Lecture 5-2: Automation: History and What We Do Not Know
목차 31
- Lecture 1-1: Why AI Ethics, and Why Now?
- Lecture 1-2: The Image of God and the Dignity of Persons
- Lecture 1-3: Three Traditions, One Set of Questions
- Lecture 1-4: Wisdom for Hard Cases: Five Questions
- Lecture 1-5: Practice Lab: The Five Questions
- Lecture 2-1: Who Is Responsible? The Gap
- Lecture 2-2: How Scripture Speaks of Responsibility
- Lecture 2-3: Decisions a Person Must Keep
- Lecture 2-4: Admitting Error and Repairing
- Lecture 2-5: Practice Lab: A Map of Responsibility
- Lecture 3-1: Where Bias Comes From
- Lecture 3-2: What Is Fair? Scripture and Several Measures
- Lecture 3-3: Structures and Persons
- Lecture 3-4: Who Is Missing? Listening in Church and Work
- Lecture 3-5: Practice Lab: Who Is Missing?
- Lecture 4-1: The God Who Sees and the Watchers
- Lecture 4-2: Privacy, Consent and Entrusted Information
- Lecture 4-3: Safety and Liberty: Uses of Watching
- Lecture 4-4: Being Watched and Watching with Love
- Lecture 4-5: Practice Lab: What Is Seen, What Is Hidden
- Lecture 5-1: A Theology of Work
- Lecture 5-2: Automation: History and What We Do Not Know
- Lecture 5-3: Dignity, Sharing and the Neighbour Who Loses Work
- Lecture 5-4: Rest, Worth and Not Being Useful
- Lecture 5-5: Practice Lab: My Work, My Neighbour's Work
Every few years, someone announces that machines will take most of our work. A few years later, someone else announces that machines will create more work than they destroy. Both speak with confidence. Both cannot be right, and sometimes neither is.
This lecture does not join either side. It does three smaller things. It tells a little certain history, briefly. It shows why forecasts about the future of work deserve caution, from the structure of the question and without any statistics. And it sets out, as fairly as it can, the two main ways thoughtful people read the present. Then it asks what a Christian should do when she or he does not know.
The central claim of the course applies here with force. The ethical question is not "what will the machine do?" It is "who will be carried and who will be left, and who is responsible for noticing?" That question can be asked without a forecast.
이 17분으로 얻는 것
- Tell three short historical examples of changes in work, without claiming more than is certain.
- Explain why a forecast about work is a weak basis for a moral judgement.
- State the optimistic and the pessimistic readings of automation, each in its strongest honest form.
- Say what this course requires of a student on this question, and what it does not.
- Name two ways a church can act without knowing the future.
Don’t say, “Why were the former days better than these?” For you do not ask wisely about this." — Ecclesiastes 7:10
World English Bible
In the morning sow your seed, and in the evening don’t withhold your hand; for you don’t know which will prosper, whether this or that, or whether they both will be equally good." — Ecclesiastes 11:6
WEB
The first verse warns against one kind of looking: the habit of saying the past was better. The second is for those who must act without knowing the outcome: sow in the morning, sow in the evening, and do not claim to know which seed will grow. Neither verse speaks of machines. Together they describe a posture that the question needs: not mourning, not boasting, and not freezing.
1. A little history, kept short
We use only history we can state with confidence, and we use it for one purpose: to remind ourselves that the question is not new.
The printing press. In the fifteenth century printing with movable type spread in Europe. Before that, books were copied by hand. Copying was skilled work, and some of that work shrank as printing grew. At the same time, new kinds of work appeared: making type, printing, selling books, and later many others. Reading itself spread, and with it the Bible in many languages. People who lived through those years did not see the whole outcome; we see it only from far away.
The mechanised loom. In England in the early nineteenth century, machines for weaving changed the work of textile workers. Some workers, now known as Luddites, broke machines in protest. The usual picture treats them as people who feared progress. A fairer picture is that they were skilled workers who saw their living and the standing of their trade fall, and who had few other ways to be heard. We are not saying they were right to break machines. We are saying their grievance was about livelihood and dignity, the two gifts of work we named in lecture 5-1.
The age of industry. As factories grew in the nineteenth century, many people moved from farms to cities and took new kinds of work. For many families life was hard, and the churches responded in different ways. In 1891 the Catholic Church published the encyclical Rerum Novarum, which spoke about the condition of working people. Protestant and Orthodox communities also responded, in their own ways. We mention this only to show that the church has stood beside the question of changing work before.
That is all the history we will claim. These three stories do not prove that "everything turns out fine" and they do not prove that "this is the end." They show that change in work has often been painful for the people in the middle of it, even in times when later generations judged the change to be good. That is a modest claim, and it is enough.
2. Why forecasts are weak ground for moral judgement
Most arguments about the future of work begin with a prediction. Here are three reasons to hold such predictions loosely.
- The future depends on choices not yet made. What happens to work will depend on what companies, governments, workers, churches and families decide. A forecast that treats these as fixed is describing a world where nobody chooses. But people choose.
- Past change does not settle future change. Someone who says "work always came back before" is using the past as a guide. Someone who says "this time is different" is saying the past is no guide. Neither can show, from the past alone, which is right. Both are making a judgement about similarity, and that judgement may be wrong.
- A forecast can serve an interest. A person who sells a product may like to say work will vanish, or may like to say nothing will be lost. We do not say anyone is lying. We say that a forecast is more reliable when its maker does not gain by being believed.
