무료

수료증 무료 발급 — 2027년 3월 31일까지.

CH403E Figures and Movements in Christian Thought

Lecture 6-3: Abelard's Condemnation and Mysticism's Contested Place

목차 97
CH403E Figures and Movements in Christian Thought
제 0 장 · Introduction: Why Study People and Their Ideas
  1. Introduction: Why Study People and Their Ideas
제 1 장 · Chapter 1: The Method of Studying Figures and Movements
  1. Lecture 1-1: What "History of Christian Thought" Studies
  2. Lecture 1-2: Handling Sources — Primary, Secondary, and the Discipline of Context
  3. Lecture 1-3: The Researcher's Traps and Ethics
제 2 장 · Chapter 2: Origen and the Alexandrian School
  1. Lecture 2-1: Origen's Life — Alexandria, Martyrdom, and Exile
  2. Lecture 2-2: On First Principles and the Alexandrian Reading of Scripture
  3. Lecture 2-3: Condemned Three Centuries Later — the Origenist Controversies
제 3 장 · Chapter 3: Athanasius
  1. Lecture 3-1: Life and Exile
  2. Lecture 3-2: On the Incarnation and Homoousios
  3. Lecture 3-3: Athanasius Against the World, Fact and Legend
제 4 장 · Chapter 4: Augustinianism and the Pelagian Controversy
  1. Lecture 4-1: Two Conversions, Two Convictions
  2. Lecture 4-2: Grace, Original Sin, and Two Councils
  3. Lecture 4-3: The Argument's Long Afterlife
제 5 장 · Chapter 5: Anselm
  1. Lecture 5-1: Anselm's Life — Bec, Canterbury, and Two Kings
  2. Lecture 5-2: Faith Seeking Understanding — the Proslogion and Cur Deus Homo
  3. Lecture 5-3: Satisfaction Theory's Legacy — Dominance, Dissent, and an Honest Question
제 6 장 · Chapter 6: Bernard and Medieval Mysticism
  1. Lecture 6-1: Clairvaux, Popes, and a Crusade
  2. Lecture 6-2: On Loving God and the Sermons on the Song of Songs
  3. Lecture 6-3: Abelard's Condemnation and Mysticism's Contested Place
제 7 장 · Chapter 7: Thomas Aquinas and Thomism
  1. Lecture 7-1: Life and the Aristotle Crisis
  2. Lecture 7-2: The Summa Theologiae — Method and Central Moves
  3. Lecture 7-3: Thomism's Long Afterlife
제 8 장 · Chapter 8: Scotus, Ockham, and Nominalism
  1. Lecture 8-1: Two Friars, Two Crises
  2. Lecture 8-2: Univocity, Voluntarism, and Two Kinds of Power
  3. Lecture 8-3: The Covenant That Could Not Give Certainty
제 9 장 · Chapter 9: Martin Luther
  1. Lecture 9-1: Erfurt, Rome, and the Tower
  2. Lecture 9-2: Faith Alone, the Bound Will, and the Cross
  3. Lecture 9-3: Legacy — A Movement, a Failure, and a Dialogue
제 10 장 · Chapter 10: John Calvin
  1. Lecture 10-1: Noyon to Geneva — Calvin's Life
  2. Lecture 10-2: Union with Christ — the Institutes and Calvin's Method
  3. Lecture 10-3: Confessions, Kings, Capitalism, and Contested Ownership — Calvin's Legacy
제 11 장 · Chapter 11: The Anabaptists and the Radical Reformation
  1. Lecture 11-1: Origins — Zurich, Zwingli, and Schleitheim
  2. Lecture 11-2: Core Convictions and a Divided Movement
  3. Lecture 11-3: Legacy — Mennonites, Hutterites, Amish, and Religious Liberty
제 12 장 · Chapter 12: Beza and Reformed Orthodoxy
  1. Lecture 12-1: Theodore Beza's Life and His Succession of Calvin
  2. Lecture 12-2: Reformed Scholasticism and the Muller Debate
  3. Lecture 12-3: The Canons of Dort and Their Long Influence
제 13 장 · Chapter 13: John Owen and Puritan Theology
  1. Lecture 13-1: John Owen's Life, from Oxford to Nonconformist Exile
  2. Lecture 13-2: Owen's Major Works — Mortification, Definite Atonement, and the Spirit
  3. Lecture 13-3: Puritan Theology's Shape and Its Twentieth-Century Recovery
제 14 장 · Chapter 14: Spener, Francke, and Pietism
  1. Lecture 14-1: Spener's Reform Program and Francke's Halle
  2. Lecture 14-2: The New Birth, the Collegia Pietatis, and Practical Christianity
  3. Lecture 14-3: Zinzendorf, Wesley, and the Warmth/Precision Tension
제 15 장 · Chapter 15: Jonathan Edwards
  1. Lecture 15-1: Jonathan Edwards — Life and Context
  2. Lecture 15-2: Jonathan Edwards — Religious Affections, Freedom of the Will, and the Beauty of God
  3. Lecture 15-3: Jonathan Edwards — Legacy, Slavery, and New Calvinism
제 16 장 · Chapter 16: John Wesley and Methodism
  1. Lecture 16-1: Aldersgate and Fifty Years on Horseback
  2. Lecture 16-2: Prevenient Grace, Christian Perfection, and the Split with Whitefield
  3. Lecture 16-3: A Global Church, a Holiness Movement, and an Unfinished Reckoning
