Lecture 4-2: Low Mood, Depression and Crisis
목차 31
- Lecture 1-1: What a Calling Is
- Lecture 1-2: Discerning a Call
- Lecture 1-3: When the Call Wavers
- Lecture 1-4: One Call, Many Shapes of Service
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab, Telling My Call Story
- Lecture 2-1: Beloved Before Useful
- Lecture 2-2: The Pressure to Perform
- Lecture 2-3: Comparison, Praise and Criticism
- Lecture 2-4: Loneliness in Ministry
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: What Do I Use to Know I Am Well?
- Lecture 3-1: The Hidden Place and the Place of Service
- Lecture 3-2: Masks and Motives
- Lecture 3-3: Teaching What You Are Still Learning
- Lecture 3-4: One Life, Not Two
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab, An Hour in the Hidden Place
- Lecture 4-1: The Tired Minister
- Lecture 4-2: Low Mood, Depression and Crisis
- Lecture 4-3: The Road Back
- Lecture 4-4: What Congregations and Overseers Can Do
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab, My Signs and My Support List
- Lecture 5-1: Spiritual Direction and Companionship
- Lecture 5-2: Peers and Support Where You Are Alone
- Lecture 5-3: Sabbath and the Rhythm of Work
- Lecture 5-4: Body, Family and Household
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab, My Weekly and Yearly Rhythm
This lecture does not replace care. It is a study of what Scripture says and of how a minister, and the people around a minister, may think about low mood and crisis. It is not a way to find out whether you are ill, and it is not treatment. If low mood has become lasting and heavy, if it is changing how you sleep, eat, think or live, or if you have any thoughts of harming yourself or ending your life, do not carry it alone. Tell a doctor, a mental-health professional or a trusted person at once. If you are in danger now, call your local emergency number now, and do not wait for the end of this lecture.
Having said that, there is a reason this lecture exists. Many ministers will go through a time of deep low mood. Many ministers will stand beside someone else in it. And many ministers have been taught, in one way or another, that such a time means they have failed God, or that it should be hidden, or that prayer alone should be enough. This lecture takes those fears seriously. It answers them from Scripture and from plain care for the person.
The key claims are these. Low mood and depression are not failures of faith. Prayer and professional care are not rivals. A person who has thoughts of self-harm or suicide is not a sinner to be judged but a person in pain who needs help, and who should not be left alone with it. A minister is such a person, like anyone else.
이 34분으로 얻는 것
- Show from Psalm 88, Job 3, Elijah and Psalm 42:5 that Scripture lets deep distress be spoken to God, and say what those texts do not claim.
- Describe common marks of lasting low mood in plain words, and say why only a qualified person can say what it is.
- Explain why prayer and medical or professional care are not rivals, and say what each tradition's strength and risk may be.
- State what to do if there are thoughts of self-harm or suicide, and what to do if there is danger now.
- Describe how a friend or colleague should respond: ask directly and kindly, stay, do not leave the person alone, and help them reach professional care.
Yahweh, the God of my salvation, I have cried day and night before you. Let my prayer enter into your presence. Turn your ear to my cry. For my soul is full of troubles. My life draws near to Sheol. I am counted among those who go down into the pit. I am like a man who has no help, set apart among the dead, like the slain who lie in the grave, whom you remember no more. They are cut off from your hand. You have laid me in the lowest pit, in the darkest depths. Your wrath lies heavily on me. You have afflicted me with all your waves. Selah. You have taken my friends from me. You have made me an abomination to them. I am confined, and I can’t escape. My eyes are dim from grief. I have called on you daily, Yahweh. I have spread out my hands to you." — Psalm 88:1-9
World English Bible
After this Job opened his mouth, and cursed the day of his birth. Job answered: “Let the day perish in which I was born, the night which said, ‘There is a boy conceived.’" — Job 3:1-3
WEB
Why are you in despair, my soul? Why are you disturbed within me? Hope in God! For I shall still praise him for the saving help of his presence." — Psalm 42:5
WEB
Among the psalms of lament, Psalm 88 is almost alone in not turning toward hope by its end. Job opens his mouth, after a long silence, and speaks of the day of his birth. Psalm 42:5 is a person talking to their own soul. None of these texts is a treatment. All of them show that distress is allowed to be spoken, and spoken to God.
