Lecture 8-1: The Year the Empire Ended, and the Work That Did Not
목차 33
- Lecture 1-1: Pentecost and the Jerusalem Community
- Lecture 1-2: Stephen, the Scattering, and the Road to Samaria
- Lecture 1-3: Paul, the Roads of the Empire, and the Greek World
- Lecture 1-4: Worship, Sacrament, and the Catacombs
- Lecture 2-1: Why Rome Persecuted
- Lecture 2-2: From Local Riot to Empire-Wide Order
- Lecture 2-3: Writing Back — Justin, Tertullian, and Two Ways to Meet a Culture
- Lecture 2-4: What Martyrdom Left Behind
- Lecture 3-1: Knowledge, Matter, and the God Who Made It
- Lecture 3-2: Marcion and the New Prophecy
- Lecture 3-3: Canon, Creed, and Bishop
- Lecture 3-4: The Generation That Handed It On
- Lecture 4-1: The Year the Persecution Ended
- Lecture 4-2: From a Persecuted Church to a Church with Power
- Lecture 4-3: What Came In With the Crowds
- Lecture 4-4: Emperor and Church — Symphony, Subordination, Resistance
- Lecture 5-1: Arius, Athanasius, and One Word at Nicaea
- Lecture 5-2: Fifty-Six Years, and the Spirit
- Lecture 5-3: Who Is Jesus Christ? Ephesus and Chalcedon
- Lecture 5-4: What the Settlements Did to East and West
- Lecture 6-1: Antony and the Desert
- Lecture 6-2: From Solitude to Common Life — Pachomius and Basil
- Lecture 6-3: Benedict and the Rule
- Lecture 6-4: What the Monasteries Gave Back
- Lecture 7-1: The Restless Heart: Manichaeism, Milan, and the Garden
- Lecture 7-2: The Donatist Controversy: Holiness, Sacraments, and Force
- Lecture 7-3: The Pelagian Controversy: Nature, Grace, and What the Church Received
- Lecture 7-4: The City of God: History Without a Chosen Empire
In September 476 a general named Odoacer deposed a teenage emperor called Romulus Augustulus, sent the imperial regalia to Constantinople, and informed the eastern emperor Zeno that the West no longer required an emperor of its own. He asked instead for the rank of patrician and permission to govern Italy in Zeno's name.
The most striking thing about this event is how little anyone said about it. The chroniclers of the next generation record it in a line, and nobody wrote that Rome had fallen. There was still a legitimate western emperor alive in Dalmatia — Julius Nepos, murdered in 480 — and the man now ruling Italy presented himself as an imperial officer rather than a replacement. Only in the sixth century did a chronicler first frame 476 as the end of the western empire, and only in the eighteenth did Gibbon make it a date every schoolchild would learn.
This lecture takes the date seriously and takes the silence seriously. Something genuinely ended in the fifth-century West — not on one afternoon but over three or four generations: the tax system, the professional army, the trade in ordinary goods, the assumption that a distant government would do certain things. And as those things stopped, one institution was still standing in almost every city, with a chain of command, a building, an income and a legal personality. Bishops began doing work nobody had asked them to do, because the alternative was that nobody did it.
That is the chapter's principle in its first form: when the state collapsed, the church inherited the work of the state — and the debts of it. This lecture is mostly about the inheritance. The debts arrive in 8-3 and 8-4.
이 25분으로 얻는 것
- Say what actually happened in 476, explain why contemporaries treated it as unremarkable, and describe how Christians of the period read the collapse of Rome theologically.
- Describe the practical work bishops took over as imperial administration failed — food, ransom, courts, negotiation, buildings — and how much of Roman law, language and letters survived through church institutions.
- Explain the missionary situation created by the Germanic settlements, including why most of the incoming peoples were already Christian but not Nicene, and what conversion by a ruler did and did not accomplish.
- Describe how the bishop of Rome's authority grew in the absence of a western emperor, and state the Catholic, Orthodox and Protestant readings of Petrine primacy fairly.
He changes the times and the seasons; he removes kings, and sets up kings; he gives wisdom to the wise, and knowledge to those who have understanding;" — Daniel 2:21
World English Bible
Daniel says this in a book about empires that end, and it was a favourite of fifth-century preachers for the obvious reason. It can be used two ways: as a comfort, or as a way of not asking what a Christian should do while an order dissolves. The bishops in this lecture mostly took it the first way and then went and organised the grain supply.