제 17 장 · Chapter 17: Friedrich Schleiermacher
  1. Lecture 17-1: Schleiermacher's Life and the Speeches to the Cultured Despisers
  2. Lecture 17-2: The Christian Faith and the Feeling of Absolute Dependence
  3. Lecture 17-3: Liberal Protestantism's Century and the Argument That Followed
제 18 장 · Chapter 18: Søren Kierkegaard
  1. Lecture 18-1: Copenhagen, Regine, and the Attack on Christendom
  2. Lecture 18-2: Abraham, Despair, and the Stages on Life's Way
  3. Lecture 18-3: Existentialism, Neo-Orthodoxy, and an Unresolved Inheritance
제 19 장 · Chapter 19: Charles Hodge and Old Princeton
  1. Lecture 19-1: Charles Hodge's Life and Princeton's Long Memory
  2. Lecture 19-2: Systematic Theology, Baconian Method, and the Doctrine of Inerrancy
  3. Lecture 19-3: Fundamentalism, Machen, and a Historians' Argument That Will Not Close
제 20 장 · Chapter 20: Abraham Kuyper
  1. Lecture 20-1: Kuyper's Life — From Parish to Parliament
  2. Lecture 20-2: Common Grace, Sphere Sovereignty, and Neo-Calvinism
  3. Lecture 20-3: Legacy — Bavinck, Worldview Evangelicalism, and an Honest Reckoning
제 21 장 · Chapter 21: Karl Barth
  1. Lecture 21-1: Barth's Life — From Liberal Pastor to the Barmen Declaration
  2. Lecture 21-2: The Church Dogmatics and the "Nein!" to Natural Theology
  3. Lecture 21-3: Legacy — Claimed by Everyone, Debated on Election, Honest About Von Kirschbaum
제 22 장 · Chapter 22: Bavinck, Vos, and Dutch Reformed Theology
  1. Lecture 22-1: Two Sons of the Secession — Bavinck's and Vos's Formation
  2. Lecture 22-2: Grace Restores Nature — Bavinck's System and Vos's Method
  3. Lecture 22-3: A Late Arrival — Bavinck in English and Vos at Westminster
제 23 장 · Chapter 23: Dietrich Bonhoeffer
  1. Lecture 23-1: From Lecture Hall to Underground Seminary to Conspiracy
  2. Lecture 23-2: Costly Grace and an Unfinished Ethics
  3. Lecture 23-3: A Legacy Claimed by Everyone, Resolved by No One
제 24 장 · Chapter 24: C. S. Lewis
  1. Lecture 24-1: From Atheism to Christianity — Life and Friendships
  2. Lecture 24-2: Mere Christianity, Narnia, and Screwtape
  3. Lecture 24-3: Legacy, Popular Influence, and Honest Criticism
제 25 장 · Chapter 25: Martyn Lloyd-Jones and Expository Preaching
  1. Lecture 25-1: From Harley Street to a Mission Church
  2. Lecture 25-2: Logic on Fire
  3. Lecture 25-3: The Chair, the Call, and the Reply
제 26 장 · Chapter 26: Francis Schaeffer and Cultural Apologetics
  1. Lecture 26-1: Francis Schaeffer's Life and the Founding of L'Abri
  2. Lecture 26-2: The God Who Is There and How Should We Then Live?
  3. Lecture 26-3: Schaeffer's Legacy — Political Mobilization and Later Critique
제 27 장 · Chapter 27: Carl Henry, J. I. Packer, and Neo-Evangelicalism
  1. Lecture 27-1: Carl Henry's Uneasy Conscience
  2. Lecture 27-2: Packer, Fuller, the NAE, and the Chicago Statement
  3. Lecture 27-3: Fractures and the Contested Label
제 28 장 · Chapter 28: Gustavo Gutiérrez and Liberation Theology
  1. Lecture 28-1: A Priest in Lima and a Bishops' Conference in Medellín
  2. Lecture 28-2: A Theology of Liberation and Its Central Claims
  3. Lecture 28-3: Rome's Caution, and a Family of Liberation Theologies
제 29 장 · Chapter 29: Moltmann and Pannenberg
  1. Lecture 29-1: Two Formations — A Prisoner's Hope and a Historian's Discipline
  2. Lecture 29-2: Hope from the Cross, Revelation from the Future
  3. Lecture 29-3: Legacy — Political Theology, Faith and Reason, and Two Honest Objections
제 30 장 · Chapter 30: John Stott and the Lausanne Movement
  1. Lecture 30-1: One Parish, One World
  2. Lecture 30-2: Basic Christianity, the Cross, and a Covenant
  3. Lecture 30-3: A Movement That Outlived the Room, and a Question Stott Left Open
제 31 장 · Chapter 31: The New Perspective on Paul
  1. Lecture 31-1: Origins — E. P. Sanders and Covenantal Nomism
  2. Lecture 31-2: Development — Dunn, Wright, and the New Perspective Named
  3. Lecture 31-3: The Live Dispute — New Perspective and Traditional Response
제 32 장 · Chapter 32: Korean Figures and Movements
  1. Lecture 32-1: The 1907 Pyongyang Revival and the Shrine-Worship Resistance
  2. Lecture 32-2: Minjung Theology and Its Relation to Latin American Liberation Theology
  3. Lecture 32-3: Growth, Global Mission, and Honest Reckoning

