. Lecture 5-4: Gathered and Scattered: What the Local Church Is For
  5. Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: My Screen and My Gathering
Chapter 6 · Week 6: Reading Technology Theologically, and AI as the Last Chapter
  1. Lecture 6-1: Neutral Tool or Driving Force?
  2. Lecture 6-2: Theologians and Philosophers Read Technology
  3. Lecture 6-3: The Last Chapter So Far: AI
  4. Lecture 6-4: Discernment: Questions for Any New Tool
  5. Lecture 6-5: Practice Lab: My One Page on Faith and Technology

Jump to the key points ↓

18 min

Every lecture in this course has ended with questions. This one gathers them. A congregation, a parish council, a group of teachers or a family does not need a theory of technology in order to decide about a new tool. It needs a short list of good questions and a way of asking them together. This lecture offers seven questions that grow out of the course, a way of using them, and some cautions about misusing them.

The lecture does not tell you whether to adopt or refuse any tool. It does not name or evaluate any product. It gives a practice, which is a way of looking that you and others can use again.

What these 18 minutes give you

  • Name the seven questions and say where in the course each one came from.
  • Explain why discernment is practised together and not only by individuals.
  • Use the questions on an invented case, reaching a provisional decision with a date for review.
  • Name two ways in which a list of questions can be misused.
  • State fairly two views on how quickly or slowly a community should take up a new tool.

Test all things, and hold firmly that which is good." — 1 Thessalonians 5:21

World English Bible

This I pray, that your love may abound yet more and more in knowledge and all discernment; so that you may approve the things that are excellent; that you may be sincere and without offense to the day of Christ; being filled with the fruits of righteousness, which are through Jesus Christ, to the glory and praise of God." — Philippians 1:9-11

WEB

But solid food is for those who are full grown, who by reason of use have their senses exercised to discern good and evil." — Hebrews 5:14

WEB

What the text says. First Thessalonians 5:21 tells believers to test everything and hold on to what is good. Philippians 1:9-11 is a prayer that love would grow "in knowledge and all discernment", so that believers can approve what is excellent. Hebrews 5:14 says that discernment comes from practice, "by reason of use".

A tradition's reading. Christian traditions have long spoken of discernment as a skill learned over time, within a community, and not as a rule applied once. Some traditions give special weight to the guidance of elders or a spiritual father or mother; others to the counsel of the gathered congregation; others to the leading of the Spirit in prayer. These are not exclusive, and many hold all three.

Our judgement. None of these verses is about tools. They do show that the New Testament expects believers to judge between things, and to grow in the skill by using it.

1. Discernment is a practice

The word "discernment" can sound grand. In the verses above it is simple. To test all things is to look closely at them. To hold what is good is to keep it. And Hebrews 5:14 gives an important detail: the senses are exercised by use. A person who has made many careful decisions with others finds the next one easier. A congregation that has never asked the questions will find the first time awkward. That is normal, and it is the reason to begin with small tools before large ones.

Notice also that Philippians 1:9 puts love before discernment: "that your love may abound... in knowledge and all discernment". Discernment is not cleverness. It is love learning to see.

2. Seven questions

Here are seven questions. Each is worded for a tool, and each comes from a part of the course. They are not a formula. They are lights to carry into a room.

1. Does it serve love of neighbour? Who will be helped, and who might be harmed? This is the heart of the matter and the question of lecture 1-4: direction and heart, not the tool alone. A tool that makes it easier to visit, to give, to teach or to listen passes a first test; a tool that makes it easier to ignore people does not.

2. What does it do to the weak? Think of the poor, the old, the sick, the very young, people who read slowly or not at all, people who live far from help, and people who cannot afford or cannot use the tool. Lecture 3-2 reminded us that new tools often favour those who already have power. Ask who is left out, and ask who is left carrying a cost that others do not see.

3. What does it do to time and rest? Lectures 3-1 and 3-4 taught us to ask whether a tool gives time or takes it, and whether it respects the day of rest or eats into it. A tool that promises to save time may fill the time it saves. Ask what the gained time will be used for.

4. What does it do to the gathered body? Lecture 5-4 asked what only a gathered people can do. Ask whether the tool draws people together in bread, water, prayer and shared burdens, or whether it lets them drift apart. Ask also whether it helps those who cannot gather.

5. Is it truthful? Does it help us tell the truth, or does it make it easier to mislead, to flatter, to hide? Does it ask us to appear to be what we are not? Scripture does not mention tools, but it does tell us to put away falsehood and to speak the truth in love. A congregation can ask whether its use of a tool, and its way of speaking about it, would stand in the open.

6. What does it make us depend on? Every tool makes us depend on something: on a supply, a maker, a skill that fewer people have, a service that can be withdrawn or priced beyond us. Dependence is not always wrong, since we depend on bread and on one another. The question is whether we know what we depend on and whether we could carry on if it were withdrawn.

7. What does it ask of us? Every tool has a price in attention, money, learning and habit. Ask what we shall be asked to give, to learn and to become. Ask also what the tool asks of those who cannot say no, such as children, workers and the poor. This is the question of formation from lecture 6-1.

3. Using them together

The questions are best asked in a group, for four reasons.

First, nobody sees everything. The person who is eager to use a tool sees its gain; the person who is wary sees its cost; the person who has least power in the room may see the cost to the weak. Discernment improves when all three speak and are heard.

Second, a group keeps a person from deciding by mood. A tool introduced in an exciting meeting can look different on a quiet morning.

Third, Hebrews 5:14 says that discernment grows by practice; a group practises together, and the practice stays when members come and go.