1. What ended, and what 476 was not
The western Roman state did not stop in a year. It thinned out.
The visible sequence is familiar: the crossing of the Rhine in 406, the sack of Rome in 410, the loss of Africa to the Vandals in 439 — which mattered more than the sack, because Africa was where Rome's grain came from — a second sack in 455, and by the 470s a western government controlling little more than Italy and run by its generals. Odoacer was one such general, who decided not to appoint another figurehead.
Beneath that runs the change historians regard as the substantial one. The tax system that paid the army broke down, and without an army there was no leverage to collect the tax. Trade in everyday goods — the mass-produced African pottery found on every Mediterranean site, the tiled roofs, the coinage small enough to buy bread with — contracts sharply, and material life in most western provinces got simpler and poorer.
Naming the fifth century
Historians disagree sharply about how to describe this, and you should know that they do. One line of argument, associated with Walter Goffart and differently with Chris Wickham, stresses accommodation: the incoming peoples were settled by treaty as often as by conquest, wanted to inherit the Roman system rather than destroy it, and "fall" is the wrong picture. Bryan Ward-Perkins argues that the archaeology shows a real collapse in living standards and that it a peaceful transition is a kindness to nobody. This course does not adjudicate. Both agree the fifth century was a genuine discontinuity; they disagree about what to call it.
Two words to avoid
Two words are not used here. "Dark Ages" described the darkness of our evidence and then quietly came to mean the darkness of the people, and historians have abandoned it. "Barbarian" is a Roman category, and this lecture names it as one because Roman attitudes are sometimes the point. It is not a description of the Goths, Franks, Vandals or Saxons, who had law, poetry, metalwork of a quality Roman craftsmen could not match, and — in most cases — churches.
2. How Christians read it
The literate Christians of the period reacted in two ways, and both are worth having.
The first was shock. When Rome was sacked in 410, Jerome, in Bethlehem, wrote that he could not dictate for weeping; the city that had taken the world had itself been taken. He was not being merely rhetorical: educated men had been taught that Rome was eternal, and many Christians had absorbed the idea, in the form Eusebius gave it in lecture 4-4, that empire and gospel rose together by .
The second was Augustine's, and chapter 7 has just given it. The City of God was begun because pagan Romans blamed the sack on the abandonment of the old gods, and it refuses the premise on both sides. Rome is not eternal and was never holy; it is one earthly city among the empires that rise and fall, and the city of God is a pilgrim among them. This is the most consequential thing the fifth-century church did, and it is intellectual rather than administrative. It let western Christians survive the end of their political world without concluding that God had failed — and, by detaching the church from any particular state, it left it free to build something new with whoever turned up.
3. Bishops doing the work
Here is the concrete form of this chapter's principle.
A late Roman city had a bishop with a permanent staff, a treasury fed by rents and gifts, a legal right to hold property, and an obligation, already ancient by 400, to feed the poor. When the imperial machinery thinned, that apparatus was often the only one left. Bishops did not seize civil power; the work walked over to them and they did it.
Food. Church estates and granaries kept cities alive through sieges and failed harvests. Gregory the Great's letters, a century later, show the papal grain accounts in enough detail that we can watch it happening.
Ransom. Warfare in this period produced captives who were sold. Ambrose in the 380s had already melted church plate to buy prisoners back and defended himself for it in writing; Caesarius of Arles in the 500s did the same on a large scale, arguing that the living vessels of God mattered more than the metal ones. The practice became normal, and law came to permit it explicitly.
Courts. From Constantine onwards a bishop could hear a civil case if both parties agreed — the episcopalis audientia — and his decision was enforceable. As secular courts became unreliable this quietly became the working justice system of many regions, free of charge and reasonably quick. Note the honest edge: it was also a considerable accretion of power, and it made the bishop the man everyone needed.
Negotiation. When an army arrived the bishop was often sent to talk to it, being the person with standing who did not represent a rival army. Leo I met Attila in 452 and Attila withdrew; Leo met the Vandal Gaiseric in 455 and Rome was sacked but not burned and its people not massacred. The traditional account gives Leo the credit outright, and it is worth being careful here. The embassy to Attila included two senior senators, the Huns were short of supplies and suffering from disease, and an eastern army was attacking their homeland. Leo's presence mattered; it was probably not the only thing that did. Elegant single-cause stories about this period are usually ours rather than the sources'.
