FREE

Course certificates are free until March 31, 2027.

Review by summary

All 31 lectures of STEL8E, as nothing but their summaries. For the night before an exam.

Try to recall each summary from the title before revealing it. It stays with you far longer than re-reading does.

Chapter 0 Introduction: Why Think Theologically About Bioethics?

Show summary
  • Medical technology gives us choices older generations never had, and Christians ask not only "can we?" but "should we?"
  • Life is a gift of God and the body is entrusted to us; technology can serve that gift and also gives us new burdens.
  • The course avoids both "technology will save us" and "technology will destroy what is human".
  • Christians bring Scripture, tradition, reason and experience together, stand beside the patient and the weakest, and listen to the strongest form of each side.
  • Protestant, Catholic and Orthodox thinking are each described in their own terms and not ranked.
  • Where readers will not agree, the course gives each side fairly with its weak point; it gives no medical or legal advice and recommends or forbids no treatment.
  • Every Practice Lab has three ways in and four privacy promises, and never asks about your own or a family member's health.
Front Back
The central claim Life is a gift and the body is entrusted to us; technology can serve that gift and also hands us new burdens; we judge together, beside the patient and the weakest.
Two stories to avoid "Technology will save us" and "technology will destroy what is human".
The six weeks Ways of judging; start of life; body and death; limits of treatment; suffering; justice and community.
What it leaves to others AI ethics (STEL5E); the human person (STEL6E); the general theory of technology (STEL7E).
Three ways into a lab Your own place; the observer's way; the partner's way.

One sentence to remember Before every new medical power, ask what it makes possible, what burden it gives, and who stands beside the person who must choose.

Chapter 1 Week 1: Seeing Bioethics

Show summary
  • Medical technology has moved the edges of life: it can help a life begin, hold back dying, read the body and move organs between people.
  • Bioethics is the shared study of the moral questions medicine raises; it grew as medicine gained power, with theologians among those who took part.
  • "Can we?" asks what is possible; "should we?" asks what is good, for whom, and at what cost.
  • Two simple stories, that technology saves us and that technology destroys life, each hold some truth and each hide something.
  • Patient, family and clinician each carry the decision differently; this course blames none of them.
  • The course gives no medical or legal advice and neither urges nor forbids any treatment, test or technology.
Front Back
Bioethics The careful, shared study of the moral questions raised by medicine and the life sciences.
"Can we?" and "should we?" Can asks what is possible; should asks what is good, for whom, at what cost. The first does not settle the second.
Two stories to avoid "Technology saves us" has no room for limits; "technology destroys life" can turn from the sick.
Three faces at the bedside The patient, the family and the clinician; each carries the decision differently and none is blamed.

One sentence to remember Medical technology gives us choices we never had, so we ask not only what can be done but what should be, and who stands at the bedside.

This week's action Write down one medical choice that did not exist a hundred years ago, and one "can we?" and one "should we?" question about it.

Show summary
  • People judge hard medical cases in three main ways: by principles, by virtues and by the story of faith.
  • Principlism names respect for autonomy, beneficence, non-maleficence and justice; it gives a shared language but its principles can collide and are thin.
  • Some writers say "autonomy" reflects a Western stress; others say it protects the weak; a careful use asks each patient how decisions should be shared.
  • Virtue ethics asks what kind of person to be at the bedside, with compassion, honesty and temperance, but does not say what to do in a new case.
  • Theological ethics reasons from story, community and vocation; natural law, Protestant faith ethics and the Orthodox sacramental view each speak of it in their own way.
  • The three ways work best together, and none is ranked above the others.
Front Back
Four principles Respect for autonomy, beneficence, non-maleficence and justice; a shared language that can collide.
Virtue ethics Asks what kind of person to be at the bedside: compassion, honesty, temperance.
Theological ethics Reasons from the story of faith, from community and from vocation; traditions speak of it differently.
Why use all three Each sees what the others miss; when they pull apart the question is hard, not failed.

One sentence to remember Principles say what matters, virtues say who to be, and the story of faith says what we are called to; a wise judgement listens to all three.

This week's action Think of a decision you made recently and ask yourself the three questions: what mattered, who did I want to be, and what was I called to.