핵심만 먼저 보기 ↓

21분

Chapter 1 warned against the "tidy villain" — the temptation to read a historical dispute as a clean story of one side simply being wrong and the other simply being right, because the tidiness is usually a sign that you have flattened something. The Council of Sens is as good a test of that warning as this course offers. Bernard of Clairvaux, by his own later admission, arranged the outcome of the council before it opened; Peter Abelard, expecting a fair hearing, discovered there would not be one and walked out to appeal to Rome instead. On the facts alone, this looks like a straightforward case of institutional power silencing honest inquiry. It is worth taking seriously anyway that a large number of thoughtful readers across nine centuries — including some quite unsympathetic to Bernard generally — have concluded that Bernard was defending something real, and that Abelard's own writing gave him more grounds to worry than a simple story of persecuted genius allows.

This lecture asks you to hold the tension rather than resolve it in advance, and then turns to a second, related question: why medieval and modern Christianity alike have kept finding mysticism — claimed direct religious experience, described in terms that sometimes strain past what settled doctrine comfortably contains — a genuinely difficult category to place, in a tradition that is generally more institutionally at ease adjudicating propositions than adjudicating experience.

이 21분으로 얻는 것

  • Narrate what happened at the Council of Sens (1140 or 1141) and state, in Abelard's own terms and in Bernard's own terms, what each man believed was at stake.
  • Identify at least two specific theological propositions attributed to Abelard that Bernard found dangerous, and assess how fairly each represents what Abelard actually taught.
  • Explain why chapter 1's warning about the "tidy villain" applies directly to this dispute, and state your own reasoned judgment about it while acknowledging its complexity.
  • Describe at least two reasons mysticism has remained a contested category within a tradition often more comfortable with doctrine than with claimed experience, using Bernard's own case as one example.

