Lecture 4-2: From a Persecuted Church to a Church with Power
목차 33
- Lecture 1-1: Pentecost and the Jerusalem Community
- Lecture 1-2: Stephen, the Scattering, and the Road to Samaria
- Lecture 1-3: Paul, the Roads of the Empire, and the Greek World
- Lecture 1-4: Worship, Sacrament, and the Catacombs
- Lecture 2-1: Why Rome Persecuted
- Lecture 2-2: From Local Riot to Empire-Wide Order
- Lecture 2-3: Writing Back — Justin, Tertullian, and Two Ways to Meet a Culture
- Lecture 2-4: What Martyrdom Left Behind
- Lecture 3-1: Knowledge, Matter, and the God Who Made It
- Lecture 3-2: Marcion and the New Prophecy
- Lecture 3-3: Canon, Creed, and Bishop
- Lecture 3-4: The Generation That Handed It On
- Lecture 4-1: The Year the Persecution Ended
- Lecture 4-2: From a Persecuted Church to a Church with Power
- Lecture 4-3: What Came In With the Crowds
- Lecture 4-4: Emperor and Church — Symphony, Subordination, Resistance
- Lecture 5-1: Arius, Athanasius, and One Word at Nicaea
- Lecture 5-2: Fifty-Six Years, and the Spirit
- Lecture 5-3: Who Is Jesus Christ? Ephesus and Chalcedon
- Lecture 5-4: What the Settlements Did to East and West
- Lecture 6-1: Antony and the Desert
- Lecture 6-2: From Solitude to Common Life — Pachomius and Basil
- Lecture 6-3: Benedict and the Rule
- Lecture 6-4: What the Monasteries Gave Back
- Lecture 7-1: The Restless Heart: Manichaeism, Milan, and the Garden
- Lecture 7-2: The Donatist Controversy: Holiness, Sacraments, and Force
- Lecture 7-3: The Pelagian Controversy: Nature, Grace, and What the Church Received
- Lecture 7-4: The City of God: History Without a Chosen Empire
Constantine exempted the Christian clergy from the munera — the compulsory, expensive public duties that fell on the propertied class of every city. A curial councillor was personally liable for collecting his town's taxes and for funding its games, baths and repairs, and men ruined themselves in the office.
The exemption was generous. It was also, within a very few years, a problem, and we know this because Constantine had to legislate against the consequence: men of property were getting themselves ordained in order to escape their civic obligations. New laws restricted ordination to men of modest means, and then to filling actual vacancies.
That sequence — a privilege granted from genuine goodwill, exploited within a decade, patched by further legislation — is this lecture in miniature. Nobody in it is a villain. The gifts were real gifts, the gratitude was real gratitude, and the corrosion was not planned by anyone.
이 21분으로 얻는 것
- Explain why Constantine came to see the church as an instrument of imperial cohesion, and state that motive precisely rather than cynically.
- Describe how clerical privilege and the right to hold property changed the church from a body defined by risk into an institution, and give concrete examples of both the gain and the cost.
- Explain what Constantine meant, or may have meant, by calling himself a "bishop of those outside", and how his role at Nicaea created a precedent.
- State the spiritual crisis that prosperity brought — including the problem of nominal adherence — and set it honestly against what the church was newly able to do.
The kings of the nations lord it over them, and those who have authority over them are called 'benefactors.' But not so with you. But one who is the greater among you, let him become as the younger, and one who is governing, as one who serves." — Luke 22:25–26
World English Bible
Note the word benefactor — euergetēs in Greek. It was a formal civic honour, inscribed on statues across the Roman world for men who paid for a city's grain or games. Jesus is not objecting to generosity; he is objecting to the system in which generosity buys standing. Within a generation of 313 the church was the largest beneficiary of exactly that system, and a great deal of this chapter follows from that fact.
1. Why an emperor wanted a church
Constantine's interest in Christianity is easy to caricature in both directions, so state it precisely.
He inherited an empire that had nearly disintegrated in the third century — civil wars, invasions, currency collapse, a rapid turnover of murdered emperors. Diocletian had rebuilt it by force and administration. Constantine appears to have concluded that administration was not enough, and that what held a state together in the end was the favour of heaven and a population that shared something.
The old religion could not supply the second. It was local by nature: every city had its gods, every people its rites, and there was no common content. The imperial cult gave a common act — chapter 2 showed how — but no common belief, and it commanded no loyalty.
Christianity offered something no cult in the empire offered: a single God, one body of teaching, a translocal organisation with officers and correspondence, an ethic that the state could not have legislated, and a network of charity already running in most cities. Constantine did not need to invent an institution. There was one, and it worked.
Two important qualifications, both usually missed.
He was pursuing unity, not orthodoxy, and the distinction matters. H. A. Drake's study makes the case that Constantine consistently wanted agreement and would accept a wide range of it, which explains his repeated attempts to broker compromises, and his impatience with theologians on both sides who would not take one.