Show summary
  • Scripture says directly that life is a gift, that the body has dignity, and that the weak are to be cared for.
  • Scripture does not mention IVF, genetic tests or ventilators, so applying it to them is tradition's reading and our judgement.
  • Catholic, Protestant and Orthodox traditions weigh Scripture, tradition, reason and experience differently; this is description, not ranking.
  • Proof-texting lifts a verse out of its setting to settle a modern argument; this course presents no verse as a decisive proof text.
  • Psalm 139:13-16 and Exodus 21:22-25 are read in different ways by careful readers, each with a strong point and a weak point.
  • Say what the text says, what a tradition reads, and what we judge, and keep them apart.
Front Back
Three things Scripture says directly Life is a gift; the body has dignity; the weak are to be cared for.
Four sources Scripture, tradition, reason and experience, weighed differently by different traditions.
Proof-texting Lifting a verse out of its setting to settle a modern argument.
Psalm 139:13-16 Read as God's care before birth, or as a poetic prayer not meant to define when a person begins. Each has a weak point.

One sentence to remember Scripture gives convictions and a direction, not a ruling on every new technology, so we keep apart what the text says, what a tradition reads and what we judge.

This week's action Take one verse you have heard used in a medical argument and ask the four questions of it.

Show summary
  • The method has seven steps: facts, people, goods in conflict, voices of tradition, options, judgement, and the weak point of that judgement.
  • Facts and people come first; a rule applied before looking at the case may fit the rule and miss the person.
  • A hard decision is often a conflict between real goods, so those who differ are not foolish or faithless.
  • The voices of tradition help a family think; they must not be used to press a family toward one answer.
  • Naming the weak point of one's own judgement is honesty, and it lets us stand with those who chose differently.
  • Deliberation is best done with others (Proverbs 15:22); the method gives no medical advice.
Front Back
The seven steps Facts, people, goods in conflict, voices of tradition, options, judgement, weak point.
Why facts and people first A decision made on a misunderstanding, or by a rule applied before seeing the person, can fit the rule and miss the care.
Goods in conflict Several real goods that cannot all be served; naming them shows that those who differ are moved by a good.
Why state the weak point It is honest, it keeps humility and firmness together, and it allows us to stand with those who chose differently.

One sentence to remember Look at the facts and the people before the rule, hear the traditions without pressing, choose with reasons, and say where your judgement is weakest.

This week's action Take a past decision of your own that you found hard, and walk through the seven steps in writing, with no real names.

Show summary
  • The lab asks you to look at the grounds of your own judgement on a general question of medical technology.
  • It never asks about your own or a family member's health, a diagnosis or a bereavement, and nothing of that should be written.
  • Name which of principles, virtues and story you lean on, what you may neglect, and what Scripture, a tradition and you each say.
  • State the weak point of your own judgement, one question you hold, and one step you will take.
  • Four promises hold: nobody reads it, nothing is marked, you may pass, the leader writes too.
  • There are three ways in: your own place, the observer's way with the printed case, the partner's way.
Front Back
What the lab practises Looking at the grounds of your own judgement on a general question, saying what you do not know, and choosing one step.
The four promises Nobody reads it; nothing is marked; you may pass; the leader writes too.
Three ways in Your own place; the observer's way; the partner's way.
What the lab never asks Your own or a family member's health, a diagnosis or a bereavement; a real name or confidential matter.

One sentence to remember Look honestly at what you rely on when you judge, say what you do not know, and take one small step.

This week's action Fill in the form on paper, on a general question, and keep it where only you will find it.

Chapter 2 Week 2: The Beginning of Life

Show summary
  • IVF joins egg and sperm outside the body; it can be a gift to the childless, and it raises questions about making, storing, choosing and discarding embryos.
  • Christians differ on the embryo's moral status: full from fertilisation, developing, or understood in relationship; each has a strong argument and a weak point.
  • All three positions say the embryo is human life and that it matters; they differ on how much and why.
  • Catholic teaching does not approve IVF, while Orthodox and Protestant communities differ among themselves and within themselves.
  • The abortion debate shares the question of the embryo but is a different debate; readers in this room may have made hard choices.
  • Pastoral care begins with listening and without judgement, for the childless, the bereaved and those deciding now.
Front Back
IVF Joining egg and sperm in a laboratory so that an embryo may be placed in the womb; it raises questions about storing, choosing and discarding embryos.
Moral status of the embryo The kind of regard, protection and rights it is owed. Three Christian views: full from fertilisation, developing, relational.
Why Psalm 139 and Jeremiah 1:5 do not settle it They speak of God's care at the start of a life, in poetry and personal testimony; readers differ on what follows for the embryo.
How to care for the childless and the bereaved Listen first; avoid careless remarks; do not judge any choice; point to a pastor, priest or local support.

One sentence to remember The question of the embryo is held with its strongest argument and its weak point, and the people inside the question are held with care.

This week's action Write down one careless remark a person who longs for a child might hear, and one sentence you would say instead.