Yes most certainly, and I count all things to be loss for the excellency of the knowledge of Christ Jesus, my Lord, for whom I suffered the loss of all things, and count them nothing but refuse, that I may gain Christ" — Philippians 3:8

World English Bible

Let him kiss me with the kisses of his mouth; for your love is better than wine." — Song of Solomon 1:2

WEB

Both men in this dispute could have claimed Philippians 3:8 for themselves in good conscience — Bernard, who believed he was defending the surpassing worth of the knowledge of Christ against a rationalism that risked reducing it to a puzzle to be solved; Abelard, who believed he was pursuing that same knowledge of Christ more honestly by refusing to paper over real contradictions in received authority. And Song of Solomon 1:2, read again here, is a reminder of what this whole chapter has been arguing: that Bernard's theology of intimate, experiential love for Christ was not a private hobby set apart from his public conduct, but the same conviction that, in this instance, hardened into confidence that he alone could see clearly enough to act for the church.

1. What Abelard actually taught

Peter Abelard (1079–1142) was, by the 1120s and 1130s, the most famous teacher in Paris, drawing students from across Europe to hear him lecture on logic and theology. His reputation rested partly on his skill and partly on his willingness to state theological problems plainly rather than smooth them over. His Sic et Non ("Yes and No"), composed as a teaching tool, laid out roughly one hundred fifty questions with quotations from respected on both sides of each one, without resolving most of the contradictions himself — a method meant to train students in the discipline of reconciling apparently conflicting authorities, but one that could also be read, by an unsympathetic eye, as advertising that the fathers of the church did not actually agree with each other.

More consequential for the Sens dispute were specific positions Abelard took in his theological writing, particularly his Theologia in its various revised versions. He proposed analogies for the drawn from logic and natural philosophy — famously comparing the three Persons to properties like power, wisdom, and goodness, an analogy his critics worried subordinated the Persons to attributes of a single divine substance in a way that echoed older, condemned heresies about the Trinity, even though Abelard insisted this was not his meaning. On the atonement, Abelard is often credited — accurately, though the label oversimplifies a more nuanced text — with proposing what later historians call a "moral influence" or "exemplarist" account, emphasizing Christ's death as a supreme demonstration of God's love meant to draw sinners to repentance, in a way some contemporaries read as understating the older Western emphasis (found, for instance, in Anselm's satisfaction theory, covered in chapter 5) on the cross as objectively necessary to satisfy justice.

None of this makes Abelard a heretic by simple inspection. He repeatedly insisted his intent was orthodox, that his analogies were teaching tools rather than final metaphysical claims, and that dialectic applied to theology served faith rather than undermined it. But it does mean Bernard's alarm was not manufactured from nothing: Abelard was doing something genuinely new and genuinely risky with genuinely central doctrines, in front of very large audiences of future clergy, at a moment when the church had no settled, agreed method for adjudicating how far theological speculation using the tools of logic could go before it crossed into error.

2. The Council of Sens

Bernard had corresponded with and preached against Abelard's teaching for some time before 1140, but the direct confrontation came when William of St. Thierry — Bernard's friend and fellow monk, introduced in lecture 6-2 — sent Bernard a list of propositions drawn from Abelard's writings that William considered dangerous, and urged Bernard to act. Bernard wrote to bishops across France laying out his concerns, and a council was convened at Sens, timed to coincide with a gathering where relics were being displayed and King Louis VII himself would be present — a setting calculated for maximum public and royal attention.

Abelard, hearing of the coming council, requested the opportunity to defend himself in open debate against Bernard directly, and initially it appears this is what was planned. What happened next is the crux of the dispute. On the evening before the council opened, Bernard met privately with the assembled bishops and went through the list of propositions attributed to Abelard one by one, securing their agreement in advance that these propositions were to be condemned. When the council opened the next day and Abelard arrived expecting a debate, he found instead that the bishops had already reached their verdict; rather than participate in what he now recognized as a formality, Abelard declared he would not answer and instead appealed his case directly to Rome. Pope Innocent II — the same pope Bernard had helped install a decade earlier during the schism — confirmed the condemnation of the propositions and ordered Abelard to be silent and his books burned.