And he did not make Christianity the state religion. That is one of the most common errors about this period. Milan gave freedom to everyone; Constantine gave the church patronage, kept the title pontifex maximus, and left the old cults in place. Christianity became the official religion of the empire under Theodosius, in 380, sixty-seven years later — and Theodosius, not Constantine, is where legal pressure against pagans and heretics really begins.
2. What the church received, and what it became
Privileges. Exemption from the munera, as above. Exemption from military service. Bishops were given the right to hear cases — the episcopalis audientia — and their judgements were enforceable at law.
Property and money. Churches could receive legacies, own land, and hold endowments. Constantine's own gifts were enormous: the Lateran basilica in Rome, land revenues assigned in perpetuity, building programmes in Palestine and Constantinople. From this point the church has capital and, therefore, administration, accounts, and people whose job is money.
Now the accounting, and it has to run both ways.
What it cost. The church became an institution in which office carried worldly advantage, and people behave accordingly — the ordination loophole is the first documented instance and not the last. Bishops of great sees became figures of real power, with clients and rivals, and the contested episcopal elections of the fourth century were sometimes violent. A church that has property has something to lose, and a body with something to lose calculates differently from one that does not.
What it bought. This is the half the traditional account omits, and it is not small.
- Poor relief at a scale nothing else in the ancient world attempted. Churches kept registers of the poor of their city and fed them. In Antioch in the late fourth century, John Chrysostom says the church was supporting around three thousand widows and virgins, besides prisoners, the sick, travellers and the disabled — and he says it while complaining that the congregation could do more.
- The first hospitals. Basil of Caesarea built a complex outside his city in the 370s — the Basileias — with a hostel, a poorhouse and quarters for the sick, including lepers, whom Basil is reported to have cared for himself. There had been infirmaries for soldiers and slaves before; an institution to nurse the destitute because they were destitute is new.
- A court the poor could reach. The episcopalis audientia meant a bishop's court, free, without the delays and bribes of the imperial system. It was open to abuse and was abused. It was also, for a poor litigant, the only realistic forum.
- Ransom of captives, which became a standard call on church funds — Ambrose melted down church plate to buy back prisoners of war, and defended himself for it by saying that the church has gold in order to spend it on the needy, not to keep it.
- Legal reform, though its extent is argued about. Constantine restricted gladiatorial shows, forbade branding on the face because it disfigured the , and made it possible to free a slave in church before the congregation.
And then the sentence quoted in the chapter overview. When the emperor Julian set out around 362 to restore the old gods, he wrote that he wanted a pagan system of poor relief and hostels, "for it is disgraceful that... the impious Galileans support not only their own poor but ours as well." That is an enemy of the church, with every motive to say otherwise, testifying to what it was doing.
Peter Brown's Through the Eye of a Needle is the book to read on this, precisely because he takes the corruption entirely seriously and still shows what the wealth was for.
3. "A bishop of those outside"
Eusebius reports that Constantine, entertaining bishops at dinner, remarked that they were bishops of those within the church, while he was a bishop of those outside it — episcopus tōn ektos.
Nobody is certain what he meant. Two readings compete: that he was bishop to those outside the church, meaning the pagans he hoped to bring in; or that he was overseer of the church's external affairs, its property, finance and public standing, as against its doctrine. Eusebius does not explain, and the phrase may have been a compliment at a dinner rather than a constitutional claim.
What is not in doubt is what he did.
He summoned the in 325, paid for the bishops' travel, provided the venue, opened the proceedings, and took an active part. Whether he presided over the sessions is unclear — Hosius of Cordoba, his ecclesiastical adviser, seems to have chaired much of it — but the council met because the emperor called it, and after it he enforced its decision by exiling those who refused to sign.
And there the precedent is set. From 325 onward, when the church needed to settle something at the level of the whole church, the mechanism for doing so belonged to the emperor. He convened, he paid, and he could enforce. Every one of the seven councils that the Orthodox and Catholic churches recognise as ecumenical was called by an emperor.
Be careful about the conclusion, because two overstatements are common.
It is not true that Constantine decided the theology at Nicaea. The theological work was done by bishops, the crucial term homoousios had a history in Greek Christian debate before him, and he seems not to have grasped the argument. What he wanted was a settlement.
It is not true that this made the church simply a department of state. Chapter 5 will show Athanasius defying three emperors in turn and being exiled five times, and lecture 4-4 will show what the church could still do to an emperor when it chose.
But something real changed. The church acquired a way of settling disputes that it did not control, and it began to acquire the habit of resolving theological arguments by getting the state to remove the losers. Within a generation, exile for holding the wrong view of the was normal, and it was applied by whichever side had the emperor's ear that decade — including, for long stretches, against the party the church now regards as orthodox.
4. Prosperity as a test
One common description of what followed is "prosperity without suffering", and the phrase is a good one.
Nominal adherence. When belonging to the church became socially advantageous, people belonged who would not otherwise have done so. This is not moralising; it is arithmetic. In 300 becoming a Christian could cost you your life, and the people who did it had decided something. By 380 it was the path of least resistance, and by 400 it was in places compulsory. The average level of commitment in any group falls when the cost of joining falls, and no institution has ever escaped this.