1. What to hold on to first
Three sentences carry the whole lecture. Read them before anything else, and return to them at the end.
- Tiredness and depression are not failures of faith.
- Prayer and medical or professional care are not rivals.
- If low mood is lasting and heavy, or if there are thoughts of self-harm or suicide, do not carry it alone. Tell a doctor, a mental-health professional or a trusted person at once. In danger, call your local emergency number.
The rest of the lecture explains, tests and applies them. If at any point reading it brings up strong distress, stop. Speak with a doctor, a mental-health professional, or a trusted pastor, priest or friend. If there is danger now, call your local emergency number.
2. What Scripture lets a person say
The Bible does not hide distress. It gives it words. Four examples show this.
Psalm 88. The psalm begins with a cry to God by day and night, and then it goes on to say that the person's "soul is full of troubles," that his life "draws near to Sheol" (the place of the dead in Hebrew thought), that friends have been taken away, and that he feels cut off from God's own hand. Near the end the psalm still has no turn toward comfort. Its last verse in this translation ends with the words "my friends into darkness." Many readers have found this psalm a difficult one for that reason. Some have found it a relief. A person is allowed to pray a prayer that ends without light. Notice that this person still prays. The psalm is addressed to God and begins with "Yahweh, the God of my salvation."
Job. After days of silence with his friends, Job speaks, and the first thing he says is a curse on the day of his birth. He later asks why light is given to people "in misery." The book of Job does not call him sinful for this. In its end, God speaks to Job, and criticises Job's friends, who had tried to explain his suffering as a result of something he had done. We will return to the friends below, because ministers often play their part.
Elijah. We saw in lecture 4-1 that Elijah asked to die and was met with bread, water and sleep. This is another form of the same fact. A faithful servant of God can come to a point where life itself seems too heavy.
Psalm 42:5. "Why are you in despair, my soul? Why are you disturbed within me? Hope in God!" Here a person speaks to their own inner self. The line is often quoted as if it were a command to cheer up. Read it with the rest of the psalm. The question is asked more than once, because the despair does not leave after one asking. The psalm holds the question and the hope side by side, and does not claim that one cancels the other at once.
What these texts do not claim. They do not claim that every person who feels this way is "like Job" or "like the psalmist", and they do not say what is happening inside any particular person. They are not a diagnosis. They do not say that medical care is unnecessary, and they do not say that it is needed in every case. They show that distress can be prayed. They do not replace asking a doctor. A person can pray Psalm 88 and see a doctor on the same day, and this is not a contradiction. This is what a whole person does.
3. Marks of lasting low mood, without a diagnosis
How does lasting low mood show itself? What follows is a description in everyday words. It is not a checklist. Only a doctor or a mental-health professional can say what is happening in a particular person, and they may find that it is depression, or grief, or an illness of the body, or something else.
Some people describe:
- a low, empty or heavy mood that stays for a long time and does not lift when good things happen;
- a loss of interest or pleasure in things that once mattered, including the work;
- being very tired, and moving or thinking more slowly;
- sleep that is much more or much less than before, and a change in eating;
- trouble thinking clearly or deciding;
- a feeling of being worthless, or guilt that is far out of proportion to anything done;
- a sense that nothing will get better;
- withdrawing from people;
- thoughts of death, of not wanting to be here, or of harming oneself.
Three notes.
First, these things overlap with ordinary sadness, grief and the exhaustion of lecture 4-1. Sadness after a loss is not an illness. Grief is not a fault. A dry time in prayer, which lecture 6-2 describes, is not always low mood. The point of this lecture is not to teach you to sort them. It is the opposite: you do not have to sort them alone. When it is hard to tell, and especially when it lasts, a qualified person can help.