Show summary
  • Genetic and prenatal tests often speak in probability; they rarely tell how a life will go, and they cannot tell what a person is worth.
  • There is a right to know and a right not to know; each has good reasons, and neither choice shows lack of faith.
  • Genetic information is shared in a family, so one person's result can touch others and raises questions of telling and confidence.
  • After a prenatal diagnosis, Christians hold different positions; each has a strong argument and a weak point, and no family is to be judged.
  • Disabled people and many parents critique testing; their voices deserve weight, and disability is never to be written as a lack.
  • A congregation listens first, keeps confidences, does not press in either direction, and stays after the decision.
Front Back
Screening and diagnostic tests Screening raises or lowers the estimated chance of a condition; diagnostic testing aims to say whether it is present.
Right to know / not to know Each protects something: preparation and choice, or peace. A Christian can hold either with a clear conscience.
The disability critique Testing can carry a message that some lives are worth less; many disabled people and parents ask for a world that welcomes them.
What a congregation does Listens first, avoids false comfort, keeps confidences, does not press, offers practical help and stays afterwards.

One sentence to remember A test gives information, not a verdict on a person's worth, and a family in the middle of a hard choice needs company before it needs argument.

This week's action Write one sentence of true comfort you could say to a family waiting for a result, with no advice in it.

Show summary
  • Gene editing, in principle, alters the instructions in cells; we speak of it in the conditional and make no claim about what exists now.
  • Body-cell editing stays in one person; germline editing is heritable, and affects those who cannot consent and may be hard to reverse.
  • Healing and enhancing are clear at the ends and blurred in the middle; what counts as normal or as illness is disputed.
  • "Playing God" names a danger of pride but proves too much if it condemns all healing; its strength and weakness both matter.
  • Justice is part of the question: a costly technology could widen the gap between rich and poor.
  • Catholic, Orthodox and Protestant writers all value healing and are cautious about remaking the human being, and they weigh the two differently.
Front Back
Body-cell vs germline editing Body-cell changes stay in one person; germline changes are heritable, affect those who cannot consent, and are hard to reverse.
Healing and enhancing Clear at the ends, blurred in the middle; what counts as normal or as illness is disputed.
"Playing God" Strong as a warning against pride and treating children as products; weak because it may condemn all healing and does not say which acts are pride.
Why justice belongs here A costly technology could be used by the rich and not the poor, and widen the gap in the human family itself.

One sentence to remember We are called to heal and not to grasp at control, and the work of judgement is to tell the two apart, together and with the poor in view.

This week's action Write one sentence naming a change you would call healing and one you would call enhancing, and note where you were unsure.

Show summary
  • Scripture calls children a gift, which is received, not owed or ordered; "product" names a risk in the habit of mind.
  • The method alone does not settle gift or product; a child can be received with thanks after medical help or without it.
  • Families feel quiet pressures: to have children, to have a certain kind, to use every technology, and to pay for it.
  • A family is a line through time; the future is not secured by control, and a child is a person and not a project.
  • A congregation begins with a question, names the choice as the family's, keeps confidences and promises welcome.
  • It avoids claims no one can know, such as "God's plan" or "all will be well", and does not blame those who chose differently.
Front Back
A child as gift Received, not owed or ordered; welcomed before any test of worth; a person with a life of her or his own.
A child as product A risk in the habit of mind: welcome depends on measuring up. It can occur with or without technology.
Quiet pressures To have children, to have a certain kind, to use every technology, to be able to pay.
How a congregation speaks Starts with a question, offers teaching as a resource, keeps confidences, promises welcome, claims nothing it cannot know.

One sentence to remember Every child is received as a gift, and every family at the start of life is met with a question, a welcome and no pressure.

This week's action Write two sentences you could say to a family at the start of life, and one sentence you would take care never to say.

Show summary
  • The lab practises holding a hard question at the start of life: stating a position fairly, naming its weak point, and finding the grounds of one's own judgement.
  • Nobody is asked about their own or a relative's health, pregnancy, result or loss; the observer's way uses an invented case.
  • Four promises hold: nobody reads it, nothing is marked, you may pass, the leader writes too.
  • There are three ways in: your own place, the observer's way with the printed case, the partner's way.
  • "I do not yet have a view" is an honest answer; the lab ends with one question carried and one step taken.
  • A leader asks which question was hardest, never what position anyone took, and offers private follow-up.
Front Back
What the lab practises Stating a position fairly, naming its weak point, and finding the grounds of one's own judgement or saying honestly that there is none yet.
The four promises Nobody reads it; nothing is marked; you may pass; the leader writes too.
What the lab never asks Anything about your own or a relative's health, pregnancy, result, diagnosis or loss, or any real name.
What a leader asks Which question was hardest to answer, never what position anyone took.

One sentence to remember Hold a hard question by stating each side fairly, naming where it is weak, and saying honestly what you do not yet know.