The disappearance of a boundary. Chapter 2's whole argument was that the church knew itself by what it would not do. Remove the demand and the definition goes soft. This is the deepest cost of the settlement, and it is why chapter 6 exists — is, in large part, people going out into the desert to find a boundary again, and the earliest monks say so almost explicitly.
But two cautions against the standard lament.
Shallow or deep conversion?
Ramsay MacMullen argues that conversion in this period was often shallow and that old practice continued under new names — a pessimistic reading with real evidence behind it. Peter Brown reads the same period very differently, seeing genuine and deep Christianisation working slowly through ordinary life. They disagree fundamentally, and a course that presents the "mass of nominal Christians" as simple fact is taking a side without saying so.
And the church did not simply lie down. Within decades of Constantine's death, the same church was producing Basil's hospital, Chrysostom's furious sermons against the rich in Constantinople, Ambrose selling the plate, and the desert movement. A body that had truly been absorbed would not have generated its own opposition on that scale.
5. Both halves
Add it up honestly.
The church of 400 was worse than the church of 300 at knowing who it was, and better at feeding people. It had lost a boundary and gained a hospital. It had acquired members who did not mean it and the capacity to ransom prisoners. It could now settle a doctrinal dispute across the whole empire, and it could now settle it by having the losers exiled.
Freedom cost the church things persecution never could, and bought it things persecution never could. Anyone who can only see one column is not reading the sources; they are reading their own tradition's summary of them. The interesting question — and it is the question chapter 6 and chapter 7 are both trying to answer — is whether the two columns could have been separated, or whether they always come together.
Diagram 1. Summary table
| Area | What it bought | What it cost | Where it leads |
|---|---|---|---|
| Clerical privilege | Exemptions; a free bishop's court open to the poor | Ordination as an escape from civic burdens, within ten years | Office as a career, and contested elections |
| Property and money | Poor registers, ransom of captives, the first hospitals | An institution with assets, and therefore with interests | Chapter 6: people leaving it to find poverty again |
| Councils | A way to settle a question for the whole church | The mechanism is the emperor's, and losers are exiled | Chapter 5: Nicaea, and Athanasius exiled five times |
| Numbers | A hearing no illegal church could have had | Adherence without cost, and a boundary that stops working | Chapter 6, and Augustine's arguments in chapter 7 |
5. Going to the Sources
- Eusebius, Life of Constantine 4.24 — the "bishop of those outside" remark, in its one sentence of context. Read it and decide what you think it means.
- Julian, Letter to Arsacius — two pages. The emperor trying to build a pagan charity system, and explaining why he has to.
- Gregory of Nazianzus, Oration 43, on Basil — the funeral speech that describes the Basileias, by a man who knew him.
- Ambrose, On the Duties of the Clergy 2.28 — the defence of melting church plate to ransom captives.
- The Codex Theodosianus, book 16 — the imperial laws about the church, collected. Dry, and the fastest way to see the privileges accumulate year by year.
핵심 요약
- Constantine wanted unity, not orthodoxy. He saw in the church a single God, one teaching, a translocal organisation and working charity. He did not make Christianity the state religion. That came under Theodosius in 380.
- The church gained clerical privileges, property and bishops' courts. The cost was that office carried worldly advantage, and the ordination loophole was the first documented example.
- The gains were also real: large-scale poor relief, Basil's hospital complex, a court the poor could reach, ransom of captives and some legal reform. Even the emperor Julian admitted the church's care for the poor.
- Constantine's phrase "a bishop of those outside" is unclear. His convening of Nicaea set a precedent: the mechanism for settling church-wide disputes belonged to the emperor. He did not decide the theology.
- Prosperity brought nominal adherence and a softer boundary. MacMullen and Peter Brown disagree on how shallow conversion was. The church also produced its own critics, including monks.
Topic: How imperial favour changed the church from a persecuted body into an institution with power, property and new responsibilities.
Remember: One change brought both gains and costs, and the two cannot be easily separated. The church of 400 was worse at knowing who it was and better at feeding people.
Caution: Constantine did not make Christianity the state religion, and he did not decide the theology at Nicaea. Historians also disagree about how shallow conversion was.
One line to carry into ministry: Receive generosity and influence gratefully, but guard the church's boundary and keep serving the poor, since both can fade together.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- Within ten years, a privilege given in goodwill was being exploited. Was the exemption a mistake, or is that simply what happens to every privilege? What follows for how a church should handle advantages it is offered?
- The lecture insists on two columns. Write out the two columns for your own congregation's relationship to money, standing or state recognition. Is either column empty?
- Every ecumenical council was summoned by an emperor. What does the church use now, in place of that mechanism, when it needs to settle something across the whole church — and does it have one?
- Brown and MacMullen disagree about whether the fourth-century conversions went deep. What evidence would settle it, and does your own tradition have a stake in the answer?