Second, a person may be in this state and still preach well. A minister is used to going on when unwell. The public face can stay the same while the inside changes. This is one reason why it is easy to miss.
Third, depression is not laziness and it is not a lack of effort or of trust. A person who cannot get up in the morning is not being proud or slack. Lecture 4-1 said that honest accountability about motives matters, and it does. But it is not a tool to use on low mood. If someone says, "I cannot feel anything," the answer is care, not a search for faults.
4. The minister's fear of looking weak
Ministers often delay seeking help, and the reasons are human ones.
- "People look to me." A minister may feel that the congregation needs a strong person, and that showing weakness will let them down.
- "It means my faith is weak." In some communities, in more than one tradition, people have been taught that a believer who is truly trusting will not feel such things. A minister who has taught this to others may find it very hard to say, "I am struggling."
- "What will they think?" A minister may fear losing the position, the respect, or the call. In places where mental illness carries shame, this fear can be strong.
- "Others have it worse." This is true in a sense, and it is a poor reason to go without help. Pain is not a competition.
- "I should be able to pray my way through." This leads to the next section.
None of these fears is stupid. Each deserves a patient answer. The answer to the first is that a congregation is usually helped more by a minister who is well than by one who is hiding. The answer to the second is the passages we have read. The answer to the third and fourth is that care costs less than carrying on until something breaks. We say this gently, because the fears are real.
5. Prayer and treatment are not rivals
A person who believes in God and is suffering may ask, "Should I pray, or should I see a doctor?" The question is wrongly framed, because it sets two good things against each other. The better question is: how can I do both?
All the main Christian traditions have a place for prayer for the sick and a place for the care of the body. A Catholic or Orthodox minister may ask for the prayers of the community, or the of anointing for the sick, and may also go to a doctor. A Protestant may ask for prayer at the front of a church or in a small group, and may also go to a doctor. A Pentecostal or charismatic believer may seek prayer for healing with great hope, and may also go to a doctor. In each case the two belong together.
Each tradition also has a risk, and it is fair to name it without making any tradition the problem.
- Where much weight is given to prayer for healing, the strength is that a person is prayed for with hope and not left alone. The risk is that someone may be told to wait, or that a lasting trouble may be taken as a sign that their faith is weak. This delays care and adds guilt.
- Where much weight is given to the sacraments and to the spiritual father or mother, the strength is that a person is known and held in a long relationship. The risk is that a spiritual guide may be asked questions that belong to a doctor, or that a person may feel that their pain should be dealt with only in confession or in prayer.
- Where much weight is given to personal faith and effort, the strength is a deep honesty before God. The risk is that low mood is treated as a problem of the will or of trust.
- In a community where medical language is used for everything, the risk is the other way. The spiritual side of the person may be left out.
The same principle answers all of these: care for the whole person. A minister may find comfort in a Psalm, in a sacrament, in a spiritual guide and in a doctor. None is a replacement for the others. And no medical question, including any question about treatment or medicine, is for a minister to answer. Such questions belong to the doctor who knows the person.
6. Care is different in different places
Access to care differs very much from one country to another. In some places there is a clinic within a short walk and a mental-health professional within reach. In other places the nearest doctor is a long journey away, a visit costs more than a month's income, or there is nobody who speaks the minister's language. In some places seeking help for the mind brings shame. Do not assume that what is easy for one reader is possible for another.
So here is a ladder, with no assumption about what you have.
- A doctor or other health worker. Any trained person who looks after people's health can listen, check the body, and say what the next step is. Some medical causes of low mood are in the body.
- A mental-health professional, where one can be reached. Ask a doctor, a trusted person, or a health office where to find one. Some places have telephone or online help. These vary, so ask someone locally.
- A trusted person. This may be a friend, a colleague, a family member, a pastor, a priest, a spiritual father or mother. This person is not a replacement for professional care, but may help you to reach it. If there is no professional near, such a person is still better than silence.