This week's action Fill in the form on paper, and keep it where only you will find it.

Chapter 3 Week 3: The Body, Organs and the Definition of Death

Show summary
  • The Bible calls the body created and good, the place where people serve God, and, in Christian hope, a body that will be raised.
  • “You are not your own” (1 Corinthians 6:19-20) is read in several ways, and it was written about a different question than medicine.
  • Many writers say the body is entrusted: really in our care, but not owned in the way a possession is owned.
  • Stewardship and self-ownership each protect something real and each has a weak point; readers do not agree on which should come first.
  • Two errors are to despise the body and to make it an idol; the entrusted body lies between them.
Front Back
The body is entrusted It is really in our care and our decisions are real, but we hold it for God and we answer for how we use it.
Two errors about the body Despising it as a low shell; or making health and length of life the highest good.
Stewardship and self-ownership Stewardship stresses that the body is a gift held for another; self-ownership protects the person from being used by others. Each has a weak point.
1 Corinthians 6:19-20 Paul says the believer is not their own and is to glorify God in the body; the verse was written about sexual conduct and is not a ruling on medicine.

One sentence to remember The body is a created gift that is entrusted to us, to be cared for with thanks and not despised or worshipped.

This week's action Write down one sentence you often hear about the body, and ask whether it despises the body, worships it, or receives it as a gift.

Show summary
  • Many Christian traditions understand organ donation as an act of love, but a gift must be free, informed, proportionate and without a price.
  • A living donor gives at a risk and is not owed a duty; donation after death raises questions of when death has come and who decides.
  • Many traditions guard against commerce in organs because need can be used against the poor, and against pressure that takes away freedom.
  • Believers who decline to donate or to receive act from conscience and are not blamed.
  • The resurrection hope rests on God’s power, not on the state of the body; readers still differ on how far respect for the body bears on donation.
Front Back
Conditions of a gift Free, informed, proportionate (not at grave cost to the giver) and without a price.
Two kinds of donation By a living person, which raises questions of freedom and risk; after death, which raises questions of when death has come and who decides.
Two dangers Commerce, where need is used against the poor; and pressure, where family or community leaves no room to decline.
People who decline They act from conscience and faith; the church does not blame them, and does not make a hard choice a test of faith.

One sentence to remember Donation can be a gift of love, and a gift is only a gift when it is free.

This week's action Write one sentence that honours the gift of donation and one that honours the freedom to decline, as a congregation might say them.

Show summary
  • Death was long recognised by the stopping of breath and heartbeat; machines that support breathing made the question harder.
  • The brain criterion says that when brain function has ended for good, the person has died even if machines keep other organs going; criteria and tests differ by country.
  • Christians ask what a person is and whether death is a moment or a process; the Bible’s breath-and-dust verses do not name a moment.
  • Readers differ: one view stresses the brain’s unifying role, another warns against declaring death while the body shows signs of life; each has a weak point.
  • Donation after death needs an honest answer to when death has come; families need company and plain explanation, not a test of faith.
Front Back
Heart-lung and brain criteria Death recognised by the end of breathing and heartbeat; or by the end, for good, of the brain’s functions even when machines support other organs.
The case for the brain criterion The brain holds the body together as a whole; what machines keep going is not the person. Weak point: the unifying role is debated, and the need for organs may have shaped the criterion.
The case for doubting it A warm body with a heartbeat looks alive; in doubt we protect the vulnerable. Weak point: what “alive” means where the brain has ended.
The dead donor rule Organs are taken only from a person who is dead, and no one is hastened to death to give them.

One sentence to remember Sincere Christians answer the question of death differently, and each answer should be heard with its weak point and with care for the family.

This week's action Practise saying, in two plain sentences, why a person might accept the brain criterion and why another might doubt it, without saying who is right.

Show summary
  • For Christians death is an enemy that God will abolish, and the believer belongs to the Lord in life and in death.
  • The voice of death as enemy protects the value of life; its risk is that every death becomes a defeat.
  • The voice of death as passage protects acceptance and peace; its risk is that grief is hushed or death is hurried.
  • Together the two voices guard against clinging to life at any cost and against hurrying death; Christians may still decide particular cases differently.
  • Applying these verses to medical choices is a judgement; the text does not mention medicine.
Front Back
Death as enemy Paul calls death the last enemy (1 Cor 15:26). It protects the value of life; it risks treating every death as a failure.
Death as passage The believer belongs to the Lord in life and in death (Rom 14:8). It protects peace and acceptance; it risks hushing grief or hurrying death.
Christian hope in brief Death does not have the last word; God will raise the dead and abolish death. This is a promise, not our project.
What the two voices guard against Clinging to life at any cost, and hurrying death.