Fourth, the decision is more likely to be honoured. A rule that the council has reached after listening is easier to follow than one announced by a single person.

A simple pattern works in many settings. Name the tool and the purpose in one plain sentence. Invite the people the tool will touch, especially those who do not use it with ease. Ask the seven questions, one at a time, writing down what is said. Decide provisionally: adopt, adopt with limits, wait or decline. Set a review date and say what will be looked at then. Keep a written note, so that the next group knows how the last one decided. The community should follow its own written rules and any local law that applies to the tool, such as laws on data or on the care of children; this course does not give legal advice.

An invented example. A parish considers putting a screen in the sanctuary to show the words of hymns and the readings. The council meets with a wide circle: the choir, the older members who sit near the front, a family with young children, the person who cleans the hall, and a teenager who runs the sound. They ask the seven questions.

On love of neighbour, those who have trouble reading small print say that a large screen would help. On the weak, the choir director notes that the cost would come out of the fund for the church's help to the poor. On time and rest, the cleaner says the screen would add a set-up task on Saturday afternoon. On the gathered body, an older member says that when everyone holds a book, people look at the page; when they look at a screen, they may look up, which is good, but fewer would learn the songs by heart. On truth, no one sees a problem. On dependence, the teenager says that the screen needs a person who knows how to run it and that he will be away at university next year. On what it asks, the council notes that it would ask the parish to spend money, learn a new routine and rely on someone's skill.

They do not reach full agreement. They decide to try it for three months on one Sunday a month, to keep the books in the pews, to ask the teenager to teach two others, and to meet again to review. Notice that the tool is not praised or condemned. It has been looked at.

4. Two ways the questions go wrong

They can be used to win an argument. Someone who already wants a tool may use the questions to build a case, and someone who dislikes it may do the same. The questions work only when they are asked with the willingness to hear an answer that one does not like.

They can become a licence. A group that has "asked the questions" may feel that the matter is closed and stop watching. Discernment does not end with the decision. It goes on in use, which is why the review date matters.

5. How fast, how cautious

This is a point where readers will not agree. Some Christian communities hold that a congregation should be slow to take up a new tool. They give reasons: tools shape habits before we have understood them; the weak are often harmed first; it is easier to wait and learn from others than to undo a habit; and several traditions have lived with tools they judged on a long view. Other communities hold that a congregation should be willing to try, and to learn by doing. Their reasons are equally serious: people who have not heard the gospel or who cannot gather may wait in vain for a church that is afraid; mistakes in small trials can be corrected; and a church that says no to everything new may simply lose touch with those it serves. Each side has a weak point. The first may confuse delay with wisdom and leave the weak without help for a long time. The second may confuse speed with faithfulness and discover harms only after habits are set. A third way, held by many, is to try in small steps with a review date, which is what the parish in the example chose. But even that is a judgement, and communities will weigh it differently. The course asks you to state both fairly, not to choose.

6. What discernment is for

The aim of Philippians 1:9-11 is not that we shall always be right. It is that love abounds and that we are found "sincere and without offense", full of the fruit of righteousness for God's glory. A congregation that has practised these questions together has not only decided about a tool. It has grown in a habit of looking, listening and loving, and that habit is worth more than any single decision. The last lecture of the course asks you to gather it into a page of your own.


Diagram 1. Seven questions for any new tool

Seven questions for any new tool Asked together, with a review date 1. Love of neighbour Who is helped, who might be harmed? 2. The weak Who is left out or left to carry the cost? 3. Time and rest Does it give time or take it? 4. The gathered body Does it draw people together or apart? 5. Truthfulness Does it help us tell the truth in the open? 6. Dependence On what do we come to depend? 7. What it asks of us In attention, money, learning and habit; and what it asks of those who cannot say no. A pattern for deciding together Name it tool and purpose Invite those it touches Ask seven questions Decide provisionally Review on a set date Write it down for the next group Misuse: using the questions to win an argument, or treating the decision as the end of watching. Follow your community's written rules and local law.

In short

  • Discernment is a practice learned by use, and in Philippians 1:9 love comes before it.
  • Seven questions: love of neighbour, the weak, time and rest, the gathered body, truthfulness, dependence, what the tool asks of us.
  • Discernment is best practised together, with those the tool touches, a provisional decision, a review date and a written note.
  • The questions can be misused to win an argument or taken as a licence to stop watching.
  • Readers disagree on how fast to take up a new tool; the course asks you to state both views fairly.
Front Back
The seven questions Love of neighbour; the weak; time and rest; the gathered body; truthfulness; dependence; what it asks of us.
Why together? Nobody sees everything; a group steadies mood; it practises the skill; its decision is more likely to be kept.
A pattern Name it, invite those it touches, ask, decide provisionally, set a review date, write it down.
Two misuses Using the questions to win an argument; treating the decision as the end of watching.

One sentence to remember Discernment is love learning to see, practised together and reviewed on a date.

This week's action Choose one small tool in your community and ask the seven questions with at least one other person.

Review every summary in this course →

Check yourself

Not "did you read it" but "can you explain it". Ticks are kept on this device only.

Reflection and discussion

  • Which of the seven questions comes most easily to you, and which do you tend to forget? Say as much as you wish.
  • Why is discernment better practised together? Give two reasons from the lecture.
  • In the parish example, what did each person bring that the others might not have seen? What was decided, and why a review date?
  • Describe the two ways the questions can be misused. How would you notice them in a meeting?
  • State the two views on how fast a community should take up a new tool, so that a holder of each would say, "Yes, that is my view."

Sign in to write and keep your answers

What next

The lecture ends here. What follows was written by its readers.