- Your local emergency number, in danger.
If you serve alone and far from any of these, take the first step you can: tell one trustworthy person in words as plain as, "I have been very low for a long time, and I am afraid." Then ask them to help you find the next step.
7. Thoughts of self-harm or suicide
This section is the most important in the lecture, and so it is written as plainly as possible.
Some people who are in deep pain have thoughts of harming themselves, or of ending their lives, or of not wanting to wake up. Ministers are not excepted. Having such thoughts does not mean that a person is wicked, weak or faithless. It is often a sign of pain that has become too great to bear alone, and it must be taken seriously. A person with such thoughts is not to be called sinful. They are to be met with care.
If you have such thoughts:
- Do not carry them alone. Tell a doctor, a mental-health professional or a trusted person at once. You can say it in simple words: "I have been thinking about ending my life," or "I am having thoughts of hurting myself." You do not have to explain why.
- If you feel you might act on them, or if you are in danger now, call your local emergency number. Do not wait. Go to be with other people, and do not stay alone.
- Do not wait until you are better to tell someone. The thoughts often feel as if they cannot be spoken. That silence is part of what makes them so heavy, and telling someone is a way of no longer carrying them alone.
- Do not decide alone what the thoughts mean. Thoughts are not facts about your worth, or about the future.
This lecture describes no method of self-harm and will not. That is deliberate. What matters is that you reach help.
If a friend or colleague tells you, or if you are worried about them, the next section applies.
8. How a friend or colleague can help
A fellow minister, a member of a congregation, a friend or a family member may notice that someone is struggling. Perhaps they have withdrawn, or said something dark. They may be unsure whether to say anything. This is what is asked of you.
Ask directly and kindly. Do not hint. You might say, "I have noticed you seem very low. Are you having thoughts of ending your life?" Use plain words. You may fear that asking will make things worse. Helpers are often taught that a plain, kind question is better than silence, but this course cannot promise how any one person will answer. What it can say is that a kind, direct question tells the person that this can be spoken of, and silence leaves them alone with it.
Stay and listen. Let them speak. Do not hurry to fix it, argue, or give a lecture on faith. You do not need to have the right words. Being with them counts for more than any answer you give.
Do not leave the person alone if you think they may be in danger. Stay with them, or arrange for another trusted person to stay, until help has come.
Help them reach professional care. Offer to go with them to a doctor, or to make a call with them, or to find where help can be found. If there is danger now, call the local emergency number yourself and stay with them.
Do not promise to keep it secret if their life is at risk. You can say, "I care too much to keep this to myself. I need to get help for you."
Things not to say. Do not say, "You have so much to live for," as if they had not thought of it, and do not say, "Think of your family," or "Pray harder," or "This is a sin," or "You do not have enough faith." Such sentences add shame, which is a heavy weight, to a person already carrying a great deal.
Do not try to treat it yourself. You are not a doctor or a counsellor for this. Counselling theory and the limits of are taught in other courses (PT719E and PT723E), and neither removes the need to bring in professional help. Your part is to be a safe person who helps them reach it.
Look after yourself too. Standing beside someone in crisis is heavy. Tell a trusted person what you are carrying, within the limits of the other person's privacy, and make sure someone is supporting you.
9. Two invented cases
(An invented example.) Joseph is a pastor of a small church. For a long time he has felt flat. Nothing he does gives him pleasure, and he has been sleeping badly and eating little. On Sundays he preaches as usual, and nobody guesses. At night he sometimes thinks that the church and his family would manage better without him. He tells himself that his faith must be thin, and that the thoughts are shameful. He prays hard, and the heaviness does not lift. He tells nobody.
What has gone wrong? Not his faith. He has taken a heavy mood as a verdict on his trust in God, and he has carried it alone for a long time. The thoughts about not being here are a sign that he needs help now, not at a convenient time. A better path begins with one sentence to one person: "I have been very low for a long time, and some nights I think about ending my life." He might say it to a doctor, to a mental-health professional, or to a trusted friend or a bishop, or older colleague who can be told in confidence, and ask them to help him reach care. If he is in danger, he calls his local emergency number. Prayer goes on beside all of this, and it is not taken away.