One sentence to remember Christians hold death as an enemy and as a passage, and the hope that death will not have the last word.

This week's action Notice one prayer, hymn or saying about death that you know, and ask which voice it speaks in, or whether it holds both.

Show summary
  • The lab asks you to write the grounds of your own judgement about the body, donation and death, a question you hold open, and one step.
  • It never asks for your own or a family member’s health, diagnosis or bereavement, and it neither urges nor forbids any treatment or donation.
  • Four promises hold: nobody reads it, nothing is marked, you may pass, the leader writes too.
  • There are three ways in: your own place, the observer’s way with the printed case, the partner’s way.
  • Never write a real name, church, employer, hospital or confidential detail.
  • A leader asks which box was hardest, never what you decided.
Front Back
What the lab practises Naming the grounds of my judgement, a question I hold open, and one step.
The four promises Nobody reads it; nothing is marked; you may pass; the leader writes too.
Three ways in Your own place; the observer’s way; the partner’s way.
What a leader asks Which box was hardest to fill, never what you decided.

One sentence to remember Look honestly at the grounds of what you think about the body and about death, and keep your questions open.

This week's action Fill in the form on paper, and keep it where only you will find it.

Chapter 4 Week 4: Prolonging Life and the Limits of Treatment

Show summary
  • Life-support machines can carry a person across a danger and can also hold a body when illness will not turn; the burden of that is nobody's fault.
  • Vitalism makes bodily life the highest good; a hurried acceptance of death treats some lives as less worth the effort. Each is a danger.
  • Readers differ on how to weigh preserving life against relieving burden; both sides agree that life is a gift and no one is worth less.
  • Catholic teaching asks whether a means is proportionate: its benefit against its burden for this person, not whether it is common or high-tech.
  • A decision about a treatment is not a decision about the worth of a life.
Front Back
Vitalism The view that preserving bodily life is the highest good and must be done at any cost. Several traditions say it mistakes a gift for the giver.
Hurried acceptance of death A way of speaking or acting that treats the lives of the old, ill or disabled as less to be mourned or protected.
Ordinary and extraordinary means (Catholic) A distinction about benefit and burden: one is normally bound to use means that help without grave burden, and not bound to use means that are gravely burdensome or give little hope. Often now called proportionate and disproportionate.
The shared ground of the two voices Life is God's gift; no person is worth less; a decision about a treatment is not a decision about a life's worth.

One sentence to remember Life is a gift to be guarded and not a god to be served, and the person is always worth more than the treatment.

This week's action Write in your own words why you think a family might say "do everything" and why another might say "let go", and keep both reasons in mind before you read lecture 4-2.

Show summary
  • Withholding or withdrawing a treatment is kept distinct from euthanasia by many traditions, because cause, intention and hope of benefit differ; critics say the line is less clear than it sounds.
  • Artificial nutrition and hydration is a point where readers differ: basic care owed to all, or a medical treatment judged by benefit and burden.
  • Advance wishes and proxies help, have limits, and are governed by local law and local practice.
  • A family is never blamed for continuing, stopping or waiting; a dying person is never left without care and company.
Front Back
Withholding and withdrawing Not starting, or stopping, a treatment, judged by its benefit and burden. Many traditions distinguish it from euthanasia.
A criticism of that distinction Stopping is also an act, and intentions are hard to see; defenders answer that cause, aim and hope of benefit make the moral difference.
Artificial nutrition and hydration Readers differ: some call it basic care owed to every person; others call it a medical treatment to be weighed like any other.
Advance wishes and proxy Ways in which a patient's wishes reach the room. Useful, limited, and different in each country.

One sentence to remember Decide together, with advice, and never blame a family that carried the decision.

This week's action Write down three questions you would want to ask a care team, and one you would want to ask a pastor or priest. Keep the paper private.

Show summary
  • Palliative care aims at relief of suffering and care of the whole person; it neither hastens death nor delays it at any cost.
  • Hospice grew from Christian hospitality to the sick and the stranger, and from a later movement in which Christians were active.
  • It is a misunderstanding that faith requires enduring pain; the traditions see relief of suffering as mercy.
  • The double effect separates what is aimed at from what is foreseen; readers differ on how far the principle goes.
  • Family carers carry a heavy burden; the church shares the work and does not judge.
Front Back
Palliative care Care that aims at relief of suffering and support of the whole person and the family, not only at curing the disease.
A harmful misunderstanding That faith requires enduring pain. The main traditions do not teach it; relieving suffering is an act of mercy.
Double effect A good act with a foreseen bad side-effect may be allowed if the act is not wrong, the bad effect is not intended or used as the means, and the reason is proportionate. Readers differ on how far it goes.
What a congregation can do for carers Share concrete work (a meal, a night's relief, a lift, a visit), listen, and never judge tiredness.