Books, law and language. The church did preserve the Roman inheritance, with two qualifications: selectively, since what a monastery copied was what a monastery wanted, and incidentally, since monks copied because Latin was needed for Scripture. What survived, survived because the church needed it — and it was enough to keep Latin as the language of literacy and to carry Roman legal habits inside canon law until they could be recovered.
4. The Germanic peoples and a mission with a complication
The peoples who settled the western provinces were not, for the most part, pagans awaiting a first hearing of the gospel. Most of them were already Christians, and not of the same kind as the Roman population.
The Goths had been evangelised in the fourth century, above all through Ulfilas, who translated the Bible into Gothic — inventing an alphabet to do it, and reportedly leaving out the books of Kings on the grounds that his people needed no encouragement in warfare. The theology he brought north was the imperial theology of the 350s, which was not Nicene. Scholars usually call it Homoian rather than Arian: it held that the Son is like the Father and declined the Nicene word homoousios. It travelled to the Visigoths, Ostrogoths, Vandals, Burgundians and Lombards, and became an ethnic marker — the faith of the rulers, distinct from the Catholic faith of the population they governed.
That produced a strange arrangement: two churches in the same city, with the same Scriptures and separate bishops. It went better than one might expect. Theodoric the Ostrogoth ruled Italy from Ravenna for thirty years, kept the senate and Roman law running, built churches for his own communion and left the Catholic ones alone. The Vandal kings in North Africa were the exception and did persecute Catholics, exiling bishops and closing churches, which is why "Vandal" entered European languages as an insult.
Conversion in these societies normally began with a ruler. A king's decision brought his household, his warband and, over time, his people. It is easy to be dismissive about this, and two things are worth noticing instead. The pattern is not peculiar to Germanic peoples — it is how most of Europe became Christian. And the church did not treat a royal baptism as the end of the work: it sent priests, built churches, wrote penitential books, argued about what converts must give up and what they could keep, and spent generations on . Whether that produced faith or produced conformity is a fair question, and it is the one 8-4 has to face.
5. Rome, and where the disagreement is
The last piece is the growth of the Roman see, and it needs to be stated carefully because it is the most contested subject in this course.
The observable facts are these. Rome was the only apostolic see in the West, associated with the deaths of both Peter and Paul, and western churches had appealed to it for rulings since the second century. Its bishops articulated a Petrine theology of their own office with increasing precision across the fifth century — Leo I most of all, who argued that Peter continues to speak and act through the bishop who holds his chair, and whose Tome was received at Chalcedon in 451 in the words "Peter has spoken through Leo", though the same council passed a canon on Constantinople's rank that Leo rejected. In 494 Gelasius I wrote to the emperor Anastasius that the world is ruled by two things, the consecrated authority of bishops and the royal power, and that in religion the emperor must submit. And, decisively, after 476 there was no western emperor to argue with.
This is a point where readers will not agree.
Catholic Christians hold that Christ conferred on Peter a primacy of jurisdiction over the whole church — the keys, the strengthening of the brethren, the charge to feed the sheep — and that this office passes to the bishops of Rome as his successors. The growth described above is the unfolding of an office that was there from the beginning; a seed becoming a tree is not a fabrication.
Orthodox Christians hold that Rome possessed a real and honoured primacy: the first see, presiding in love, the natural court of appeal. They deny that it was ever a jurisdiction over the other churches. Peter's confession is the rock, every bishop sits in Peter's chair, and the councils — not any single see — are where the church speaks. On this reading the fifth- and sixth-century claims are the point at which a primacy of honour began to be re-described as a primacy of power.
Protestant Christians differ among themselves, but the common Reformation reading takes the rock to be Christ or Peter's confession, denies that any transmissible office of universal jurisdiction was instituted, and explains Rome's rise historically: the capital city, the apostolic graves, and above all the vacuum this lecture has described. Many would add that a ministry of universal unity is a real question, even if the papal answer is not theirs.
These are not three degrees of one claim, and the history is not settled by picking one. The Catholic historian Klaus Schatz is candid that a Christian of the year 200 would not have recognised the later description of the Roman bishop's office, and argues that this is what development means rather than what refutes it.