Abelard's appeal to Rome, in the circumstances, changed almost nothing in practice; the pope who received it was the pope Bernard's own intervention had made possible, and the outcome Bernard wanted was the outcome that followed. Abelard, in poor health, retired to Cluny, where the abbot, Peter the Venerable, took him in and worked to reconcile him with Bernard. Whatever passed between the two men in Abelard's final two years, later tradition holds that some form of reconciliation was reached before Abelard's death in 1142 — a detail that complicates any reading of the affair as a simple, unresolved feud between implacable enemies.

3. Reading the dispute both ways

Read one way, this is a story about power overriding argument. Bernard, the most influential monk in Europe, used private persuasion of the very bishops who were supposed to be Abelard's judges to guarantee a verdict before the accused ever spoke — a procedure that, described in modern terms, looks less like a trial than a show trial with the outcome fixed the night before. Abelard, for all his flaws, was engaging in exactly the kind of careful, honest theological work — naming real tensions in authoritative sources rather than hiding them — that a healthy tradition should welcome rather than punish, and a council convened with a king in the audience and the verdict pre-arranged is not a body genuinely testing whether Abelard's teaching was actually heretical.

Read the other way, Bernard was not a jealous rival silencing a superior mind out of spite or institutional turf-protection, but a churchman responsible, in his own understanding, for guarding doctrines — the Trinity, the meaning of the cross — that were not his personal property to negotiate away in the name of intellectual fashion. Abelard's Trinitarian analogies genuinely could be, and had historically been, read in subordinationist directions; his emphasis on Christ's death as moral example genuinely could, if pressed, undercut the church's confession that something objective and not merely exemplary happened at the cross. Bernard's tactics at Sens were, by modern standards, unfair to Abelard as an individual defendant — but the question Bernard believed he was answering was not "did Abelard receive due process" so much as "should these specific propositions be taught to the next generation of Europe's clergy," and on that narrower question a council that agreed the propositions were dangerous, however it reached that agreement, was not obviously wrong to have reached it.

Chapter 1's warning applies to both halves of this reading. It is tempting, especially for modern readers instinctively sympathetic to intellectual freedom and suspicious of institutional power, to cast Bernard as the tidy villain and Abelard as the tidy martyr of honest inquiry silenced by dogmatism. It is equally tempting, for a reader instinctively protective of settled doctrine, to cast Abelard as the tidy villain, a proto-rationalist who deserved exactly what he got. Both readings are available in the historical record, and both are too tidy. Bernard defended real doctrinal concerns using tactics that denied Abelard a fair hearing; Abelard pursued real theological honesty using formulations that were, at minimum, genuinely capable of misleading a less careful reader than he claimed to be. Neither fact cancels the other.

4. Mysticism's contested place

Bernard's clash with Abelard is, on its surface, a dispute about method — logic applied to revealed mystery versus a more traditional, authority-bound theology. But it sits inside a larger and longer pattern: a tradition built substantially around settled doctrinal formulas, creeds, and conciliar definitions has never been entirely comfortable with claims of direct, personal religious experience, even when — as with Bernard himself — those claims come from a figure whose orthodoxy on the doctrines that actually got tested (the Trinity, the person of Christ) was never seriously questioned.

Part of the discomfort is practical: a claimed experience of God is, by its nature, difficult to verify, difficult to distinguish from delusion or manipulation, and difficult to adjudicate using the tools — councils, creeds, careful reading of authoritative texts — the tradition has built for settling doctrinal disputes. This is why the church, across its history, has treated mystics unevenly: Bernard himself was canonized and later declared a Doctor of the Church; Meister Eckhart, writing in a related tradition two centuries later, had a list of his propositions condemned by Pope John XXII after his death; visionaries like Hildegard of Bingen or, centuries later, figures within the Spanish mystical tradition faced real suspicion from ecclesiastical authorities during their own lifetimes even when later vindicated. The line between an approved mystic and a suspected one has often turned less on the intensity of the experience claimed than on how well the writer's language could be squared, after the fact, with settled doctrinal categories — which means a tradition uncomfortable with ambiguity has sometimes rewarded mystics chiefly for writing carefully enough to avoid trouble, rather than for the accuracy of what they claimed to experience.