One sentence to remember Care for the dying is care for the whole person, and relief of suffering is mercy and not a lack of faith.

This week's action Think of one practical thing your congregation or circle could offer to a family carer, and write it down in one sentence.

Show summary
  • A decision about treatment is best made with many counsellors, each knowing something the others do not.
  • Shared decision-making avoids both "the doctor decides" and "the patient chooses alone"; patterns differ across cultures and countries.
  • The person who speaks for the patient is asked to say what the patient would want, not what they themselves want; the law of each country sets who it is.
  • A congregation helps by presence and practical support, and must not press, blame or explain; "I am here" is better than an answer.
Front Back
Shared decision-making Clinicians, patient (or the one who speaks for them) and family reach a decision by talking together, each bringing what they know.
The one who speaks for the patient Is asked to say what the patient would want, and where that is unknown, what serves the patient's good. Who it is depends on local law.
A clinician A person with a calling and a conscience, who knows the medicine but not the patient's faith and hopes unless told.
What a church may offer Presence, listening, prayer if wanted, and practical help; not blame, forced answers or pressure.

One sentence to remember Be swift to hear and slow to speak, and weep with those who weep.

This week's action Write one sentence you could say to a family in a hospital corridor that offers presence and does not explain or blame.

Show summary
  • The lab asks for the grounds of your judgement, your questions and one step; it asks nothing about your own or your family's health.
  • The invented case holds goods in tension (life as a gift, relief of burden, the patient's own wishes), and nobody in it is wrong.
  • Four promises hold: nobody reads it, nothing is marked, you may pass, the leader writes too.
  • There are three ways in: your own place, the observer's way with the printed case, the partner's way.
  • A leader asks which question was hardest, never what the family should do, and does not invite personal stories.
Front Back
What the lab practises Saying on what grounds you judge, what questions you hold, and one step you will take, using a case or general terms.
The four promises Nobody reads it; nothing is marked; you may pass; the leader writes too.
What the lab never asks Anything about your own or a family member's health, diagnosis or bereavement, or any real name.
What a leader asks Which question was hardest to answer, never what the family should do.

One sentence to remember Bring your questions and your trust together, and hold the people in the case without blaming any of them.

This week's action Fill in the form on paper, keep it where only you will find it, and choose one step for this month.

Chapter 5 Week 5: Euthanasia and the Theology of Suffering

Show summary
  • Euthanasia means another person acts on purpose to end a life to end suffering; assisted suicide means the person does the last act with help.
  • The words are disputed: each side tends to choose its own, so say which you mean.
  • Withholding or withdrawing a burdensome treatment is the matter of Week 4, and many traditions keep it distinct.
  • Palliative sedation is care aimed at relief, though some ask whether aim and result can be separated.
  • People ask to die from pain, loss of control, fear of being a burden and loss of dignity; listen before arguing.
  • Laws differ by country and are not given here; a person in danger needs a pastor or priest, professional help and the local emergency number.
Front Back
Euthanasia Another person acts, on purpose, to end a life in order to end suffering.
Assisted suicide (assisted dying) The person does the last act, with help from another; the two names are each preferred by one side.
Palliative sedation Care for a dying person whose suffering nothing else relieves; its users say the aim is relief, and some ask whether aim and result can be parted.
Four reasons people ask to die Pain, loss of control, fear of being a burden, and loss of dignity.

One sentence to remember Before any argument, ask what the person is asking, and sit beside them.

This week's action Write the three definitions in your own words and note one word you will use more carefully.

Show summary
  • The case against rests on life as gift, pressure on the weak, the slippery slope and care as the answer.
  • The case for allowing rests on autonomy, compassion, dignity and a last mercy for rare cases.
  • Each argument has a weak point; the weak points are not refutations, and each side has answers.
  • Most Christian traditions oppose euthanasia and assisted suicide, while allowing refusal of burdensome treatment; some voices struggle or argue otherwise.
  • Verses such as Deuteronomy 30:19 and Galatians 6:2 are not decisive proof for either side.
  • Christians can disagree without condemning each other, and nobody may leave the sufferer alone.
Front Back
Four arguments against Life as gift; pressure on the weak; the slippery slope; care as the answer.
Four arguments for allowing Autonomy; compassion; dignity; a last mercy for rare cases.
A weak point of autonomy Choices are shaped by pain, fear and worry for the family, and Christian faith says we are not the owners of our lives.
A weak point of "care as the answer" Good care is not always available and does not remove every suffering, so the answer may sound like a promise that cannot be kept.