(An invented example.) Maria is a , and Teresa is her friend and fellow worker. At a meeting Teresa notices that Maria has become quiet and has stopped eating with the group. Later Maria says, almost as a joke, "Sometimes I think everyone would be better off without me." Teresa feels afraid, and for a moment she wants to change the subject.
What does a good response look like? Teresa does not change the subject. She says, "That sounds very heavy. I want to ask you plainly: are you thinking about ending your life?" She listens. She does not argue with Maria's feelings or preach. If Maria says yes, Teresa stays with her, does not leave her alone, and helps her to reach a doctor or another qualified person. If there is danger now, she calls the local emergency number. She also tells a trusted person that she is helping, because she needs support too. If Maria says no, Teresa still says, "I am glad you told me. Let's talk again tomorrow," and she does.
Both cases give the shape of a situation without details. Neither is a script, and no tradition alone could answer them.
This lecture does not replace care
If anything here sounds like you, do not wait for certainty. Tell a doctor, a mental-health professional or a trusted person now. If you are in danger, call your local emergency number.
10. What comes after
A crisis that has passed is not the end of care. Many people need support for a long time. A minister who has been through a low period is still a minister, called and loved by God. This is the subject of lecture 4-3, which looks at the road back, and lecture 4-4, which looks at what others can do.
Diagram 1. If you or someone near you is struggling
Diagram 2. What Scripture shows, and what it does not claim
| Text | What it shows | What it does not claim |
|---|---|---|
| Psalm 88 | Deep distress prayed to God, without a turn to comfort | That every person will feel this, or that care is unnecessary |
| Job 3 | A faithful man curses the day of his birth and is not condemned for it | That suffering is always a result of a fault |
| 1 Kings 19 | A servant of God asks to die and is first given food and sleep | That food and sleep alone will always be enough |
| Psalm 42:5 | A person speaks to their own soul and holds hope beside despair | That the question is answered by cheering up |
핵심 요약
- Psalm 88, Job 3, Elijah and Psalm 42:5 show that deep distress may be spoken to God. They are not a diagnosis and not a treatment.
- Low mood and depression are not failures of faith, and prayer and professional care are not rivals.
- If low mood is lasting and heavy, or there are thoughts of self-harm or suicide, do not carry it alone: tell a doctor, a mental-health professional or a trusted person at once.
- A person in danger should call their local emergency number. A person with such thoughts is not called sinful. They are met with care.
- To help a friend or colleague: ask directly and kindly, stay, do not leave them alone, and help them reach professional care.
- Access to care differs by country and cost. Take the first step you can reach, and this lecture does not replace care.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Prayer and care | Not rivals. A person can pray and see a doctor on the same day. |
| Thoughts of self-harm or suicide | Do not carry them alone. Tell a doctor, a mental-health professional or a trusted person at once. |
| Danger now | Call your local emergency number and do not stay alone. |
| Helping a friend | Ask directly and kindly, stay, do not leave them alone, help them reach professional care. |
One sentence to remember Low mood is not a failure of faith, and nobody has to carry it alone.
This week's action Write down, for yourself only, who you could tell and what you would say if low mood lasted, and which kind of help can be reached where you live.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- Psalm 88 ends without a turn to hope. Why might it matter that this prayer is in the Bible?
- The lecture says that prayer and professional care are not rivals. How would you explain this to a person who has been taught that seeing a doctor shows weak faith?
- Which fear from the list (people look to me, it means my faith is weak, what will they think, others have it worse, I should pray my way through) is the strongest where you serve? What is a patient answer to it?
- Where you live, what is the first step a person could realistically take if they were low for a long time? Who could they tell?
- Why does the lecture say to ask directly and kindly, to stay, not to leave the person alone, and to help them reach professional care? What does each of the four protect?