What this course requires of you is less than any of the three traditions requires of its own members. You should be able to describe what the Roman see actually did between 440 and 600, explain the conditions that made it possible, and state each reading in a form a member of that tradition would accept as fair. You are not asked to decide whether the office is of divine institution.
6. What was inherited
By 590, when Gregory becomes bishop of Rome, the position is this. There is no emperor in the West. There is an eastern emperor with a garrison in Italy that cannot defend it. There are Lombards in the north taking cities. And there is a church which feeds the city, ransoms its captives, hears its lawsuits, holds its land and negotiates with its enemies.
None of that was planned. It was picked up because it was dropped. Everything the church had gained was real, and every one of those gains was also a liability it would spend the next five centuries paying for.
Diagram 1. Summary table
| The usual account | What the evidence supports | |
|---|---|---|
| 476 | of Rome | A general stops appointing figureheads; contemporaries barely notice; the date is a later construction |
| The fifth century | Sudden catastrophe | A long thinning of tax, army and trade — a real discontinuity, described very differently by Ward-Perkins and by Wickham |
| The incoming peoples | Pagan invaders to be evangelised | Mostly Christians already, of a non-Nicene kind, often settled by treaty and keen to inherit Roman government |
| The bishops' civil role | The church seized the power the state lost | The work was dropped and picked up: grain, ransom, courts, negotiation — and power followed the work |
| Preserving classical letters | The church saved civilisation | It saved what it needed for Scripture and worship, and that selection is why some authors survive whole and others do not |
| Rome's authority | Ambition, or divine institution | Both are readings of the same record; the record itself shows an apostolic claim articulated in a political vacancy |
5. Going to the Sources
- Augustine, City of God, Book I, preface and chapters 1–7 — written just after 410. Watch him refuse the pagan explanation and the triumphalist one alike.
- Jerome, Letter 127, sections 12–13 — the most direct evidence of what the sack felt like.
- Leo I, Sermon 82 — Rome re-described: head of the world by the apostles' graves rather than by conquest.
- Gelasius I, Letter to the Emperor Anastasius (494) — two pages, quoted by every later argument about church and state, usually inaccurately.
- Victor of Vita, History of the Vandal Persecution, Book I — hostile, valuable, and a corrective to any picture of the settlements as uniformly peaceful.
핵심 요약
- In 476 Odoacer deposed a teenage emperor, and few contemporaries noticed. The western state thinned out over generations as tax, army and trade failed. Historians such as Ward-Perkins and Wickham describe this differently.
- Christians reacted with shock, as Jerome did, or with Augustine's view that Rome was never eternal or holy. This let western Christians survive the loss of their political world.
- Bishops took on food, ransom, courts and negotiation because nobody else did. The lecture cautions that Leo's meeting with Attila was probably not the only reason he withdrew.
- Most Germanic peoples were already Christians of a non-Nicene kind. Conversion usually began with a ruler and took generations of teaching to reach the people.
- Rome's authority grew with no western emperor. Catholic, Orthodox and Protestant Christians read Petrine primacy differently, and the lecture does not choose between them.
Topic: This lecture describes the end of the western empire in 476 and the work, from food to courts, that the church picked up when the state dropped it.
Remember: The church inherited the state's work because it was left undone. Every gain was real, and each also became a liability the church would carry for centuries.
Caution: 476 was not a sudden fall, and single-cause stories, such as Leo alone turning back Attila, are usually ours and not the sources'. The lecture does not decide whether Rome's office is of divine institution.
One line to carry into ministry: Take up needs that nobody else will meet, but ask honestly when the church should hand a task back.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- Augustine's argument freed the church from depending on Rome's survival. Which institution does your church currently assume will still be there in fifty years, and what would change if it were not?
- Bishops took on food, courts and negotiation because nobody else would. Where is the line between that and a church absorbing functions it should hand back — and who decides when to hand them back?
- Conversion in this period usually began with a ruler and took generations to reach the household. What are the strengths of that pattern, and what does it fail to produce?
- Three traditions read Matthew 16:18 in incompatible ways. Take the reading that is not yours and state it in the strongest form you can, without adding a rebuttal. What did you have to leave out to make it strong?