One sentence to remember State each side so well that its holder would nod, and then name its weak point.

This week's action Write the strongest argument of the side you disagree with, in four sentences, and its weak point in one.

Show summary
  • The Bible has many voices on suffering: Job, the laments, Ecclesiastes, the cross and Paul; none is thrown away.
  • The friends of Job did best in their silence and went wrong when they explained.
  • A comfort that gives suffering a meaning from outside can wound; meaning found by the sufferer is theirs to name.
  • The cross says that God has entered human suffering; it does not say that pain is good or that relief must be refused.
  • Protestant, Catholic and Orthodox traditions speak differently but each says that God is near and the church accompanies.
  • A church that follows Job 2:11-13 comes, weeps, sits and does not explain.
Front Back
What Job's friends did right They came, wept, and sat in silence with him for seven days.
A comfort that wounds An explanation from outside ("it happens for a reason") that shuts the door on grief or suggests fault.
What the cross says about suffering God has entered human suffering and is not far away; it does not say that pain is good or that relief must be refused.
Why the lament psalms matter They show that grief, complaint and anger may be brought to God.

One sentence to remember Sit first, speak slowly, and let the sufferer name what the pain means.

This week's action Read Psalm 22:1 aloud, slowly, and write down one thing you would not say to someone in pain.

Show summary
  • Whatever one judges about euthanasia, the sufferer must not be left alone; care is the first duty on every side.
  • A community can visit, bring meals, take shifts, listen, pray if asked, keep the person in the community and ask for good care.
  • Carers need rest, company and a listener, and should not be judged for tired or conflicted feelings.
  • When someone says they want to die: listen, do not argue, do not leave, ask plainly if worried, and bring in help.
  • Never promise secrecy if there is danger, and never give or discuss any method.
  • Where there is danger now, call the local emergency number; a pastor or priest and trained help come before secrecy.
Front Back
Why care comes first on every side A church that has not visited, fed and sat beside the ill has no right to be heard on the matter, and one that has done so has earned a hearing.
What to do when someone says they want to die Listen, say you are glad they told you, ask plainly if worried, stay, and bring in a pastor or priest and trained help.
What not to do Argue, scold, change the subject, promise secrecy in a danger, leave, or give any method.
Care for carers Offer rest, food, company and a listener; do not judge tired or mixed feelings.

One sentence to remember Nobody should ask to die because nobody came.

This week's action Write down one person who is ill or caring for someone, and one small, specific act of care you will offer them this month.

Show summary
  • The lab prepares, before the moment, what you would say, not say, and whom you would bring in when someone is in pain.
  • It does not ask what you judge about euthanasia, and it never asks about your own or a family member's health or bereavement.
  • Four promises hold: nobody reads it, nothing is marked, you may pass, the leader writes too.
  • There are three ways in: your own place, the observer's way with the printed case, the partner's way.
  • Never write a real name, church, employer, hospital or personal detail; if danger is now, call the local emergency number.
  • A leader asks which question was hardest, never what was written, and does not let the lab become a debate.
Front Back
What the lab practises Preparing, before the moment, words that listen, things not to say, and whom to bring in when someone is in pain.
The four promises Nobody reads it; nothing is marked; you may pass; the leader writes too.
Three ways in Your own place; the observer's way; the partner's way.
What a leader asks Which question was hardest to answer, never what was written.

One sentence to remember Prepare in a quiet hour the words that listen, so that you can stay in the hard hour.

This week's action Fill in the form on paper, keep it where only you will find it, and write on it one sentence you could say to a person in pain.

Chapter 6 Week 6: Justice, Disability and the Community That Discerns

Show summary
  • Care is always limited, and new technology makes the question of who receives it sharper.
  • Luke 4, Matthew 25 and James 2 put the poor and the sick near the centre of the church's concern, but do not say how a modern system should be built.
  • Catholic social teaching and Protestant social-gospel and other streams each describe care for the poor as part of the gospel, in different language.
  • Equal claim and responsibility-and-freedom are two ways of thinking about sharing, each with a strength and a weak point.
  • If new technology reaches only those who can pay, a gap may widen; the church keeps asking who is left out.
  • Health workers carry real burdens, and the church does not blame them.
Front Back
What the three texts say Good news and healing for the poor; the sick are the king's own; kind words without meeting the body's need are empty.
Equal claim Every person has an equal claim on care; its weak point is deciding what counts as basic when a community cannot afford all.
Responsibility and freedom Mercy is local and personal; its weak point is that giving may not reach the poorest.
The question for any new technology Who will be able to have it, and who will be left outside?

One sentence to remember Care is a question of justice as well as of the bedside, and the church keeps asking who is outside the door.