The other part of the discomfort is theological, and it runs in both directions. A tradition weighted toward propositional doctrine risks treating faith as assent to correct statements while losing the experiential, relational dimension Bernard insisted was the whole point — a risk many later evangelical and Reformed movements (Pietism, covered in chapter 14, and the revivalism of Jonathan Edwards, chapter 15) would push back against in their own idiom, arguing that right doctrine without a felt love for God is not yet the faith the New Testament describes. But a tradition that leans too far the other way, privileging claimed experience over careful doctrinal testing, risks exactly what worried Bernard about Abelard from the other side: a subjectivity with no external check, vulnerable to error, manipulation, or simple self-deception dressed up as spiritual insight. Bernard himself, read fairly, was trying to hold both — an insistence on real, felt love for God disciplined by close, patient attention to the actual words of Scripture rather than free-floating claimed experience — and whether that balance is achievable, or whether every tradition eventually tips one way or the other, is a live question this course will meet again.


Diagram 1. Two readings of the Council of Sens

The Council of Sens, 1140/1141 — Read Both Ways Power over honest inquiry Bernard secured the bishops' verdict the night before, with the king present for effect. Abelard was doing careful, honest theological work and never received a real hearing. Verdict: a show trial. Real doctrine defended Abelard's Trinitarian analogies and exemplarist account of the cross carried genuine risk. Bernard, responsible for what the next clergy generation was taught, acted on that concern. Verdict: a real danger, addressed. Both are true. The tactics were unfair to Abelard the individual; the concerns were not manufactured.

5. Going to the Sources

Bernard's own case against Abelard survives as Letter 190 (also transmitted separately as the Tractatus contra quaedam capitula errorum Abaelardi), addressed to Pope Innocent II and listing the specific propositions Bernard wanted condemned. Read alongside it, for balance, Abelard's own Historia Calamitatum ("The Story of My Misfortunes"), his autobiographical account of his career's controversies written not long before Sens — both are available in English translation through public digital libraries such as ccel.org and the Internet Medieval Sourcebook. Reading Bernard's charges next to Abelard's own account of himself is the fastest way to feel, rather than simply be told, why this dispute resists a tidy verdict.


핵심 요약

  • Abelard was a famous Paris teacher. His Sic et Non set out conflicting statements from the fathers, and his Trinity analogies and view of the cross as a moral example worried Bernard.
  • At Sens, Bernard met the bishops the evening before and secured their agreement to condemn the propositions. Abelard refused to answer and appealed to Rome, where Innocent II confirmed the condemnation.
  • One reading sees power overriding honest inquiry, a show trial. The other sees Bernard defending real doctrine, so his tactics were unfair to Abelard but his concerns were not invented.
  • The lecture says both readings are too tidy. It also notes that Peter the Venerable is said to have reconciled the two men.
  • Mysticism is hard to place because experience is hard to verify. Churches that stress doctrine can lose felt love, and those that stress experience can lose any outside check.

Topic: The lecture examines the Council of Sens and the condemnation of Abelard, and then asks why mysticism has stayed a contested category in Christian tradition.

Remember: Bernard defended real doctrinal concerns by tactics that denied Abelard a fair hearing, and Abelard pursued honesty in formulations that could mislead. Neither fact cancels the other.

Caution: Do not cast either man as a tidy villain or martyr. Abelard is not a heretic by simple inspection, and Bernard's concern was not manufactured.

One line to carry into ministry: Hold doctrine and felt love for God together, and be fair to someone whose ideas you must test, even when the concern is real.

이 과목 요약 전체 보기 →

스스로 확인해 보세요

읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.

묵상 및 토론

  • Bernard secured the bishops' agreement before the Council of Sens opened. Does the fact that his underlying doctrinal concerns may have been legitimate change how you judge that procedural choice, or are the two questions independent of each other?
  • Peter the Venerable is said to have reconciled Bernard and Abelard before Abelard's death. What do you make of a story that complicates a dispute you might otherwise want to resolve into clear winners and losers?
  • Name one tradition or community you know of, past or present, that leans heavily toward propositional doctrine and one that leans heavily toward claimed religious experience. What does each gain, and what does each risk losing, by that emphasis?
  • This lecture argued that Bernard himself tried to hold doctrine and experience together rather than choose between them. Based on what you have read across this whole chapter, do you think he succeeded? Defend your answer with a specific example from his life or writing.

로그인하시면 여기에 답을 적고 보관하실 수 있습니다

다음 단계

여기까지가 강의입니다. 아래는 읽은 사람들이 남긴 글입니다.