For these reasons this course gives no numbers about jobs and makes no prediction. "We do not know" is an honest sentence. It is also not the end of the discussion, because we can still ask who is being hurt now, and who has the power to help.
3. The two readings
This is a point where readers will not agree. Thoughtful people read the present in two main ways, and both deserve their strongest form.
The optimistic reading. Those who hold it say: every earlier change in work destroyed some jobs and created others, and those who came later were, on the whole, better off. Machines took the heaviest and most dangerous tasks and left people freer for others. New tools make new needs, and people are inventive in finding something worth paying for. In this view the right response to change is to prepare people to move into the new work, to avoid blocking change that would help many, and to trust that human creativity, a gift of God, will find new tasks. The reading is not careless; its holders usually care a great deal about the people who must move, and ask only that we not give up hope.
The pessimistic reading. Those who hold the opposite say: this time a tool is being made to do things that were the human advantage, such as reading, writing, judging and talking, and it may do them cheaply and everywhere at once. Earlier machines replaced muscle, and people moved to work that used the mind. If the mind's work is also taken, they ask, where will people move? They say too that "the average person ends up better off" can hide the person who did not. A skilled weaver in a bad decade was not comforted by the next generation's prosperity. In this view the right response is to take seriously the possibility of a deep break, to prepare the community and the law early, and not to rely on a hope with no evidence behind it. The reading is not gloomy for its own sake; its holders usually love the people who may be hurt and refuse to call their fear foolish.
What this course requires. Only two things. First, do not blur responsibility: when work changes, some person has decided, and some person should answer for the effect. Second, keep the weak in sight: judge any change by what happens to the person with the fewest options. A student may hold either reading, or neither, and still meet this requirement. Nothing in this course will mark a student wrong for being hopeful or for being worried.
4. What Ecclesiastes gives us
The verses chosen above are old, and they fit our case. Ecclesiastes 7:10 warns against asking "Why were the former days better than these?" The verse does not say that the past had nothing good in it. It says the question is not asked wisely. A church that answers every change by wishing for the old days will not be able to help the people who live now. The old days had their own hardships, which the nostalgic tend to forget, and people who are hurt today cannot be served by a memory.
Ecclesiastes 11:6 gives the other half. We do not know which seed will grow. The right response is to go on sowing, in the morning and in the evening, which means going on with the work of care and the work of teaching and the work of offering a hand, without waiting for certainty. This does not say "ignore risk". It says "do not make certainty the condition of acting."
What the text says. Two sayings from the Teacher: do not despise the present by praising the past; sow without knowing which seed will thrive.
A principle drawn from it. In uncertainty, act with humility: keep sowing, and do not claim to know the harvest.
Our judgement today. A church can act on the work question without a forecast, by caring for those already affected, by asking the questions in this course, and by holding its own judgements loosely.
5. What a church can do without knowing the future
(An invented example.) A parish council meets to talk about work in the town. Some members have heard that a large employer nearby will "use more automation". No one knows what that will mean. One member wants to wait. Another wants to prepare for the worst. A third says, "We do not know, but we do know who in our parish is already worried."
The council agrees on three small acts. They will ask, privately and kindly, whether any household would like to speak to someone about work. They will keep a list of people who offer a skill, such as help with writing a letter or filling in a form, and a list of those who need such help. And they will ask the employer, politely, whether a representative would meet the parish to explain what changes are planned and how workers will be told. None of the three required a forecast. All three kept the weak in sight.
Diagram 1. Two readings, one requirement
Diagram 2. Why a forecast is weak ground
| Reason | In plain words |
|---|---|
| Choices not yet made | The outcome depends on what people decide |
| The past is not a proof | "It came back before" and "this time differs" are both judgements |
| Interest | A forecast is weaker when its maker gains by being believed |
핵심 요약
- The question of changing work is old: printing, the mechanised loom and the age of industry each brought pain to people in the middle of change.
- Forecasts about work are weak ground for moral judgement, because outcomes depend on future choices and a forecaster may have an interest.
- Optimists and pessimists each have a strong case; this is a point where readers will not agree.
- The course requires two things only: do not blur responsibility, and keep the weak in sight.
- Ecclesiastes teaches us neither to praise the past nor to wait for certainty before sowing.
| Front | Back |
|---|---|
| Why distrust forecasts? | Outcomes depend on choices not yet made, the past proves nothing, and forecasters may have an interest. |
| Optimistic reading | Change ends some work and begins other work; prepare people to move. |
| Pessimistic reading | This tool reaches mind work; the average may hide the person left behind. |
| What the course requires | Do not blur responsibility; keep the weak in sight. |
One sentence to remember We do not know the future of work, but we know who is hurt now and who is able to help.
This week's action Do one small thing for a person whose work is uncertain: listen, offer a skill, or ask a question on their behalf.
스스로 확인해 보세요
읽었는지가 아니라 설명할 수 있는지를 묻는 것입니다. 체크는 이 기기에만 저장됩니다.
묵상 및 토론
- Which of the three historical examples was new to you, and what did it add to your picture of changing work?
- Which of the two readings, optimistic or pessimistic, comes more naturally to you? State the other in a form its holder would accept.
- Why does the pessimistic reading say that "the average" can hide a person, and why does the optimistic reading say that creativity finds new work? What would each reader answer to the other?
- Ecclesiastes 7:10 and 11:6 seem to pull in different directions. How do they fit together in a church facing uncertainty?
- What is one thing your community could do this month about changing work that does not depend on any forecast?