This week's action Write down one question about fair access to care that you could ask in your own community, without blaming anyone.

Show summary
  • Disability covers a wide range, and no one speaks for all disabled people.
  • The medical, social and relational ways of understanding disability each notice something and each has a weak point.
  • Disabled people have critiqued screening, cure and enhancement; others hope for treatment; both are heard fairly.
  • In 1 Corinthians 12:22-26 the weaker members are necessary; the church loses when they are absent.
  • 2 Corinthians 12:9 and John 9:1-3 are read in several ways and are never used to explain a person's disability.
  • The wider dream of enhancement is taken up in STEL6E; here we ask what it says about those who are not enhanced.
Front Back
Three ways of seeing disability Medical (a condition to treat), social (barriers in the world), relational (belonging and giving); each has a weak point.
A critique of screening Some disabled people hear in it a message that lives like theirs are less worth having; others hope for treatment. Both are heard fairly.
1 Corinthians 12:22-26 The weaker members are necessary; the body shares suffering and joy; the church loses when they are absent.
John 9:1-3 and 2 Corinthians 12:9 Read in several ways; never used to explain why a person is disabled; the clear part of John 9 is that nobody sinned.

One sentence to remember The members that seem weaker are necessary, so the church listens to disabled people before it speaks about them.

This week's action Ask yourself one question about who is missing from the life of your congregation, and note one way you could learn from someone who lives with disability.

Show summary
  • James 5:14-16 describes the elders praying and anointing the sick; traditions understand it differently, and in most it stands beside medicine, not instead of it.
  • Acts 2:44-45 shows practical sharing as part of a community's life; visits, meals, shifts and company are its modern forms.
  • A congregation must not blame, force answers, press for a miracle or judge a decision after the fact.
  • The church and the care team cooperate: neither tells the other what to do, and the family decides.
  • Romans 14:1-4 teaches members who differ to avoid contempt and judging.
  • Teaching in open settings before a crisis is different from pressing a family during one.
Front Back
James 5:14-16 The elders pray and anoint the sick; traditions differ in how they do it; most hold it beside medicine, not in place of it.
What a church can do Pray, visit, bring meals, share shifts, sit in the waiting room, work alongside the care team, and stay whichever way the family decides.
What a church must not say Blame, forced answers, pressure for a miracle or for a choice, judgement after the fact.
Romans 14:1-4 in this lecture Members who differ do not despise or judge each other; teaching is for open settings, and presence is for a crisis.

One sentence to remember The church prays and accompanies, and does not decide for the family or blame it.

This week's action Think of one practical way your community could stand beside someone facing illness, and say how you could offer it without pressing.

Show summary
  • A short list of questions can help a community to judge a technology no one has yet named.
  • The seven questions ask what it makes possible, what burden it gives, who is at the bedside, who is left out, what it says about the body, what we can leave to God and what the weakest would say.
  • 1 Thessalonians 5:21 and Philippians 1:9-11 speak of testing and discernment as the work of a community.
  • A list starts a conversation and gives no formula; it can make a matter look more settled than it is.
  • Traditions differ on how far a community's own discernment and its recognised teaching authority each weigh.
  • A judgement can be revisited as a technology and our knowledge change.
Front Back
The seven questions Possible, burden, bedside, left out, the body, what we leave to God, what the weakest would say.
1 Thessalonians 5:21 Test all things and hold what is good; addressed to a community.
A danger of a list It can make a matter seem settled; it starts a conversation and gives no formula.
Who judges? Traditions differ on how much weight falls on the community's own discernment and on recognised teaching authority; most hold some of both.

One sentence to remember Discernment is practised together, by asking questions that include the weakest, and it can be taken up again.

This week's action Choose one technology you have heard of in the news and write answers to the seven questions in a few lines each.

Show summary
  • The lab asks you to write one page: what you believe, what grounds it, what you do not know, what stays open, where another view may be right, and one step.
  • It never asks you to write about your own health, a diagnosis or a bereavement, or anyone else's.
  • Four promises hold: nobody reads it, nothing is marked, you may pass, the leader writes too.
  • There are three ways in: your own place, the observer's way with the printed case, the partner's way.
  • A page that says "I do not know" is a true and useful page.
  • A leader asks which box was hardest, never what was written.
Front Back
What the lab practises Saying in your own words what you believe, what grounds it, what you do not know and one step you will take.
The four promises Nobody reads it; nothing is marked; you may pass; the leader writes too.
Three ways in Your own place; the observer's way; the partner's way.
What a leader asks Which box was hardest to fill, never what you wrote.

One sentence to remember Write down what you believe and what you do not know, and take one small step to listen or to help.

This week's action Fill in the form on paper, and keep it where only you will find it.